This essay examines both media reports on South Africa's Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC), and the TRC's final report, to determine the reasons why women are portrayed in the media — when they are portrayed at all — almost exclusively as victims. This author examines media reports which deal with the testimony of women who lived through the period of social conflict (1960 to 1994) covered by the TRC. Building on theories that argue that media can create as well as reflect reality, the authors shows that women were not adequately represented in the media reports on the TRC, and thus in the public mind, in spite of efforts to include them in the TRC process. Thus, although the TRC process may have been helpful to individual women, it can be argued that it has had little impact on how people view women's role in South Africa, and more generally in armed conflict and social unrest world-wide.
1 'I'he TRC Finial report shows that, while six out of every ten deponents were women, over 75% of the women's testimonies and 88% of the men's testimonies were about abuses to men. Only 17% of women's testimonies and 5% of the men's were about abuses to women.
2 White men certainly made up the highest figure of those applying for amnesty, but, for instance, it is known that men involved in the liberation struggle were also perpetrators. The latter tended to be discouraged from applying individually for amnesty, both because the ANC applied for a blanket amnesty and because of the attitude that crimes committed in the struggle against apartheid cannot be equated with those committed in its name. This basic tension was never adequately resolved by the TRC.
3 Sce, for example, the work of�ohann Gaining and the Transcend network.
'Gender in Action: Militarism and War.' African GenderInstituteNewsletter. Cape Town: African Gender Institute 8, July 2001.
'Two tales of contrasting trauma.' Mail & Guardian, 1 May 1996.
BERESFORD, DAVID 1996 'Theatre of pain and catharsis.' Mail & Guardian, 19 April.
BRAUDE, CLAUDIA 1997 'Media should get the truth out.' Mail& Guardian, 7 February.
CARRINGTON, NELSON 1999 'Woman's Work.' Johannesburg: International Committee of the Red Cross.
GOLDBLATT, BETH & SHEILA MEINTJIES 1996 'Gender and the Truth and Reconciliation Commission: A submission to the Truth and Reconciliation Commission.'
HAFFAJEE, FERIAL 1999 'Still the darling of the nation.' Mail & Guardian, 9 April.
ICRC 2000 WomenandWar. Geneva: International Committee of the Red Cross.
INTERNATIONAL ALERT 21 September, 2001. (http://www.international-alert.org/women/).
INTERNATIONAL WOMEN'S MEDIA FOUNDATION 2000 Leading inaDifferent Language:WillWomenChange the NewsMedia? Washington: IWMF.
MEDIA MONITORING PROJECT n.d. 'Gender and Politics and the Media,' in RedefiningPolitics:South AfricanWomenandDemocracy. Johannesburg: MMP.
MOKONYANE, NOMVULA 1997 FedtrawSubmission. Truth and Reconciliation Commission Women's Hearing.
OLIVER, GUY 1998 'For Nomonde Calata, the truth is not enough.' Mail& Guardian, 30 October.
SAPA REPORTS, October-November 1996; December 1999.
SCHECHTER, DANNY 2001 August-September 'Media and Racism: Time For An Accounting' and 'Covering Violence: How Should Media Handle Conflict?,' MediaChannel. (http://www.mediachannel.org/views/dissector/index.html). The Sowetan 1997 September.
TRUTH AND RECONCILIATION COMMISSION 1998 (August 2001). Final Report. Johannesburg: TRC. (http://www.polity.org.za/govdocs/commissions/1998/trc/index.htm).
TUTU, DESMOND 1997 Truth and Reconciliation Commission women's hearing, 28 July.
UDA, ENZA 2000 'Front Line Women.' Thunderbird 2(4), March.