Beyond Metropolitanism and Nativism: Re-grounding Media Theory

in Asian Journal of Social Science
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



While de-Westernisation is an interesting political intervention in media theory, analytically it offers little. We critique this approach through six inter-related arguments. The first point of critique challenges the putative singularity of the West. The second line of enquiry raises questions about the emergence of new academic disciplines and their intellectual offerings. Our third point is that the call to de-Westernise Media Studies is naïve, ignores history and the long patterns of global interconnectedness that have mutually formed the West/Rest. The fourth argument is that “de-Westernisation” suggests that the theory and methods of Media Studies offer nothing of use outside their original birthplaces, while the fifth argument is the conceptual danger of nativism. The sixth critique centres on the problem of essentialising culture as a determinate object. Examining the contemporary media practices of the Islamic Republic of Iran, we suggest that the true alternative to a repressive theocracy is its internal challenge by women, students and other parts of civil society that offers a critical third way beyond the binary divide.

Beyond Metropolitanism and Nativism: Re-grounding Media Theory

in Asian Journal of Social Science



AbazaM. “More on the shifting worlds of Islam. The Middle East and Southeast Asia: A troubled relationship” The Muslim World 2007 97 3 419 436

AhmadA. On communalism and globalization 2004 New Delhi Three Essays Collective

AhmadA. PanitchL.LeysC. “Islam, Islamisms and the West” Global flashpoints: Reactions to imperialism and neoliberalism 2008 New York Monthly Review Press (Socialist Register)

AlatasS. F. “The theme of ‘Relevance’ in third world human sciences” Singapore Journal of Tropical Geography 1995 16 2 123 140

AlatasS. F. “Academic dependency and the global division of labour in the social sciences” Current Sociology 2003 51 6 599 613

Al-AzmehA. Islams and Modernities 1993 London Verso

AminS. Eurocentrism 1989 London Monthly Review Press

AyishM. “Beyond western-oriented communication theories: A normative Arab-Islamic perspective” Javnost 2003 10 2 79 92

BayatA. Life as politics 2010 Amsterdam Amsterdam University Press

BullietR. The Case for Islamo-Christian Civilization 2004 New York Columbia University Press

CarnoyM. Education as Cultural Imperialism 1974 New York John Wiley

ChakrabartyD. Provincializing Europe: Postcolonial thought and historical difference 2000 Princeton NJ Princeton University Press

ChibberV. Post-Colonial Theory and the Specter of Capital 2013 London Verso

ConnellR. Southern Theory: social science and the global dynamics of knowledge 2007 Cambridge Polity

CurranJ.ParkM.-J. De-Westernizing media studies 2000 London Routledge

DabashiH. The Arab Spring: The End of Postcolonialism 2012 London Zed

DirlikA. “The postcolonial Aura: Third world criticism in the age of global capitalism” Critical Inquiry 1994 20 1 328 356

DirlikA. “Modernity as history: post-revolutionary China, globalization and the question of modernity” Social History 2002 27 1 16 39

DirlikA. “Global modernity? Modernity in an age of global capitalism” European Journal of Social Theory 2003 6 3 275 292

DowningJ. Internationalizing media theory 1996 London Sage

FabianJ. FabianJ. “Culture, time and the object of anthropology” Time and the work of anthropology 1991 New York Harwood

GoleN. “Snapshots of Islamic modernities” Daedalus 2000 129 1 91 117

GreeneS. MirsepassiA.BassuA.WeaverF. “The Multiple Worlds of African Studies” Localising Knowledge in a Globalizing World 2003 New York Syracuse University Press

HallinD.ManciniP. Comparing Media Systems Beyond the Western World 2012 Cambridge Cambridge University Press

HarveyD. Cosmopolitanism and the Geographies of Freedom 2009 New York Columbia University Press

HobartM. After Culture: Anthropology as Radical Metaphysical Critique 1990 Yogyakarta Duta Wacana Press Available at:

KhiabanyG. WangG. “Whither Eurocentrism? Media, culture and nativism in our time” De-Westernizing Communication Research 2011 New York Routledge

KhiabanyG.SrebernyA. “The Iranian Press and Continuing Struggle over Civil Society 1998–2000” Gazette 2001 63 2/3

KhiabanyG.SrebernyA. SakrN. “The Women’s Press in Contemporary Iran: Engendering the Public Sphere” Women and Media in the Middle East 2004 London I. B. Tauris

KundnaniA. “Islamism and the roots of liberal rage” Race and Class 2008 50 2 40 68

LeeC. C. “Beyond orientalist discourses: Media and democracy in Asia” Javnost/the Public 2001 8 2 7 20

LewisB. What went wrong? Western impact and Middle Eastern response 2002 New York Oxford University Press

LundJ. “Barbarian theorizing and the limits of Latin American exceptionalism” Cultural Critique 2001 47 54 90

Matin-AsgariA. “Islamic studies and the spirit of Max Weber: A critique of cultural essentialism” Critique 2004 13 3 293 312

Media Culture and Society 1993 Special edition: on Islam and Communcation 15(1)

MowlanaH. “The new global order and cultural ecology” Media Culture and Society 1993 15 1 9 27

MowlanaH. SplichalS.CalabreseA.SparksC. “Civil society, information society, and Islamic society: A comparative perspective” Information society and civil society: Contemporary perspectives on the changing world order 1994 West Lafayette, IN Purdue University Press

MowlanaH. Global communication in transition: The end of diversity 1996 Thousand Oaks CA Sage

MowlanaH.WilsonL. The passing of modernity: Communication and transformation of society 1990 New York Longman

PashaS. “Towards a cultural theory of political ideology and mass media in the Muslim world” Media Culture and Society 1993 15 1 61 79

RichardY. Shi’ite Islam 1995 Oxford Blackwell

SaidE. Orientalism 1979 New York Vintage

SardarZ. “Paper, printing and compact discs: The making and unmaking of Islamic culture” Media Culture and Society 1993 15 1 43 59

SchlesingerP. “Islam, postmodernity and the media: An interview with Akbar S. Ahmed” Media Culture and Society 1993 15 1 29 41

SparksC. Communism capitalism and the mass media 1998 London Sage

SpivakG. C. A critique of postcolonial reason 1999 Cambridge, MA Harvard University Press

SrebernyA. “On Reading Islam and Communication” Media Culture & Society 1993 15 4 661 668

SrebernyA. “The analytic challenges of studying the Middle East and its evolving media environment” Middle East Journal of Culture and Communication 2008 1 1 8 23

SrebernyA. PadovaniC.CalabreseA. “Establishing a ‘Rights’ regime in Iran: Thinking Communications, Politics and Gender together” Communication Rights and Social Justice (forthcoming) Palgrave

SrebernyA.KhiabanyG. Blogistan 2010 London I. B. Tauris

SrebernyA.TorfehM. Cultural Revolution in Iran: Contemporary popular culture in the Islamic Republic 2013 London I. B. Tauris

ThomaselliK. “ ‘Our culture’ vs. ‘foreign culture’: An essay on ontological and professional issues” Gazette 2003 65 6 427 441

WallersteinI. “Eurocentrism and its avatars: The dilemmas of social science” New Left Review 1997 226 93 108

WangG. De-Westernizing Communication Research: Altering Questions and Changing Frameworks 2011 New York Routledge

ZaidiA. H. “Muslim reconstructions of knowledge and re-enchantment of modernity” Theory Culture and Society 2006 23 5 69 91

ZubaidaS. Islam the people and the state: Political ideas and movements in the Middle East 1993 London I. B. Tauris

Index Card

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 23 23 11
Full Text Views 4 4 4
PDF Downloads 2 2 2
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0