Critical Responses to Faith Development Theory: A Useful Agenda for Change?

in Archive for the Psychology of Religion
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

Summary

Since it was first presented, James Fowler’s faith development theory has proven influential in pastoral care and counselling, pastoral and practical theology, spiritual direction, and Christian education. However, it has also been subject to substantial critical evaluation. This article reviews the major themes within psychological critiques and considers the agenda provided by these critiques for the theory’s future development. Critical themes concern Fowler’s understanding of “faith”; the theory’s structural “logic of development”; its overemphasis on cognition and lack of attention to (emotional/psychodynamic dimensions as) processes of transition and transformation; its gender bias and cultural specificity; and its purported difficulty in accommodating postmodern trends in psychology. To address these critiques in a meaningful way, there is a need to embrace alternative existing theories of faith development and spiritual/religious change, to construct a radically revised, process-focused version of faith development theory, and to continue to develop new localized process models of faith development.

Critical Responses to Faith Development Theory: A Useful Agenda for Change?

in Archive for the Psychology of Religion

Sections

References

AllportG. W.RossJ. M., 'Personal religious orientation and prejudice' (1967) 5 Journal of Personality and Social Psychology: 432-443.

J. Astley and L. Francis (eds), Christian perspectives on faith development, (Gracewing, Leominster 1992).

BaumeisterR. F., Meanings of life, (Guilford Press, New York 1991).

BaxterP.From Ubuzungu to Ubuntu: Resources for pastoral counselling in a Bantu context2006(Doctoral thesis Kimmage Mission Institute of Theology and Culture Milltown Institute Dublin).

BrainerdC., Piaget’s theory of intelligence, (Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ 1978).

BreakwellG. M., Coping with threatened identity, (Methuen, London 1986).

CharmazK., Constructing grounded theory: A practical guide through qualitative analysis, (Sage, London 2006).

CoyleA.RafalinD., 'Jewish gay men’s accounts of negotiating cultural, religious, and sexual identity: A qualitative study' (2000) 12(4) Journal of Psychology & Human Sexuality: 21-48.

H. Dahl, H. Kächele and H. Thomä (eds), Psychoanalytic process research strategies, (Springer-Verlag, Berlin 1988).

deLaurentisH.Maturity of faith: An interdisciplinary clarification of the term1985(Master’s thesis Catholic University of America)

C. Dykstra and S. Parks (eds), Faith development and Fowler, (Religious Education Press, Birmingham, AL 1986a).

DykstraC.ParksS., 'Introduction', in C. Dykstra and S. Parks (eds), Faith development and Fowler, (Religious Education Press, Birmingham, AL 1986b) 1-12.

FischerK. W.BidellT. R., 'Dynamic development of action and thought', in W. Damon and R. M. Lerner (eds), Handbook of child psychology (6th edn.). Volume one: Theoretical models of human development, (John Wiley, Hoboken, NJ 2006) 313-399.

FowlerJ. W., Stages of faith: The psychology of human development and the quest for meaning, (Harper and Row, San Francisco, CA 1981).

FowlerJ. W., 'Faith and the structuring of meaning', in C. Dykstra and S. Parks (eds), Faith development and Fowler, (Religious Education Press, Birmingham, AL 1986) 15-42.

FowlerJ. W., Faith development and pastoral care, (Fortress Press, Philadelphia, PA 1987).

FowlerJ. W., 'Foreword', in J. Astley and L. Francis (eds), Christian perspectives on faith development, (Gracewing, Leominster 1992) ix-xv.

FowlerJ. W., Stages of faith: The psychology of human development and the quest for meaning, (Harper and Row, San Francisco, CA 1995).

FowlerJ. W., Faithful change: The personal and public challenges of postmodern life, (Abingdon Press, Nashville, TN 1996).

FowlerJ. W., Stufen des Glaubens: Die Psychologie der menschlichen Entwicklung und die Suche nach Sinn, (Kaiser, Gütersloh 2000).

FowlerJ. W., 'Faith development theory and the postmodern challenges' (2001) 11 International Journal for the Psychology of Religion: 159-172.

FowlerJ. W., 'Faith development at 30: Naming the challenges of faith in a new millennium' (2004) 99 Religious Education: 405-421.

J. W. Fowler, K. E. Nipkow and F. Schweitzer (eds), Stages of faith and religious development: Implications for church education and society, (SCM Press, London 1991).

GellnerE., Postmodernism reason and religion, (Routledge, London 1992).

GergenK. J., 'Psychological science in a postmodern context' (2001) 56 American Psychologist: 803-813.

GilliganC., In a different voice: Psychological theory and women’s development, (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA 1982).

GoldmanR., Religious thinking from childhood to adolescence, (Seabury Press, New York 1964).

GollnickJ., Religion and spirituality in the life cycle, (Peter Lang, New York 2005).

GrenzS. J., A primer on postmodernism, (Eerdmans, Grand Rapids, MI 1996).

HamrickT. R.Transitional factors in the faith development of middle adults1988(Doctoral dissertation University of Georgia)

HarrisM., Dance of the Spirit: The seven steps of women’s spirituality, (Bantam, New York 1989).

HeywoodD., 'Faith development theory: A case for paradigm change' (2008) 29 Journal of Beliefs & Values: 263-272.

JaspalR.CinnirellaM., 'Coping with potentially incompatible identities: Accounts of religious, ethnic, and sexual identities from British Pakistani men who identify as Muslim and gay' (2010) 49 British Journal of Social Psychology: 849-870.

LevinsonD., The seasons of a man’s life, (Knopf, New York 1978).

LyotardJ. F., The postmodern condition: A report on knowledge, (Manchester University Press, Manchester 1984).

McDarghJ., 'Faith development theory and the postmodern problem of foundations' (2001) 11 International Journal for the Psychology of Religion: 185-199.

MillerP. H., Theories of developmental psychology, (Worth, New York 2002).

MoseleyR. M.JarvisD.FowlerJ. W., 1993 manual for faith development research, (Center for Research in Faith and Moral Development, Atlanta, GA 1993).

NelsonC. E.AleshireD., 'Research in faith development', in C. Dykstra and S. Parks (eds), Faith development and Fowler, (Religious Education Press, Birmingham, AL 1986) 180-201.

NiebuhrH. R., Radical monotheism and Western culture, (Harper and Row, New York 1960).

OserF.GmünderP., Religious judgement: A developmental approach, (Religious Education Press, Birmingham, AL 1991).

PaloutzianR. F., 'Religious conversion and spiritual transformation: A meaning-system analysis', in R. F. Paloutzian and C. L. Park (eds), Handbook of the psychology of religion and spirituality, (Guilford Press, New York 2005) 331-347.

ReichK. H., 'The person-God relationship: A dynamic model' (2003) 13 International Journal for the Psychology of Religion: 229-247.

ReichK. H., 'Stage-structural approach to religious development', in E. M. Dowling and W. G. Scarlett (eds), Encyclopedia of spiritual and religious development in childhood and adolescence, (Sage, Thousand Oaks, CA 2005) 431-437.

ReichK. H., 'Extending the psychology of religion: A call for exploration of psychological universals, more inclusive approaches, and comprehensive models' (2008) 30 Archive for the Psychology of Religion: 115-134.

RizzutoA.-M., 'Religious development beyond the modern paradigm discussion: The psychoanalytic point of view' (2001) 11 International Journal for the Psychology of Religion: 201-214.

SleeN. M., 'Further on from Fowler: Post-Fowler faith development research', in L. J. Francis, W. K. Kay and W. S. Campbell (eds), Research in religious education, (Gracewing, Leominster 1996) 73-96.

SleeN., Women’s faith development: Patterns and processes, (Ashgate, Aldershot 2004).

StreibH., 'The symposium on faith development theory and the modern paradigm' (2001a) 11 International Journal for the Psychology of Religion: 141-142.

StreibH., 'Faith development theory revisited: The religious styles perspective' (2001b) 11 International Journal for the Psychology of Religion: 143-158.

StreibH., 'Faith development at 20 years', in R. Osmer and F. Schweitzer (eds), Faith development and public life, (Chalice Press, St Louis, MO 2003) 2-20.

StreibH., 'Extending our vision of developmental growth and engaging in empirical scrutiny: Proposals for the future of faith development theory' (2004) 99 Religious Education: 427-434.

StreibH., 'Faith development research revisited: Accounting for diversity in structure, content, and narrativity of faith' (2005) 15 International Journal for the Psychology of Religion: 99-121.

VuykR., Overview and critique of Piaget’s genetic epistemology 1965-1980: Volume 1, (Academic Press, London 1981).

S. Wilkinson and C. Kitzinger (eds), Representing the Other: A ‘Feminism & Psychology’ reader, (Sage, London 1996).

Index Card

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 48 48 47
Full Text Views 14 14 14
PDF Downloads 6 6 6
EPUB Downloads 8 8 8