Is the Homo Ludens Cheerful and Serious at the Same Time? An Empirical Study of Hugo Rahner’s Notion of Ernstheiterkeit

in Archive for the Psychology of Religion
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



The theologian Hugo Rahner argued that the homo ludens is a man of ‘Ernstheiterkeit’ (serious-cheerfulness), a person who can smile under tears but also recognizes the gravity in all earthly cheerfulness. The primary aim of this study was to test the validity of this notion: Do homines ludentes exist? Two hundred sixty-three adult subjects were measured for (1) seriousness and cheerfulness and (2) playfulness. Results provided unequivocal support for Rahner’s thesis. Numerous subjects scored high in both seriousness and cheerfulness thus confirming the existence of homines ludentes. It was further found that these subjects were among those scoring highest in playfulness. Subjects scoring high in cheerfulness but low in seriousness were, however, even more closely associated with playfulness. The scores for homines ludentes did not differ from the rest of the subjects in the creative and dynamic facets of playfulness. The importance of developing empirical research to investigate hypotheses derived from non-scientific concepts is discussed.

Archive for the Psychology of Religion

Archiv für Religionspsychologie



AmabileT.M.HillK.G.HennesseyB.A.TigheE.M. The work preference inventory: Assessing intrinsic and extrinsic motivational orientations Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1994 Vol. 66 5 950 967

Aristotle CrispR. Nicomachean Ethics 2000 Cambridge, England Cambridge University Press

BarnettL.A. Playfulness: Definition, design, and measurement Play and Culture 1990 Vol. 3 319 336

BarnettL.A. The playful child: Measurement of a disposition to play Play and Culture 1991a Vol. 4 51 74

BarnettL.A. Characterizing playfulness: Correlates with individual attributes and personality traits Play and Culture 1991b Vol. 4 371 393

BarnettL.A. The nature of playfulness in young adults Personality and Individual Differences 2007 Vol. 43 4 949 958

BarnettL.A. Playful people: Fun is in the mind of the beholder Imagination, Cognition and Personality 2012 Vol. 31 3 169 197

BeermannU.RuchW. How virtuous is humour? What we can learn from current instruments The Journal of Positive Psychology 2009 Vol. 4 6 528 539

CappsD. Religion and humour: Estranged bedfellows Pastoral Psychology 2006 Vol. 54 5 413 438

CaputoJ.D. The prayers and tears of Jacques Derrida: Religion without religion 1997 Bloomington, IL Indiana University Press

Carretero-DiosH.EidM.RuchW. Analyzing multitrait-mulitmethod data with multilevel confirmatory factor analysis: An application to the validation of the State-Trait Cheerfulness Inventory Journal of Research in Personality 2011 Vol. 45 2 153 164

CoxH. The feast of fools—A theological essay on festivity and fantasy 1973 New York, NY Harper Colophon Books

DroogersA. DroogersA.ClarkeP. B.DavieG.GreenfieldS. M.VersteegP. The third bank of the river: Play, methodological ludism and the definition of religion Playful religion: Challenges for the study of religion 2006 Delft, The Netherlands Eburon 75 96

FredricksonB.L. The role of positive emotions in positive psychology: The broaden-and-build theory of positive emotions American Psychologist 2001 Vol. 56 3 218 226

GervaisM.WilsonD.S. The evolution and functions of laughter and humour: A synthetic approach Quarterly Review of Biology 2005 Vol. 80 4 395 430

GlynnM.A.WebsterJ. The Adult Playfulness Scale: An initial assessment Psychological Reports 1992 Vol. 71 83 103

GlynnM.A.WebsterJ. Refining the nomological net of the Adult Playfulness Scale: Personality, motivational, and attitudinal correlates for highly intelligent adults Psychological Reports 1993 Vol. 72 1023 1026

KaufmannG. In the beginning . . . creativity 2004 Minneapolis, IL Fortress Press

KierkegaardS. Abschließende unwissenschaftliche Nachschrift zu den philosophischen Brocken 1910 2. Teil Jena, Germany Diederichs [Concluding unscientific postscripts to the philosophical fragments (part 2)]

KöhlerG.RuchW. Sources of variance in current sense of humour inventories: How much substance, how much method variance? Humor: International Journal of Humor Research 1996 Vol. 9 3/4 363 397

LiebermanN.J. Playfulness: Its relationship to imagination and creativity 1977 New York, NY Academic Press

McGheeP.E. Health, healing and the amuse system: Humor as survival training 1996 Dubuque, IO Kendall/Hunt Publishing Company

MorreallJ. Taking laughter seriously 1983 Albany, NY State University of New York Press

MüllerL.RuchW. Humor and strengths of character The Journal of Positive Psychology 2011 Vol. 6 5 368 376

OerterR. Psychologie des Spiels Psychology of play 1999 Weinheim, Germany Beltz

PetersonC.SeligmanM.E.P. Character strengths and virtues: A handbook and classification 2004 Washington, DC American Psychological Association

ProyerR.T. Being playful and smart? The relations of adult playfulness with psychometric and self-estimated intelligence and academic performance Learning and Individual Differences 2011 Vol. 21 4 463 467

ProyerR.T. A psycho-linguistic study on adult playfulness: Its hierarchical structure and theoretical considerations Journal of Adult Development 2012a Vol. 19 3 141 149

ProyerR.T. Development and initial assessment of a short measure for adult playfulness: The SMAP Personality and Individual Differences 2012b Vol. 53 8 989 994

ProyerR.T. Examining playfulness in adults: Testing its correlates with personality, positive psychological functioning, goal aspirations, and multi-methodically assessed ingenuity Psychological Test and Assessment Modeling 2012c Vol. 54 2 103 127

ProyerR.T.RuchW. The virtuousness of adult playfulness: The relation of playfulness with strengths of character Psychology of Well-Being: Theory, Research and Practice 2011 Vol. 1 4

ProyerR.T.RuchW.MüllerL. Sense of humour among the elderly: Findings with the German version of the SHS Zeitschrift für Gerontologie und Geriatrie 2010 Vol. 43 1 19 24

QianX.L.YarnalC. The role of playfulness in the leisure stress-coping process among emerging adults: An SEM analysis Leisure/Loisir 2011 Vol. 35 2 191 209

RahnerH. Eutrapelie, eine vergessene Tugend Eutrapelia, a forgotten virtue 1954 Vol. 27 346 353 Geist und Leben

RahnerH. Man at play or did you ever practice eutrapelia? 1965 London, England Burns & Oates

RahnerH. Der spielende Mensch Man at play 2008 11th ed. Einsiedeln, CH Johannes (orig. published 1948).

RäwelJ. Humor als Kommunikationsmedium Humor as a communication medium 2005 Konstanz, Germany UVK

RuchW. Temperament, Eysenck’s PEN system, and humour-related traits Humor: International Journal of Humor Research 1994 Vol. 7 3 209 244

RuchW.HofmannJ. GremigniP. A temperament approach to humour Humor and health promotion 2012 Hauppauge, NY Nova Science Publishers 79 112

RuchW.KöhlerG.van ThrielC. Assessing the “humorous temperament”: Construction of the facet and standard trait forms of the State-Trait-Cheerfulness-Inventory—STCI Humor: International Journal of Humor Research 1996 9 3/4 303 339

SaridO.MelzerI.KurzI.ShaharD.R.RuchW. The effect of helping behaviour and physical activity on mood states and depressive symptoms of elderly people Clinical Gerontologist 2010 Vol. 33 4 270 282

SaroglouV. Religion and sense of humour: An a priori incompatibility? Theoretical considerations from a psychological perspective Humor: International Journal of Humor Research 2002 Vol. 15 2 191 214

SaroglouV.JaspardJ.-M. Does religion affect humour creation? An experimental study Mental Health, Religion & Culture 2001 Vol. 4 1 33 45

SchaffP. On the priesthood, ascetic treatises, selected homilies and letters, homilies on the statutes 1889 New York, NY The Christian Literature Co. (Vol. 9 of a select library of Nicene and Post-Nicene fathers of the Christian church).

SnowC.P. The two cultures 1959 London Cambridge University Press

VersteegP. DroogersA.ClarkeP.B.DavieG.GreenfieldS.M.VersteegP. Playing religion: Experience, meaning and the ludic approach Playful religion: Challenges for the study of religion 2006 Delft, The Netherlands Eburon 97 108

YuP.WuJ.-J.ChenI.LinY.-T. Is playfulness a benefit to work? Empirical evidence of professionals in Taiwan International Journal of Technology Measurement 2007 Vol. 39 3/4 412 429


Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 11 11 8
Full Text Views 5 5 5
PDF Downloads 4 4 4
EPUB Downloads 8 8 8