Believing is Seeing: A Perspective on Perceiving Images of Objects on the Shroud of Turin

in Archive for the Psychology of Religion
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

For many years, the Shroud of Turin has been famous for images of a body and face which many believe were formed during The Resurrection. More recently, however, claims have been made that the Shroud also contains evidence of other objects, and these claims have been used to support the view that the Shroud is the burial cloth of Jesus. However, these claims are based on marks that are barely visible and the psychological processes known to be involved in perceiving objects under data-limited conditions have been largely ignored. Here, we consider these processes and assess the claims that objects can be seen on the Shroud. We conclude that the viewing conditions provided by images of the Shroud are likely to lead to the illusory perception of objects, and knowing the psychological processes underlying these perceptions is crucial for accurately determining the provenance of the Shroud and other material artefacts.

Believing is Seeing: A Perspective on Perceiving Images of Objects on the Shroud of Turin

in Archive for the Psychology of Religion

Sections

References

AlinkA.SchwiedrzikC. M.KohlerA.SingerW.MuckliL. Stimulus predictability reduces responses in primary visual cortex Journal of Neuroscience 2010 30 2960 2966

AllenP. A.SmithA. F.LienM. C.KautK. P.CanfieldA. A multi-stream model of visual word recognition Attention Perception & Psychophysics 2009 71 281 296

AxmacherN.SchmitzD. P.WagnerT.ElgerC. E.FellJ. Interactions between medial temporal lobe, prefrontal cortex, and inferior temporal regions during visual working memory: A combined intracranial eeg and functional magnetic resonance imaging study Journal of Neuroscience 2008 28 7304 7312

BallP. Material witness: Shrouded in mystery Nature Materials 2008 7 349

BarM. A cortical mechanism for triggering top-down facilitation in visual object recognition Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 2003 15 600 609

BarM. Visual objects in context Nature Reviews: Neuroscience 2004 5 617 629

BarM.KassamK. S.GhumanA. S.BoshyanJ.SchmidA. M.DaleA. M.HalgrenE. Top-down facilitation of visual recognition Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2006 103 449 454 . . .

BarM.UllmanS. Spatial context in recognition Perception 1996 25 343 352

BarrettJ. L. Cognitive science of religion: What is it and why is it? Religion Compass 2007 1 6 768 786

BenedictXVI Jesus of Nazareth: Holy Week 2011 Ignatius Press

BiedermanI. Recognition-by-components: A theory of human image understanding Psychological Review 1987 94 115 147

BiedermanI.MezzanotteR.RabinowitzJ. Scene perception: Detecting and judging objects undergoing relational violations Cognitive Psychology 1982 14 143 177

BlakeR.LogothetisN. K. Visual competition Nature Reviews Neuroscience 2002 3 13 21

BolloneB. P. ScanneriniS.SavarinoP. Images of extraneous objects on the Shroud The Turin Shroud: Past present and future 2000 International scientific symposium 2-5 March 2000 Turin Cantalupa Effata 133

BruggerP.GravesR. E. Testing vs. believing hypotheses: Magical ideation in the judgment of contingencies Cognitive Neuropsychiatry 1997 2 55 57

BruggerP.RegardM.LandisT.CookN.KrebsD.NiederbergerJ. ‘Meaningful’ patterns in visual noise: Effects of lateral stimulation and the observer’s belief in esp Psychopathology 1993 26 261 265

CavadaC.CompañyT.TejedorJ.Cruz-RizzoloR. J.Reinoso-SuárezF. The anatomical connections of the macaque monkey orbitofrontal cortex. A review Cerebral Cortex 2000 10 220 242

ChopinA.MamassianP. Predictive properties of visual adaptation Current Biology 2012 22 622 626

CostelloP.JiangY.BaartmanB.McGlennenK.HeS. Semantic and subword priming during binocular suppression Consciousness and Cognition 2009 18 375 382

DamonP.DonahueD.GoreB.HathewayA.JullA.LinickT.TiteM. S. Radiocarbon dating of the Shroud of Turin Nature 1989 337 611 615 . . .

DaninA. Botany of the Shroud of Turin: An addition concerning new information since the 1999 report 2008 August Paper presented at the Shroud of Turin Conference Ohio

DaninA.BaruchU. AdlerA. D.PiczekI.MinorM. Floristic indicators for the origin of the Shroud of Turin The Shroud of Turin / Unraveling the Mystery 1998 Proceedings of the 1998 Dallas Symposium, Alexander Books Alexander, North Carolina 202 214

DavenportJ. Consistency effects between objects in scenes Memory & Cognition 2007 35 393 401

DavenportJ. L.PotterM. C. Scene consistency in object and background perception Psychological Science 2004 15 559 564

Di LazzaroP.MurraD.SchwortzB. Pattern recognition after image processing of low-contrast images, the case of the Shroud of Turin Pattern Recognition 2013 46 1964 1970

EnrieG. La Santa Sindone 1933 Turin Società Editrice Internazionale 47 51

EgnerT.MontiJ. M.SummerfieldC. Expectation and surprise determine neural population responses in the ventral visual stream Journal of Neuroscience 2010 30 16601 16608

EstermanM.YantisS. Perceptual expectation modulates category-selective cortical activity Cerebral Cortex 2010 20 1245 1253

FantiG. Hypotheses regarding the formation of the body image on the Turin Shroud. A critical compendium Journal of Imaging Science and Technology 2011 55 60507 60514

FantiG.MaggioloR. The double superficiality of the frontal image of the Turin Shroud Journal of Optics A: Pure and Applied Optics 2004 6 491 503

FilasF. The dating of the Shroud of Turin from coins of Pontius Pilate 1982 Chicago Francis L. Filas

FristonK. J. A theory of cortical responses Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 2005 360 815 836

FristonK. J.KiebelS. Predictive coding under the free-energy principle Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 2009 364 1211 1121

GoveH. Dating the Turin Shroud; An assessment Radiocarbon 1990 32 87 92

GuthrieS. E. Faces in the clouds: A new theory of religion 1995 Oxford University Press

HindsE. The devil sings the blues: Heavy metal, gothic fiction and “postmodern” discourse The Journal of Popular Culture 1992 26 151 164

HospersJ. An introduction to philosophical analysis 1967 London Routledge & Paul

JacksonJ. P.JumperE. J.MotternR. W.StevensonK. E. The three-dimensional image of Jesus’ burial cloth 1977 Proceedings of the United States Conference of Research on The Shroud of Turin, Holy Shroud Guild New York 74 79

PaulJohnII Speech, Turin Cathedral 1988

JordanT. R.McGowanV.PatersonK. P. Reading with a filtered fovea: The influence of visual quality at the point of fixation during reading Psychonomic Bulletin & Review 2012 19 1078 1084

JordanT. R.McGowanV. A.PatersonK. B. Reading with filtered fixations: Adult-age differences in the effectiveness of low-level properties of text within central vision Psychology and Aging 2014 29 229 235

JordanT. R.SheenM.AbedipourL.PatersonK. B. Seeing Inscriptions on the Shroud of Turin: The Role of Psychological Influences PLoS ONE 2015 44 8 251 288

JumperE. J.AdlerA. D.JacksonJ. P.PellicoriS. F.HellerJ. H.DruzikJ. R. A comprehensive examination of the various stains and images on the Shroud of Turin. acs Advances in Chemistry Archaeological Chemistry III 1984 205 447 476

KelleyH. H. The warm-cold variable in first impressions of persons Journal of Personality 1950 18 431 439

KveragaK.BoshyanJ.BarM. Magnocellular projections as the trigger of top-down facilitation in recognition Journal of Neuroscience 2007 27 13232 13240

LiuJ.LiJ.FengL.LiL.TianJ.LeeK. Seeing Jesus in toast: Neural and behavioral correlates of face pareidolia Cortex 2014 53 60 77

LuckS.ChelazziL.HillyardS.DesimoneR. Neural mechanisms of spatial selective attention in areas V1, V2, and V4 of macaque visual cortex Journal of Neurophysiology 1997 77 24 42

LupyanG.WardE. Language can boost otherwise unseen objects into visual awareness Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2013 110 14196 14201

MarionA. Discovery of inscriptions on the shroud of Turin by digital image processing Optical Engineering 1998 37 2308 2313

MarrD. Vision 1982 New York W. H. Freeman and Co Ltd

McNamaraT. Semantic priming: Perspectives from memory and word recognition 2005 New York Psychology Press

MumfordD. On the computational architecture of the neocortex Biological Cybernetics 1992 251 241 251

NieuwboerW.van SchieH. T.WigboldusD. Priming with religion and supernatural agency enhances the attribution of intentionality to natural phenomena Journal for the Cognitive Science of Religion 2014 2 97 120

OkuboM.MichimataC. The role of high spatial frequencies in hemispheric processing of categorical and coordinate spatial relations Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 2004 16 1576 1582

OlivaA.TorralbaA. The role of context in object recognition Trends in Cognitive Science 2007 11 520 527

OwadT. Confirmation bias: A ubiquitous phenomenon in many guises Review of General Psychology 2006 2 175 220

PalmerS. E. The effects of contextual scenes on the identification of objects Memory & Cognition 1975 3 519 526

PanichelloM. F.CheungO. S.BarM. Predictive feedback and conscious visual experience Frontiers in Psychology 2013 3 620 doi:10.3389/fpsyg.2012.00620

PatchingG. R.JordanT. R. Assessing the role of different spatial frequencies in word perception by good and poor readers Memory & Cognition 2005a 33 961 971

PatchingG. R.JordanT. R. Spatial frequency sensitivity differences between adults of good and poor reading ability Investigative Ophthalmology & Visual Science 2005b 46 2219 2224

PuriA.WojciulikE. Expectation both helps and hinders object perception Vision Research 2008 48 589 597

RianiM.AtkinsonA. C.FantiG.CrosillaF. Regression analysis with partially labelled regressors: Carbon dating of the Shroud of Turin Journal of Statistical Computing 2013 23 4 551 562

RaoR. P.BallardD. H. Predictive coding in the visual cortex: A functional interpretation of some extra-classical receptive-field effects Nature Neuroscience 1999 2 79 87

RiethC. A.LeeK.LiuJ.TianJ.HuberD. E. Faces in the mist: Illusory face and letter detection i-Perception 2011 2 458 476

RiekkiT.LindemanM.AleneffM.HalmeA.NuortimoA. Paranormal and religious believers are more prone to illusory face perception than skeptics and non-believers Applied Cognitive Psychology 2013 27 150 155

RogersR. Studies on the radiocarbon sample from the Shroud of Turin Thermochimica Acta 2005 425 189 194

SaganC.DruyanA. The demon-haunted world 1996 New York Random House

SaneyoshiA.MichimataC. Categorical and coordinate processing in object recognition depends on different spatial frequencies Cognitive Processing 2015 16 27 33

SchynsP. G.OlivaA. From blobs to boundaries: Evidence for time- and spatial-scale-dependent scene recognition Psychological Science 1994 5 195 201

SerencesJ.YantisS.CulbersonA.AwhE. Preparatory activity in visual cortex indexes distractor suppression during covert spatial orienting Journal of Neurophysiology 2004 92 3538 3545

ShapleyR. Visual sensitivity and parallel retinocortical channels Annual Review of Psychology 1990 41 635 658

SheenM.JordanT. R. Effects of contextual information on seeing pareidolic religious inscriptions on an artifact: Implications for the Shroud of Turin Perception 2015 0 1 doi:0301006615607156

ShwalbeL.RogersR. Physics and chemistry of the Shroud of Turin, a summary of the 1978 investigations Analytica Chimica Acta 1982 135 3 49

Simmonds-MooreC. Exploring the perceptual biases associated with believing and disbelieving in paranormal phenomena Consciousness and Cognition 2014 28 30 46

SterzerP.KleinschmidtA.ReesG. The neural bases of multistable perception Trends in Cognitive Science 2009 13 310 318

StevensonK. E.HabermasG. R. Verdict on the shroud: Evidence for the death and resurrection of Jesus Christ 1981 Ann Arbor, Michigan Servant Books

ThomasS. M.JordanT. R. Determining the influence of Gaussian blurring on inversion effects with talking faces Perception & Psychophysics 2002 69 932 944

van ElkM.RutjensB. T.van der PligtJ.van HarreveldF. Priming of supernatural agent concepts and agency detection Religion Brain & Behavior 2016 6 1 4 33

VossJ.FedermeierK.PallerK. The potato chip really does look like Elvis! Neural hallmarks of conceptual processing associated with finding novel shapes subjectively meaningful Cerebral Cortex 2011 22 2354 2364

WhangerM.WhangerA. The Shroud of Turin: An adventure of discovery 1998 Franklin, TN Providence House Publishers

WhangerA.WhangerM. FantiG. Revisiting the eye images: What are they? The Shroud of Turin: Perspectives on a multifaceted enigma 2008 Proceedings of the 2008 Columbus Ohio International Conference August 14-17, 2008 Padua, Italy Progetto Libreria 136

WhitsonJ. A.GalinskyA. D. Lacking control increases illusory pattern perception Science 2008 332 115 117

WilsonI.SchwortzB. The Turin Shroud: The illustrated evidence 2000 London Michael O’Mara Books

WisemanR.GreeningE.SmithM. Belief in the paranormal and suggestion in the seance room British Journal of Psychology 2003 94 285 297

ZhangH.LiuJ.HuberD.RiethC.TianJ.LeeK. Detecting faces in pure noise images: A functional MRI study on top-down perception Neuroreport 2008 19 229 233

Figures

Index Card

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 40 40 30
Full Text Views 7 7 7
PDF Downloads 2 2 2
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0