“Acting Like a Rich Bully”?: Madonna, Mercy, Malawi, and international children’s rights law in adoption
In: The International Journal of Children's RightsAlthough it may seem ironic that a policy affecting so few children should engage so much political and social attention, the symbolic significance of intercountry adoption far outweighs its practical import. A recent reminder of this fact on the African continent is the 2009 Madonna adoption case. This note considers Madonna’s second adoption of a child from Malawi in the light of international children’s rights laws. Although human rights groups have alleged that Madonna was “acting like a rich bully” in the main, Madonna’s adoption can withstand the scrutiny of children’s rights, and in fact, has contributed towards helping the discourse of children’s rights in Malawi “stumble” forward.
Purchase
Buy instant access (PDF download and unlimited online access):
Institutional Login
Log in with Open Athens, Shibboleth, or your institutional credentials
Personal login
Log in with your brill.com account
-
Adoption Cause No. 1 of 2009 In the Matter of the Adoption of Children Act (Cap. 26:01) and In the Matter of CJ (A Female Infant) (unreported) (“High Court infant CJ case”).
-
Adoption Cause No. 2 of 2006 In the Matter of the Adoption of Children Act (Cap. 26:01) and In the Matter of David Banda (A Male Infant) (unreported) (“infant DB case”).
-
Adoption Cause No. 1 of 2009 In the matter of Adoption of Children Act (Cap. 26:01 and in the matter of Chifundo James (a Female Infant) (unreported) (MSCA Adoption Appeal No. 28 of 2009) (“SCA infant CJ case”).
-
ANPPCAN Uganda, ‘Child link’, Government Should Revisit Law and Policy on Adoption 12(2) (2009) 7.
-
Bartholet E., ‘International adoption: Propriety, prospects and pragmatics’, Journal of American Academy of Matrimonial Law 13 (1996) 181.
-
BBC, “Father” opposes Madonna adoption (May 3 2009), available at <http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/entertainment/8031242.stm>
-
Cantwell N., ‘Intercountry adoption. A comment on the number of ‘adoptable’ children and the number of persons seeking to adopt internationally’. In The Judges’ Newsletter of The Hague Conference of Private International Law, Volume V (The Hague: HCCH, 2003).
-
Carlson R., ‘The emerging law of intercountry adoptions: An analysis of the Hague conference on intercountry adoption’, Tulane Law Journal 30 (1994) 243.
-
Chirwa D., Kaime T., ‘Where are the missing pieces? Constructing a mosaic of the CRC and the African Children's Charter in Malawi’s law and policy’, Malawi Law Journal 2(2008) 85.
-
CNN, Madonna’s Adoption Appeal Begins in Malawi (May 4 2009), available at <http://www.cnn.com/2009/SHOWBIZ/Music/05/04/madonna.adoption/index.html>
-
Daly L., ‘To regulate or not to regulate: The need for compliance with international norms by Guatemala and cooperation by the United States in order to maintain intercountry adoptions’, Family Court Review 45 (2007) 620.
-
Dillon S., ‘Making legal regimes for inter-country adoption reflect human rights principles: Transforming the United Nations Convention on the rights of the Child with the Hague Convention on Inter-country Adoption’, Boston University International Law Journal 21 (2003) 179.
-
Dillon S., ‘The missing link: A social orphan protocol to the United Nations Convention on the rights of the child’, Human Rights & Globalization Law Review 1 (2008) 39.
-
Doek J., ‘The protection of children's rights and the United Nations Convention on the rights of the child: Achievements and challenges’, Saint Louis University Public Law Review 22 (2003) 235.
-
Ethica, ‘Hearing only one voice: What does the future hold for Mercy and Malawi?’, (June 15 2009), available at <http://www.ethicanet.org/hearing-only-one-voice-what-does-the-future-hold-for-mercy-and-malawi>
-
Freeman M., ‘The best interests of the child? Is the best interests of the child in the best interests of children?’, International Journal of Law, Policy and the Family 11 (1997) 360.
-
Goetz P., ‘Is Brazil complying with the U.N. Convention on the rights of the child?’, Temple International & Comparative Law Journal 10 (1996) 147.
-
Graff J., ‘Foreign policy: The lie we love’, Foreign Policy 69 (2008) 1, available at <http://www.crin.org/docs/lie_we_love.pdf>
-
Graff N., ‘Intercountry adoption and the Convention on the rights of the child: Can the free market in children be controlled?’, Syracuse Journal of International Law and Commerce 27 (2000) 405.
-
Hague Conference on Private International Law (HCCH), (April 2001) ‘Report and conclusions of the special commission on the practical operation of the Hague convention of 29 May 1993 on protection of children and co-operation in respect of intercountry adoption, 28 November to 1 December 2000’, (drawn up by the Permanent Bureau in April 2001).
-
Hague Conference on Private International Law (HCCH), ‘The implementation and operation of the 1993 Hague intercountry adoption convention: Guide to good practice’, (2008) 106 (Guide No. 1) (“Guide to Good Practice”).
-
Hodgkin R., Newell P., Implementation Handbook for the Convention on the Rights of the Child (New York: UNICEF, 2007).
-
ISS, Intercountry Adoption: The Principle of Subsidiarity (factsheet No 36) (April 2007).
-
ISS, Adoption: General Principles (Fact sheet No 19) (2006), available at <http://www.crin.org/docs/19%20Adoption%20general%20principles%20ENG.doc>
-
King S., ‘Challenging MonoHumanism: An argument for changing the way we think about intercountry adoption’, Michigan Journal of International Law 30 (2009) 413.
-
Malawi Law Commission, Law Commission Report on the Technical Review of the Constitution (1998) Malawi Gazette of November 16 1998.
-
Mezmur B.D., ‘‘As painful as giving birth’: A reflection on the Madonna adoption saga’, Comparative and International Law of Southern Africa 41 (2008a) 382.
-
Mezmur B.D., ‘The African children's charter versus the convention on the rights of the child: A zero-sum game?’, SA Public Law 23 (2008b) 1.
-
Mezmur B.D., ‘From Angelina (to Madonna) to Zoe’s Ark: What are the ‘A-Z’ lessons for intercountry adoptions in Africa’, International Journal of Law, Policy and the Family 23 (2009a) 145.
-
Mezmur B.D., ‘Intercountry adoption as a measure of last resort in Africa: Advancing the rights of a child than a right to a child’, SUR- International Journal on Human Rights (2009b) 83.
-
Olsen L., ‘Lie or let die: Could intercountry adoption make the difference?’, Penn State International Law Review 22 (2004) 483.
-
Parra-Aranguren G., Explanatory Report to the Hague Convention of 29 May 1993 on Protection of Children and Co-operation in Respect of Intercountry Adoption (1994) (Hague Conference on Private International Law, Proceedings of the Seventeenth Session, Tome II).
-
Petition to Classify Orphan as an Immediate Relative Pursuant to Section IOl(b)(l)(F) of the Immigration and Nationality Act, 8 U.S.C. I lOl (b)(l)(F), U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services, January 07 2009 available at <http://www.uscis.gov/uscis-ext-templating/uscis/jspoverride/errFrameset.jsp>
-
Republic of Malawi Constitution of 1994 Act, No. 20 of 1994 (came into force on May 18 1994).
-
Rios-Kohn R., ‘The convention on the rights of the child: Progress and challenges’, Georgia Journal of Fighting Poverty 5 (1998) 139.
-
Schwartz S., ‘The myth of habitual residence: Why American courts should adopt the Delvoye standard for habitual residence under the Hague Convention on the civil aspects of international child abduction’, Cardozo Women's Law Journal 10 (2004) 691.
-
Splagounias G., ‘Habitual residence under Hague Convention equated with ordinary residence, Friedrich v. Friedrich, 983 F.2d 1396 (6th Cir. 1993)’, Suffolk Transnational Law Review 18 (1995) 823.
-
Sloth-Nielsen J., Mezmur B.D., ‘(Illicit) transfer by De Gree’, Law, Democracy and Development 11 (2007) 81.
-
Sloth-Nielsen J., Mezmur B.D., ‘2 + 2 = 5? Exploring the domestication of the CRC in the South African courts (2002–2006)’, The International Journal of Children’s Rights 16 (2008) 1.
-
Smolin D., ‘Intercountry adoption and poverty: A human rights perspective’, Capital University law Review 36 (2007b) 413.
-
The Guardian, Madonna Adoption Blow After Man Claims to be Girl’s Father (May 3 2009), available at <http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2009/may/03/madonna-adoption-malawi-orphan-father>
-
The Guardian, Madonna, Mercy and Malawi: Her Fight to Adopt a Second African Child (June 12 2009), available at <http://www.guardian.co.uk/music/2009/jun/12/madonna-mercy-malawi>
-
USA Today, Madonna's Adoption Ruling Delayed Until Friday, (March 30 2009), available at <http://www.usatoday.com/life/people/2009-03-29-malawi-madonna_N.html>
-
U.S. Department of State, Intercountry Adoption: Burkina Faso (August 2008), available at <http://adoption.state.gov/country/burkina%20faso.html>
-
U.S. Department of State, Intercountry Adoption: Democratic Republic of Congo (March 2009), available at <http://adoption.state.gov/country/democratic%20republic%20of%20congo.html>
-
U.S. Department of State, Intercountry Adoption: Eritrea (March 2009), available at <http://adoption.state.gov/country/eritrea.html>
-
U.S. Department of State, Intercountry Adoption: Ghana (February 2009), available at <http://adoption.state.gov/country/ghana.html>
-
U.S. Department of State, Intercountry Adoption: Malawi (June 2009), available at <http://adoption.state.gov/country/malawi.html>
-
U.S. Department of State, Intercountry Adoption: Mali (July 2008), available at <http://adoption.state.gov/country/mali.html>
-
U.S. Department of State, Intercountry Adoption: Morocco (February 2007), available at <http://adoption.state.gov/country/morocco.html>
-
U.S. Department of State, Intercountry Adoption: Tanzania (March 2009), available at <http://adoption.state.gov/country/tanzania.html>
-
U.S. Department of State, Intercountry Adoption: Uganda (April 2008) available at <http://adoption.state.gov/country/uganda.html>
-
U.S. Department of State, Intercountry Adoption: Zambia (December 2007), available at <http://adoption.state.gov/country/zambia.ahtml>
-
U.S. Department of State, Intercountry Adoption: Zimbabwe (June 2006), available at <http://adoption.state.gov/country/zimbabwe.html>
-
Vité S., Boéchat H., , ‘Article 21: adoption’. In A commentary on the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child. eds. Alen A. et al. (Leiden/ Boston: Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, 2008).
-
Worthington R., ‘The road to parentless children is paved with good intentions: How the Hague Convention and recent Intercountry adoption rules are affecting potential parents and the best interests of children’, Duke Journal of Comparative & International Law 19 (2009) 559.
-
7)
Ratified on September 10 1999.
| All Time | Past Year | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 723 | 136 | 22 |
| Full Text Views | 169 | 9 | 3 |
| PDF Views & Downloads | 92 | 22 | 5 |
“Acting Like a Rich Bully”?: Madonna, Mercy, Malawi, and international children’s rights law in adoption
In: The International Journal of Children's RightsAlthough it may seem ironic that a policy affecting so few children should engage so much political and social attention, the symbolic significance of intercountry adoption far outweighs its practical import. A recent reminder of this fact on the African continent is the 2009 Madonna adoption case. This note considers Madonna’s second adoption of a child from Malawi in the light of international children’s rights laws. Although human rights groups have alleged that Madonna was “acting like a rich bully” in the main, Madonna’s adoption can withstand the scrutiny of children’s rights, and in fact, has contributed towards helping the discourse of children’s rights in Malawi “stumble” forward.
| All Time | Past Year | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 723 | 136 | 22 |
| Full Text Views | 169 | 9 | 3 |
| PDF Views & Downloads | 92 | 22 | 5 |