Children with Disabilities: A Critical Appraisal

in The International Journal of Children's Rights
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?


This essay contemplates the rights of children with disabilities under international law. It analyses the philosophical and practical reasons for the failure of the Convention on the Rights of the Child to protect the rights of children with disabilities, and looks at the remedial measures adopted under the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (CRPD). The argument advanced is that, especially when children’s perspectives are considered, assistive technologies are at the heart of national and international efforts to advance the rights of children with disabilities, most importantly, a right to inclusion. I consider the challenges ahead and draw conclusions on the future of the rights of children with disabilities.

Children with Disabilities: A Critical Appraisal

in The International Journal of Children's Rights



  • AlstonP.The unborn child and abortion under the draft convention of the rights of the childHuman Rights Quarterly 12 (1990): 156178.

  • AusAIDDevelopment for All: Towards a disability-inclusive Australian aid program (2009–2014).

  • BoezaartT.Protecting the reproductive rights of children and young adults with disabilities: The roles and responsibilities of the family, the state, and judicial decision-makingEmory International Law Review 26 (2012): 6985.

  • BorgJ.LarssonS. & OstergrenP.-OThe right to assistive technology: For whom, for what, and by whom?Disability & Society 26(2) (2011a): 151167.

  • BorgJ.LindstromA. & LarssonS.Assistive technologies in developing countries: National and international responsibilities to implement the convention on the rights of persons with disabilitiesLancet 374 (2009): 19631965.

  • BorgJ.LindstromA. & LarssonS.Assistive technologies in developing countries: A review from the perspective of the convention on the rights of persons with disabilitiesProsthetic and Orthotics International 35(1) (2011b): 2029.

  • BraithwaiteJ. & MontD.Disability and Poverty: A Survey of World Bank Poverty Assessments and Implications (World Bank2008).

  • CESCRGeneral Comment 17, the right of everyone to benefit from the protection of the moral and material interests resulting from any scientific literary or artistic production of which he or she is the author (Article 15 para 1 (c) of the Covenant) U.N. Doc. E/C.12/GC/17 (2006).

  • Committee on the Rights of the ChildGeneral Comment No. 9 The Rights of Children with Disabilities (Forty-third session 2007) U.N. Doc. CRC/C/GC/9 (2007).

  • ConnellT. ‘The challenge of assistive technology and braille literacy

  • Costa and Pavan v. Italy Application no. 54270/10 ECHR 28 August 2012.

  • CRCGeneral Day of Discussion Children with Disabilities (1997).

  • Dalal A.K.Social interventions to moderate discriminatory attitudes: the case of the physically challenged in IndiaPsychology Health & Medicine 11 (2006): 374382.

  • SilvaDede AlwisR.Mining the intersections: Advancing the rights of women and children with disabilities within an interrelated web of human rightsPacific Rim Law & Policy Journal 18 (2009): 293322.

  • DevasM.Support and access in sports and leisure provisionDisability and Society 18(2) (2003): 231245.

  • Đorđević v. Croatia ECHR Application no. 41526/10 judgment of 24 July 2012.

  • FayT. & WolffE.Disability in sport in the twenty-first century: Creating a new sport opportunity spectrumBoston University International Law Journal 27 (2009): 231248.

  • FreemanM.The future of children’s rightsChildren & Society 14 (2000): 277293.

  • Glass v. the UK ECHR Application No. 61827/00 judgment of 9 March 2004.

  • Glor v. Switzerland ECHR Application No. 13444/04 judgment 30 April 2009.

  • GuernseyK.NicoliM. & NinioA.Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities: Its Implementation and Relevance for the World Bank (World Bank2007).

  • HeahT.Successful participation: The lived experience among children with disabilitiesCanadian Journal of Occupational Therapy 74(1) (2007): 3847.

  • HRWHuman Rights for Women and Children with Disabilities (2010).

  • HuangI.-CSugdenD. & BeveridgeS.Assistive devices and cerebral palsy: The use of assistive devices at school by children with cerebral palsyChild: Care Health and Development 35(5) (2009): 698708.

  • JonesM. & MarksL.A.B.Beyond the convention on the rights of the child: The rights of children with disabilities in international lawInternational Journal of Children’s Rights 5 (1997): 177192.

  • K. v. Latvia ECHR Application 33011/08 (undecided).

  • K.A. v. Hungary ECHR Application no. 38832/06 judgment of 20 May 2010.

  • KirkS.How children and young people construct and negotiate living with medical technologySocial Science & Medicine 71 (2010): 17961803.

  • LansdownG.Children with disabilities’ In Human Rights and Disability Advocacy. eds. SabatelloM. & SchulzeM. (forthcoming Penn. Univ. Press2013).

  • MegretF.The disabilities convention: Towards a holistic conception of rightsInternational Journal of Human Rights 12(261) (2008): 266269.

  • MitraS. et al. Disability and Poverty in Developing Countries: A Snapshot from the World Health Survey (World Bank2011).

  • MortierK. et al. ‘“I want support, not comments”: Children’s perspectives on supports in their lifeDisability and Society 26(2) (2011): 207221.

  • MurphyN.A.CarboneP.S. & the Council on Children with Disabilities ‘Promoting the participation of children with disabilities in sports, recreation, and physical activitiesPediatrics 121(5) (2008): 10571061.

  • NUHProvision of Assistive Technology in the Nordic Countries (2007)

  • O’CinneideC.Extracting protection for the rights of persons with disabilities from human rights frameworks: Established limits and new possibilities’. In The UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities: European and Scandinavian Perspectives. eds. ArnardottirO.M. & QuinnG. (Martinus Nijhoff2009) 163200.

  • OlusanyaB.O.LuxonL.M. & WirzS.L.Screening for early childhood hearing loss in NigeriaJournal of Medical Screening 12(3) (2005): 115118.

  • ParishS.L. et al ‘Material hardship in U.S. families raising children with disabilitiesCouncil for Exceptional Children 75(1) (2008): 7192.

  • PoulsenA. & ZivianiJ.M.‘Can I play too? Physical activity engagement of children with developmental coordination disordersThe Canadian Journal of Occupational Therapy 71(2) (2004): 100107.

  • Quinn Gerard/Theresia Degener Human Rights and Disability.

  • RameshR.Four in 10 disabled young living in poverty, report saysThe Guardian (6 October 2011).

  • ReadJ.BlackburnC. & SpencerN.Disabled children and their families: A decade of policy changeChildren & Society 26 (2012): 223233.

  • Recommendation CM/Rec (2010) 2 of the Committee of Ministers to member states on Deinstitutionalisation and community living of Children with Disabilities (Council of Europe 10 February 2010).

  • Report of the Special Rapporteur in the field of cultural rights Farida Shaheed The right to enjoy the benefits of scientific progress and its applications (UN A/HRC/20/26 NY May 2012).

  • SabatelloM.Children’s Bioethics: The International Bio-political Discourse on Harmful Traditional Practices and the Right of the Child to Cultural Identity (Martinus Nijhoff/Brill publishing2009).

  • SabatelloM.The new diplomacy’. In Human Rights and Disability Advocacy. eds. SabatelloM. & SchulzeM. (forthcoming Penn. Univ. Press2013).

  • Sentges v. The Netherlands ECHR Application no.27677/02 judgment of 8 July 2003.

  • Stanev v. Bulgaria ECHR (Grand Chamber) Application no. 36760/06 judgment of 17 January 2012.

  • Stergious-KitaM.YantziA. & JeffreyW.The personal and workplace factors relevant to work readiness evaluation following acquired brain injury: Occupational therapists’ perceptionsBrain Injury 24(7–8) (2010): 948958.

  • SullivanP.M.Violence exposure among children with disabilitiesClinical Child Family Psychological Review 12 (2009): 196216.

  • TaubD.E. & GreerK.R.Physical cctivity as normalizing experience for school-age children with physical disabilities: Implications for legitimation of social identity and enhancement of social tiesJournal of Sport & Social Issues 24 (2000): 395414.

  • TisdallE.K.M.The challenge and challenging of childhood studies? Learning from disability studies and research with disabled childrenChildren & Society 26 (2012): 181191.

  • UN Enable

  • UN General Secretary’s Study on Violence against ChildrenSummary Report of the Thematic Meeting on Violence against Children with Disabilities (UN, NY2005).

  • UNESCOGendered outcomes in education: Why girls still held back’. In Education for All Global Monitoring Report 2003/4 (2003).

  • UNESCOEFA Global Monitoring Report 2010 Reaching the Marginalized (Oxford2010).

  • UNICEFEducation for Some More than Others? (Geneva: UNICEF Regional Office for Central and Eastern Europe and the Commonwealth of Independent States2007).

  • UNICEFCalls for Children with Disabilities to Be Included in All Development (3 December 2011).

  • UNICEFThe Right of Children with Disabilities to Education: A Rights-Based Approach to Inclusive Education in the CEECIS Region (2012).

  • VeermanP.The ageing of the UN convention on the rights of the childInternational Journal of Children’s Rights 2010 (18): 585618.

  • WHOCommunity-Based Rehabilitation: CBR Guidelines (2010).

  • WHOJoint Position Paper on the Provision of Mobility Devices in Less Resources Settings (2011).

  • WHO/EUBetter Health Better Lives: Children and Young People with Intellectual Disabilities and Their Families (WHO 2010).

  • WoolleyH.Now being social: The barrier of designing outdoor play spaces for disabled childrenChildren & Society (2012).

  • WHO & World BankWorld Report on Disability (WHO2011).

Index Card

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 56 54 3
Full Text Views 156 156 0
PDF Downloads 16 16 0
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0