What Inequality means for Children

Evidence from Young Lives

in The International Journal of Children's Rights
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

Understanding how poverty and inequalities impact on children is the major goal of Young Lives, a unique longitudinal, mixed-methods study. Two cohorts totaling 12,000 children are being tracked since 2001, growing-up in Ethiopia, the state of Andhra Pradesh (ap) India, Peru and Vietnam. Earlier versions of this paper were prepared as Young Lives contribution to a unicef/un Women consultation on the post-2015 Development agenda (www.worldwewant2015.org/inequalities) and published as Woodhead, Dornan and Murray (2013).

We summarise Young Lives evidence to date on eight research issues that are central to any child rights agenda:

  1. How inequalities interact in their impact on children’s development and the vulnerability of the most disadvantaged households.

  2. The ways inequalities rapidly undermine the development of human potential.

  3. How gender differences interconnect with other inequalities, but do not always advantage boys in Young Lives countries.

  4. The links between poverty, early ‘stunting’, and later outcomes, including psycho-social functioning, as well as emerging evidence that some children recover.

  5. Inequalities that open up during the later years of childhood, linked to transitions around leaving school, working, and anticipating marriage etc.

  6. Children’s own perceptions of poverty and inequality, as these shape their well-being and long-term prospects.

  7. Evidence of the growing significance of education, including the ways school systems can increase as well as reduce inequalities.

  8. The potential of social protection programmes in poverty alleviation.

We conclude that since inequalities are multidimensional, so too must be the response. Equitable growth policies, education and health services, underpinned by effective social protection, all have a role to play.

What Inequality means for Children

Evidence from Young Lives

in The International Journal of Children's Rights

Sections

References

AmesP. (2012) ‘Language, Culture and Identity in the Transition to Primary School: Challenges to Indigenous Children’s Rights to Education in PeruInternational Journal of Educational Development32(3) 454464.

BoydenJ. (2009) ‘Risk and Capability in the Context of Adversity: Children’s Contributions to Household Livelihoods’ in Ethiopia. Children Youth and Environments19(2) 111137.

BoydenJ. (2012) ‘Modernity Mobility and the Reshaping of Childhood in the Twenty-first Century: Educational Aspirations and ChallengesKeynote address to British Association for International and Comparative Education ConferenceCambridge September 2012.

BoydenJ. and CrivelloG. (2012) ‘Political Economy, Perception and Social Change as Mediators of Childhood Risk in Andhra Pradesh’ in BoydenJ. and BourdillonM. (eds) Childhood Poverty Multidisciplinary Approaches. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan;

BoydenJ. and DerconS. (2012) Child Development and Economic Development: Lessons and Future Challenges. Oxford: Young Lives.

BoydenJ.PankhurstA. and TafereY. (2012). ‘Child Protection and Harmful Traditional Practices: Female Early Marriage and Genital Modification in EthiopiaDevelopment in Practice22(4) 510522.

CamfieldL. (2011) ‘“From School to Adulthood”? Young People’s Pathways through Schooling in Urban EthiopiaEuropean Journal of Development Research23(5) 679694.

CamfieldL.StreuliN. and WoodheadM. (2009) ‘What’s the use of “well-being” in contexts of child poverty? Approaches to research, monitoring and children’s participation”International Journal of Children’s Rights vol 17 No. 1 pp. 65109.

CamfieldL. and TafereY. (2009). ‘“Children with a Good Life Have to Have School Bags”: Diverse Understandings of Well-being among Older Children in Three Ethiopian Communities Working Paper 37 Oxford: Young Lives.

CamfieldL. and TafereY. (2011) ‘Community Understandings of Childhood Transitions in Ethiopia: Different for Girls?Children’s Geographies19(2) 247262.

CamfieldL. and VennamU. (2012) ‘From Policy to Implementation: An In-depth Exploration of the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme in Andhra Pradesh’ Working Paper 82 Oxford: Young Lives.

CantrilH. (1965) The Pattern of Human Concerns. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.

CrivelloG. and BoydenJ.. (2012) ‘On Childhood and Risk: An Exploration of Children’s Everyday Experiences in Rural PeruChildren and Society.

CrivelloG. and ChutaN. (2012) ‘Rethinking Orphanhood and Vulnerability in EthiopiaDevelopment in Practice22(4) 536548.

CrivelloG.VennamU. and KomanduriA. (2012) ‘Ridiculed for not having anything: Children’s Views on Poverty and Inequality in Rural India’ in BoydenJ. and BourdillonM. (eds) Childhood Poverty: Multidisciplinary Approaches. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.

CrookstonB.PennyM.AlderS.DickersonT.MerrillR.StanfordJ.PorucznikC. and DeardenK. (2010). Children Who Recover from Early Stunting and Children Who Are Not Stunted Demonstrate Similar Levels of Cognition. Journal of Nutrition140(11) 19962001.

CrookstonB.DeardenK.AlderS.PorucznikC.StanfordJ.MerrillR.DickersonT. and PennyM. (2011) ‘Impact of Early and Concurrent Stunting on CognitionMaternal and Child Nutrition7(4) 397409.

CrookstonB.SchottW.CuetoS.DeardenK.EngleP.GeorgiadisA.LundeenE.PennyM.SteinA. and BehrmanJ. (2013) ‘Post-infancy Growth, Schooling, and Cognitive Achievement: Young LivesAmerican Journal of Clinical Nutrition.

CuetoS.EscobalJ.PennyM. and AmesP. (2011a) Tracking Disparities: Who Gets Left Behind? Initial Findings from Peru. Oxford: Young Lives.

CuetoS.LeonJ. and MuñozI. (2011b) ‘Who Gets Ahead? Educational Achievement Gaps Over Time across Four Countriespresentation at UKFIET conferenceOxford September 2011.

CuetoS.LeonJ. J. and MuñozI. (forthcoming 2014) ‘Educational Opportunities, Verbal and Math Achievement for Children in Peru: A Longitudinal Model’ in BoydenJ. A. and BourdillonM. (eds) Growing up in Poverty: Findings from Young Lives. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.

DerconS. (2008) ‘Children and the Food Price Crisis’ Policy Brief 5 Oxford: Young Lives.

DerconS and SanchezA. (2011) ‘Long-term Implications of Under-nutrition on Psychosocial Competencies: Evidence from Four Developing Countries’ Working Paper 72 Oxford: Young Lives.

DerconS. and SinghA. (2011) ‘From Nutrition to Aspirations and Self-Efficacy: Gender Bias over Time among Children in Four Countries’. Working Paper 71 Oxford: Young Lives.

DornanP. (2010) ‘Understanding the Impacts of Crisis on Children in Developing Countries’Round 3 Preliminary FindingsOxford: Young Lives.

DornanP. (2011) ‘Growth, Wealth and Inequality: Evidence from Young Lives’ Policy Paper 5 Oxford: Young Lives.

DornanP. and BoydenJ. (2011) ‘Putting Children at the Centre of Poverty Debates’ Policy Brief 12 Oxford: Young Lives.

DornanP. and Ogando PortelaM. (2014 forthcoming) ‘Do feelings of shame undermine children’s development?’ Working paper Oxford: Young Lives.

dsdsassa and unicef. 2012. The South African Child Support Grant Impact Assessment: Evidence from a survey of children adolescents and their households. Pretoria: UNICEF South Africa.

EngleP.FernaldL.AldermanH.BehrmanJ.O’GaraC.YousafzaiA.Cabral de MelloM.HidroboM.UlkuerN.ErtemI.IltusS. and the Global Child Development  Steering Group (2011) ‘Strategies for Reducing Inequalities and Improving Developmental Outcomes for Young Children in Low-income and Middle-income CountriesThe Lancet378133953.

EscobalJ.AmesP.CuetoS.PennyM. and FloresE. (2008) Young Lives: Peru Round 2 Survey Country Report. Oxford: Young Lives.

European Commission (2010) Social Protection for Inclusive Development: A New Perspective in eu Cooperation with Africa. European Report on Development Brussels: European Commission.

FrostM. and RollestonC. (2013) ‘Improving Education Quality, Equity and Access: A Report on Findings from the Young Lives School Component (Round 1) in Ethiopia’ Working Paper 96 Oxford: Young Lives.

GalabS.KumarV.ReddyP.SinghR. and VennamU. (2011) ‘The Impact of Growth on Childhood Poverty in Andhra Pradesh: Initial Findings from India’ Round 3 Survey Report Oxford: Young Lives.

HeisslerK. and PorterC. (2010) ‘Know Your Place: Ethiopian Children’s Contributions to the Household Economy’ Working Paper 61 Oxford: Young Lives.

HelmersC. and PatnamM. (2009) ‘The Formation and Evolution of Childhood Skill Acquisition: Evidence from India’ Young Lives Working Paper 38 Oxford: Young Lives.

HimazR. (2009a) ‘Is There a Boy Bias in Household Education Expenditure? The Case of Andhra Pradesh in India Based on Young Lives Data’ Working Paper 46 Oxford: Young Lives.

HimazR. (2009b) ‘The Impact of Parental Death on Schooling and Subjective Well-being: Evidence from Ethiopia using Longitudinal Data’ Working Paper 44 Oxford: Young Lives.

ilo (2012). Text of the recommendation concerning national floors of social protection. ILO: Geneva.

JerrimJ. and VignolesA. (2013) ‘Social mobility, regression to the mean and the cognitive development of high ability children from disadvantaged homesJournal of the Royal Statistical Society: Series A (Statistics in Society) Vol. 176 Issue 4 pp. 887906.

KumarV. (2012) ‘Prioritising Nutrition in Order to Achieve the Millennium Development Goals in India. Policy Brief 17Oxford: Young Lives.

LeT.D.NguyenP. N.TranM. C.NguyenV. T. and VoT. S. (2008) ‘Young Lives: Vietnam’ Round 2 Survey Oxford: Young Lives.

LeT.D. (2009) ‘The Effect of Early-age Stunting on Cognitive Achievement among Children in Vietnam’ Working Paper 45 Oxford: Young Lives.

LeT.D.NguyenT.NguyenV. T.MaiT. H. and VuT. T. T. (2011) ‘How Do Children Fare in the New Millennium? Initial Findings from Vietnam’ Round 3 Survey Report Oxford: Young Lives.

LundeenE.BehrmanJ.CrookstonB.DeardenK.EngleP.GeorgiadisG.PennyM. and SteinA.Growth faltering and recovery in children aged 1–8 years in four low- and middle-income countries’ Young Lives Public Health Nutrition Cambridge University Press.

MurrayH. (2010) ‘Early Childhood Care and Education as a Strategy for Poverty Reduction: Evidence from Young Lives’ Policy Brief 9 Oxford: Young Lives.

MurrayH. (2012) ‘Is School Education Breaking the Poverty Cycle for Children? Factors Shaping Education Inequalities in Ethiopia, India, Peru and Vietnam’ Policy Paper 6 Oxford: Young Lives.

OrkinK. (2011) ‘“If God wills … next year I will send her back to school”: The Effects of Child and Parental Illness on School Participation in Rural Ethiopiacreate Pathways to access Research Monograph 60.

OrkinK.YadeteW. and WoodheadM. (2012) ‘Delivering Quality Early Learning in Low-resource Settings: Progress and Challenges in Ethiopia’ Working Papers in Early Childhood Development 59 The Hague: Bernard van Leer Foundation.

OutesI. and PorterC. (2013) Catching Up from Early Nutritional Deficits?Economics & Human Biology Vol. 11 Issue 2 PP. 148163.

PellsK. (2011a) ‘Poverty, Risk and Families’ Responses: Evidence from Young Lives’ Policy Paper 4 Oxford: Young Lives.

PellsK. (2011b) ‘Poverty and Gender Inequalities: Evidence from Young Lives’ Policy Paper 3 Oxford: Young Lives.

PellsK. (2012) ‘Risky Lives: Risk and Protection for Children Growing up in Poverty. Development in Practice22(4) 562573

PorterC. with DornanP. (2010) ‘Social Protection and Children: A Synthesis of Evidence from Young Lives Research in Ethiopia, India and Peru’ Policy Paper 1 Oxford: Young Lives.

RollestonC. and JamesZ. (2011) ‘The Role of Schooling in Skill Development: Evidence from Young Lives in Ethiopia, India, Peru and Vietnam’ Background paper for the Education For All Global Monitoring Report 2012 Paris: UNESCO.

RollestonC. (2012) ‘Value added in Vietnam: Preliminary Findings from the School Survey Data’ Young Lives (internal presentation).

RollestonC.JamesZ.Pasquier-DoumerL. and TamY. (2013) ‘Making Progress: Report of the Young Lives School Survey in Vietnam’ Working Paper 100 Oxford: Young Lives.

SanchezA. (2009) ‘Early Nutrition and Cognitive Achievement in Pre-School Children in Peru’ Working Paper 57 Oxford: Young Lives.

SanfilippoM.de NeubourgC.MartoranoB. (2012) ‘The Impact of Social Protection on Children: A Review of the Literature’ Working paper 2012–06 Florence: UNICEF Office of Research.

Save the Children (2012) ‘“The Future We Want”: Learning from Children’s Experiences of Sustainable DevelopmentLondon: Save the Children UK (paper written by Young Lives for Save the Children).

SchottW.CrookstonB.LundeenE.SteinA. and BehrmanJ. (2013) ‘Periods of child growth up to age 8 years in Ethiopia, India, Peru and Vietnam: Key distal household and community factorsSocial Science and Medicine Vol. 97 pp. 278287.

SinghA.ParkA. and DerconS. (2012) ‘School Meals as a Safety Net: An Evaluation of the Midday Meal Scheme in India’ Working Paper 75 Oxford: Young Lives.

SinghA. (2013) ‘Size and Sources of the Private School Premium in Test Scores in India’ Working Paper 98 Oxford: Young Lives.

StreuliN.VennamU. and WoodheadM. (2011) ‘Increasing Choice or Inequality? Pathways through Early Education in Andhra Pradesh, India’ Working Papers in Early Child Development 58 The Hague: Bernard van Leer Foundation.

StreuliN. (2012) ‘Children’s Experiences of Juntos, a Conditional Cash Transfer Scheme in Peru’ Working Paper 78 Oxford: Young Lives.

TafereY and WoldehannaT. (2012) ‘Beyond Food Security: Transforming the Productive Safety Net Programme in Ethiopia for the Well-being of Children’ Working Paper 83 Oxford: Young Lives.

unicef (2012) Integrated Social Protection Systems Enhancing Equity for Children: unicef social protection strategic framework; UNICEF: New York.

UppalV. (2009) ‘Is the nregs a Safety Net for Children?’ Student Paper Oxford: Young Lives.

WoodheadM.AmesP.VennamU.AbebeW. and StreuliN. (2009) ‘Equity and Quality? Challenges for Early Childhood and Primary Education in Ethiopia, India and Peru’ Working Papers in Early Childhood Development 55 The Hague: Bernard van Leer Foundation.

WoodheadM.FrostM. and JamesZ. (2013) ‘Does Growth in Private Schooling Contribute to Education For All? Evidence from a Longitudinal, Two-cohort Study in Andhra Pradesh, IndiaInternational Journal of Educational Development33(1) 6573.

WoodheadM. and StreuliN. (2013) ‘Early Education For All: Is There a Role for the Private Sector?’ In BrittoP.EngleP. and SuperC. (eds) Handbook of Early Child Development Research and its Impact on Global PolicyNew York: Oxford University Press.

WoodheadMDornanP. and MurrayH. (2013b) ‘What inequality means for childrenOxford: Young Lives.

World Bank (2012) Resilience Equity and Opportunity: The World Bank 2012–2022 Social Protection and Labor StrategyWashington DC: World Bank.

Figures

  • View in gallery

    High levels of stunting are linked to multiple disadvantages (Peru, Younger Cohort, age eight in 2009)

  • View in gallery

    Large differences in the numbers of shocks and adverse events, especially comparing rural versus urban communities (Ethiopia, families of Younger Cohort children, age eight in 2009)

  • View in gallery

    Achievement gap (standard deviations) for cognitive measures (Peru, Younger Cohort, age eight in 2009)

  • View in gallery

    Learning trajectories between five and eight years (Andhra Pradesh, India)

  • View in gallery

    Gaps in maths scores between boys and girls grow with age, but differences do not always favour boys (Younger Cohort age 8 and Older Cohort age 12 and 15)

  • View in gallery

    Differences in maths scores are more marked when combined with other household characteristics rather than gender alone (ap India, Younger Cohort, age eight in 2009)

  • View in gallery

    Children who were stunted at age 1 but physically recovered by age 5 have similar test results as children who were never stunted (Peru, Younger Cohort, age five, 2006)

  • View in gallery

    Gender differences in responsibilities (Ethiopia, Older Cohort, age 12 in 2006)

  • View in gallery

    Feelings of shame reported by 12 year olds, by household expenditure quintile

  • View in gallery

    Growth in private sector schools is associated with gender differences (ap India, Younger and Older Cohorts, 2009 with projections to 2016)

  • View in gallery

    School enrolment by child age for poorest and least-poor household quintiles (ap India, Older Cohort, 2009)

  • View in gallery

    Progress in maths test scores over school year (2011–12) (Vietnam, Younger Cohort, age ten in 2011)

Information

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 43 43 16
Full Text Views 85 85 63
PDF Downloads 6 6 3
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0