Is Anyone Listening? The Impact of Children’s Participation on Public Policy

in The International Journal of Children's Rights
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

Children’s participation has attracted a great deal of attention from academics, policy-makers and practitioners over the past 25 years. This article presents findings from research into the impacts on policy-making from such participation by children in Wales, within the United Kingdom, and Tamil Nadu, in India. The paper considers how the dominant objectives for children’s participation in the uk context can be seen to be helping to ensure that new structures set up to facilitate children’s participation such as youth forums and school councils, have been much more about providing opportunities for children to practice “good” citizenship than about children’s voices being heard and acted upon. This approach is compared with a more “bottom-up” initiative designed to enable children to participate in public decision-making in rural villages in south India. In Tamil Nadu’s Neighbourhood Children’s Parliaments, children aged 6–17 have successfully brought about what they consider to be significant improvements in their living environment. The reasons for these differences are explored and consideration given to some of the factors that work as enablers and inhibitors in children’s voices not only being heard by policy makers and service providers but also being taken into account and given due weight. The paper continues with a discussion on these findings, exploring the extent to which children’s participation may be seen as a means of empowerment or social control and makes some tentative comparisons between experiences in India and Wales before concluding with some thoughts on policy and practice implications.

The term children is used throughout the paper to refer to people under the age of 18 years.

Is Anyone Listening? The Impact of Children’s Participation on Public Policy

in The International Journal of Children's Rights

Sections

References

ArnottM. (2008) “Public Policy, Governance and Participation in the UK: A Space for Children?International Journal of Children’s Rights16: 355367.

BirchS.GottfriedG. and LodgeG. (2013) “Divided democracy: Political inequality in the UK and why it matters” London: IPPR.: http://www.ippr.org/publication/55/11420/divided-democracy-political-inequality-in-the-uk-and-why-it-matters.

BurtonP. (2009) Conceptual, “Theoretical and Practical Issues in Measuring the Benefits of Public Participation”Evaluation15 (3): 263283.

Bryne B. and Lundy L. (2013) “Reconciling Children’s Policy and Children’s Rights: Barriers to Effective Government DeliveryChildren & Society. doi: 10.1111/chso.12045.

CornwallA. (2008) “Unpacking ‘Participation’: models, meanings and practices”Community Development Journal43(3) pp. 269283.

DrakefordM.ScourfieldJ.HollandS. and DaviesA. (2009) “Welsh Children’s Views on Government and ParticipationChildhood16: 247264.

HartR. (1992) Children’s participation: from tokenism to citizenship Innocenti Essays No 4. Florence: UNICEF International Child Development Centre.

JenksC. (2005) Childhood (2nd edn). Abingdon: Routledge.

KingdonJ. (1984) Agendas Alternatives and Public Polices (2nd edn) New York: Harper Collins College.

KirbyP. with BrysonS. (2002) Measuring the MagicLondon: Carnegie Young People’s Trust.

KirbyP.LawsS. and PettittB. (2004) Assessing the Impact of Children’s Participation: A discussion paper (unpublished paper) London: Save the Children UK.

KothariU. (2001) “Power, Knowledge and Social Control in Participatory Development” in CookeB. and KothariU. (eds.) Participation: the new tyranny?London: Zed Books.

LansdownG. (2011) A framework for monitoring and evaluating children’s participation. crin: http://www.crin.org/en/library/news-archive/global-monitoring-and-evaluating-childrens-participation.

LansdownG. (2001) “Children’s Welfare and Children’s Rights” in FoleyP.RocheJ. and TuckerT. (eds.) Children in Society: Contemporary Theory Policy and PracticeBasingstoke: Palgrave (in association with the Open University)

LansdownG. (2006) “International developments in children’s participation: lessons and challenges” in TisdallK.DavisJ. Hill M and Prout A. (eds.) Children Young People and Social Inclusion Participation for What?Bristol: Policy Press.

LuptonC.PeckhamS. and TaylorP. (1998) Managing Public Involvement in Health-Care Purchasing. Bucks: Open University Press.

MacphersonS. (2008) “Reaching the top of the ladder? Locating the voices of excluded young people within the participation debatePolicy and Politics36 (3): 36179.

MatthewsH. (2001) “Citizenship, Youth Councils and Young People’s ParticipationJournal of Youth Studies4 (3): 299319.

MilbourneL. (2009) “Valuing Difference or Securing Compliance? Working to involve young people in Community SettingsChildren and Society23 pp. 347363.

NewmanJ.BarnesM.SullivanH. and KnopsA. (2004) “Public Participation and Collaborative GovernanceJournal of Social Policy33 (2) 203223.

Percy-SmithB. and ThomasN. (2009) “Conclusion: Emerging themes and new directions” in Percy-SmithB. and ThomasN. (eds) Handbook of Children’s ParticipationLondon: Routledge.

Percy-SmithB. (2007) Evaluating the development of young people’s participation plans in two Children’s Trusts (Interim Report Year 1)Leceister: National Youth Agency.

PopkewitzT.S. and BlochM. (2000) “Administering freedom: a history of present – rescuing the parent to rescue the child for society” in DahlbergG. and HultqvistK. (eds) The Changing Child in a Changing World: current ways of thinking and practising childhoodNew York: Routledge.

ProutA. (2000) “Children’s Participation: Control and Realisation in British Late Modernity”Children and Society14(4): 30415.

ProutA. (2003) “Participation, policy and childhood” in HalletC. and ProutA. (eds.) Hearing the Voices of Children: social policy for the new centuryLondon: Routledge Farmer.

QvortrupJ. (2003) “Sociological Perspectives on Childhood” in VerhellenE. and WeytsA. (eds.) Understanding Children’s Rights: Collected papers presented at the sixth international interdisciplinary course on Children’s Rights. Ghent: University of Ghent.

RothermundD. (2009) India: the Rise of the Asian Giant. London: Yale University Press.

Save the Children (2005) Practice Standards in Children’s Participation: http://www.savethechildren.org.uk/en/54_3169.htm.

Save the Children (2006) National Standards for Children and Young People’s Participation (Wales): http://www.savethechildren.org.uk/en/docs/wales_nat_standard.pdf.

ShierH. (2010) “Navigating the Tensions”Children and Society24: 2437.

SinclairR. (2004) “Participation in practice: making it meaningful, effective and sustainableChildren and Society18 (2): 106118.

ShawI. and Shaw. A. (1997) “Keeping Social Work Honest: Evaluating as profession and Practice”British Journal of Social Work27 (6): 847869.

TaylorM. (2007) Community Participation in the Real World: Opportunities and pitfalls in New Governance SpacesUrban Studies44 (2): 297317.

ThomasN. and CrowleyA. (2007) “Children’s Rights and Well-being in Wales in 2006”Contemporary Wales19: 16179.

ThomasN. and O’Kane C. (1998) “The Ethics of Participatory Research with ChildrenChildren and Society12: 336348.

ThoratS. (2009) Dalits in IndiaNew Delhi: Sage

TisdallE.K.M.DavisJ. and GallagherM. (2008) “Reflecting on Children and Young People’s Participation in the UKInternational Journal of Child Rights16: 343354.

TobinJ. (2011) “Understanding a Human Rights Based Approach to Matters Involving Children: Conceptual Foundations and Strategic Considerations” in InvernizziA. and WilliamsJ. (eds.) The Human Rights of Children: from Visions to Implementation. Farnham: Ashgate.

TresederP. (1997) Empowering Children and Young People: A Training Manual. London: Save the Children and the Child Rights Development Unit.

Information

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 30 30 13
Full Text Views 73 73 47
PDF Downloads 5 5 5
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0