Children’s Wellbeing and Children’s Rights in Tension?
In: The International Journal of Children's RightsChildren’s wellbeing has moved from an academic field of interest to a policy and practice framework, internationally and in many countries. Children’s wellbeing tends to be twinned casually with children’s rights but recent Scottish legislation – the Children and Young People (Scotland) Act 2014 – has put children’s rights and children’s wellbeing in tension. This provides an opportunity to consider the concepts critically. The article scrutinises parliamentary debates and accompanying submissions, to reveal that children’s rights arguments failed due to political concerns about litigation and a lack of evidence that children’s rights improved children’s lives. Children’s wellbeing arguments were more successful, as children’s wellbeing continues the familiar trajectory of a needs-based approach. It has additional benefits of maximising outcomes, emphasising early intervention and prevention, and statistical development. It also risks being apolitical and professionally-driven, with no minimum standards and limited recourse for children’s and their families’ rights and complaints. These findings raise broader questions about how to argue for children’s rights in national and global contexts where children’s wellbeing has ever-increasing prominence, fuelled by calls for evidence-based policy and accountability via outcomes.
Purchase
Buy instant access (PDF download and unlimited online access):
Institutional Login
Log in with Open Athens, Shibboleth, or your institutional credentials
Personal login
Log in with your brill.com account
-
Ben-Arieh A., “Where are the children? Children’s role in measuring and monitoring their well-being”, Social Indicators Research 74 (2005): 573–96.
-
Ben-Arieh A., et al., “Multifaceted Concept of Child Well-Being” in Handbook of Child Well-Being, ed. Ben-Arieh A.et al. (Dordrecht: Springer, 2014).
-
Bradshaw J., , “Overview: Social Policies and Child Well-Being” in Handbook of Child Well-Being, ed. Ben-Arieh A.et al. (Dordrecht: Springer, 2014).
-
Bradshaw J., , Hoelscher P., and Richardson D., “An Index of Child Well-Being in the European Union”, Social Indicators Research 80(1) (2007): 133–177.
-
Camfield L., , Streuli N., and Woodhead M., “What the Use of ‘Well-Being’ in Contexts of Child Poverty? Approaches to Research, Monitoring and Children’s Participation”, International Journal of Children’s Rights 17(1) (2009): 65–109.
-
Children’s Parliament, Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill (Edinburgh: Education and Culture Committee, Scottish Parliament, 2013).
-
Christie Commission, Commission on the Future Delivery of Public Services (Edinburgh: Scottish Government, 2011).
-
cosla, Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill (Edinburgh: Education and Culture Committee, Scottish Parliament, 2013).
-
Davis J. M., Integrated Children’s Services (London: Sage, 2011).
-
Doek J. E., , “Child Well-Being: Children’s Rights Perspective” in Handbook of Child Well-Being, ed. Ben-Arieh A.et al. (Dordrecht: Springer, 2014).
-
Dworkin R., Taking Rights Seriously (Boston ma: Harvard University Press, 1979).
-
Education and Culture Committee, Scottish Parliament, Stage 1 Report on the Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill (Edinburgh: Scottish Parliament, 2013), http://www.scottish.parliament.uk/S4_EducationandCultureCommittee/Reports/edR-13-11w.pdf.
-
Education and Culture Committee, Scottish Parliament, Official Report 25.6.13 (Edinburgh: Scottish Parliament, 2013).
-
Education and Culture Committee, Scottish Parliament, Official Report 3.9.13 (Edinburgh: Scottish Parliament, 2013).
-
Education and Culture Committee, Scottish Parliament, Official Report 17.9.13 (Edinburgh: Scottish Parliament, 2013).
-
Education and Culture Committee, Scottish Parliament, Official Report 1.10.13 (Edinburgh: Scottish Parliament, 2013).
-
Education and Culture Committee, Scottish Parliament, Official Report 8.10.13 (Edinburgh: Scottish Parliament, 2013).
-
Education and Culture Committee, Scottish Parliament, Official Report 17.12.13 (Edinburgh: Scottish Parliament, 2013).
-
Education and Culture Committee, Scottish Parliament, Official Report 7.1.14 (Edinburgh: Scottish Parliament, 2014).
-
Elsley S., , Tisdall E. K. M., and Davidson E., Children and young people’s experiences of, and views on, issues relating to the implementation of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (Edinburgh: Scottish Government, 2013).
-
Farrell A., , Tisdall E. K.M and Kagan, S. L. (eds), Sage Handbook of Early Childhood Research (London: Sage, 2015).
-
Faculty of Advocates, Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill (Edinburgh: Education and Culture Committee, Scottish Parliament, 2013).
-
Freeman M. D. A., The Rights and Wrongs of Children (London: Frances Pinter, 1983).
-
Grek S., “Expert moves: international comparative testing and the rise of expertocracy”, Journal of Education Policy 28(5) (2013): 695–709.
-
Hanson K., and Nieuwenhuys O., “Living rights, social justice, translations” in Reconceptualizing Children’s Rights in International Development, ed K. Hanson and O. Nieuwenhuys (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2012).
-
Harris-Short S., “International human rights law: imperialist, inept and ineffective? Cultural relativism and the un Convention on the Rights of the Child”, Human Rights Quarterly 25(1) (2003): 130–181.
-
Government Local, and Committee Regeneration, , Parliament Scottish, Official Report 4.9.13 (Edinburgh: Local Government and Regeneration Committee, Scottish Parliament, 2013).
-
Lundy L., , “United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child and Child-Wellbeing” in Handbook of Child Well-Being, ed. Ben-Arieh A.et al. (Dordrecht: Springer, 2014).
-
Lundy L.et al., The un Convention on the Rights of the Child: a study of legal implementation in 12 countries (London: unicef uk, 2012).
-
Melton G., “‘ Because it’s the Right (or Wrong) Thing to Do’: When Children’s Well-Being Is the Wrong Outcome” in Handbook of Child Well-Being, ed. A. Ben-Arieh et al. (Dordrecht: Springer, 2014).
-
Monaghan K., “Early Child Development Policy: The Colonization of the World’s Childrearing Practices?” in Childhoods at the Intersection of the Local and the Global, ed. A. T. Imoh and R. Ame (Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, 2012), 56.
-
Morrow V., and Mayall B., “What is wrong with children’s well-being in the uk? Questions of meaning and measurement”, Journal of Social Welfare and Family Law 31(3) (2009): 217–229.
-
Norrie K.McK., Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill (Edinburgh: Education and Culture Committee, Scottish Parliament, 2013).
-
Pawson R., Evidence-based Policy: A realistic perspective (London: Sage, 2006).
-
Reading R.et al., “Promotion of children’s rights and prevention of child maltreatment”, Lancet 373 (2009): 332–343.
-
Scottish Government and CoSLA, Concordat between the Scottish Government and local government (Edinburgh: Scottish Government, 2007).
-
Scottish Government, A guide to getting it right for every child (Edinburgh: Scottish Government, 2008).
-
Scottish Government, Consultation on the Rights of Children and Young People Bill (Edinburgh: Scottish Government, 2011).
-
Scottish Government, Consultation on the Rights of Children and Young People: Scottish Government Response (Edinburgh: Scottish Government, 2012).
-
Scottish Government, The 5th uk Government Report to the un Committee on the Rights of the Child Scottish Government Submission (Edinburgh: Scottish Government 2013a).
-
Scottish Government, uncrc: The foundation of getting it right for every child (Edinburgh: Scottish Government, 2013b).
-
Scottish Government, Draft Statutory Guidance on Parts 18, Section 96 (Wellbeing) 4 (Named Person), and 5 (Child’s Plan) of the Children and Young People (Scotland) Act 2014 (Edinburgh: Scottish Government, 2015).
-
Scottish Parliament, Official Report 21.11.13 (Edinburgh: Scottish Parliament, 2013).
-
Scottish Parliament, Official Report 19.2.14 (Edinburgh: Scottish Parliament, 2014).
-
Statham J., and Chase E., Childhood Wellbeing: A brief overview (England: Children’s Wellbeing Research Centre, 2010).
-
Stradling B., and Alexander B., “Getting it right for children: promoting effective change” in Children’s Services: Working Together, ed. M. Hill et al. (Harlow: Pearson Publishing, 2012).
-
Stradling B., , MacNeil M., and Berry H., Changing professional practice and culture to get it right for every child (Edinburgh: Scottish Government, 2009).
-
Sutherland E., Supplementary Evidence in respect of the Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill (Edinburgh: Education and Culture Committee, Scottish Parliament, 2013).
-
Tag M., , “Universalizing Early Childhood: History, Forms and Logics” in Childhoods at the Intersection of the Local and the Global, ed. Imoh A. T., and Ame R. (Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, 2012), 34.
-
Tisdall E. K. M., and Davis J. M., “Children’s Rights and Wellbeing: tensions within the Children and Young People (Scotland) Act 2014” in Enhancing the Rights and Wellbeing of Children: Connecting Research, Policy and Practice, ed. A. Smith (Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, 2015).
-
Tisdall K., and Plows V., Children in need: examining its use in practice and reflecting on its currency for proposed policy changes (Edinburgh: Scottish Executive, 2007).
-
Tisdall E. K. M., The Children (Scotland) Act 1995: Developing Policy and Law for Scotland’s Children (Edinburgh: The Stationery Office, 1997).
-
Tisdall E. K. M., , “Children should be seen and heard? Children and young people’s participation in the uk” in Children and Young People’s Participation and Its Transformative Potential, ed. Tisdall E. K. M., , Gadda A. M., and Butler U. M. (Basingstoke: Palgrave, 2014), 168.
-
Together, State of Children’s Rights in Scotland Report 2014 (Edinburgh: Together, 2014).
-
un Committee on the Rights of the Child, General Comment No. 5 General measures of implementation of the Convention on the Rights of the Child (2003), http://tbinternet.ohchr.org/_layouts/treatybodyexternal/Download.aspx?symbolno=crc%2fgc%2f2003%2f5&Lang=en.
-
unicef uk, Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill (Edinburgh: Education and Culture Committee, Scottish Parliament, 2013a).
-
unicef uk, Supplementary Evidence Education and Culture Committee, Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill (Edinburgh: ECC Scottish Parliament, 2013b).
-
Wells K., Childhood in a Global Perspective, 2nd Edition (Cambridge: Polity Press, 2015).
-
World Health Organisation, Preamble to the Constitution of the World Health Organization as adopted by the International Health Conference, New York, 19–22 June 1946; signed on 22 July 1946 by the representatives of 61 States (Official Records of the World Health Organization, no. 2, p. 100) and entered into force on 7 April 1948. (1946).
-
Young M., “Converting the Science of Early Human Development into Action – Closing the Gap between What We Know and What We Do” in Sage Handbook of Early Childhood Research, ed. A. Farrell, S. L. Kagan and E.K.M. Tisdall (London: Sage, 2015).
| All Time | Past Year | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 1437 | 458 | 44 |
| Full Text Views | 925 | 301 | 15 |
| PDF Views & Downloads | 1093 | 734 | 45 |
Children’s Wellbeing and Children’s Rights in Tension?
In: The International Journal of Children's RightsChildren’s wellbeing has moved from an academic field of interest to a policy and practice framework, internationally and in many countries. Children’s wellbeing tends to be twinned casually with children’s rights but recent Scottish legislation – the Children and Young People (Scotland) Act 2014 – has put children’s rights and children’s wellbeing in tension. This provides an opportunity to consider the concepts critically. The article scrutinises parliamentary debates and accompanying submissions, to reveal that children’s rights arguments failed due to political concerns about litigation and a lack of evidence that children’s rights improved children’s lives. Children’s wellbeing arguments were more successful, as children’s wellbeing continues the familiar trajectory of a needs-based approach. It has additional benefits of maximising outcomes, emphasising early intervention and prevention, and statistical development. It also risks being apolitical and professionally-driven, with no minimum standards and limited recourse for children’s and their families’ rights and complaints. These findings raise broader questions about how to argue for children’s rights in national and global contexts where children’s wellbeing has ever-increasing prominence, fuelled by calls for evidence-based policy and accountability via outcomes.
| All Time | Past Year | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 1437 | 458 | 44 |
| Full Text Views | 925 | 301 | 15 |
| PDF Views & Downloads | 1093 | 734 | 45 |