We evaluate Peter Adler’s challenge to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (cdc) draft recommendations on male circumcision (this issue, see pp. 237–262). The cdc advocates elective male circumcision (mc) to improve public health in the usa based on strong scientific evidence. In marked contrast to the cdc, Adler’s criticisms depend on speculative claims and obfuscation of the scientific data. Adler’s central argument that circumcision in infancy should be delayed to allow a boy to make up his own mind as an adult fails to appreciate that circumcision later in life is a more complex operation, entails higher risk, is more likely to involve general anaesthesia and presents financial, psychological and organisational barriers. These limitations are avoided by circumcision early in infancy, when it is convenient, safe, quick, low risk, usually involves local anaesthesia and provides benefits immediately. Benefits of male circumcision include: protection against: urinary tract infections that are ten times higher in uncircumcised infants; inflammatory skin conditions; other foreskin problems; sexually transmitted infections and genital cancers in the male and his female sexual partners. Circumcision during infancy is also associated with faster healing and improved cosmetic outcomes. Circumcision does not impair sexual function or pleasure. Some authorities regard the failure to offer circumcision as unethical, just as it would be unethical to fail to encourage paediatric vaccination. Since the benefits vastly outweigh the risks, each intervention is in the best interests of the child. In conclusion, Adler’s criticisms of the cdc’s evidence-based male circumcision policy are flawed scientifically, ethically and legally, and should be dismissed as endangering public health and individual well-being.
Adam & Eve. “AdamAndEve.com asks women: Do you prefer a circumcised or uncircumcised penis?”: http://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/adamandevecom-asks-women-do-you-prefer-a-circumcised-or-uncircumcised-penis-246386151.html. Adam & Eve, Hillsborough, North Carolina, usa. (2014).
AdlerP. W., “Is it lawful to use Medicaid to pay for circumcision?”, J. Law. Med.19 (2011), 335–353.
AuvertB., TaljaardD., LagardeE., Sobngwi-TambekouJ., SittaR. and PurenA., “Randomized, controlled intervention trial of male circumcision for reduction of hiv infection risk: The anrs 1265 Trial”, ploS Med.2(e298) (2005), 1112–1122.
BaileyR. C., MosesS., ParkerC. B., AgotK., MacleanI., KriegerJ. N., WilliamsC. F., CampbellR. T. and Ndinya-AcholaJ. O. “Male circumcision for hiv prevention in young men in Kisumu, Kenya: a randomised controlled trial”, Lancet369 (2007), 643–656.
BalciM., TuncelA., BaranI., GuzelO., KetenT., AksuN. and AtanA., “High-risk oncogenic human papilloma virus infection of the foreskin and microbiology of smegma in prepubertal boys”, Urology86 (2015), 368–372.
BatesM. J., ZieglerJ. B., KennedyS. E., MindelA., WodakA. D., ZolothL. S., TobianA. A. R. and MorrisB. J., “Recommendation by a law body to ban infant male circumcision has serious worldwide implications for pediatric practice and human rights”, bmc Pediatr.13(Article ) (2013), 1–9.
CastellsagueX., BoschF. X., MunozN., MeijerC. J., ShahK. V., de SanjoseS., Eluf-NetoJ., NgelangelC. A., ChichareonS., SmithJ. S., HerreroR., MorenoV., FranceschiS. and International Agency for Research on Cancer Multicenter Cervical Cancer Study Group, “Male circumcision, penile human papillomavirus infection, and cervical cancer in female partners”, N. Engl. J. Med.346 (2002), 1105–1112.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, “Neonatal herpes simplex virus infection following Jewish ritual circumcisions that included direct orogenital suction – New York City, 2000–2011”, mmwr Morb. Mortal Wkly. Rep.61 (2012), 404–409.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, “Recommendations for Providers Counseling Male Patients and Parents Regarding Male Circumcision and the Prevention of hiv Infection, stis, and Other Health Outcomes”, Docket No. cdc-2014-0012:http://www.regulations.gov/-!documentDetail;D=cdc-2014-0012-0002 (2014).
ChemtobD., Op de CoulE., Van SighemA., MorZ., CazeinF. and SemailleC., “Impact of male circumcision among heterosexual hiv cases: comparison between three low prevalence countries”, Isr. J. Health Policy Res.4 (2015), article 36: 31–38.
CherpesT. L., MeyneL. A., KrohnM. A. and HillerS. L., “Risk factors for infection with herpes simplex virus type 2: Role of smoking, douching, uncircumcised males, and vaginal flora”, Sex. Transm. Dis.30 (2003), 405–410.
Cornell University Law School, Legal Information Institute, 18 U.S. Code 116 – Female genital mutilation: https://http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/116 (2013).
Cortés-GonzálezJ. R., Arratia-MaqueoJ. A. and Gómez-GuerraL. S., “[Does circumcision has an effect on female’s perception of sexual satisfaction?] (article in Spanish)”, Rev. Invest. Clin.60 (2008), 227–230.
Cortés-GonzálezJ. R., Arratia-MaqueoJ. A., Martínez-MontelongoR. and Gómez-GuerraL. S., “[Does circumcision affect male’s perception of sexual satisfaction?]” (article in Spanish), Arch. Esp. Urol.62 (2009), 733–736.
DalingJ. R., MadeleineM. M., JohnsonL. G., SchwartzS. M., SheraK. A., WurscherM. A., CarterJ. J., PorterP. L., GallowayD. A., McDougallJ. K. and KriegerJ. N., “Penile cancer: importance of circumcision, human papillomavirus and smoking in in situ and invasive disease”, Int. J.116 (2005), 606–616.
El BcheraouiC., ZhangX., CooperC. S., RoseC. E., KilmarxP. H. and ChenR. T., “Rates of adverse events associated with male circumcision in us medical settings, 2001 to 2010”, jama Pediatr.168 (2014), 625–634.
FindLawAmstrong v. State. Supreme Court of Montana. No. 98–066. Decided 26 October 1999: http://caselaw.findlaw.com/mt-supreme-court/1489482.html (1999).
FrischM., AigrainY., BarauskasV., BjarnasonR., BoddyS.-A., CzaudernaP., de GierR. P. E., de Jong, T. P. V. M., FaschingG., FetterW., GahrM., GraugaardC., GreisenG., GunnarsdottirA., HartmannW., HavranekP., HitchcockR., HuddartS., JansonS., JaszczakP., KupferschmidC., Lahdes-VasamaT., LindahlH., MacDonaldN., MarkestadT., MärtsonM., NordhovS. M., PälveH., PetersonsA., QuinnF., QvistN., RosmundssonT., SaxenH., SöderM., StehrM., von LoewenichV. C. H., WallanderJ. and WijnenR., “Cultural bias in the aap’s 2012 technical report and policy statement on male circumcision”, Pediatrics131 (2013) 796–800.
GrayR., KigoziG., KongX., SsempiijaV., MakumbiF., WattyaS., SerwaddaD., NalugodaF., SewenkamboN. K. and WawerM. J., “The effectiveness of male circumcision for hiv prevention and effects on risk behaviors in a post-trial follow up study in Rakai, Uganda”, aids26 (2012), 609–615.
GrayR. H., KigoziG., SerwaddaD., MakumbiF., WatyaS., NalugodaF., KiwanukaN., MoultonL. H., ChaudharyM. A., ChenM. Z., SewankamboN. K., Wabwire-MangenF., BaconM. C., WilliamsC. F., OpendiP., ReynoldsS. J., LaeyendeckerO., QuinnT. C. and WawerM. J., “Male circumcision for hiv prevention in men in Rakai, Uganda: a randomised trial”, Lancet369 (2007), 657–666.
Habous, M., Tealab, A., Williamson, B, Binsaleh, S., El Dawy, S., Mahmoud, S., Abdelwahab, O., Nassar, M., Mulhall, J. P., Veale, D. and Muir, G., “Erect penile dimensions in a cohort of 778 Middle Eastern men: establishment of a nomogram.” J. Sex. Med. 12 (2015), 1402–1406.
HammondT., “A preliminary poll of men circumcised in infancy or childhood”, bju Int.83(suppl 1) (1999), 85–92.
HobermanA., WaldE. R., HickeyR. W., BaskinM., CharronM., MajdM., KearneyD. H., ReynoldsE. A., RuleyJ. and JanoskyJ. E., “Oral versus initial intravenous therapy for urinary tract infections in young febrile children”, Pediatrics104 (Pt 1) (1999), 79–86.
KigoziG., LukabweI., KagaayiJ., WawerM. J., NantumeB., KigoziG., NalugodaF., KiwanukaN., Wabwire-MangenF., SerwaddaD., RidzonR., BuwemboD., NabukenyaD., WatyaS., LutaloT., NkaleJ. and GrayR. H., “Sexual satisfaction of women partners of circumcised men in a randomized trial of male circumcision in Rakai, Uganda”, bju Int.104 (2009), 1698–1701.
KigoziG., WatyaS., PolisC. B., BuwemboD., KiggunduV., WawerM. J., SerwaddaD., NalugodaF., KiwanukaN., BaconM. C., SsempijjaV., MakumbiF. and GrayR .H., “The effect of male circumcision on sexual satisfaction and function, results from a randomized trial of male circumcision for human immunodeficiency virus prevention, Rakai, Uganda”, bju Int.101 (2008), 65–70.
KriegerJ. N., MehtaS. D., BaileyR. C., AgotK., Ndinya-AcholaJ. O., ParkerC. and MosesS., “Adult male circumcision: Effects on sexual function and sexual satisfaction in Kisumu, Kenya”, J. Sex Med.5 (2008), 2610–2622.
LeiJ. H., LiuL. R., WeiQ., YanS. B., YangL., SongT. R., YuanH. C., LvX. and HanP., “Circumcision status and risk of hiv acquisition during heterosexual intercourse for both males and females: A meta-analysis”, PLoS One10 (2015), .
LiuC. M., HungateB. A., TobianA. A., RavelJ., ProdgerJ. L., SerwaddaD., KigoziG., GaliwangoR. M., NalugodaF., KeimP., WawerM. J., PriceL. B. and GrayR. H., “Penile microbiota and female partner bacterial vaginosis in Rakai, Uganda”, mbio6 (2015), .
LiuC. M., HungateB. A., TobianA. A. R., SerwaddaD., RavelJ., LesterR., KigoziG., AzizM., GaliwangoR. M., NalugodaF., Contente-CuomoT. L., WawerM. J., KeimP., GrayR. H. and PriceL. B., “Male circumcision significantly reduces prevalence and load of genital anaerobic bacteria”, Mbio4 (2013), 1–9.
MoretonS. (2014), “Debunking anticircumcision pseudoscience”. An annotated version of the National Coalition for Men’s letter to the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation: http://www.quackdown.info/article/debunking-anti-circumcision-pseudoscience/.
MorrisB. J., BaileyR. C., KlausnerJ. D., LeibowitzA., WamaiR. G., WaskettJ. H., BanerjeeJ., HalperinD. T., ZolothL., WeissH. A. and HankinsC. A., “Review: a critical evaluation of arguments opposing male circumcision for hiv prevention in developed countries”, aids Care24 (2012a), 1565–1575.
MorrisB. J., BailisS. A. and WiswellT. E., “Circumcision rates in the United States: Rising or falling? What effect might the new affirmative pediatric policy statement have?”, Mayo Clin. Proc.89 (2014), 677–686.
MorrisB. J. and CastellsagueX. (2011), “The role of circumcision in preventing stis”, Sexually Transmitted Infections and Sexually Transmitted Diseases, Gross, G. E. and Tyring, S. K. (eds), Berlin and Heidelberg, Springer-Verlag.2011
MorrisB. J., GrayR. H., CastellsagueX., BoschF. X., HalperinD. T., WaskettJ. H. and HankinsC. A., “The strong protection afforded by circumcision against cancer of the penis (Invited Review)”, Adv. Urol. (Article id 812368) (2011), 1–21.
MorrisB. J., TobianA. A. R., HankinsC. A., KlausnerJ. D., BanerjeeJ., BailisS. A., MosesS. and WiswellT. E., “Veracity and rhetoric in pediatric medicine: A critique of Svoboda and Van Howe’s response to the aap policy on infant male circumcision”, J. Med. Ethics40 (2013), 463–470.
MorrisB. J., WaskettJ. H., BanerjeeJ., WamaiR. G., TobianA. A. R., GrayR. H., BailisS. A., BaileyR. C., KlausnerJ. D., WillcourtR. J., HalperinD. T., WiswellT. E. and MindelA., “A ‘snip’ in time: what is the best age to circumcise?”, bmc Pediatr
. 12 (article 20) (2012b), 1–15.
MorrisB. J., WodakA. D., MindelA., SchrieberL., DugganK. A., DillyA., WillcourtR. J. and CooperD. A., “The 2010 Royal Australasian College of Physicians policy statement ‘Circumcision of infant males’ is not evidence based”, Intern. Med. J.42 (2012d), 822–828.
MorrisB. J., WodakA. D., MindelA., SchrieberL., DugganK. A., DillyA., WillcourtR. J., CooperD. A., LumbersE. R., RussellC. T. and LeederS. R., “Infant male circumcision: An evidence-based policy statement”, Open J
Prevent. Med.2 (2012e), 79–82.
NelsonD. E., DongQ., Van der PolB., TohE., FanB., KatzB. P., MiD., RongR., WeinstockG. M., SodergrenE. and FortenberryJ. D., “Bacterial communities of the coronal sulcus and distal urethra of adolescent males”, ploS One7 (2012), .
RothJ. D., KeenanA. C., CarrollA. E., RinkR. C., CainM. P., WhittamB. M. and BennettW. E.Jr., “Readmission characteristics of elective pediatric circumcisions using large-scale administrative data”, J. Pediatr. Urol
. 12 (2015), 27. e1–6.
Royal Dutch Medical Association (knmg), “Non-therapeutic circumcision of male minors. Utrecht: Royal Dutch Medical Association (knmg)”, (2010): http://knmg.artsennet.nl/Publicaties/knmgpublicatie/Nontherapeutic-circumcision-of-male-minors-2010.htm.
RushtonH. G. and MajdM., “Dimercaptosuccinic acid renal scintigraphy for the evaluation of pyelonephritis and scarring: a review of experimental and clinical studies”, J. Urol.148 (Pt 2) (1992a), 1726–1732.
SchoenE. J., “Critique of Van Howe rs. Incidence of meatal stenosis following neonatal circumcision in a primary care setting. Clin Pediatr (Phila) 2006;45:49–54”, Clin. Paediatr. (Phila)46 (2007), 86.
SimforooshN., TabibiA., KhaliliS. A., SoltaniM. H., AfjehiA., AalamiF. and BodoohiH., “Neonatal circumcision reduces the incidence of asymptomatic urinary tract infection: A large prospective study with long-term follow up using Plastibell”, J. Pediatr. Urol.8 (2012), 320–323.
Singh-GrewalD., MacdessiJ. and CraigJ., “Circumcision for the prevention of urinary tract infections in boys: a systematic review of randomized trials and observational studies”, Arch. Dis. Child.90 (2005), 853–858.
SmithD. K., TaylorA., KilmarxP. H., SullivanP., WarnerL., KambM., BockN., KohmescherB. and MastroT. D., “Male circumcision in the United States for the prevention of hiv infection and other adverse health outcomes: Report from a cdc consultation”, Public Health Reports125(Suppl 1) (2010), 72–82.
SvobodaJ. S., “A treatise from the trenches: Why are circumcision lawsuits so hard to win?”, Circumcision and Human Rights: http://download.springer.com/static/pdf/912/bokpercent3A978-1-4020-9167-4.pdf?originUrl=httppercent3Apercent2Fpercent2Flink.springer.compercent2Fbook percent2F10.1007percent2F978-1-4020-9167-4&token2=exp=1453860990~acl=percent2Fstaticpercent2Fpdfpercent2F912percent2Fbokpercent3A978-1-4020-9167-4.pdfpercent3ForiginUrlpercent3Dhttppercent3Apercent2Fpercent2Flink.springer.compercent2Fbookpercent2F10.1007percent2F978-1-4020-9167-4*~hmac=0826f2d67cc6fa12853c95dcfb0746a811b9a518f18dea501235686b2a7e2ad8 in DennistonG., HodgesF., MilosM., FayreM. (eds), Berlin, Germany, Springer. (2009), 201–217.
TaddioA., ChambersC. T., HalperinS. A., IppM., LockettD., RiederM. J. and ShahV., “Inadequate pain management during routine childhood immunizations: the nerve of it”, Clin. Ther.31 (Suppl 2) (2009), S152–S167.
TaddioA., StevensB., CraigK., RastogiP., BendavidS., ShennanA., MulliganP. and KorenG., “Efficacy and safety of lidocaine-prilocaine cream for pain during circumcision”, N. Engl. J. Med.336 (1997b), 1197–1201.
United Nations Human Rights Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights, Convention on the Rights of the Child. 44/25, 20 November 1989: http://www.ohchr.org/en/professionalinterest/pages/crc.aspx. Retrieved from: http://www.un.org/documents/ga/res/44/a44r025.htm.
WamaiR. G. et al., “Male circumcision for protection against hiv infection in sub-Saharan Africa: the evidence in favour justifies the implementation now in progress”, Glob. Public Health10 (2015), 639–666.
WamaiR. G. et al., “Male circumcision is an efficacious, lasting and cost-effective strategy for combating hiv in high-prevalence aids epidemics: Time to move beyond debating the science”, Future hiv Ther. 2 (2008), 399–405.