Breaking Down Boundaries: Voice and Participation in English Primary Education

in The International Journal of Children's Rights
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?


Pupil voice and active participation form two central elements of international Human Rights Education (hre) provisions. This article draws upon empirical research conducted in primary schools across England to gauge the nature and extent of these processes at classroom and school level and to understand better the reasons for apparent deficiencies in their practice. It argues that whilst there is good practice regarding both concepts, they are nevertheless constrained within tightly controlled boundaries. The underlying reasons for these constraints – including concerns about loss of control and reservations about the value and efficacy of school councils – are explored by drawing upon data from qualitative interviews with teachers. Suggestion is made that in order to break down the boundaries that currently restrict voice and participation, teachers need to become comfortable with the idea of rights respecting learning environments and this will only happen through the provision of hre in their own teacher training.

Breaking Down Boundaries: Voice and Participation in English Primary Education

in The International Journal of Children's Rights



AldersonP. and GoodwinM.Contradictions within Concepts of Children’s Competence”The International Journal of Children’s Rights 1993 (1) 303313.

AldersonP.Human Rights and Democracy in Schools: Do They Mean More Than Simply “Picking Up Litter and Not Killing Whales”?”The International Journal of Children’s Rights 1999 (7) 185205.

AldersonP.School Students’ Views on School Councils and Daily Life at School”Children and Society 2000 (14(2)) 121134.

AndersonC. C. “Human Rights in Elementary and Middle Schools” in M. S. Branson and J. Torney Purta (eds.) International Human Rights Society and the Schools (National Council for the Social Studies: Washington dc 1982) 49–59.

AppleM. W. and BeaneJ. A. “The Case for Democratic Schools” in M. W. Apple and J. A. Beane (eds.) Democratic Schools: Lessons from the Chalk Face (Open University Press: Buckingham 1999) 1–28.

ArnsteinS. R.Eight Rungs on the Ladder of Citizen Participation”Journal of The American Institute of Planners 1969 (35(4)) 216224.

AudigierF.Basic Concepts and Core Competencies for Education for Democratic Citizenship (Council of Europe: Strasbourg2000) (dgiv/edu/cit (2000) 23).

BanksJ. A. “Foreword” in M. S. Branson and J. Torney Purta (eds.) International Human Rights Society and the Schools (National Council for the Social Studies: Washington dc 1982) viii–x.

BrownD.Implementing Citizenship Education in a Primary School” in OslerA. (ed.) Citizenship and Democracy in Schools: Diversity Identity Equality (Trentham Books: Stoke-on-Trent2000) 113124.

CairnsL.Investing in Children: Learning How to Promote the Rights of all Children”Children & Society 2001 (15) 347360.

CarterC. and OslerA.Human Rights, Identities and Conflict Management: A Study of School Culture through Classroom Relationships”Cambridge Journal of Education 2000 (30(3)) 335356.

DavidP.Implementing the Rights of the Child: Six Reasons Why the Human Rights of Children Remain a Constant Challenge”International Review of Education 2002 (48(3/4)) 259263.

De WinterM.Children as Fellow Citizens: Participation and Commitment (Radcliffe Medical Press: Oxford1997).

Department for Education and Skills Building a Culture of Participation: Involving children and young people in policy service planning delivery and evaluation (2003).

Department for Education Statistical First Release School Workforce in England: November 2012 (30 April 2013) (sfr 15/2013).

Department for Education Statutory framework for the early years foundation stage: Setting the standards for learning and care for children from birth to five (March 2014).

DevineD. “Children: Rights and status in education – a socio-historical analysis” Irish Educational Studies 1999 (18(1)) 1428.

DevineD.Children’s Citizenship and the Structuring of Adult-Child Relations in the Primary School”Childhood 2002 (9(3)) 303320.

EekelaarJ.The emergence of children’s rights”Oxford Journal of Legal Studies 1986 (6) 161182.

FeinbergJ. “The child’s right to an open future” in W. Aiken and H. LaFollette (eds.) Whose child? Parental Rights Parental Authority and State Power (Littlefield Adams: Totowa nj 1980) 124–153.

FlekkøyM. G. and KaufmanN. H.The Participation Rights of the Child: Rights and Responsibilities in Family and Society (Jessica Kingsley: London1997).

FlutterJ. and RudduckJ.Consulting Pupils: what’s in it for schools? (RoutledgeFalmer: London2004).

FreemanM. “Children’s education; a test case for best interests and autonomy” in R. Davie and D. Galloway (eds.) Listening to Children in Education (David Fulton: London 1996) 29–48.

FreemanM.The Sociology of Childhood and Children’s Rights”The International Journal of Children’s Rights 1998 (6(4)) 433444.

HahnC.Becoming Political: Comparative Perspectives on Citizenship Education (State University of New York Press: Albany1998).

HartR. A.Children’s Participation: From Tokenism to Citizenship (unicef Innocenti Essays No.4 1992).

HoweB. R. and CovellK.Empowering Children: Children’s Rights Education as a Pathway to Citizenship (University of Toronto Press: Canada2005).

KrappmanL.The Rights of the Child as a Challenge to Human Rights Education”Journal of Social Science Education 2006 (5(1)) 6071.

LundyL.Voice is Not Enough: Conceptualising Article 12 of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child”British Educational Research Journal 2007 (33(6)) 927942.

McNeishD. and NewmanT. “Involving Children and Young People in Decision Making” in D. McNeish T. Newman and H. Roberts (eds.) What Works for Children? Effective services for children and families (Open University Press: Buckinghamshire 2002) 186–204.

MeintjesG. “Human Rights Education as Empowerment: Reflections on Pedagogy” in G. J. Andreopoulos and R. P. Claude (eds.) Human Rights Education for the 21 st Century (University of Pennsylvania Press: usa 1997) 64–79.

NagelJ.Participation (Prentice-Hall: New Jersey1987).

NoyesA.Pupil Voice: purpose, power and the possibilities for democratic schooling”British Educational Research Journal 2005 (31(4)) 532540.

Ofsted School Inspection Handbook: Handbook for inspecting schools in England under section 5 of the Education Act 2005 (as amended by the Education Act 2011) (January 2015).

OslerA.Children’s Rights, Responsibilities and Understandings of School Discipline”Research Papers in Education 2000 (15(1)) 4967.

OslerA.Students’ Perspectives on Schooling (Open University Press: Maidenhead2010).

OslerA.Bringing Human Rights Back Home: Learning from ‘Superman’ and Addressing Political Issues at School”The Social Studies 2013 (104) 6776.

OslerA. and StarkeyH.Children’s Rights and Citizenship: some implications for the management of schools”The International Journal of Children’s Rights 1998 (6) 313333.

PaisM. S.A Human Rights Conceptual Framework for unicef (unicef Innocenti Essays No.9 1999).

PrintM.ØrnstrømS. and SkovgaardH.Education for Democratic Processes in Schools and Classrooms”European Journal of Education 2002 (37(2)) 193210.

PruntyA. “Implementing Children’s Rights: Considering the Views of Children in the Individual Education Plan (iep Process)” in F. Waldron and B. Ruane (eds.) Human Rights Education: Reflections on Theory and Practice (The Liffey Press: Ireland 2010) 86–111.

RocheJ.Children: Rights, Participation and Citizenship”Childhood 1999 (6) 475493.

ShierH. “Pathways to Participation: Openings Opportunities and Obligations: A New Model for Enhancing Children’s Participation in Decision-making in line with Article 12.1 of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child” Children & Society 2001 (15) 107–117.

ShorI. and FreireP.A Pedagogy for Liberation: Dialogues on Transforming Education (Bergin & Garvey: Massachusetts1987).

SinclairR.Participation in Practice: Making it Meaningful, Effective and Sustainable”Children and Society 2004 (18) 106118.

StruthersA. “Human Rights: A Topic Too Controversial for Mainstream Education?” Human Rights Law Review 2016 (16(1)) 131–162.

un Committee on the Rights of the Child “General Comment No.1: Article 29(1): The Aims of Education” (2001) (crc/gc/2001/1).

un General Assembly “Revised Draft Plan of Action for the First Phase (2005–2007) of the World Programme for Human Rights Education” (2005) (A/59/525/Rev.1).

unesco International Congress on the Teaching of Human Rights “Final Document” (1978) (ss-78/conf.401/33).

unesco and ohchrPlan of Action: World Programme for Human Rights Education: First Phase” (2006).

WoodhouseB. B.Enhancing Children’s Participation in Policy FormationArizona Law Review 2003 (45) 751763.

WyseD.Felt Tip Pens and School Councils: Children’s Participation Rights in Four English Schools”Children & Society 2001 (15) 209218.

Index Card

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 29 29 23
Full Text Views 6 6 6
PDF Downloads 1 1 1
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0