This article reviews forms of detention and their reforms in the People’s Republic of China (prc). We examine the changing scope and uses of both administrative and criminal detention powers in the reform period and the impact of changing politics, ideology, and law in reform of both detention powers and institutions.
In Part 1, we focus on the continuities and discontinuities in the ideology of punishment, the perceived role and uses of detention in shaping society and in social control. In Part 2, we explore the factors relevant to the reform or abolition of range of administrative detention powers. We seek to understand how reforms have occurred, where they have stalled and where they are now possible. We ask how relevant these considerations are to the reform of criminal detention powers and find some distinctive features, not least of which is the comparative rigidity brought about by legal codification. We also note that reform to some administrative detention powers has been accompanied by an expansion in the criminal justice system. Our analysis illustrates that not only is there a wide range of people that the Party-state considers deserve to be placed outside of society, but also that in contemporary China detention is still considered to be a very useful form of social management and control.
Amnesty International. 2006. Abolishing “re-education through labour” and other forms of punitive administrative detention: An opportunity to bring the law into line with the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights. http://www.amnesty.org/en/library/info/ASA17/016/2006/.
BiddulphSarah. 2008a. The field of crime control and social order. In Examining Practice, Interrogating Theory: Comparative Legal Studies in Asia, ed. NicholsonPip and BiddulphSarah, 109–45. Leiden: Martinus Nijhoff.
BiddulphSarah. 2012. Between rhetoric and reality: the use of international human rights norms in law reform debates in China. In Narrative and Legal Transfers: Informing Law and Development, ed. GillespieJohn and NicholsonPip, 143–78. Cambridge, uk: Cambridge University Press.
BiddulphSarah. 2016. What to make of the abolition of re-education through labour? In Legal Reforms and the Deprivation of Liberty in Contemporary China, ed. NesossiElisa, BiddulphSarah, SapioFlora, and TrevaskesSue, 23–42. Abingdon, uk: Routledge.
ChenRuihua. 2003. Laodong jiaoyang de lishi kaocha yu fansi [Study and rethinking of the history of re-education through labor]. In Zhi’an guanli zhidu sicun [Reflection on the Regulation of Public Order], ed. ZhuWeiguo, 79–126. Beijing: Falü chubanshe.
ChenXingliang. 2001a. Laodong jiaoyang: genju guoji renquan gongyue zhi fenxi [Re-education through labor: Analysis with reference to international human rights covenants]. Faxue [Law Science], 10:49–52.
ChenXingliang. 2001b. Laodong Jiaoyang: genju guoji renquan gongyue zhi fenxi [Research on China’s system of re-education through labor: From the perspective of criminal rule of law]. Zhongwai faxue [Peking University Law Journal]13, no. 6:689–700.
ChenZaishang, and CuiXiangqian. 2008. Laodong jiaoyang zhidu de sanwei quexian yu chongsu [Three-dimensional defects and remodeling of the system of re-education through labor]. Tiedao jingguan gaodeng zhuanke xuexiao xuebao [Journal of Railway Police College]4:32–38.
ChenZexian, LiuRenwen, XuewuQu, and FengRui. 2002. Guanyu laodong jiaoyang zhidu de yanjiu baogao [Research report on the system of re-education through labor]. In Lixing yu chengxu: zhongguo laodong jioyang zhidu yanjiu [Rationality and Order: Research on China’s System of Re-Education through Labor], ed. ChuHuaizhi, ChenXingliang, and ZhangShaoyan, 331–43. Beijing: Falü chubanshe.
ChengKeqiang, YongshengYan, and XimeiYan. 2012. Jianyufa xiugai wanshanzhi sikao [Considerations on amending and perfecting the prison law]. Fanzui yu gaizao yanjiu [Research on Crime and Punishment]6:18–22.
ChengLei. 2016. Zhiding jusuo jianshe juzhu shishi wenti de jieshilun fenxi [Analysis on the interpretative theory on implementing surveillance at a designated place of residence]. Zhongguo faxue [China Legal Science]3:226–43.
ChengLei and NesossiElisa. 2016. China’s pre-trial detention centres: challenges and opportunities for reform. In Legal Reforms and Deprivation of Liberty in Contemporary China, eds., NesossiElisa, BiddulphSarah, SapioFlora and TrevaskesSusan, 95–111. London and New York: Routledge.
cntv [China National Television]. 2013. Quanguo zhengfa gongzuo huiyi: laojiao zhidu jinnian ni tingzhi shiyong [National political-legal committee meeting: Intends to stop using re-education through labor this year]. January 8. http://news.cntv.cn/2013/01/08/ARTI1357583580324680.shtml.
CuiQingxin, and YizhanLiu. 2013. Zhongguo jiang tuijin laojiao, huji deng zhidu gaishan [China will promote reform of re-education through labor, household registration and other systems]. Xinhua net, January 7. http://www.chinanews.com/fz/2013/01-07/4467425.shtml.
DuttonMichael and XuZhangrun. 1998. Facing difference: Relations, change and the prison sector in contemporary China. In Comparing prison systems: Toward a comparative and international penology, ed. WeissRobert and SouthNigelAmsterdam, Gordon and Breach Publishers.
DuttonMichael, and XuZhangrun. 2005. A question of difference: the theory and practice of the Chinese prison. In Crime, Punishment and Policing in China
, ed. BakkenBørge, 103–40. Lanham, md: Rowman & Littlefield.
FanBin. 2009. Xianxing laodong jiaoyang zhidu cunzai de zhuyao wenti he gaige gouxiang [Current problems of re-education through labor system and proposal for its reforms]. Shanxi gaodeng xuexiao shehui kexue xuebao [Social Sciences Journal of Colleges of Shanxi]21, no. 12:83–86.
FengRuirui, LiuYanhai, and DaiYing. 2008. Lun feichu laodong jiaoyang zhidu de biyaoxing [Discussing the necessity of abolishing re-education through labor]. Fazhi yu shehui [Legal System and Society]18:246.
FuHualing. 2005a. Punishing for profit. profitability and rehabilitation in a laojiao institution. In Engaging the Law in China. State, Society, and Possibilities for Justice
, ed. DiamantNeil J., LubmanStanley, and O’BrienKevin J., 213–29. Redwood City, ca: Stanford University Press.
GaoQiang. 2011. Guowuyuan jiedu tiaoli sui dabu chuangxin dan xiaoqu dongtai guankong reng yaoyao wu [Despite the big innovation in the state council’s drug prohibition regulations, abolition of dynamic control is still remote]. July 21. http://bbs.tianya.cn/post-news-217161-1.shtml.
GuoZhiyuan. 2016. Deprivation of liberty against one’s will in mental health institutions in contemporary China? In Legal Reforms and the Deprivation of Liberty in Contemporary China, ed. NesossiElisa, BiddulphSarah, SapioFlora, and TrevaskesSusan, 62–76. Abingdon, uk: Routledge.
HanShuqin. 2013. “Jianyu fa” xiugai ying zhu zhong jiejue de ruogan wenti [Several major problems that needed to be solved in the revision of the “prison law”]. Henan sifa jingguan zhiye xueyuan xuebao [Journal of Henan Judicial Police Vocational College]11, no. 1:27–29.
HuWeilie. 2003. Laodong jiaoyang zhidu ying yu feichu [The system of re-education through labor should be abolished]. In Zhi’an guanli zhidu sicun [Reflections on the Public Order Regulation], ed. ZhuWeiguo, 136–47. Beijing: Falü chubanshe.
HuXingdou, LiuRenwen, ZhuShunzhong, and HeXiaopeng. 2007. Shiyue tan: laojiao zhidu de hefaxing weiji [October talks: The crisis in legitimacy of the system of re-education through labor]. Xin shiji zhoukan [New Century Weekly]31:64–67.
LiBaozhen. 1999. Dangqian gong’an zhefa zhong cunzai de zhuyao wenti ji duice zhengwen zongshu [Summary of solicited articles on the main problems and counter-measures existing in current public security enforcement]. Gong’an yanjiu [Public Security Studies]2, no. 64:19–21.
LiEnshen. 2016. China’s socialization of administrative offenders in the community: An unrealistic agenda? In Legal Reforms and the Deprivation of Liberty in Contemporary China, ed. NesossiElisa, BiddulphSarah, SapioFlora, and TrevaskesSusan, 43–61. Abingdon, uk: Routledge.
LiuJingying, ZhiFang, and ZhengLeize. 1998. Zhiding jianyufa shishi tiaoli wanshan jianyufa tizhi [Enacting the implementing regulations on the prison law to perfect the system of prison legislation]. Zhongguo sifa [China Judiciary]9:6.
LiuJinpeng. 2005. You gao fuxilü dui woguo xianxing jiedu tixi de sikao [Considering China’s drug rehabilitation system from the perspective of the high relapse rate]. Fanzui yu gaige yanjiu [Crime and Reform Research]7:24.
MaWeigang, ed. 1993. Jinchang jindu: jianguo chuqi de lishi huigu [Prohibition of Prostitution and Drugs: A Historical Review of the Early Period in Establishing China]. Beijing: Jingguan xueyuan jiaoyu chubanshe.
MacbeanNicola. 2016. Addressing the “hide and seek” scandal: Restoring the legitimacy of kanshousuo. In Legal Reforms and the Deprivation of Liberty in Contemporary China, ed. NesossiElisa, BiddulphSarah, SapioFlora, and TrevaskesSusan, 112–30. Abingdon, uk: Routledge.
MunroDonald J.1977a. Belief control: The psychological and ethical foundations. In Deviance and Social Control in Chinese Society, ed. WilsonAmy Auberacher Sidney, GreenblattLeonard, and WilsonRichard Whittingham, 14–36. New York: Praeger.
NesossiElisa. 2014. Detention, stability and “social management innovation.” In The Politics of Law and Stability in China, ed. TrevaskesSusan, NesossiElisa, SapioFlora, and BiddulphSarah, 219–43. Cheltenham, uk: Edward Elgar.
NesossiElisa, and TrevaskesSusan. 2016. Framing imprisonment studies in China: ideology, law and politics. In Legal Reforms and the Deprivation of Liberty in Contemporary China, ed. NesossiElisa, BiddulphSarah, SapioFlora, and TrevaskesSusan, 133–144. Abingdon, uk: Routledge.
NesossiElisa, BiddulphSarah, SapioFlora, and TrevaskesSusan. 2016. Opportunities and challenges for legislative and institutional reform of detention in China. In Legal Reforms and the Deprivation of Liberty in Contemporary China, ed. NesossiElisa, BiddulphSarah, SapioFlora, and TrevaskesSusan, 162–70. Abingdon, uk: Routledge.
PeerenboomRandall2003. Out of the pan and into the fire: Well-intentioned but misguided recommendations to eliminate all forms of administrative detention in China. Northwestern University Law Review98:991–1000.
RosenzweigJoshua. 2016. Residential surveillance: Evolution of a Janus-faced measure. In Legal Reforms and the Deprivation of Liberty in Contemporary China, ed. NesossiElisa, BiddulphSarah, SapioFlora, and TrevaskesSue, 79–94. Abingdon, uk: Routledge.
RosenzweigJoshua, SapioFlora, JueJiang, BiaoTeng, and PilsEva. 2013. Comments on the 2012 revision of the Criminal Procedure Law. In Comparative Perspectives on Criminal Justice in China, ed. McConvilleMike and PilsEva, 455–503. Cheltenham, uk: Edward Elgar.
United Nations, Commission on Human Rights. 2004. Civil and Political Rights, Including the Questions of Torture and Detention. Report of the Working Group on Arbitrary Detention. Mission to China, e/cn.4/2005/6/Add.4, https://documents-dds-ny.un.org/doc/UNDOC/GEN/G05/102/74/PDF/G0510274.pdf?OpenElement.
United Nations, Commission on Human Rights. 2006. Civil and Political Rights, Including the Question of Torture and Detention. Report of the Special Rapporteur on Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment, Manfred Nowak. Mission to China, e/cn4/2006/6/Add6, https://documents-dds-ny.un.org/doc/UNDOC/GEN/G06/117/50/PDF/G0611750.pdf?OpenElement.
WangWei. 2015. Huang Haibo piaochang shijian nuzhuren liuxinyu yu yishen huoxing 6 ge yue [Huang Haibo prostitution case mistress Liu Xinyu sentenced at first instance to 6 months’ imprisonment]. news.qq.com, May 12.
WangZhiliang. 2002. Jianyufa yin shengge wei jibenfa [The prison law ought to be upgraded to a basic law]. Anhui jingcha zhiye xueyuan xuebao [Journal of the Anhui Police Training College]1, no. 2:29–31.
YangCheng. 2008. Balancing the needs in the reform of labor re-education. In Zhongguo laodong jiaoyang zhidu de jiantao yu gaige [Re-Assessing and Reforming the Labor Re-Education System in China], ed. BingzhiZhao and ChengYang, 1–23. Beijing: Zhongguo renmin gong’an daxue chubanshe.
ZhangChuanwei. 2009. Cong ganga, dianfu zouxiang xinsheng: laodong jiaoyang gaizao wei shequ jiaozheng zhi fenxi [From embarrassment and subversion to rebirth: An analysis of the reform of re-education through labor to community corrections]. Beijing xingzheng xueyuan xuebao [Journal of Beijing Administrative College]1:80–85.
ZhangMinfa. 2008. Guanyu laodong jiaoyang zhidu jiben wenti de sikao [Reflections on the fundamental issues of the system of re-education through labor in China]. Zhengfa xuekan [Journal of Political Science and Law], 6:56–60.