Explaining the Prevalence of Voluntary Associations among 351 Massachusetts Municipalities circa 1965: Testing a Theory

in The China Nonprofit Review
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Data from an extensive research project in the state of Massachusetts (USA), collected in the 1960s and never before reported, are used to test a theory of association prevalence among 351 municipalities. The dependent variable to be explained was an Association Prevalence Index (total number existing) in each municipality. The Index was derived from Massachusetts Statehouse physical records for all incorporated Nonprofit Organizations (NPOs), and showed an average of 33 associations per municipality. Using bivariate correlations, the results confirmed the theory generally. Association prevalence (raw number of associations) in a municipality was positively and significantly related to larger population size, being a county administrative center, more business telephones, greater circulation of weekly newspapers (local newspapers), more service businesses, more state government agencies, more churches, larger percentage of African-Americans, and more halls/buildings available for association gatherings (meetings, events). Contrary to the theory, the socioeconomic status of municipalities was not significantly related to association prevalence. The Statehouse Association Prevalence Index was correlated very highly (r = .92) with an independent measure of association prevalence, derived from coding the “Yellow Pages” of phone books. This result indicates the reliability and general validity of both prevalence measures.



AbzugRikkiTurnheimJoy K. “Bandwagon or Band-Aid: A Model of Nonprofit Incorporation by State.” Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly 1998 27 300 322

AndersonRobert T. SmithD. H. “Voluntary Associations in History: From Paleolithic to Present Times.” Voluntary Action Research: 1973 1973 Lexington, MA Lexington Books 9 28

BielefeldWolfgangMurdochJ. C.WaddellP. “The Influence of Demographics and Distance on Nonprofit Location.” Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly 1997 26 207 225

BradfieldRichard M. A Natural History of Associations 1973 London, UK Duckworth 2 Vols.

CorbinJ. J. “A Study of Factors Influencing the Growth of Nonprofits in Social Services.” Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly 1999 28 296 314

FungArchon “Associations and Democracy: Between Theories, Hopes, and Realities.” Annual Review of Sociology 2003 29 515 539

GavelinKarinSvedbergLars “The Scope and Magnitude of Volunteering.” Unpublished External Paper BP1, State of the World’s Volunteerism Report Project, UN Volunteers, Bonn, Germany, March 2011

GrønbjergKirstenPaarlbergLaurie “Community Variations in the Size and Scope of the Nonprofit Sector: Theory and Preliminary Findings.” Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly 2001 30 684 706

KloppenborgJohn S.WilsonStephen G. Voluntary Associations in the Graeco-Roman World 1996 London, UK Routledge

LincolnJ. R. “The Urban Dimensions of Voluntary Organizations.” Social Science Quarterly 1977 58 472 480

McPhersonJ. Miller “Hypernetwork Sampling – Duality and Differentiation among Voluntary Organizations.” Social Networks 1982 3 225 249

McPhersonJ. Miller “The Size of Voluntary Organizations.” Social Forces 1983 61 1044 1064

NolanPatrickLenskiGerhard Human Societies 2006 10th ed. Boulder, CO Paradigm Publishers

PeiMinxin “Chinese Civic Associations: An Empirical Analysis.” Modern China 1998 24 285 318

PutnamRobert D. Making Democracy Work: Civic Traditions in Modern Italy 1993 Princeton, NJ Princeton University Press

Ross, Jack C. An Assembly of Good Fellows: Voluntary Associations in History. Westport, CT: Greenwood, 1976

SalamonLester M.AnheierHelmut K. “Social Origins of Civil Society: Explaining the Nonprofit Sector Cross-Nationally.” Voluntas 9 1998 213 248

SaxtonGregory D.BensonMichelle A. “Social Capital and the Growth of the Nonprofit Sector.” Social Science Quarterly 2005 86 16 35

SmithDavid Horton “National Nonprofit, Voluntary Associations: Some Parameters.” Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly 1992 21 1 81 94

SmithDavid Horton “The International History of Grassroots Associations.” International Journal of Comparative Sociology 1997a 38 3-4 189 216

SmithDavid Horton “The Rest of the Nonprofit Sector: Grassroots Associations as the Dark Matter Ignored in Prevailing ‘Flat-Earth’ Maps of the Sector.” Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly 1997b 26 114 131

SmithDavid Horton Grassroots Associations Thousand Oaks, CA Sage 2000

SmithDavid Horton Steven OttJ. “Modernization and the Emergence of Voluntary Organizations.” The Nonprofit Sector: An Overview 2000 [1973] Boulder, CO Westview Press 51 55

SmithDavid Horton Steven OttJ. “The Impact of the Voluntary Sector on Society.” The Nature of Nonprofit Sector 2001 Boulder, CO Westview Press 79 97

SmithDavid Horton “Urban/Suburban Hierarchical Dominance and Associational Prevalence in Eight Massachusetts Communities: Re-examining Data from the 1960s.” China Third Sector Research 2011 1 105 110 [Text in Chinese; References & Abstract in English.]

SmithDavid Horton “Review and Assessment of China’s Nonprofit Sector after Mao: Is It ‘Civil Society’ Now and Does that Matter?” 2012 Chestnut Hill, MA Department of Sociology Unpublished paper submitted for editorial review

SmithDavid HortonBaldwinBurt “Voluntary Group Prevalence among the U.S. States: Factors Affecting the Distribution of Intercultural Understanding Groups (Sister City Programs).” International Journal of Comparative Sociology 1990 XXXI 79 85

SmithDavid HortonBaldwinBurt SmithDavid H.TilJon V. “Voluntary Organization Prevalence in the States of the USA: Presentation and a Test of the Revised Smith Model.” International Perspectives on Voluntary Action Research 1983 Washington, D.C. University Press of America 50 62

SmithDavid HortonShenCe “The Roots of Civil Society: A Model of Voluntary Association Prevalence Applied to Data on Larger Contemporary Nations.” International Journal of Comparative Sociology 2002 42 2 93 133

SmithDavid HortonStebbinsRobert A.DoverMichael A Dictionary of Nonprofit Terms and Concepts 2006 Bloomington, IN Indiana University Press

TuckerDavid J.SinghJitendra V.MeinhardAgnes G. “Organizational Form, Population Dynamics, and Institutional Change: The Founding Patterns of Voluntary Organizations.” Academy of Management Journal 1990 33 151 178

TwombleyEric “What Factors Affect the Entry and Exit of Nonprofit Human Service Organizations in Metropolitan Areas?” Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly 2003 32 211 235

WaltzingJean P. Etudes Historiques sur les Corporations Professionelles chez les Romains Depuis les Origines Jusquà la Chute de l’Empire d’Occident Historical Studies of Professional Corporations of the Romans from the Origins to the Fall of the Empire in the West 1895 Louvain, Belgium Paters 4 Vols.

WangMing Emerging Civil Society in China, 1978-2008 2011 Leiden, Netherlands Brill Academic Publishers

WangMingLiuQiushi “Analyzing China’s NGO Development System.” China Nonprofit Review 2009 1 5 35 [English journal version.]

WangMingSunWeilin “Trends and Characteristics in the Development of China’s Social Organization.” China Nonprofit Review 2010 2 153 176 [English journal version.]

WangShaoguangHeJianyu “Associational Revolution in China: Mapping the Landscapes.” Korea Observer 2004 35 485 533

WarrenMark E. Democracy and Association 2001 Princeton, NJ Princeton University Press

WilsonJ.MusickM. A. “Who cares? Toward an Integrated theory of volunteer work.” American Sociological Review 1997 62 694 713

WirthLouisReissAlbert J. Of Cities and Social Life: Selected Papers 1981 Chicago, IL University of Chicago Press

XuJunSmithDavid Horton “Pathways Legitimacy Theory: How Nonprofit Organizations in Post-Mao China Seek Recognition and Government Acceptance.” 2012 Beijing, China Capital University of Economics and Business Unpublished paper submitted for editorial review


See Smith 1997b, and Smith 2000: Chap. 2, for estimates of the degree of undercounting using records such as these.


Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 34 34 1
Full Text Views 2 2 2
PDF Downloads 1 1 1
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0