The Typological Legitimacy of Nonpublic Fundraising Foundations

in The China Nonprofit Review
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?


As an emergent type of charitable organizations, nonpublic fundraising foundations (非公募基金会) are questioned on its legal entity – on whether nonpublic fundraising foundations qualify as a valid type of charitable organizations. In terms of its origin, nonpublic fundraising foundations emerged in China as a product of the mixture of history, reality and imported elements. Fundraising, a key word in the term, is not a right but a duty. The problem with nonpublic fundraising foundations is the overstress on the concept on the one hand and the ignorance of the institution on the other. The solution lies in setting up a sound and clear institution, so as to form an organic system of charitable organizations. The fact that nonpublic fundraising foundations are hardly supported in the existing theories of legal personality reflects the need to reform relevant aspects in the legal system.



BrownRichard GuangMa Modernization: The Transformation of American Life 1600-1865 2008 Beijing World Knowledge Press In Chinese Translation

CassirerErnst LiuShuxian An Essay on Man 2006 Guilin Guangxi Normal University Press In Chinese Translation

China Association of Chief Financial Officers “One Foundation in the Predicament of the Charity Institution.” Chinese Chief Financial Officers 10 167

China Civil Affairs Statistics China Civil Affairs Statistical Yearbook 2005. Beijing: China Statistics Press 2005

China Foundation Center Website The Development of Chinese Foundations: An Independent Research (2012) 2012 Beijing Social Sciences Academic Press, ed.

China Philanthropy Research Institute of Beijing Normal University Towards Modern Charity: The 2012 Annual Report of the Development of Chinese Charity and Philanthropy 2012 Beijing Beijing Normal University Press

DengXinjian “Nongovernmental Organizations Have Gained the Rights of Fundraising.” 2012 .

Department of Policies, Laws and Regulations of Ministry of Civil Affairs Selected Studies of Charity Legislation in China 2009 Beijing China Social Press ed.

FumaSusumu Chūgokuzenkaizendōshikenkyū 2005 Beijing Commercial Press In Chinese Translation

HopfeldWesledy Newcomb ZhangShuyou Fundamental Legal Conceptions 2009 Beijing China Legal Publishing House In Chinese Translation

JiangPing “Making an Open Civil Code.” Tribune of Political Science and Law 2003 1 3 8

JinJinping “Jin Jinping: An Expert’s Opinion That Nonpublic Fundraising Foundations Reflect the Transformation of the Charity and Philanthropy.”

KansakuHiroyuki XuChangshuai LiangHuixing “The Legal Personality of General Associations and Enterprises: the profit-seeking and the non-profit-seeking.” Studies of Civil and Commercial Laws 1994 Vol. 42 Beijing The Law Press In Chinese Translation

LarenzKarl WangXiaoye AllgemeinerTeil des DeutschenBürgerlichenRechts I 2003 Beijing The Law Press In Chinese Translation

LiBengong “Promoting the Sound Development of Foundations with Rules and Management: An Interview with Director-General Li Bengong of the Bureau of Management of Nongovernmental Organizations.” Chinese Civil Affairs 2004 4 32 33

LiYongjun “A Study of Issues Regarding Charity and Fundraising in Ancient China.” Guangxi Social Sciences 2011 12 94 98

LiZhenghui “Profit as a Concept of Fundamental Distinction.” Legal Forum 2012 4 59 64

LiuTaigang Legal Regulation of Nonprofit Organizations 2009 Beijing China Legal Publishing House

MaXin “A Study of Nonpublic Fundraising Foundations and Their Governance System.” Chinese Civil Affairs 2004 6 40 41

MacComickNeilWeinbergerOta ZhouYeqian An Institutional Theory of Law 2004 Beijing China University of Political Science and Law Press In Chinese Translation

Ministry of Civil Affairs “The Answer of the Ministry of Civil Affairs to Questions on the Regulations for the Management of Foundations” 2004

MizoguchiKozo ZhengJing Chūgokukoh to shi 2011 Beijing Joint Publishing, In Chinese Translation

MoYun The Philosophy of the Entity and Its Application in Private Law: A Study of the Capacity for Rights 2012 Beijing The Law Press

PanZhizhenYinHang “Guangzhou NGOs Given Public Fundraising rights.” New Express 2012 April 27 A27

QinHui The Way to Changes 2007 Zhengzhou Zhengzhou University Press

ScottW. Richard YaoWeiWangLifang Institutions and Organizations: Ideas and Interests 2010 Beijing China Renmin University Press In Chinese Translation

ShuiBing “A Study of the Concept of Nonprofit Legal Personality.” Journal of Anhui University (Philosophy and Social Sciences) 2010 2 109 116

SunWeilin “The Speech of Sun Weilin from the Bureau of Management of Nongovernmental Organizations, Advisor of the Forum Organization Committee.” 2009

TaoChuanjinLiuZhongxiang An Introduction to Foundations 2011 Beijing China Social Press

The State Council Legislative Affairs Office and the Ministry of Civil Affairs “The Explanation of the State Council Legislative Affairs Office and the Ministry of Civil Affairs on the Regulations for the Management of Foundations (Draft).” 2001 .

Von JheringRudolf HuBaohai LiangHuixing Der Kampf ums Recht.In Chinese Translation 1994 Vol. 2 Beijing The Law Press In. Studies of Civil and Commercial Laws

WagnerPeter LiKang Not All That Is Solid Melts into Air: A History and Theory of Social Sciences 2011 Beijing Peking University Press In Chinese Translation

WangBaoshu “The Tendency of the Reform of the Legal Form and Structure of Companies.” China Legal Science 2012 1 106 116

WangChunmei The Historical Changes and Contemporary Construction of the Entity in Civil Affairs 2011 Beijing People’s Press

WangMingJiaXijin “The Property Rights Structure and Governance of Foundations.” Economic Affairs 2003 1 40 45

XiaYong “Fundamental Problems in the Philosophy of Rights.” Law Science 2004 3 3 26

XuGuodong General Principles of the Civil Law 2007 Beijing Higher Education Press

YangGuangbin The Institutional Form in the Rise and Decline of the State: A Comparative Study of Political Development 2005 Beijing Peking University Press

YangPengcheng “Public Aid to Disasters in Ancient China Seen in a Case Study of Hunan.” Yinshan Academic Journal 2003 4 70 74

YangYueChaiMei “The Management of Foundations in China: the Legal Context and Its Recent Development.” Chinese Civil Affairs 2003 10 25 26

ZhangWen “Market-Oriented and Social Measures of Public Aid in Northern Song and Southern Song.” Journal of Southwest Normal University (Humanities and Social Sciences) 2003 1 124 130

ZhouZhiyuan Disaster Management in the Ming Dynasty 2007 Hefei Anhui University Press

ZhuWeiguo “Ideological Transformation and Institutional Innovation: An Analysis of the Regulations for the Management of Foundations.” China Nonprofit Review 2007 Vol. 1 Beijing Social Sciences Academic Press

ZhuangFaqiWangMengjie “Chinese Charity Foundations Must Be Disconnected from the Government.” China Youth Daily 2011 August 12 3 Page

ZippeliusReinhold Rechtsphilosophie In Chinese Translation. Beijing: Peking University Press 2013 Sixth Edition


Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 79 79 2
Full Text Views 8 8 3
PDF Downloads 6 6 4
EPUB Downloads 1 1 0