Comparative Study of the Non-Profit Sectors of Pakistan and India

in The China Nonprofit Review
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

This is a theoretical paper that has analysed more than 55 publications to draw comparison between Pakistan and India non-profit sectors. The two countries share their history under British rule before 1947 partition. Before the partition the non-profit sector saw a rise under different religious umbrellas, however after the partition the sectors saw a rise in nonreligious, non-political organizations in both countries. The paper draws the similarities and differences among the types of organizations, funding sources, giving, and legal framework. The paper debates the reasons for different evolutions of the sectors in post-independence era and its reasons. The findings show that both sectors evolved different due to differences in religious influence, political instability, and check and balance systems. The paper aims to contribute in depth analysis of the both sectors in the literature.

Comparative Study of the Non-Profit Sectors of Pakistan and India

in The China Nonprofit Review

Sections

References

  • AnheierHelmut KSimmonsAdeleWinderDavid Innovation in Strategic Philanthropy 2007 New York Springer

  • BaitenmannHelga “NGOs and the Afghan war: the Politicisation of Humanitarian Aid” Third World Quarterly 1990 12 1 62 85

  • BanoMasooda “Dangerous Correlations: Aid’s Impact on NGOs’ Performance and Ability to Mobilize Members in Pakistan” World Development 2008a 36 11 2297 2313

  • BanoMasooda “Nonprofit Education Providers vis-à-vis The Private Sector: Comparative Analysis of Non-governmental Organizations and Traditional Voluntary Organizations in Pakistan” Journal of Comparative Education 2008b 38 4 471 482

  • BanoMasooda “Public Perception and the Decision to Join NGOs in Pakistan” Journal of South Asian Development 2008c 3 1 87 108

  • BatleyRichard “Engaged or Divorced? Cross‐Service Findings on Government Relations with Non‐State Service‐Providers” Public Administration and Development 2006 26 3 241 251

  • BrownDavid L.KortenDavid “Working more effectively with NGOs” IDR Reports: Institute for Development Research 1991 Boston Institute of Development Studies

  • BukhariIman SaleemJabeenNasiraJadoonZafar Iqbal “Governance of Third Sector Organizations in Pakistan: The Role of Advisory Board” South Asian Studies 2014 29 2 583

  • CamposNauro FKhanFeisal UTessendorfJennifer E “From Substitution to Complementarity: Some Econometric Evidence on the Evolving NGO-State Relationship in Pakistan” The Journal of Developing Areas 2004 37 2 49 72

  • Charities Aid Foundation (caf) World Giving Index 2011: A Global View of Giving Trends 2011 Kent, UK Charities Aid Foundation

  • Charities Aid Foundation (caf) World Giving Index 2012 2012 Kent, UK Charities Aid Foundation

  • Dasra India Philanthropy Report 2015 2015 Mumbai Bain & Company, Inc

  • EjazIramShaikhBabar TRizviNarjis “NGOs and government partnership for health systems strengthening: a qualitative study presenting viewpoints of government, NGOs and donors in Pakistan” BMC Health Services Research 2011 no. 11 1 122

  • FosterW.BradachJ. “Should Nonprofits Seek Profits?” Harvard Business Review 2005 83 2 92 100

  • FowlerAlan “Strengthening the Role of Voluntary Development Organizations: Policy Issues Facing Official Aid Agencies” Paper read at International Conference on Strengthening Financing for the Voluntary Sector in Development: The Role of Official Development Assistance 1995 London

  • Ghaus-PashaAishaJamadHaroonIqbal MuhammadAsif “Dimensions of the Nonprofit Sector in Pakistan (Preliminary estimates)” Social Policy and Development Centre Pakistan Aga Khan Foundation Pakistan and Centre for Civil Society Studies Johns Hopkins University USA 2002 Pakistan Social Policy and Development Centre and Aga Khan Foundation edited by spdc Working Papers

  • Ghaus-PashaAishaIqbal MuhammadAsif “Defining the Nonprofit Sector: Pakistan” Working Papers of the Johns Hopkins Comparative Nonprofit Sector Project 2003 Baltimore The Johns Hopkins Center for Civil Society Studies

  • HodgkinsonVirginia A. HodgkinsonVirginia ALymanW “Key Challenges Facing the Nonprofit Sector” The Future of the Nonprofit Sector 1989 San Francisco Jossey-Bass 3 19

  • HopkinsBruce R. The Law of Tax-Exempt Organizations 1987 5th ed. New York Wiley

  • Iqbal MuhammadAsif “The Ideological Divide of the Nonprofit Sector in Pakistan” International Conference of the International Society for Third-Sector Research 2006 Bangkok

  • Iqbal MuhammadAsifKhanHinaJavedSurkhab “Nonprofit sector in Pakistan: Historical background” SPDC Working Paper No. 4. USA: Social Policy and Development Centre 2004 Baltimore Aga Khan Foundation and Center for Civil Society, Johns Hopkins University usa

  • IsmailZafar H. “Law and the Nonprofit Sector in Pakistan” The Johns Hopkins Comparative Nonprofit Sector Project Pakistan Islamabad Social Policy and Development Centre 2002 Baltimore Aga Khan Foundation and Centre of Civil Society John Hopkins University usa

  • KickbuschIlona S. “Health literacy: Addressing the Health and Education Divide” Health Promotion International 2001 16 3 289 297

  • LathaKakumani LavanyaPrabhakarKotte “Non-Government Organizations: Problems and Remedies in India” Serbian Journal of Management 2011 6 1 109 121

  • LloydsRobert The Role of NGO Self-Regulation in Increasing Stakeholder Accountability 2005 London One World Trust

  • MorrisSusannah “Defining the Nonprofit Sector: Some Lessons from History” Voluntas: International Journal of Voluntary and Nonprofit Organizations 2000 11 1 25 43

  • NajamAdil “Understanding the Third Sector: Revisiting the Prince, the Merchant, and the Citizen” Nonprofit Management and Leadership 1996 7 2 203 219

  • PashaAisha GhausIqbalAsif “Non-profit Sector in Pakistan: Government Policy and Future Issues” The Pakistan Development Review 2002 41 4 879 908

  • PashaAisha GhausIqbal MuhammadAsifMumtazSoofia “Non-profit sector in Pakistan: Government policy and future issues [with Comments]” The Pakistan Development Review 2002 879 908

  • Pakistan Centre for Philanthropy (pcp) “Pakistan Centre for Philanthropy 2017” [cited 19th Jan 2017 available from http://pcp.org.pk/aboutus.html.

  • Pakistan Centre of Philanthropy (pcp) Philanthropy in Pakistan 2002 Pakistan Pakistan Centre of Philanthropy

  • Pakistan Centre of Philanthropy (pcp) Individual Philanthropy in Punjab 2012 Islamabad Pakistan Centre of Philanthropy

  • Pakistan Centre of Philanthropy (pcp) Giving at Shrines in Pakistan: An Untapped Resource for Social Development 2016 Pakistan Pakistan Centre of Philanthropy

  • PrakashAseemGugertyMary Kay “Trust but verify? Voluntary Regulation Programs in the Nonprofit Sector” Regulation & Governance 2010 4 1 22 47

  • pria “Historical Background of the Nonprofit Sector in India” PRIA in Collaboration with the Centre of Civil Society Studies John Hopkins University usa 2001 New Delhi Participatory Research in Asia (PRIA)

  • pria “Invisible, yet Widespread: The Non-Profit Sector in India” PRIA in Collaboration with the Centre of Civil Society Studies John Hopkins University usa 2003 New Delhi Participatory Research in Asia (PRIA)

  • pria “Dimensions of Giving and Volunteering in India” PRIA in Collaboration with the Centre of Civil Society Studies John Hopkins University usa 2004 New Delhi Participatory Research in Asia (PRIA)

  • PryorFrederic “Reflection on the Non-profit Sector” Comparative Economic Studies 1994 36 1

  • QureshiAyaz “AIDS Activism in Pakistan: Diminishing Funds, Evasive State” Development and Change 2015 46 2 320 338

  • RanaMuhammad Ahsan “Pakistan-Setting Standards in the Nonprofit Sector: The Certification Experience in Pakistan” International Journal of Civil Society Law 2004 2 1 83

  • RavichandranN.RajashreeS.SathyapriyaY.JainAjit “Perspectives on Non-profit Mission and Financing in India” Journal of Health Management 2006 8 2 207 227

  • SalamonLester M.Wojciech SokolowskiS.ListRegina Global Civil Society: Dimensions of the Nonprofit Sector Vol. II 2004 Baltimore Johns Hopkins Center for Civil Society Studies

  • SalamonLester M. America & The Nonprofit Sector 1992 Washington, DC Washington Foundation Center Washington

  • SalamonLester M.AnheierHelmut K. Caring Sector Or Caring Society?: Discovering the Nonprofit Sector Cross-nationally 1994 Baltimore Johns Hopkins University Institute for Policy Studies

  • SalamonLester M.AnheierHelmut K. Defining the Nonprofit Sector: A Cross-national Analysis 1997 Manchester Manchester University Press

  • SalamonLester M.AnheierHelmut K. The Emerging Nonprofit Sector: An Overview 1996 Manchester Manchester University Press

  • SalimLailaSadruddinSalimZakusDavid “Organizational Commitment in a Health NGO in Pakistan” Voluntas: International Journal of Voluntary and Nonprofit Organizations 2012 23 3 584 604

  • SandersMathew L.McClellanJohn G. “Being Business-like While Pursuing a Social Mission: Acknowledging the Inherent Tensions in US Nonprofit Organizing” Organization 2012 21 1 68 69

  • SattarNikaht “Has Civil Society Failed in Pakistan?” Social Policy and Development Centre Working Papers no. 6 2011 Baltimore Aga Khan Foundation and Centre of Civil Society John Hopkins University usa

  • SattarTehminaYasinGhulamAfzalSaima “Socio-Cultural and Economic Impediments of Inequality in Provision of Educational Right to Female: A Case of Southern Punjab (Pakistan)” International Journal of Human Resource Studies 2012 2 1 122 138

  • SenSiddhartha SalamonL.M.AnheierH.K. “Defining the Nonprofit Sector: India” Working Papers of the Johns Hopkins Comparative Nonprofit Sector Project 1993 no. 12 Baltimore The Johns Hopkins Institute for Policy Studies

  • ShethArpanSinghalMadhur Indian Philanthropy Report 2011 2011 New Delhi Bain & Company

  • SiddharthaSenSalamonLester M.AnheierHelmut K. SalamonL.M. “Defining the Nonprofit Sector INDIA” Working Papers of the John Hopkins Comparative Nonprofit Sector Project 1993 Baltimore John Hopkins University

  • SiddiqueMuhammad HaroonAhmadMokbul Morshed “NGO Fieldworkers in Pakistan” GMSARN International Journal 2010 4 1 183 192

  • SidelMark “The Promise and Limits of Collective Action for Nonprofit Self-regulation: Evidence from Asia” Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly 2010 39 6 1039 1056

  • SrivastavaS.S.TandonRajeshGuptaS.K.DwivediS.K. “Dimensions of Giving and Volunteering in West Bengal” Working Papers of the John Hopkins Comparative Nonprofit Sector Project no. 7 (New Delhi: Participatory Research in Asia (pria) in collaboration with the Centre of Civil Society Studies John Hopkins University usa 2003).

  • Transparency-Watch-Organization “A Study of NGOs: Pakistan” A Study of NGOs in Asia 1999 Karachi Transparency Watch Organization

  • YasmeenSamina “Islamisation and activism of a Muslim NGO in Pakistan: Jama’at-ud-Da’wa as a case study” Australian Journal of Social Issues 2012 47 3 407

  • 2

    Pasha Aisha Ghaus and Asif Iqbal“Defining the Nonprofit Sector: Pakistan,” in Working Papers of the Johns Hopkins Comparative Nonprofit Sector Project (Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins Center for Civil Society Studies 2003); Lester Salamon and Wojcieh Sokolowski Global Civil Society: Dimensions of the Nonprofit Sector Vol II (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins Center for Civil Society Studies 2004); priaInvisible yet Widespread: The Non-Profit Sector in India (New Delhi: Participatory Research in Asia (pria) 2003).

  • 5

    Sanders Mathew L. and John G. McClellan“Being Business-Like While Pursuing a Social Mission: Acknowledging the Inherent Tensions in Us Nonprofit Organizing,” Organization 21(1) (2012): 68-69; Foster William and Jeffrey Bradach “Should Nonprofit Seek Profits” Harvard Business Review 83(2) (2005): 92-100.

  • 6

    Salamon Lester M. and Helmut K. AnheierDefining the Nonprofit Sector: A Cross-National Analysis. (Manchester: Manchester University Press1997).

  • 7

    Salamon Lester M. and Helmut K. Anheier“In Search of the Non-Profit Sector: The Question of Definitions.” Voluntas: International Journal of Voluntary and Nonprofit Organizations 3(2) (1992): 125-51.

  • 8

    Pryor Frederic“Reflection on the Non-Profit Sector.” Comparative Economic Studies 36(1) (1994).

  • 12

    Hodgkinson Virginia A.“Key Challenges Facing the Nonprofit Sector,” in The Future of the Nonprofit Sectoredited by Virginia A. Hodgkinson and W. Lyman (San Francisco: Jossey-Bass 1989): 3-19.

  • 13

    Morris Susannah“Defining the Nonprofit Sector: Some Lessons from History,” Voluntas: International Journal of Voluntary and Nonprofit Organizations 11(1) (2000): 25-43.

  • 14

    Najam Adil“Understanding the Third Sector: Revisiting the Prince, the Merchant, and the Citizen,” Nonprofit Management and Leadership 7(2) (1996): 203-19.

  • 15

    Brown L. David and David Korten“Working More Effectively with NGOs” in IDR Reports (Boston: Institute for Development Research 1991).

  • 17

    Iqbal Muhammad Asif et. al.“Nonprofit Sector in Pakistan: Historical Background,” in SPDC Working Paper No. 4 (Pakistan: Social Policy and Development Centre in collaboration with Aga Khan Foundation Pakistan and Center for Civil Society Johns Hopkins University usa 2004).

  • 19

    Ayaz Qureshi“Aids Activism in Pakistan: Diminishing Funds, Evasive State,” Development and Change 46(2) (2015): 320-38.

  • 30

    Siddhartha Sen et. al.“Defining the Nonprofit Sector India,” in Working Papers of the John Hopkins Comparative Nonprofit Sector Projectedited by L.M. Salamon. (Baltimore: John Hopkins University 1993); Ravichandran N. et. al. “Perspectives on Non-Profit Mission and Financing in India” Journal of Health Management 8(2) (2006): 207 Perspectives on Non-Profit Mission and Financing in India” 27; priaInvisible yet Widespread: The Non-Profit Sector in India.

  • 31

    DasraIndia Philanthropy Report 2015 (Mumbai: Bain & Company, Inc2015).

  • 35

    Richard Batley“Engaged or Divorced? Cross‐Service Findings on Government Relations with Non‐State Service‐Providers,” Public Administration and Development 26(3) (2006): 241-51; Pasha Aisha Ghaus et. al. “Non-Profit Sector in Pakistan: Government Policy and Future Issues.”

  • 37

    Pakistan Centre of PhilanthropyPhilanthropy in Pakistan (Islamabad: Pakistan Centre of Philanthropy2002).

  • 38

    Yasmeen Samina“Islamisation and Activism of a Muslim Ngo in Pakistan: Jama’at-Ud-Da’wa as a Case Study,” Australian Journal of Social Issues 47(3) (2012): 407.

  • 46

    Yasmeen Samina“Islamisation and Activism of a Muslim Ngo in Pakistan” 407-424.

  • 49

    Transparency Watch Organization“A Study of NGOs: Pakistan,” in A Study of NGOs in Asia. (Karachi: Transparency Watch Organization 1999).

  • 52

    Prakash Aseem and Mary Kay Gugerty“Trust but Verify? Voluntary Regulation Programs in the Nonprofit Sector,” Regulation & Governance 4(1) (2010): 22-47.

  • 53

    Rana Muhammad Ahsan“Pakistan-Setting Standards in the Nonprofit Sector: The Certification Experience in Pakistan,” International Journal of Civil Society Law 2(1) (2004): 83; Sidel Mark “The Promise and Limits of Collective Action for Nonprofit Self-Regulation: Evidence from Asia” Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly 39(6) (2010): 1039-1056.

  • 54

    Prakash and Gugerty“Trust but Verify? Voluntary Regulation Programs in the Nonprofit Sector” 22-47.

  • 56

    Bano Masooda“Dangerous Correlations: Aid’s Impact on NGOs’ Performance and Ability to Mobilize Members in Pakistan,” World Development 36(11) (2008): 2297-2313; Bano Masooda “Public Perception and the Decision to Join NGOs in Pakistan” Journal of South Asian Development 3(1) (2008): 87-108.

  • 57

    Yasmeen Samina“Islamisation and Activism of a Muslim Ngo in Pakistan” 407-424.

  • 58

    Bano Masooda“Nonprofit Education Providers Vis-À-Vis the Private Sector: Comparative Analysis of Non-Governmental Organizations and Traditional Voluntary Organizations in Pakistan,” Journal of Comparative Education 38(4) (2008): 471-482; Yasmeen Samina “Islamisation and Activism of a Muslim NGO in Pakistan” 407-24.

  • 59

    Anheier Helmut K. et. al.Innovation in Strategic Philanthropy (New York: Springer2007).

  • 60

    Bukhari Iman Saleem et. al.“Governance of Third Sector Organizations in Pakistan: The Role of Advisory Board.” South Asian Studies 29(2) (2014): 583.

  • 62

    Flowers Paul“Research Philosophies – Importance and Relevance,” Economic Record 1(1) (2009): 1-3.

  • 63

    Bano Masooda“Public Perception and the Decision to Join NGOs” 87-108; Transparency Watch Organization “A Study of NGOs: Pakistan”; Iqbal Muhammad Asif “The Ideological Divide of the Nonprofit Sector in Pakistan.” Paper presented at the International Conference of the International Society for Third-Sector Research Bangkok 2006.

  • 64

    Baitenmann Helga“NGOs and the Afghan War: The Politicization of Humanitarian Aid” 62-85; Salim L. S. Sadruddin and D. Zakus “Organizational Commitment in a Health Ngo in Pakistan” voluntas: International Journal of Voluntary and Nonprofit Organizations 23(3) (2012): 584-604.

  • 65

    Campos Nauro F. et al.“From Substitution to Complementarity: Some Econometric Evidence on the Evolving NGO-State Relationship in Pakistan.” The Journal of Developing Areas 37(2) (2004): 49-72.

  • 66

    Qureshi Ayaz“Aids Activism in Pakistan: Diminishing Funds Evasive State” 320-38.

  • 73

    Bano“Public Perception and the Decision to Join NGOs in Pakistan” 87-108.

  • 77

    Kickbusch Ilona S.“Health Literacy: Addressing the Health and Education Divide,” Health Promotion International 16(3) (2001): 289-97.

  • 83

    Dasra “India Philanthropy Report 2015.

  • 86

    Ismail Zafar H.“Law and the Nonprofit Sector in Pakistan,” in The Johns Hopkins Comparative Nonprofit Sector Project Pakistan (Islamabad: Social Policy and Development Centre in Collaboration with Aga Khan Foundation and Centre of Civil Society John Hopkins University 2002).

Index Card

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 135 135 20
Full Text Views 190 190 2
PDF Downloads 19 19 1
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0