When we assume that we have cultural competence rather than thoroughly engaging in what Dewey calls the pattern of inquiry, we fail to achieve cultural humility. By analyzing how habits undermine inquiry and underlie failure in situations that call for cultural humility, we may be better equipped to address unintentional offenses. In this essay, I define cultural humility and contrast it with cultural competence, explaining why aiming for cultural competence alone is problematic. Next, I consider the attributes necessary for cultural humility and the attitudes that Dewey considers beneficial for inquiry. This is followed by an outline of Dewey’s pattern of inquiry and explanation of how unquestioned habits of thought short-circuit our ability to become culturally humble. I suggest that we forgo attempting to achieve cultural competence and instead use Dewey’s pattern of inquiry with the attitudes he recommends as tools to work toward cultural humility.
DeweyJohn. 1941. “Propositions, Warranted Assertibility, and Truth.” in The Essential Dewey, Volume Two: Ethics, Logic, Psychology (ed 2), eds. Larry A.Hickman and Thomas M.Alexander (Bloomington: Indiana University Press), pp. 201–212.
JuarezJennifer Anderson, KimMarvel, Kristen L.Brezinski, CherieGlazner, Michael M.Towbin, and SusanLawton. 2006. “Bridging the Gap: A Curriculum to Teach Residents Cultural Humility.” Family Medicine38(2): 97–102.
PaavolaSami. 2015. “Deweyan Approaches to Abduction?” in Action, Belief and Inquiry: Pragmatist Perspectives on Science, Society and Religion, ed. UlfZackariasson (Helsinki: Nordic Pragmatism Network), pp. 230–249.
RosenblattPaul C. 2016. “Cultural Competence and Humility.” in Handbook of Social Justice in Loss and Grief: Exploring Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion, eds. Darcy L.Harris and Tashel C.Bordere (New York: Routledge), pp. 67–74.
TervalonMelanie and JannMurray-García. 1998. “Cultural Humility Versus Cultural Competence: A Critical Distinction in Defining Physician Training Outcomes in Multicultural Education,” Journal of Health Care for the Poor and Underserved9(2): 117–125.