What Does it Mean to be Part of the Elite?

Comparing Norwegian, French and British Top Bureaucrats’ Understandings of the Elite Concept when Applied to Themselves

in Comparative Sociology
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

Whether top bureaucrats are part of the elite or not, and to what degree their possible elite status is legitimate, will depend on how the elite concept is defined. Analyzing 81 British, French and Norwegian top bureaucrats’ arguments for belonging to the elite or not, this paper unpacks the elite concept and explores its meaning along a range of dimensions (organizational, prestige, education, social status, power, wage). These dimensions can be analyzed as indicating either an elite status delimited to the profession or exceeding it, as a societal elite. Rather than what might be expected, a clear contrast between anti-elitist Norwegian and elitist British and French bureaucrats, the comparative analysis of the interviews shows a variation between two different understandings of the elite concept: Norwegians interpret their elite status as delimited to the profession, and British and French bureaucrats define themselves as societal elites.

What Does it Mean to be Part of the Elite?

Comparing Norwegian, French and British Top Bureaucrats’ Understandings of the Elite Concept when Applied to Themselves

in Comparative Sociology

Sections

References

AberbachJoel D.PutnamRobert D.RockmanBert A. Bureaucrats and Politicians in Western Democracies 1981 Cambridge, Mass. Harvard University Press

BarberisPeter The Elite of the Elite: Permament Secretaries in the British Higher Civil Service 1996 Dartmouth Aldershot

BleiklieIvarHøstakerRoarVabøAgnete Policy and Practice in Higher Education 2000 London Jessica Kingsley

BourdieuPierre La Distinction 1979 Paris Les éditions de minuit

BragelienIverMjøsAksel “En Gjennomgang Av Statens Lederlønnssystem. Snf-Rapport Nr. 05/09” 2009 Vol. Bergen Samfunns- og næringslivsforskning AS

ChevènementJean-Pierre L’énarchie Ou Les Mandarins De La Société Bourgeoise 1967 Paris La Table ronde

Dale-OlsenHaraldØstbakkenKjersti Misje “Lønnsulikhet I Norge 1995–2006” Søkelys på arbeidslivet 2009 Vol. 26 Institutt for samfunnsforskning Institutt for samfunnsforskning

DargieCharlotteLockeRachel PageE. C.WrightV. “The British Senior Civil Service” Bureaucratic Elites in Western European States 1999 Oxford Oxford university press

Det tekniske beregningsutvalget for inntektsoppgjørene “Etter Inntektsoppgjørene 2014” 2014 Vol. Oslo Arbeidsdepartementet

DevineFionaSavageMikeScottJohn Rethinking Class: Culture Identities and Lifestyles 2005 Basingstoke Palgrave Macmillan

DrewryGavinButcherTony The Civil Service Today 1991 Oxford B. Blackwell

EvansM. D. R.KelleyJonathanKolosiTamas “Images of Class: Public Perceptions in Hungary and Australia” American Sociological Review 1992 57 4 461 482

EymeriJean-Michel La Fabrique Des Énarques 2001 Paris Economica

EymeriJean-Michel DreyfusF.EymeriJ.-M. “Comparer Les Hauts Fonctionnaires En Europe: Variations Sur Le Thème De La Carrière” Sciences Politique De L’administration. Une Approche Comparative 2006 Paris Economica

FaberStine ThidemannPrieurAnnickRosenlundLennartSkjøtt-LarsenJakob Det Skjulte Klassesamfund 2012 Århus Aarhus universitetsforlag

GallyNatacha “Le Marché Des Hauts Fonctionnaires. Une Comparaison Des Politiques De La Haute Fonction Publique En France Et En Grande-Bretagne” 2012 Thesis in political science Centre d’études européennes Sciences Po Paris Paris

GenieysWilliam La Sociologie Des Élites Politiques 2011 Paris Armand Colin

GiddensAnthony “Elites in the British Class Structure” Sociological Review 1972 20 3 345 372

GlaserBarney G.StraussAnselm L. StraussA. L. The Discovery of Grounded Theory: Strategies for Qualitative Research 1999 New York Aldine de Gruyter [1967]

GullestadMarianne Kitchen-Table Society 2001 Oslo Universitetsforl

HartmannMichael The Sociology of Elites 2006 London Routledge

HartmannMichael Eliten Und Macht in Europa: Ein Internationaler Vergleich 2007 Frankfurt/New York Campus Verlag

HenkelMary Academic Identities and Policy Change in Higher Education 2000 London Jessica Kingsley

HjellbrekkeJohsKorsnesOlav Sosial Mobilitet 2012 Oslo Samlaget

HoudréCédricMissègueNathaliePonceauJuliette “Inégalité Et Niveau De Vie” Vol. Revenues et patrimoine des ménages 2013 Paris Insee

Insee “Salaires Annuels Bruts Dans Quelques Pays De L’union Européenne En 2010” 2013 Paris Insee

JacobsenKnut Dahl “Lojalitet, Nøytralitet Og Faglig Uavhengighet I Sentraladministrasjonen” Tidsskrift for samfunnsforskning 1960 4 231 248

KesslerMarie-Christine L’ena: La Politique De La Haute Fonction Publique 1978 Paris Presses de la FNSP

KesslerMarie-Christine Les Grands Corps De L’etat 1986 Paris Presses de Sciences Po

KhanShamus Rahman Privilege: The Making of an Adolescent Elite at St.Paul’s School 2011 Princeton, N.J. Princeton University Press

Kommunal- og moderniseringsdepartementet “Lønnsutvikling for Statlige Toppledere I 2012”: Kommunal- og moderniseringsdepartementet 2013a

Kommunal- og moderniseringsdepartementet “Statens Personalhåndbok 2014. Gjennomgående Stillinger” 2013b

LamontMichèle Money Morals and Manners: The Culture of the French and American Upper-Middle Class 1992 Chicago, Ill. University of Chicago Press

LamontMichèleMolnarVirág “The Study of Boundaries in the Social Sciences” Annual Review of Sociology 2002 167 196

LienMarianneLidénHildeVikeHalvard Likhetens Paradokser: Antropologiske Undersøkelser I Det Moderne Norge 2001 Oslo Universitetsforlaget

MangsetMarte “Likhet på fransk og norsk” Nytt norsk tidsskrift 2004 2 135 148

MangsetMarte “The discipline of historians: a comparative study of historians’ constructions of the discipline of history in English, French and Norwegian universities” 2009 Thesis in sociology Department of sociology University of Bergen Bergen

MangsetMarte KorsnesO.HjellbrekkeJ.HansenM. Nordli “Kapittel 10. Forvaltningseliten definerer forvaltningseliten” Elite og klasse i et egalitært samfunn 2014 Oslo Universitetsforlaget

MauriceMarcSellierFrancoisSilvestreJean-Jacques Politique D’éducation Et Organisation Industrielle En France Et En Allemagne: Essai D’analyse Sociétale 1982 Paris Presses Universitaires de France

MauriceMarc “Méthode Comparative Et Analyse Sociétale, Les Implications Théoriques Des Comparaisons Internationales” Sociologie du travail 1989 2 175 191

MauriceMarcSorgeArndt MauriceM.SorgeA. Embedding Organizations: Societal Analysis of Actors Organizations and Socio-Economic Context 2000 Amsterdam John Benjamins Pub

MillsC. Wright The Power Elite 1956 London Oxford university press

Ministère de la réforme de l’État de la décentralisation et de la fonction publique “Rapport Annuel De L’état De La Fonction Publique.” 2013 Vol. Paris Ministère de la réforme de l’État, de la décentralisation et de la fonction publique

MoscaGaetano The Ruling Class 1939 New York, N.Y. McGraw-Hill [1896]

MusselinChristine La Longue Marche Des Universités Francaises 2001 Paris Presses universitaires de France

PachuckiMark A.PendergrassSabrinaLamontMichèle “Boundary Processes: Recent Theoretical Developments and New Contributions” Poetics 2007 35 6 331 351

ParetoVilfredo Mind and Society: A Treatise on General Sociology 1963 New York Dover Publications

ReayDiane “Rethinking Social Class: Qualitative Perspectives on Class and Gender” Sociology 1998 32 2 259 275

RichardsDavid “Appointments to the Highest Grades in the Civil Service – Drawing the Curtain Open” Public administration 1996 74 657 677

RothblattSheldonWittrockBjörn The European and American University since 1800. Historical and Sociological Essays 1993 Cambridge Cambridge University Press

SavageMikeBagnallGaynorLonghurstBrian Globalization and Belonging 2005 London Sage

ScottJohn SavageM.WilliamsK. “Modes of Power and the Re-Conceptualization of Elites” Remembering Elites 2008 Oxford Blackwell 27 43

SkarpenesOve “Den ‘Legitime Kulturens’ Moralske Forankring” Tidsskrift for samfunnsforskning 2007 48 4 531 563

SkeggsBeverley Formations of Class and Gender: Becoming Respectable 1997 London Sage

Statistisk sentralbyrå “Lønn, Alle Ansatte, 2012” 2013 Statistisk sentralbyrå Oslo. Unpublished Table.

ThoenigJean-Claude “Les Grands Corps” Pouvoir 1996 79 107 120

VincensJeanJohnstonAnn “Graduates and the Labour Market in France” European Journal of Education 1995 30 2 133 156

WeberMax Economy and Society 1992 Berkeley, Los Angeles, London University of California press [1922]

WitteJohanna “Change of Degrees and Degrees of Change: Comparing Adaptations of European Higher Education Systems in the Context of the Bologna Process” 2006 Center for higher education policy studies University of Twente Entschede.

Information

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 56 56 34
Full Text Views 86 86 61
PDF Downloads 9 9 5
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0