The Worker’s Hotline in Israel: Simultaneous Subculture of Opposition and Collaboration

in Comparative Sociology
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?


This paper studies the cultural features of one organization promoting workers’ social welfare. The Worker’s Hotline challenges human rights violations by exploitive employers and the Israeli government. The Worker’s Hotline uses a variety of political strategies: collaborating with governmental agencies and fighting against the authorities, even while being funded by them. The main research question is: What is the Hotline’s defining cultural features? Can it be considered counterculture or subculture of values? The authors utilized qualitative research methods. They conducted 25 interviews; gathered documents from websites and then analyzed these interviews and documents. The findings indicated the Worker’s Hotline cultural features were primarily left-wing with socialist principles. This association’s organizational culture can be identified as a subculture, opposing dominant Israeli right-wing capitalist culture in legal spectrum. This case study’s uniqueness is its suggestion that the Hotline is a sophisticated subculture, whose activists simultaneously operate with and against the authorities.



AllmanP. Critical Education against Global Capitalism: Karl Marx and Revolutionary Critical Education (Critical Studies in Education and Culture Series) 2001 Westport, CT Begin & Garvey

AllmanP. On Marx 2007 Rotterdam, Netherlands Sense

AlmogO. Preidah L’Srulik: Shinui Arakhim Ba’elitah Ha’Yisraelit (Farewell to Srulik: Changing Values among the Israeli Elite) 2004 Haifa, Israel Zmora Bitan

AlthusserL. Al Ha’idiologiah: Manganone Hamedina (On Ideology: The State’s Ideological Mechanism) 2003 Tel Aviv Resling

AnovhY. Introduction to Sociology 2000 Ra’anana, Israel Open University

BangH.AndersE. “Good Governance in Network Society: Reconfiguring the Political from Politics to Policy.” Administrative Theory & Praxis 2009 31 1 7 37

Ben-RefaelE.SternbergY. Elitot Hadashot b’Yisrael (New Elites in Israel) 2007 Jerusalem Bialik Institute

BlittR.C. “Who will Watch the Watchdogs? Human Rights Non-Governmental Organizations and the Case for Regulation.” Buffalo Human Rights Law Review 2005 10 261 398

BourdieuP. The Field of Cultural Production 1993 Cambridge Polity Press

BrownC.Pluta BrownG.K. “Moo U and the 26th Amendment: Registering for Peace And Voting for Responsive City Government.” Peace and Change 2004 29 1 48 80

BrownT.S. “Subcultures, Pop Music and Politics: Skinheads and ‘Nazi Rock’ in England and Germany.” Journal of Social History 2004 38 1 157 177

CannellaG.S.PerezM.S. “Emboldened Patriarchy in Higher Education: Feminist Readings of Capitalism, Violence, and Power.” Cultural Studies ↔ Critical Methodologies 2012 12 4 279 286

CarpenterS. “Centering Marxist-Feminist Theory in Adult Learning.” Adult Education Quarterly 2012 62 1 19 35

ChandlerD. Constructing Global Civil Society: Morality and Power in International Relations 2004 New York Palgrave-Macmillan

ChatfieldC. “At the Hands Of Historians: The Antiwar Movement of the Vietnam Era.” Peace and Change 2004 29 3–4 483 521

ChurchillD.S. “Specters of Anti-Communism: Richard Rorty and Leftist Thought in Twentieth Century America.” Canadian Review of American Studies 2008 38 2 275 291

CruzJ. “This ain’t Paris Sweetie: Exploring West African and French Identity In the Southern United States.” Qualitative Inquiry 2010 16 10 792 800

DeLeonP.DanielleV.M. “Toward a Theory of Collaborative Policy Networks: Identifying Structural Tendencies.” Policy Studies Journal 2009 37 1 59 74

DetomasiD. “The Multinational Corporation and Global Governance: Modeling Global Public Policy Networks.” Journal of Business Ethics 2007 71 321 334

Etzioni-HalevyE. Makom B’tsameret Elitot V’elitism B’Yisrael (A Place at the Top: Elites and Elitism in Israel) 1997 Tel Aviv Tcherikover Press

FeixaC.PereiraI.JefferyS. “Global Citizenship and the ‘New, New’ Social Movements: Iberian Connections.” Young 2009 17 4 421 442

GeertzC. The Interpretations of Cultures 1973 New York Basic Books

GilroyP. There Ain’t No Black in the Union Jack 1987 London Hutchinson

GonzalezL.S. “Reclaiming Salsa.” Cultural Studies 1999 13 2 35 45

GraiouidS. “We have Not Buried the Simple Past: The Public Sphere and Post-Colonial Literature in Morocco.” Journal of African Cultural Studies 2008 20 2 145 158

GramsciA. Al Ha’hegamoniah (About Hegmony) 2004 Tel Aviv Resling

GrantR.W.RobertK.E. “Accountability and Abuses of Power in World Politics.” American Political Science Review 2005 99 1 29 43

HorkheimerM.AdornoT.W. Dialectic of Enlightenment: Philosophical Fragments 2002 Stanford Stanford University

HowlettM.RameshM. Studying Public Policy: Policy Cycles and Policy Subsystems. 2003 Toronto Oxford University Press

Israel Ministry of the Interior Regulation Number 5.2.0023 2013 Jerusalem Israel Ministry of the Interior

Israel Supreme Court Verdict HCJ 11437/05 2005 Jerusalem Israel Supreme Court

JanesickV.J. DenzinN.K.LincolnY.S. “The Choreography of Qualitative Research Design.” Handbook of Qualitative Research, 2000 Thousand Oaks, CA Sage 379 399

JurisJ.S. “Violence Performed and Imagined Militant Action, The Black Bloc and The Mass Media in Genoa.” Critique of Anthropology 2005 25 4 413 432

JurisJ.S.PleyersG.H. “Alter-Activism: Emerging Cultures of Participation among Young Global Justice Activists.” Journal of Youth Studies 2009 12 1 57 75

KeckM.SikkinkK. Activist Beyond Borders: Advocacy Network In International Politics 1998 Cornel, NY Cornel University Press

KimmerlingB. Mehagrim, Mityashvim, Yelidim: Hamedinah V’haḥevrah B’yisrael – Ben Riboy Tarbuyot L’milḥamot Tarbut (Immigrants, Settlers, Natives: The State and Society in Israel – Between Multiple Cultures and Culture Wars) 2004 Tel Aviv Am Oved

KlijnE.H.KoppenjanJ. “Public Management and Policy Networks: Foundations of a Network Approach to Governance.” Public Management 2000 2 2 135 158

KlinovR. NatanzonR.AhdutL. “Trumat Hagirah l’Tzorekh Avodah Litsimikhah Kalkalit Shel Medinot Hamotsah shel Ha’ovdim (The Contribution of Immigration for Work for Economic Growth of the Country of Origin of the Workers).” Hapoa’lim Haḥadashim (The New Workers: Wage Earners from Foreign Countries in Israel) 1999 Tel Aviv Hakibbutz Hameuchad 226 252

LeighT.W.PetersC.SheltonJ. “The Consumer Quest for Authenticity: The Multiplicity of Meanings within the mg Subculture of Consumption.” Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science 2006 34 4 481 493

LewisD. “NGOs, Organizational Culture, and Institutional Sustainability.” ANNALS, AAPSS 2003 590 212 227

MaozZ. “The Effects of Strategic and Economic Interdependence on International Conflict Across Levels of Analysis.” American Journal of Political Science 2009 53 1 223 240

MenuhinY. Activizim Veshinuy Hevrati (Activism and Social Change) 2010 Jerusalem November Books

MoskovichY. Disunity in Unity: The Power Struggle inside the Likud Party from 1974 to 2002 2004 Tel Aviv Tcherikover Press

MoskovichY. Activist leadership in the new Israeli labor unions – the Histadrut: Bringing about privatization, downsizing, and goal transformation, an Israeli case study International Journal of Organizational Transformation & Social Change 2015 12 2 159 172

MoskovichY.AchouchY. “Cultural Change in the Kibbutz Factory ‘Bereshit’ (Genesis): An Israeli Case Study.” Journal of Organizational Transformation & Social Change 2013 10 1 21 41

NatanG. Mehagrey Avodah V’korbanot Sahar Bivney-Adam: Mediniut Hamemshalah U’pe’ilut Reshut Hahagirah (Labor Migrants and Victims of Human Trafficking: Government Policy and Immigration Authority Action) 2009 Jerusalem The Knesset Research and Information Center

NissenkornA. “Ovdim Zarim – Hatsorekh l’Shinui (Foreign Workers – The Need for Change).” Hevrah: Hayarchon Hasocialisti L’inyanei Hevrati’im, Kalkala’im v’Hevrati’im 2002 3 3 55 70

NyeJ. Soft Power: The Means to Success in World Politics 2004 New York Public Affairs

RamU. RamU.YiftachelO. “Ben Haneshek Vehameshek: HaPost-Tsionut HaLiberalit Be’idan HaOlamkomi (Between Weapons and Economy: Liberal Post-Zionism in the Global-Local Age).” ‘Etnocratia’ v’Olamkomi’ut: Gishot Hadashot l’Heker Haḥevra v’Hamerḥav b’Yisrael (Ethnocracy and Global-Local New Approaches to Studying Israeli Society and Area) 1999 Beer Sheva, Israel Ben-Gurion University 43 102

RegevM. Sociologiah Shel Hatarbut (The Sociology of Culture) 2011 Ra’anna, Israel The Open University

RubchakM. “Seeing Pink: Searching for Gender Justice Through Opposition in Ukraine.” European Journal of Women’s Studies 2012 19 1 55 57

Sabar Ben-YehoshuaN. Hameḥkar Ha’ekhuti Behora’ah Uvae’midah (Qualitative Research in Teaching and Learning) 1999 Tel Aviv Modan

SaundersT.L. “Black Thoughts, Black Activism: Cuban Underground Hip-Hop and Afro-Latino Countercultures of Modernity.” Latin American Perspectives 2012 39 42 60

ScarrittA. “Broker Fixed: The Racialized Social Structure and The Subjugation of Indigenous Populations in the Andes.” Critical Sociology 2011 37 2 153 177

ScarrittA. “First the Revolutionary Culture Innovations in Empowered Citizenship from Evangelical Highland Peru.” Latin American Perspectives 2013 40 4 101 120

ShkediA. Milim Hamenasot Laga’at: Meḥkar Eikhutani – Te’ori’ah Veyisum (Words of Meaning: Qualitative Research – Theory and Practice) 2004 Tel Aviv Ramot

SteinbergG. “NGOs, the UN, and the Politics Of Human Rights in the Arab-Israeli Conflict.” Israel Journal of Foreign Affairs 2011 1 73 88

StraussA.CorbinJ.M. Basics of Qualitative Research: Grounded Theory Procedures and Techniques 1990 London Sage Publications

TateW. Counting the Dead: The Culture and Politics of Human Rights Activism in Colombia 2007 Berkeley University of California Press

ThorntonS. Club Cultures 1996 Lebanon, NH University Press of New England

TzabarG. Lo Banu Lehisha’er – Mehagrei Avodah, Me’Afrika LeYisrael U’veḥazarah (We Didn’t Come to Stay – Labor Migrants, from Africa to Israel and Back) 2008 Tel Aviv Tel Aviv University Press

WadhamH.WarrenR.C. “Telling Organizational Tales: The Extended Case Method in Practice.” Organizational Research Methods 2014 17 1 5 22

WalkerD.MyrickF. “Grounded Theory: An Exploration of Process and Procedure.” Qualitative Health Research 2006 16 4 547

WilliamsR. KatzE.YanovitzkyI. “Base and superstructure in Marxist Cultural Theory.” Readings in Leisure, Culture and Communication, 1999 Ramat Aviv, Israel The Open University 39 53

WinkD. “Forging Post-Colonial Identities through Acts of Translation?” Journal of African Cultural Studies 2009 21 1 65 74

Worker’s Hotline “Worker’s Hotline Website.” n.d. Retrieved August 20, 2014 (

Ya’arE.ShavitZ. Megamot Baḥevra HaYisra’elit (Trends in Israeli Society) 2001 Ramat Aviv, Israel The Open University

YinR.K. Case Study Research: Design and Methods 2014 Los Angeles Sage


Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 5 5 2
Full Text Views 2 2 2
PDF Downloads 0 0 0
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0