Voter Volatility in Electoral Authoritarian Regimes: Testing the “Tragic Brilliance” Thesis

in Comparative Sociology
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?


According to the “tragic brilliance” thesis advanced in the recent literature on electoral authoritarian regimes, such regimes retain their ability to to achieve electoral success even in the conditions when the national economy deteriorates. This study uses the data on voter volatility in 93 electoral authoritarian regimes and new democracies in order to validate the “tragic brilliance” thesis empirically. The analysis supports the “tragic brilliance” thesis. While in new democracies, a strong correlation between government economic performance and voter volatility can be observed, voter volatility in electoral authoritarian regimes is not facilitated by poor economic performance. Voter volatility declines if such regimes are able to achieve cooptation of sub-national elites without depriving them of substantial autonomy.

Voter Volatility in Electoral Authoritarian Regimes: Testing the “Tragic Brilliance” Thesis

in Comparative Sociology



BartoliniStefanoMairPeter Identity Competition and Electoral Availability: The Stabilisation of European Electorates 1885–1995 1990 Cambridge Cambridge University Press

BednarJenna The Robust Federation: Principles of Design 2008 Cambridge Cambridge University Press

BirchSarah Electoral Systems and Political Transformation in Post-Communist Europe 2003 New York Palgrave Macmillan

BlaydesLisa Elections and Distributive Politics in Mubarak’s Egypt 2010 New York Cambridge University Press

BrancatiDawn “Winning Alone: The Electoral Fate of Independent Candidates Worldwide” Journal of Politics 2008a 70 3 648 662

BrancatiDawn “The Origins and Strength of Regional Parties” British Journal of Political Science 2008b 38 1 135 159

BrinksDanielCoppedgeMichael “Diffusion Is No Illusion: Neighbor Emulation in the Third Wave of Democracy” Comparative Political Studies 2006 39 4 463 489

BrookerPaul Non-Democratic Regimes 2013 3rd edition Basingstoke Palgrave Macmillan

BunceValerie J.WolchikSharon L. “Defeating Dictators: Electoral Change and Stability in Competitive Authoritarian Regimes” World Politics 2010 62 1 43 86

CampbellAngusConversePhilip E.MillerWarren E.StokesDonald E. The American Voter 1960 New York Wiley

CaramaniDaniele The Nationalization of Politics: The Formation of National Electorates and Party Systems in Western Europe 2004 Cambridge Cambridge University Press

CrookR. C. “Winning Coalitions and Ethno-Regional Politics: The Failure of the Opposition in the 1990 and 1995 Elections in Côte D’Ivoir” African Affairs 1997 96 no. 383 215 242

DemchenkoOlegGolosovGrigorii V. “Federalism, Gubernatorial Power and the Incorporation of Subnational Authoritarianism in Russia: A Theory-testing Empirical Inquiry” Acta Politica 2016 51 1 61 79

Diaz-CayerosAlbertoMagaloniBeatrizWeingastBarry R. “Tragic Brilliance: Equilibrium Party Hegemony in Mexico” 2003 Retrieved March 5 2016 ( or

DimitrovMartin K. “Debating the Color Revolutions: Popular Autocrats” Journal of Democracy 2009 20 1 78 81

EgorovGeorgyGurievSergeiSoninKonstantin “Why Resource-poor Dictators Allow Freer Media: A Theory and Evidence from Panel Data” American Political Science Review 2009 103 4 645 668

ErssonSvanteJandaKennethLaneJan-Erik “Ecology of Party Strength in Western Europe: A Regional Analysis.” Comparative Political Studies 1985 18 2 170 205

FerreeKaren E. “The Social Origins of Electoral Volatility in Africa” British Journal of Political Science 2010 40 4 759 779

Freedom House “Freedom in the World” 2014 Retrieved December 16 2014 (

GilleyBruce “Democratic Enclaves in Authoritarian Regimes” Democratization 2010 17 3 389 415

GolosovGrigorii V. “The Effective Number of Parties: A New Approach” Party Politics 2010 16 2 171 192

GolosovGrigorii V. “The Regional Roots of Electoral Authoritarianism in Russia” Europe-Asia Studies 2011 63 4 623 639

GolosovGrigorii V. “The 2012 Political Reform in Russia: The Interplay of Liberalizing Concessions and Authoritarian Corrections” Problems of Post-Communism 2012 59 6 3 14

GolosovGrigorii V. “Authoritarian Party Systems: Patterns of Emergence, Sustainability and Survival” Comparative Sociology 2013 12 5 617 644

GolosovGrigorii V. “Party System Nationalization: The Problems of Measurement with an Application to Federal States” Party Politics 2016a 22 3 278 288

GolosovGrigorii V. “Factors of Party System Nationalization” International Political Science Review 2016b 37 2 246 260

GuterbockThomas M. Machine Politics in Transition: Party and Community in Chicago 1980 Chicago University of Chicago Press

HickenAllen “Clentelism” Annual Review of Political Science 2011 14 289 310

HowardMarc M.RoesslerPhilip G. “Liberalizing Electoral Outcomes in Competitive Authoritarian Regimes” American Journal of Political Science 2006 50 2 365 381

HuntingtonSamuel P. Political Order in Changing Societies 1968 New Haven Yale University Press

International idea “Voter Turnout Database” 2014 Retrieved December 10 2014 (

JonesMark P.MainwaringScott “The Nationalization of Parties and Party Systems: An Empirical Measure and an Application to the Americas” Party Politics 2003 9 2 139 166

JosephRichard “Democracy and Reconfigured Power in Africa” Current History 2011 110 no. 739 324 330

KuenziMichelleLambrightGina “Party Systems and Democratic Consolidation in Africa’s Electoral Regimes” Party Politics 2005 11 4 423 446

LaaksoMarkkuTaageperaRein “ ‘Effective’ Number of Parties: A Measure with Application to West Europe” Comparative Political Studies 1979 12 1 3 27

LehoucqFabrice “Electoral Fraud: Causes, Types, and Consequences” Annual Review of Political Science 2003 6 233 256

Lewis-BeckMichael S.StegmaierMary “Economic Determinants of Electoral Outcomes” Annual Review of Political Science 2000 3 183 219

LindbergStaffan I. Democratization by Elections: A New Mode of Transition 2009 Baltimore Johns Hopkins University Press

Lust-OkarEllen “Elections under Authoritarianism: Preliminary Lessons from Jordan” Democratization 2006 13 3 456 471

MagaloniBeatriz Voting for Autocracy: Hegemonic Party Survival and Its Demise in Mexico 2006 New York Cambridge University Press

MagaloniBeatriz “The Game of Electoral Fraud and the Ousting of Authoritarian Rule” American Journal of Political Science 2010 54 3 751 765

MagaloniBeatrizKricheliRuth “Political Order and One-party Rule” Annual Review of Political Science 2010 13 123 143

MainwaringScottZocoEdurne “Political Sequences and the Stabilization of Interparty Competition Electoral Volatility in Old and New Democracies” Party Politics 2007 13 2 155 178

MaleskyEdmundSchulerPaul “Paint-by-Numbers Democracy: The Stakes, Structure, Results, and Implications of the 2007 Vietnamese National Assembly Elections” Journal of Vietnamese Studies 2008 4 1 1 48

MozaffarShaheenScarrittJames “The Puzzle of African Party Systems” Party Politics 2005 11 4 399 421

NorrisPippa “The New Research Agenda Studying Electoral Integrity” Electoral Studies 2013 32 4 563 575

O’BrienRobert M. “A Caution Regarding Rules of Thumb for Variance Inflation Factors” Quality and Quantity 2007 41 5 673 690

ObydenkovaAnastassiaSwendenWilfried “Autocracy-sustaining versus Democratic Federalism: Explaining the Divergent Trajectories of Territorial Politics in Russia and Western Europe” Territory Politics Governance 2013 1 1 86 112

PedersenMogens “The Dynamics of European Party Systems: Changing Patterns of Electoral Volatility” European Journal of Political Research 1979 7 1 1 26

PedersenMogens DaalderHansMairPeter “Changing Patterns of Electoral Volatility in European Party Systems, 1948–1977” Western European Party Systems: Continuity and Change 1983 Beverly Hills, CA Sage 29 66

PepinskyThomas “The Institutional Turn in Comparative Authoritarianism” British Journal of Political Science 2014 44 3 631 653

PowellEleanor N.TuckerJoshua A. “Revisiting Electoral Volatility in Post-Communist Countries: New Data, New Results and New Approaches” British Journal of Political Science 2014 44 1 123 147

PowellG. BinghamWhittenGuy D. “A Cross-National Analysis of Economic Voting: Taking Account of the Political Context” American Journal of Political Science 1993 37 2 391 414

RenwickAlan “Electoral Reform in Europe since 1945” West European Politics 2011 34 3 456 477

ReuterOra J.RemingtonThomas F. “Dominant Party Regimes and the Commitment Problem: The Case of United Russia” Comparative Political Studies 2009 42 4 501 526

RobertsKenneth M.WibbelsErik “Party Systems and Electoral Volatility in Latin America: A Test of Economic, Institutional, and Structural Explanations” American Political Science Review 1999 93 3 575 590

RonigerLuis “Political Clientelism, Democracy, and Market Economy” Comparative Politics 2004 36 3 353 375

SchedlerAndreas “The Nested Game of Democratization by Elections” International Political Science Review 2002a 23 1 103 122

SchedlerAndreas “Elections Without Democracy: The Menu of Manipulation” Journal of Democracy 2002b 13 2 36 50

SchedlerAndreas Electoral Authoritarianism: The Dynamics of Unfree Competition 2006 Boulder, CO Lynne Rienner

ScottJames C. “Patron-Client Politics and Political Change in Southeast Asia” American Political Science Review 1972 66 1 91 113

ShefterMartin Political Parties and the State: The American Historical Experience 1994 Princeton Princeton University Press

SikkAllan “How Unstable? Volatility and the Genuinely New Parties in Eastern Europe” European Journal of Political Research 2005 44 3 391 412

SimpserAlberto AlvarezMichaelHallThad E.HydeSusan D. “Unintended Consequences of Election Monitoring” Election Fraud: Detecting and Preventing Electoral Manipulation 2008 Washington, DC Brookings Institution 216 234

StokesDonald E. ChambersWilliam N.BurnhamWalter D. “Parties and the Nationalization of Electoral Forces” The American Party Systems: States of Political Development 1967 New York Oxford University Press 182 202

StokesSusan C.DunningThadNazarenoMarceloBruscoValeria Brokers Voters and Clientelism: The Puzzle of Distributive Politics 2013 New York Cambridge University Press

TavitsMargit “The Development of Stable Party Support: Electoral Dynamics in Post-Communist Europe” American Journal of Political Science 2005 49 2 283 298

TavitsMargit “On the Linkage between Electoral Volatility and Party System Instability in Central and Eastern Europe” European Journal of Political Research 2008 47 5 537 555

TezcurGünes M. Lust-OkarEllenZerhouniSaloua “Intra-elite Struggles in Iranian Elections” Political Participation in the Middle East and North Africa 2008 Boulder, CO Lynne Rienner 51 74

TókaGabor “Party Appeals and Voter Loyalty in New Democracies” Political Studies 1998 46 3 589 610

TókaGaborGosselinTania “Persistent Political Divides, Electoral Volatility and Citizen Involvement: The Freezing Hypothesis in the 2004 European Election” West European Politics 2010 33 3 608 633

United Nations Statistics Division UNdata 2015 Retrieved March 13 2015 (

WahmanMichael “Democratization and Electoral Turnovers in Sub-Saharan Africa and Beyond” Democratization 2014 21 2 220 243

WeingastBarry R. “Second Generation Fiscal Federalism: Political Aspects of Decentralization and Economic Development” World Development 2014 53 14 25

ZavadskayaMargaritaWelzelChristian “Subverting Autocracy: Emancipative Mass Values in Competitive Authoritarian Regimes” Democratization 2015 22 6 1105 1130

ZhongYangChenJie “To Vote or not to Vote: An Analysis of Peasants’ Participation in Chinese Village Elections.” Comparative Political Studies 2002 35 6 686 712



Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 44 44 17
Full Text Views 68 68 49
PDF Downloads 4 4 1
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0