The Transformation of Higher Education Systems in Six Post-Soviet Countries: Causes and Consequences of Organizational Change

in Comparative Sociology
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?


The paper examines how and to what extent the Soviet higher education system transformed after the collapse of the ussr. It offers a research-based analysis of the external and internal factors of transformation in six post-Soviet countries: three “Slavic” states (Belarus, Russia, Ukraine), and three Baltic states (Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania). The paper characterizes a bounded number of types of organizations of higher education in each country. Using the set-theoretic multi-value qualitative comparative analysis (mvQCA), the authors identify several causal chains that led to the transformation of the Soviet comprehensive university into a ‘post-Soviet research university’ or ‘general education organization’. This paper compares the drivers of organizational diversity in Soviet and post-Soviet education, and traces country-specific features of the organizational transformation of universities in six post-Soviet countries.

The Transformation of Higher Education Systems in Six Post-Soviet Countries: Causes and Consequences of Organizational Change

in Comparative Sociology



BatesA.GodońR.R. “Tackling knowledge ‘like a business’? Rethinking the modernisation of higher education in Poland” Compare 2016 10 1 14

BazhanovV.A. “From Under the Rubble: Logic and Philosophy of Logic in the USSR and the Ideologized Science Phenomenon” Social Epistemology 2016 11 1 12

BrunnerJ.J.TillettA. Higher education in Central Asia: The challenges of modernization: Case studies from Kazakhstan Tajikistan The Kyrgyz Republic and Uzbekistan 2007 Washington, DC World Bank

ByrneD.RaginC.C. ByrneD.RaginC.C. “The Case for Qualitative Comparative Analysis (qca): Adding Leverage for Thick Cross-case Comparison” The sage Handbook of Case-Based Methods 2009 London SAGE Publications Ltd 222 242

CharlesM.BradleyK. “Equal but separate? A cross-national study of sex segregation in higher education” American Sociological Review 2002 67 573 599

ChirikovI. “Do Russian Research Universities Have a Secret Mission? A Response to Forrat” Post-Soviet Affairs 2016 32 4 338 344

ClarkB.R. The Higher Education System: Academic Organization in Cross-National Perspective 1983 Berkeley and Los Angeles University of California Press

DiMaggioP.J.PowellW. “The Iron Cage Revisited Institutional Isomorphism and Collective Rationality in Organizational Fields” American Sociological Review 1983 48 147 160

DobbinsM. Higher Education Policies in Central and Eastern Europe – Convergence towards a Common Model? 2011 Basingstoke Palgrave Macmillan

Gille-BelovaO. “Reforms of Higher Education in Belarus: Between the Weight of the Soviet Heritage and a Diffuse International Influence” Revue d’Etudes Comparatives Est-Ouest 2014 45 1 55 90

HeynemanS.DeYoungA. Challenges for Education in Central Asia 2004 Greenwich, CT Information Age Publishing

HladchenkoM. “The organizational identity of Ukrainian universities as claimed through their mission statements” Tertiary Education and Management 2016 22 4 376 389

HüfnerK. Higher Education Reform Processes in Central and Eastern Europe 1995 Frankfurt am Main Peter Lang (ed.)

HuismanJ. The Conceptual Framework of The Project “Higher Education System Dynamics and Institutional Diversity in Post-Soviet Countries” 2015

JohnsonM.S. BakerD.P.WisemanA.W. “Historical Legacies of Soviet Higher Education and the Transformation of Higher Education Systems in Post-Soviet Russia And Eurasia” The Worldwide Transformation of Higher Education 2008 Emerald Group Publishing Limited 159 176 International Perspectives on Education and Society

JolliffeD.CamposN.F. “Does Market Liberalisation Reduce Gender Discrimination? Econometric evidence from Hungary 1986-1998” Labour Economics 2005 12 1 22

KapustinA. “The Bologna Process: Practical Steps for Russian Law Schools” International Journal of Legal Information 2007 35 2 246 260

KhairullinaN.G.UstinovaO.V.AntipinaN.L.ZykovaV.K.RomanovaT.A. “Reforming of the system of higher education in the state of the former Soviet Union: Characteristics and problems” International Journal of Environmental and Science Education 2016 11 9 2711 2726

KivinenO.RinneR. “Methodological Challenges for Comparative Research Into Higher Education” Interchange 1998 29 2 121 136

KovalevskyV.KirkoV. “Strategic Bases of Regional University’s Modern Economic Model” Economic Annals-XXI 2015 1-2 1 24 27

KuzminovY.SemenovD.FrouminI. “The Structure of the University Network: From the Soviet to Russian ‘Master Plan’” Russian Education and Society 2015 57 4 254 321

LobodzinskaB. “Polish Women’s Gender-Segregated Education and Employment” Women’s Studies International Forum 2000 23 49 71

LuchinskayaD.OvchynnikovaO. “The Bologna Process Policy Implementation in Russia and Ukraine: Similarities and Differences” European Educational Research Journal 2011 10 1 21 33

MarginsonS. “Dynamics of National and Global Competition in Higher Education” Higher Education 2006 52 1 1 39

MkrttchianV.AysmontasB.UddinM.A.AndreevA.VorovchenkoN. “The Academic Views from Moscow Universities on the Future of Dee at Russia and Ukraine” Identification Evaluation and Perceptions of Distance Education Experts: 2015 32 45

NewellA.B. Reilly “Rates of Return to Educational Qualifications in the Transitional Economies” Education Economics 1999 7 67 84

NorkusZ. On Baltic Slovenia and Adriatic Lithuania: a qualitative comparative analysis of patterns in post-communist transformation 2012 Vilnius, Lithuania Apostrofa

PaciP. Gender in Transition 2002 Washington, D.C. World Bank

PaternostroS.D.E. Sahn “Wage Determination and Gender Discrimination in a Transition Economy: The Case of Romania” World Bank Policy Research Working Paper 1999 No. 2113

PolyzoiE.DneprovE. PolyzoiE.FullanM.AnchanJ.P. “Harnessing the Forces of Change: Educational transformation in Russia” Change Forces in Post-Communist Eastern Europe: Education in transition 2003 London and New York Routledge Falmer

PowellW.W.DiMaggioP.J. The New Institutionalism in Organizational Analysis. 1991 Chicago/London The University of Chicago Press

RaaperR. “Tracing Assessment Policy Discourses in Neoliberalised Higher Education Settings” Journal of Education Policy 2016 11 1 18

RaginC.C. The Comparative Method: Moving Beyond Qualitative and Quantitative Strategies 1987 Berkeley University of California Press

RezaevA.MaletzO. “Higher Education Studies: Toward a New Scholarly Discipline” As the World Turns: Implications of Global Shifts in Higher Education for Theory Research and Practice 2012 Emerald Group Publishing Limited 169 196 Advances in Education in Diverse Communities: Research Policy and Praxis edited by W.R. Allen R.T. Teranishi M. Bonous-Hammarth.

SaarE.UntM.KoganI. “Transition from Educational System to Labour Market in the European Union: A Comparison between New and Old Members” International Journal of Comparative Sociology 2008 49 1 31 59

SaarE.MõttusR. Higher Education in the Crossroad: the Case of Estonia 2013 Frankfurt Peter Lang (eds.)

SaarE.RoosaluT.RoosmaaE.TammA.VöörmannR. SaarE.UreO.B.HolfordJ. “Developing human capital in post-socialist capitalism: Estonian experience” Lifelong Learning in Europe: National Patterns and Challenges 2013 Edward Elgar Publishing 372 396

ShawM.A.ChapmanD.W.RumyantsevaN.L. “The impact of the Bologna Process on academic staff in Ukraine” Higher Education Management and Policy 2012 23 3 1 21

SigmanC. “The transformations of Higher Education in Russia: The Evolution of the Public Sector and its Impact on Universities’ Strategies” Revue d’Etudes Comparatives Est-Ouest 2012 45 21 54

SilovaI.EklofB. ArnoveR.F.TorresC.A. “Education in Eastern and Central Europe: Re-thinking post-socialism in the context of globalization” Comparative education: The dialectic between the global and the local 2013 4th edition New York Rowman and Littlefield Publishers 379 402

SilovaI.MagnoC. “Gender equity unmasked: democracy, gender, and education in Central/Southeastern Europe and the Former Soviet Union” Comparative Education Review 2004 48 4 417 442

SmolentsevaA. “The Expansion of Higher Education and the Transformation of the Institutional Landscape in Post-Soviet Counties” herb 2016a 2 8 6 8

SmolentsevaA. “Universal higher education and positional advantage: Soviet legacies and neoliberal transformations in Russia” Higher Education. 2016b April 1 18

SoltysD. Education for decline: Soviet vocational and technical schooling from Khrushchev to Gorbachev 1997 Toronto University of Toronto Press

SoltysD. “Divergence, and Incapacity in the Bologna Process Reform Implementation by the Former-Socialist Countries: The Self-Defeat of SelfRegulations. Comparative Education” 2014 Retrieved October 1 2016 (

StanovnikT. “The Returns to Education in Slovenia” Economics of Education Review 1997 16 443 449

StarikovV. “Transformations of Higher Education Systems in Belarus, Russia, Ukraine and Baltic States: Comparative Analysis” PhD dissertation Department of Socio-logy St Petersburg State University St Petersburg.

TampayevaG.Y. “Importing Education: Europeanisation and the Bologna Process in Europe’s Backyard – the Case of Kazakhstan” European Educational Research Journal 2015 14 1 74 85

TeichlerU. Changing patterns of the higher education system 1988 London Jessica Kingsley

TerämäE.KõuA.KCSamir “Early transition trends and differences of higher education attainment in the former Soviet Union, Central and Eastern European countries” Finnish Yearbook of Population Research 2014 49 105 122

TerzianS. “International Influences on Post-Soviet Armenian Education” European Journal of Education 2016 51 2 281 294

TolbertP.S. “Institutional environments and resource dependence: Sources of administrative structure in institutions of higher education” Administrative Science Quarterly 1985 30 1 1 13

TomincP. “Some aspects of the gender wage gap in Slovenia” Drustvena istrazivanja 2002 11 6 879 896

TomuskV. “Aristoscientists, Academic Proletariat and Reassembling the Mega-machine: 21st century survival strategies of the Estonian academia” International Studies in Sociology of Education 2003 13 77 99

TomuskV. The open world and closed societies: essays on higher education policies ‘in transition’ 2004 New York Palgrave Macmillan

TrowM. Problems in the Transition from Elite to Mass Higher Education 1973 Carnegie Commission on Higher Education


Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 41 41 13
Full Text Views 77 77 56
PDF Downloads 6 6 4
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0