Clan-Culture Attributes in a Privatized Kibbutz Industry: An Israeli Case Study

in Comparative Sociology
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?


This article focuses on one privatized kibbutz factory. The research question was: How did this factory preserve clan cultural features after the process of privatization, while most other privatized kibbutz factories discarded their communal nature and became bureaucratic and highly hierarchic? While most privatized kibbutz factories experienced worker alienation and frustration, this case study describes an organization with a strong culture of commitment and solidarity among workers. Management, on its part, invests in the workers and encourages them to develop with the factory. The findings indicate that a double social control mechanism maintains the factory’s success. Within a family-like working environment, internal control demands professionalism, commitment, integrity, quality, and innovation. External control, from the surrounding kibbutz community, reinforces communal values.



AlmaliachT. Hata’sia Hakibbutzit 1923-2007: Hebetim Calcali’im v’Hevrati’im (The Kibbutz Industry 1923-2007: Economic and Social Considerations) 2009 Givat Chaviva, Israel Yad Ya’ari

ArbelS. Kibbutz Movement Yearly Report: Data for 2011 2013 Tel Aviv The Kibbutz Movement

AtzeniM. Alternative Work Organization 2012 London Palgrave

Ben-RafaelE. Hevrat Kibbutzit: Shinui v’Hemshehiut (Kibbutz Society: Change and Continuity) 1992 Tel Aviv Open University Press

Ben-RafaelE. and M. Topel. PalgiM.ReinharzS. “Redefining the Kibbutz” The Kibbutz at One Hundred: A Century of Crises and Reinvention 2011 Piscataway Township, NJ Transaction Publishers 249 258

BerlinY. Shorishei Hata’asia HaYisraelit (Hebrew Industry: Roots) 1987 Jerusalem Keter Publishing

CameronK. S.QuinnR. E. Diagnosing and Changing Organizational Culture-Based on the Competing Values Framework 1999 New York Addison-Wesley

CameronK. S.QuinnR. E.DegraffJ. Competing Values Leadership: Creating Value in Organizations 2007 Northampton, Massachusetts Edward Edgar Publishing

CheneyG.CruzI. S.PeredoA. M.NazarenoE. “Worker Cooperative as an Alternative: Challenges, Achievements and Promise in Business Governance and Ownership” Organization 2014 21 5 591 603

EdomS.EdurR.KrollY. “Motives, Expectations and Results of 2000-2009 M&A Privatization Process of the Industrial Activity of Israeli Kibbutzim” Journal of Cooperative Organization and Management 2015 3 2 84 93

ElsmoreP. Organizational Culture: Organizational change? 2002 Washington Library of Congress

FongP. S.KwokW.CeciliaW. C. “Organizational Culture and Knowledge Management Success at Project and Organizational Levels in Contracting Firms” Journal of Constriction Engineering and Management 2009 3 1348 1356

GatfieldT.YouseffM. “Business Clan: A Critical Examination of and Reflection on the Chinese Family Business Unit and the Chinese” Family Business Review 2001 14 153 159

GetzS. Seker al Hashinuim Bakibbutz (A Survey of Changes in the Kibbutzim) 2012 Haifa, Israel Kibbutz Movement and the Research Institute of the Kibbutz Idea

GradinS. “Radical Routes and Alternative Avenues: How Cooperatives Can Be Non-Capitalistic” Review of Radical Political Economics 2015 47 2 141 158

HanH. “The Relationship among Corporate Culture, Strategic Orientation, and Financial Performance” Cornell Hospitality Quarterly 2012 53 3 207 219

KundaG. M’handasim Tarbut (Engineering Culture) 2000 Tel Aviv Chargol

MoskovichY. “Loss of Organizational Solidarity in Three Kibbutz Factories” International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy 2016 36 5/6 1 24

MoskovichY.AchouchY. “From Collectivism to Capitalism: Cultural Change in a Kibbutz Factory” Journal of Rural Cooperation 2013 41 1 80 95

MoskovichY.AchouchY. “Changes in a Kibbutz Plant’s Life Cycle by Cultural Impact” Journal of Rural Cooperation 2014 42 2 162 179

MoskovichY.AchouchY. “Metamorphosis of a Kibbutz Industry: The Life Cycle of ‘Factory A Industry’ – An Israeli Case Study” EuroMed Journal of Business 2015 10 2 181 197

MoskovichY.PalgiM. “Cultural Change in a Kibbutz Factory: From Democratic to More Autocratic Management Style” International Cooperative Studies 2015 4 2 27 38

Naale Halom u’Ma’aseh: Arba’im Shanim l’Mifal Naale (Dream and Practice: Forty Years to Naale) 2005 Kibbutz Nadib, Israel Naale

Naale Naale: Mispar Shesh (Naale: Number Six) 2006 Kibbutz Nadib, Israel Naale

Naale Naale: Mispar Shtemisrei (Naale: Number Twelve) 2008 Kibbutz Nadib, Israel Naale

Naale Makoreh u ’Ma’ikreh (What is Happening and What will Happen) 2012 Kibbutz Nadib, Israel Naale

Naale Makoreh u’Ma’ikreh (What is Happening and What will Happen) 2013 Kibbutz Nadib, Israel Naale

Naale Makoreh u’Ma’ikreh (What is Happening and What will Happen) 2014 Kibbutz Nadib, Israel Naale

Naale Makoreh u’Ma’ikreh (What is Happening and What will Happen) 2015 Kibbutz Nadib, Israel Naale

NovkovicS. “Defining the Co-operative Difference” The Journal of Socio Economics 2008 37 3 2168 2177

PalgiM. ShenharA.YarkoniA. “Tarbut Irgunit Bata’asia Kibbutzit” (“Organizational Culture in the Kibbutz Industry”) Tarbut Nihul B’Yisrael (Management Culture in Israel) 1994 Tel Aviv Cherikover 303 320

PalgiM. “Organizational Change and Ideology: The Case of the Kibbutz” International Review of Sociology 2002 12 3 389 402

PalgiM. “Pitfalls of Self-Management in the Kibbutz” International Review of Sociology 2006 16 1 63 77

ParkerM.CheneyG.FournierV.LandC. The Rutledge Companion to Alternative Organization 2014 London Rutledge

RajR.Srivastava-KailashB. L. “Organizational Culture, hrm Practices and Learning on the Relationship among Organizational Culture and Innovativeness” Management and Labor Studies 2013 38 3 201 223

PettigrewA. M. “On Studying Organizational Cultures” Administrative Science Quarterly 1979 24 4 570 581

RogerC. Capitalism and Its Alternatives 2014 London Zed Book

RosnerM.GetzS. Hakibbutz B’idan Shinui (The Kibbutz in an Era of Change) 1996 Tel Aviv HaKibbutz HaMeuchad Publishing

RussellR.HannemanR.GetzS. The Renewal of the Kibbutz 2013 New Brunswick, NJ Rutgers University Press

SamuelY. The political agenda of organizations 2005 New Brunswick, NJ (USA) & London (UK) Transaction Publisher

ScheinE. H. Organizational Culture and Leadership 1985 San Francisco Josses Bass

StanislavA. Max Weber on Capitalism, Bureaucracy and Religion 2006 London Taylor & Francis eBook

StraussA.CorbinJ. Basics of Qualitative Research: Grounded Theory Procedures and Techniques 2015 London Sage Publications

WadhamH.WarrenR. C. “Telling Organizational Tales: The Extended Case Method in Practice” Organizational Research Methods 2014 17 1 5 20

YaziciH. J. “Significance of Organizational Culture in Perceived Project and Business Performance” Engineering Journal Management 2011 23 2 20 29

YinR. Case Study Research Design and Method 2014 London Sage


Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 21 21 10
Full Text Views 16 16 6
PDF Downloads 5 5 2
EPUB Downloads 3 3 2