Establishing a Russian-Spanish Master’s Degree in Social Work: Harmonization or a Cultural Fit?

in Comparative Sociology
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?


This paper reports on the experience of developing a double-degree master’s program in social work between a Russian and a Spanish university. It focuses on the complementarity of the existing training programs in social work and on the handling of cultural and institutional particularities. Developing international master’s degrees programs is a challenge in terms of both adjustments to the curricula and economic viability. A genuine interest in learning from the other country is a sine qua non condition difficult to meet because the traditions of social work and welfare in each county are deeply rooted in that country’s culture and history. The authors explain how they worked to establish a common ground and describe the results they were able to achieve.

Establishing a Russian-Spanish Master’s Degree in Social Work: Harmonization or a Cultural Fit?

in Comparative Sociology



Báñez TelloT. “Género y trabajo social.” [Gender and Social Work] Acciones e Investigaciones Sociales [Social Action and Research] 1997 6 152 188

Báñez TelloT. “Social Work Education and Profession in Spain” The Europe Institute for Social Work Berlin: Articles Forum [online] 2008 Retrieved May 5 2014 ( service/articles-forum.html)

bcbu (Barents Cross Border University) “Comparative Social Work Master’s” 2013 Retrieved January 16 2014 (;s_degree_programmes/Comparative_Social_Work.iw3)

eranet-mundus Eranet-Mundus: Euro-Russian Academic Network-Mundus 2011 Retrieved October 16 2014 (

escp Europe Dual Degrees 2013 Retrieved December 5 2013 (

European Commission Erasmus+ 2015 Retrieved January 15 2015 (

FirsovM. V. Istoriya sotzial’noy raboti v Rossii. [History of Social Work in Russia] 1999 Moscow Vlados

GómezF.BuendíaF. “The Development of Social Work Education in Spain” European Journal of Social Work 2009 12 1 113 117

HamburgerY. F.SanderG.WöbckeM. Social Work Education in Europe 2001 Retrieved May 5 2015 (

HealyL. M. “Universalism and Cultural Relativism in Social Work Ethics” International Social Work 2007 50 1 11 26

HofstedeG. Culture’s Consequences: Comparing Values Behaviors Institutions and Organizations across Nations 2001 2nd ed. Thousand Oaks, CA Sage

IarskaiaV. “Blagotvoritel’nost’ i miloserdie kak soziokulturnye zennosti.” [Beneficence and Charity as Socio-Cultural Values] Rossiiski zhurnal sozial’noy raboty [Russian Journal of Social Work] 1995 2 27 35

ibsa (International Business School Alliance) Master in International Management 2014 Retrieved October 16 2014 (

InglehartR. “Mapping Global Values” Comparative Sociology 2006 5 2-3 115 136

InglehartR.AbramsonP. R. “Economic Security and Value Change” American Political Science Review 1994 88 2 336 354

InglehartR.BakerW. E. “Modernization, Cultural Change and the Persistence of Traditional Values” American Sociological Review 2000 65 19 51

KnightJ. “Five Myths about Internationalization” International Higher Education 2011 62 14 15

KnightJ. The Changing Landscape of Higher Education Internationalization – for Better or Worse? Perspectives: Policy and Practice in Higher Education. Journal of the Association of University Administrators (aua) 2013 17 3 84 90

KozlovaI. RementsovA. N. V Rossiyu po obmenu: motivatsiya i ozhidaniya ispanskikh studentov. [To Russia on Exchange: Expectations and Motivation of Spanish Students] Sbornik materialov mezhdunarodnoy nauchnoprakticheskoy konferentsii Professional’no napravlennoe obuchenie russkomu yazyku inostrannykh grazhdan. [Proceedings of International Conference on Professional Russian Language Training of Foreign Citizens] 2010 Moscow МADI (State Technological University) 161 165

KupriyanovR. V. “Razvitie sotsial’noy raboty v Ispanii i Rossii.” [Development of Social Work in Spain and Russia] Herald of Kazan Technological University 2013 4 2013 367 373

KupriyanovR. V.KozlovaI. “Funktsional’nyy podkhod k mnogourovnevoy podgotovke rabotnikov sotsial’noy sfery.” [Functional Approach to the Gradual Training of Social Sphere Specialists] Herald of Kazan Technological University 2012 16 2012 220 224

KupriyanovR. V.KozlovaI. “Developing Double Degree Bilingual Master’s Program ‘Social Work in Industry’” Interactive Collaborative Learning (icl) 2013 International Conference on icl 2013 Piscataway, NJ IEEE 633 635 doi: 10.1109/ICL.2013.6644669

KupriyanovR. V.ZaripovR. N.ValeyevaN. S.ValeyevaE. R.ZaripovaI. R.NadeyevaM. I. “The Main Directions of International Educational Integration: Potential Benefits and Risks of Reforming Professional Education” Review of European Studies 2015 7 3 305 312

MaringeaF.FoskettN.WoodfieldS. “Emerging Internationalization Models in an Uneven Global Terrain: Findings from a Global Survey” Compare: A Journal of Comparative and International Education (Special Issue: Contemporary Issues on the Internationalization of Higher Education: Critical and Comparative Perspectives) 2013 43 1 9 36

Martínez-BrawleyE. E.Vázquez-AguadoO. “The Professionalization of Spanish Social Work: Moving Closer to Europe or Away from its Root” European Journal of Social Work 2008 11 1 3 13

Méndez-Bonito ZoritaP. “The History of Social Work Education in Spain: Does Harmonization Make Sense?” Portularia 2005 5 1 223 237

MesselinkA.Ten ThijeJ. D. “Unity in Super-Diversity: European Capacity and Intercultural Inquisitiveness of the Erasmus Generation 2.0” Dutch Journal of Applied Linguistics 2012 1 1 80 101

Ministerio de Educación Cultura y Deporte de España Comments of the National Report regarding the Bologna Process implementation 2009-2012 Spain 2012 Retrieved May 2 2014 (

MinkovM.HofstedeG. Clustering of 316 European Regions on Measures of Values. Do Europe’s Countries Have National Cultures? Cross-Cultural Research 2014 48 2 144 176

mgimo (Moscow State Institute of International Relations) Double Degrees Masters Programs 2013 Retrieved January 5 2014 (

ResanovS. “Osnovnye tendentsii professional’noy podgotovki kadrov dlya sfery obshchestvennogo prizreniya v Rossii vo vtoroy polovine xix-nachale xx veka.” [Main Tendencies of Professional Staff Training for the Russian State Charity System in the Late 19th – Early 20th Century] 2011 PhD dissertation Department of Education Kursk State University Kursk

RushM.KeenanM. “The Social Politics of Social Work: Anti-Oppressive Social Work Dilemmas in Twenty-First-Century Welfare Regimes” British Journal of Social Work 2014 44 6 1436 1453

SchwartzS. H. KimU. “Beyond Individualism/Collectivism: New Cultural Dimensions of Values” Individualism and Collectivism: Theory Method and Applications 1994 Thousand Oaks, CA Sage 85 119

SchwartzS. H. “A Theory of Cultural Value Orientations: Explication and Applications” Comparative Sociology 2006 5 2-3 137 182

Seguridad Social History of the Social Security 2014 Retrieved October 15 2014 (

ShaninT. RamonS. “Sozial’naya rabota kak kul’turny fenomen sovremennosti: novaya professiya i akademicheskaya disziplina v kontekste sozial’noy teorii i politicheskoy practiki nashih dney.” [Social Work as a Cultural Phenomenon of Modernity: a New Profession and an Academic Discipline in the Context of Social Theory and Political Practice of Today] Vzaimosvyaz’ socialnoy raboty i sozial’noy politiki. [The Interrelation of Social Work and Social Policy] 1997 Moscow Aspekt-Press 18 43

TauchC.RauhvargersA. Survey on Master Degrees and Joint Degrees in Europe 2002 Brussels European University Association Retrieved May 5 2013 (

TodorovT. BracherN. “European Identity” South Central Review 2008 25 3 3 15

uab Political Science Master 2013 Retrieved February 3 2014 (

ValeyevaE.BabiukhV. “Izuchenie problem sotsial’noy politiki Ispanii i Rossii v protsesse prepodavaniya pravovykh distsiplin studentam magistratury v ramkakh programmy dvoynykh diplomov.” [A Study of Social Policy Problems in Spain and Russia in the Process of Teaching Law Disciplines to Master’s Students of Double Degrees] Herald of Kazan Technological University 2013 1 2013 301 306

Vázquez-AguadoO. “El Espacio Europeo de Educación Superior y el Trabajo Social en España.” [European Higher Education Area and Social Work in Spain] Portularia 2005 5 1 239 255

Index Card

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 9 9 5
Full Text Views 9 9 9
PDF Downloads 3 3 3
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0