The Iroquois Confederacy and the Possibility of Heteronomous Democracy
In: Comparative Political TheoryBaruch College, City University of New York, New York, US
Search for other papers by Gerasimos Karavitis in
Current site
Google Scholar
Abstract
Cornelius Castoriadis (1922–1997) argues that the project of autonomy appears in only two societies throughout human history: ancient Greece and Western Europe. Is this true? The present study examines the case of the Iroquois Confederacy with the intention of testing Castoriadis’s argument. Using the debate between Castoriadis and the members of mauss as its starting point, it interprets historic Iroquois institutions with reference to what Castoriadis presents as the two inextricably linked conditions of an autonomous society: democracy and philosophy. Ultimately, the essay contends that while Castoriadis justifiably interprets the Iroquois Confederacy as heteronomous, the confederacy’s democratic institutions compel us to doubt the necessary connection he posits between democracy and philosophy. Iroquois society created a heteronomous democracy, a type of polity that Castoriadis’s theory of autonomy occludes.
Purchase
Buy instant access (PDF download and unlimited online access):
Institutional Login
Log in with Open Athens, Shibboleth, or your institutional credentials
Personal login
Log in with your brill.com account
-
Albertani, C. (2011). Qu’est-ce qu’une Société Autonome? Castoriadis, Les Peuples Indigènes, et la Relativisme Culturel. Translated by Annick Stevens. Réfractions: Recherche et Expressions Anarchistes 27, pp. 49–64.
-
Allen, P. G. (1992). The Sacred Hoop: Recovering the Feminine in American Indian Traditions. Boston: Beacon Press.
-
Aravamudan, S. (2009). Hobbes and America. In: D. Carey and L. Festa, eds., The Postcolonial Enlightenment: Eighteenth-Century Colonialism and Postcolonial Theory. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 37–70.
-
Aristotle. (1981). Politics. Translated by T.A. Sinclair. New York: Penguin Books.
-
Aristotle. (2004). The Art of Rhetoric. Translated by H. T. Lawson. London, England and New York, NY: Penguin Books.
-
Arthur, S. (2007). Where License Reigns with All Impunity: An Anarchist Study of the Rotinonshón:ni Polity. In The Northeastern Anarchist (12), pp. 29–42.
-
Campisi, J. (1996). Parker, Arthur C. (1881–1955). In: F. E. Hoxie, ed., Encyclopedia of North American Indians. Boston, MA: Houghton Mifflin.
-
Castoriadis, C. (1988). On the Content of Socialism, ii. In: D. A. Curtis, ed. and trans., Political and Social Writings, Volume 2, 1955–1960: from the Workers’ Struggle against Bureaucracy to Revolution in the Age of Modern Capitalism. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, pp. 90–155.
-
Castoriadis, C. (1995). The Problem of Democracy Today. Translated by D. Isigonis. Democracy and Nature 3 (2), pp. 18–35.
-
Castoriadis, C. (1997). Democracy as Procedure and Democracy as Regime. Translated by D. A. Curtis. Constellations 4 (1), pp. 1–18.
-
Castoriadis, C. (2004). Ce qui Fait la Grèce. Tome 1. D’Homère à Héraclite. Séminaires 1982–1983. La Création Humaineii. E. Escobar, M. Gondicas, and P. Vernay, eds. Introduction by P. Vidal-Naquet. Paris: Éditions du Seuil.
-
Castoriadis, C. (2007). What Democracy? In: W. Hamacher, ed., Figures of the Thinkable. Translated by H. Arnold. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press, pp. 118–150.
-
Castoriadis, C. (2008). Ce qui Fait la Grèce. Tome 2. La Cité et les Lois. Séminaires 1983–1984. La Création Humaineiii. E. Escobar, M. Gondicas, and P. Vernay, eds. Introduction by P. Raynaud. Paris: Éditions du Seuil.
-
Castoriadis, C. (2010). Present Issues for Democracy. In: E. Escobar, M. Gondicas, and P. Vernay, eds., A Society Adrift: Interviews and Debates, 1974–1997. Translated by H. Arnold. New York: Fordham University Press, pp. 125–130.
-
Castoriadis, C. (2011) Ce qui Fait la Grèce. Tome 3. Thucydide, la Force et le Droit. Séminaires 1984–1985. La Création Humaineiv. E. Escobar, M. Gondicas, and P. Vernay, eds. Introduction by C. Moatti. Paris: Éditions du Seuil.
-
Castoriadis, C. (2020). Democracy and Relativism: A Debate. Translated by J. V. Garner. London and New York: Rowman & Littlefield.
-
Clastres, P. (1987). Society Against the State: Essays in Political Anthropology. New York: Zone Books.
-
Colden, C. (1964). The History of the Five Indian Nations: Depending on the Province of New-York in America. London and Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
-
Curtis, D. A., ed. and trans. (1991). Philosophy, Politics, Autonomy: Essays in Political Philosophy. New York: Oxford University Press.
-
Curtis, D. A., ed. and trans. (1997a). The Castoriadis Reader. Malden, MA and Oxford, England: Blackwell.
-
Curtis, D. A., ed. and trans. (1997b). World in Fragments: Writings on Politics, Society, Psychoanalysis, and the Imagination. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
-
Curtis, D. & Kalyvas, A. (1998). Fighting the Wrong Enemy? Comments on Wolfenstein’s Critique of Castoriadis. Political Theory 26 (6), pp. 818–824.
-
De Souza, M. L. (2017). “What is Autonomy and how can we Make it Possible?” Community Development Journal 52 (33) pp. 436–453.
-
Engels, F. (2010). The Origins of the Family, Private Property, and the State. London and New York: Penguin Books.
-
Fenton, W. N. (1968). Introduction. In: W. Fenton, ed., Parker on the Iroquois. Syracuse: Syracuse University Press, pp. 1–47.
-
Fenton, W. N. (1998). The Great Law and the Longhouse: A Political History of the Iroquois Confederacy. Norman: University of Oklahoma Press.
-
Fields, J. & Mann, B. (1997). A Sign in the Sky: Dating the League of the Haudenosaunee. American Indian Culture and Research Journal 21 (2) pp. 105–163.
-
Foucault, M. (2005). The Hermeneutics of the Subject: Lectures at the Collège de France 1981–1982. F. Gros, F. Ewald, A. Fontana, and A.I. Davidson, eds. Translated by G. Burcell. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
-
Foucault, M. (2011). The Courage of Truth (The Government of Self and Othersii): Lectures at the College de France. 1983–1984. F. Gros, F. Ewald, A. Fontana, and A.I. Davidson, eds. Translated by G. Burcell. Hampshire, UK & New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
-
Garner, J. V. (2020). Foreword. In: C. Castoriadis, Democracy and Relativism: A Debate. Translated by J. V. Garner. London and New York: Rowman & Littlefield, pp. vii–xxvii.
-
Goldenweiser, A. A. (1912). On Iroquois Work. In: E. Tooker, ed., An Iroquois Source Book. Volume 1: Political and Social Organization. London and New York: Garland Publishing Inc.
-
Goldenweiser, A. A. (1916). Review of The Constitution of the Five Nations by Arthur Parker. American Anthropologist 18 (3), pp. 431–436.
-
Graeber, D. (2005). La Démocratie des Interstices: Que Reste-t-il de l’Idéal Démocratique? Revue demauss 26 (2), pp. 41–89.
-
Grinde, D. Jr. (1977). The Iroquois and the Founding of the American Nation. San Francisco: The Indian Historian Press, Inc.
-
Grinde, D. Jr. & Johansen, B. (1991). Exemplar of Liberty: Native America and the Evolution of Democracy. University of California at Los Angeles: American Indian Studies Center.
-
Grinde, D. A. & Johansen, B. (1996). Sauce for the Goose: Demand and Definitions for “Proof” Regarding the Iroquois and Democracy. The William and Mary Quarterly 53 (3), pp. 621–636.
-
Hale, H. (1881). A Lawgiver of the Stone Age. In Hiawatha and the Iroquois Confederation: A Study in Anthropology. A Paper Read at the Cincinnati Meeting of the American Association For the Advancement of Science, in August 1881, Under the Title “A Lawgiver of the Stone Age, Salem Press. Salem: Massachusetts.
-
Hansen, M. H. (1999). The Athenian Democracy in the Age of Demosthenes. London: bc Paperbacks. doi: 10.5040/9781472540614.
-
Hewitt, J. N. B (1917). Review [Untitled.] American Anthropologist 19 (3), pp. 429–438.
-
Hewitt, J. N. B. (1920). A Constitutional League of Peace in the Stone Age of America: The League of the Iroquois and its Constitution. In: E. Tooker, ed., An Iroquois Source Book. Volume 1: Political and Social Organization. London and New York: Garland Publishing Inc.
-
Hobbes, T. (1997). Leviathan. R. Flathman and D. Johnston, eds. London and New York: W.W. Norton & Company, Inc.
-
Jahanbegloo, R. (2018). The Global Gandhi: Essays in Comparative Political Philosophy. London, England & New York, NY: Routledge Taylor and Francis Group.
-
Jennings, F., Fenton, W. N., Druke, M. A., & Miller, D. R. (1985). The History and Culture of Iroquois Diplomacy: An Interdisciplinary Guide to the Treaties of the Six Nations and Their League. Syracuse: Syracuse University Press.
-
Johansen, B. (1982). Forgotten Founders: How the American Indian Helped Shape Democracy. Boston: The Harvard Common Press.
-
Johansen, B. (1995) Dating the Iroquois Confederacy. Akwesasne Notes New Series 1 (3 & 4), pp. 62–63. https://ratical.org/many_worlds/6Nations/DatingIC.html.
-
Johansen, B., Grinde, D., & Mann, B. (1998). Debating Democracy: Native American Legacy of Freedom. Santa Fe, Mexico: Clear Light Publishers.
-
Kalyvas, A. (1998). Norm and Critique in Castoriadis’s Theory of Autonomy. Constellations 5 (2), pp. 161–182.
-
La Revue du M.A.U.S.S. (Mouvement anti-utilitariste dans les sciences sociales). Site du M.A.U.S.S. (2021, March 28). https://www.revuedumauss.com.fr/.
-
Madison, J. (1999). Federalist 10. In: C. Rossiter, ed., The Federalist Papers. New York: Mentor Books.
-
Malcolm, N. (2002) Aspects of Hobbes. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
-
Mann, B. A. (2000). Iroquoian Women: The Gantowisas. Foreword by P. G. Allen. New York: Peter Lang.
-
Morgan, L. H. (1971). League of the Ho-De’-No-Sau-Nee or Iroquois. Volume I. H. M. Lloyd, ed. New York: Burt Franklin.
-
Moutsios, S. (2019). The European Comparative Gaze. European Education 52 (1), pp. 1–15.
-
Nicolacopoulos, T. & Vassilacopoulos, G. (2018). (Un)willing Collectives: On Castoriadis, Philosophy, and Politics. Melbourne: re.press.
-
Parker, A. (1916). The Constitution of the Five Nations. In: W. N. Fenton, ed., Parker on the Iroquois. Syracuse, NY: Syracuse University Press.
-
Pitkin, H. (1967). The Concept of Representation. Berkeley & Los Angeles: University of California Press.
-
Plato. (1992). Republic. In: C.D.C. Reeve, ed. Translated by G.M.A. Grube. Indianapolis and Cambridge: Hackett Publishing Company, Inc.
-
Poltier, H. (1989). De la Praxis à l’Institution et Retour. In: G. Busino ed., Autonomie et Autotransformation de la Société. La Philosophie Militante de Cornelius Castoriadis. Genève: Librairie Droz, pp. 419–440.
-
Potte-Bonneville, M. (2011). Risked Democracy: Foucault, Castoriadis, and the Greeks. Translated by S. Lillis. Radical Philosophy 166, pp. 29–38.
-
Schmitt, C. (1985). Political Theology: Four Chapters on the Concept of Sovereignty. Translated by G. Schwab. Chicago and London: The University of Chicago Press.
-
Seitz, B. & Thorp. T. (2013). The Iroquois and the Athenians: A Political Ontology. Plymouth, UK: Lexington Books.
-
Snow, D. R. (1994). The Iroquois. Cambridge, MA & Oxford UK: Blackwell.
-
Thucydides. (1919). History of the Peloponnesian War, Volumei: Books 1–2. Translated by C. F. Smith. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1919.
-
Thucydides. (1972). History of the Peloponnesian War. Translated by R. Warner. Introduction and notes by M.I. Finley. Harmondsworth, England: Penguin Book.
-
Tocqueville, A. de. (2003). Democracy in America and Two Essays on America. Translated by G. E. Bevan. London: Penguin Books.
-
Treuer, D. (2019). The Heartbeat of Wounded Knee: Native America from 1890 to the Present. New York: Riverhead Books.
-
Vescey, C. 1986. The Story and Structure of the Iroquois Confederacy. Journal of the American Academy of Religion. 54:1, pp. 79–106.
-
Wallace, P. A. W. (1946). The White Roots of Peace. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.
-
Wolfenstein, E. V. (1996). Psychoanalysis in Political Theory. Political Theory 24 (4), pp. 706–728.
| All Time | Past 365 days | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 106 | 107 | 29 |
| Full Text Views | 20 | 20 | 5 |
| PDF Views & Downloads | 45 | 45 | 10 |
The Iroquois Confederacy and the Possibility of Heteronomous Democracy
In: Comparative Political TheoryBaruch College, City University of New York, New York, US
Search for other papers by Gerasimos Karavitis in
Current site
Google Scholar
PubMed
Abstract
Cornelius Castoriadis (1922–1997) argues that the project of autonomy appears in only two societies throughout human history: ancient Greece and Western Europe. Is this true? The present study examines the case of the Iroquois Confederacy with the intention of testing Castoriadis’s argument. Using the debate between Castoriadis and the members of mauss as its starting point, it interprets historic Iroquois institutions with reference to what Castoriadis presents as the two inextricably linked conditions of an autonomous society: democracy and philosophy. Ultimately, the essay contends that while Castoriadis justifiably interprets the Iroquois Confederacy as heteronomous, the confederacy’s democratic institutions compel us to doubt the necessary connection he posits between democracy and philosophy. Iroquois society created a heteronomous democracy, a type of polity that Castoriadis’s theory of autonomy occludes.
| All Time | Past 365 days | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 106 | 107 | 29 |
| Full Text Views | 20 | 20 | 5 |
| PDF Views & Downloads | 45 | 45 | 10 |