Indonesian Religion as a Hybrid Media Space: Social Dramas in a Contested Realm

in Asiascape: Digital Asia
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



The popularity of social media in Indonesia, along with the rise of political Islam, is changing the ways in which people engage with religious matters in the country. In this article, we deploy post-Bourdieuan field theory to explore Indonesia’s religious domain as a ‘hybrid media space’ – a social space mediated by old and new media agents interacting to produce viralized forms of public communication. We undertake this exploration through three viral controversies, or ‘social dramas’, triggered by a perceived breach of the religious space’s order. All three dramas involved political Islamists in contention with various political actors, namely the Muslim senator Fahira Fahmi, the West Sumatran atheist Alexander Aan, and the then governor of Jakarta, ‘Ahok’. These examples shed light on the current state of Indonesia’s religious space and its multiple mediations, as well as taking field theory into new communicative and religious terrain.

Indonesian Religion as a Hybrid Media Space: Social Dramas in a Contested Realm

in Asiascape: Digital Asia



AbeBurhanuddin (201130 April) ‘Fahira Idris: From Garage Hobby to Successful Entrepreneur’. Jakarta Postretrieved 13 August 2017 from

Al Arabiya (20122 February) ‘Indonesian Atheist’s Arrest Sparks Tension Online’. Al Arabiya Newsretrieved 13 August 2017 from

AritonangMargareth S. (20168 December) ‘Study Finds Majority of People Condemning Ahok’s “Blasphemy” Not Well Informed’. Jakarta Post.

Article 19 (20159 December) ‘Activist Interview: Damar Juniarto of Safenet, Indonesia’. Article 19 retrieved 13 August 2017 from

BartonGreg (2014) ‘The Gülen Movement, Muhammadiyah and Nahdlatul Ulama: Progressive Islamic Thought, Religious Philanthropy and Civil Society in Turkey and Indonesia’. Islam and Christian–Muslim Relations25(3) 287-301.

bbc Indonesia (201617 November) ‘Pidato Di Kepulauan Seribu Dan Hari-Hari Hingga Ahok Menjadi Tersangka’ (The Speech of Kepulauan Seribu and the Days of Ahok as Convict) retrieved 16 August 2017 from

BenklerYochai (2011) ‘Free Irresponsible Press: Wikileaks and the Battle over the Soul of the Networked Fourth Estate’. Harvard Civil Rights – Civil Liberties Law Review46311-397.

BourdieuPierre (1993) The Field of Cultural Production. Cambridge, UK: Polity Press.

BourdieuPierre (1996) The Rules of Art: Genesis and Structure of the Literary Field. Cambridge, UK: Polity Press.

BushRobin (2015) ‘Religious Politics and Minority Rights during the Yudhoyono Presidency’. In: E. AspinallM. Mietzner & D. Tomsa (Eds.) The Yudhoyono Presidency: Indonesia’s Decade of Stability and Stagnation. Singapore: Institute of Southeast Asian Studies239-257.

ChadwickAndrew (2013) The Hybrid Media System: Politics and Power. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

ChadwickAndrew & Simon Collister (2014) ‘Boundary-Drawing Power and the Renewal of Professional News Organizations: The Case of The Guardian and the Edward Snowden nsa Leak’. International Journal of Communication82420-2441.

CochraneJoe (20143 May) ‘Embrace of Atheism Put an Indonesian in Prison’. New York Timesretrieved 13 August 2017 from

CouldryNick (2003) ‘Media Meta-Capital: Extending the Range of Bourdieu’s Field Theory’. Theory and Society32(5-6) 653-677.

EickelmanDale F. & Jon W. Anderson (2003) (Eds.) New Media and the Muslim World: The Emerging Public Sphere (2nd ed.). Bloomington: Indiana University Press.

EisenlohrPatrick (2006) ‘As Makkah Is Sweet and Beloved, so Is Madina: Islam, Devotional Genres and Electronic Mediation in Mauritius’. American Ethnologist33(2) 230-245.

EpafrasLeonard C. (2016) ‘Religious E-Xpression among the Youths in the Indonesian Cyberspace’. Jurnal Ilmu Komunikasi13(1) 1-18.

FligsteinNeil & Doug McAdam (2011) ‘Toward a General Theory of Strategic Action Fields’. Sociological Theory29(1) 1-26.

FligsteinNeil & Doug McAdam (2012) A Theory of Fields. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Freedom House (2016) ‘Indonesia Country Report’. Freedom in the World retrieved 13 August 2017 from

GryboskiMichael (201220 June) ‘Atheist Group Launches Efforts to Help Jailed Facebook User in Indonesia’. Christian Postretrieved 13 August 2017 from

HamidUsman (2017) ‘Laws, Crackdowns and Control Mechanisms: Digital Platforms and the State’. In: Ross Tapsell & Edwin Jurriens (Eds.) Digital Indonesia: Connectivity and Convergence. Singapore: ISEAS93-109.

HarsonoAndreas (201221 May) ‘Indonesia Is No Model for Muslim Democracy’. New York Times.

HarsonoAndreas (2014May 14) ‘Undoing Yudhoyono’s Sectarian Legacy’. New Mandala.

HasaniIsmail (2016) ‘The Decreasing Space for Non-Religious Expression in Indonesia: The Case of Atheism’. In: Tim Lindsey & Helen Pausacker (Eds.) Religion Law and Intolerance in Indonesia (Kindle ed.). London: Routledge197-210.

HodalKate (20123 May) ‘Indonesia’s Atheists Face Battle for Religious Freedom’. The Guardian.

HosenNadirsyah (2016) ‘Race and Religion in the 2012 Jakarta Gubernatorial Election’. In: Tim Lindsey & Helen Pausacker (Eds.) Religion Law and Intolerance in Indonesia (Kindle ed.). London: Routledge180-194.

Human Rights Watch (2013) Atas Nama Agama: Pelanggaran terhadap Minoritas Agama di Indonesia (In the Name of Religion: Offense against Religious Minority in Indonesia). New York: Human Rights Watch.

IndrayanaDenny (2008) Indonesian Constitutional Reform 1999-2002: An Evaluation of Constitution-Making in Transition. Jakarta: Kompas.

Jakarta Globe (201616 December) ‘Anthropologists Call for Stronger Unity in Face of Tensions’. Retrieved 13 August 2017 from

Jakarta Post (201431 January) ‘Atheist Alexander Aan Gets [sic] of Prison’. Retrieved 13 August 2017 from

JurisJeff S. (2008) Networking Futures: The Movements against Corporate Globalization. Durham: Duke University Press.

KaratzogianniAthina (2015) Firebrand Waves of Digital Activism 1994-2014. Basingstoke, UK: Palgrave Macmillan.

KristantiElin Y. (201030 August) ‘Fahira Idris, Tweeter Terinspiratif: “Saya Tidak Takut fpi, karena Saya Benar”’ (Fahira Idris, the Most Inspiring Tweeter: “I’m Not Afraid of the fpi, Because I’m Right’): Retrieved 12 October 2017 from:

KubitschkoSebastian (2015) ‘Hackers’ Media Practices: Demonstrating and Articulating Expertise as Interlocking Arrangements’. Convergence: The International Journal of Research into New Media Technologies21(3) 388-408.

LambKate (201616 November) ‘Jakarta’s Christian Governor to Face Blasphemy Trial over Islam Insult Claim’. The Guardianretrieved 13 August 2017 from

LimMerlyna (2013) ‘Many Clicks but Little Sticks: Social Media Activism in Indonesia’Journal of Contemporary Asia43(4) 636-657.

MehtaHemant (201214 June) ‘Alexander Aan, Atheist Who Blasphemed on Facebook, Sentenced to Two Years in Prison’. Patheos.comretrieved 13 August 2017 from

MietznerMarcus (2013) ‘Fighting the Hellhounds: Pro-Democracy Activists and Party Politics in Post-Suharto Indonesia’. Journal of Contemporary Asia43(1) 28-50.

PariserEli (2011) The Filter Bubble: What the Internet Is Hiding from You. New York: Penguin UK.

Patung (201030 August) ‘Top Tweeter: Fahira Idris’. Indonesia Mattersretrieved 13 August 2017 from

PesekWilliam (201223 June) ‘Millions Stagnate in Poverty as Indonesia Indulges in Economic Nationalism’. Sydney Morning Heraldretrieved 16 August 2017 from

PostillJohn (2011) Localizing the Internet: An Anthropological Account. Oxford: Berghahn.

PostillJohn (2014) ‘Democracy in the Age of Viral Reality: A Media Epidemiography of Spain’s Indignados Movement’. Ethnography15 (1) 50-68.

PostillJohn (2015) ‘Fields: Dynamic Configurations of Practices, Games, and Socialities’. In: Vered Amit (Ed.) Thinking Through Sociality: An Anthropological Interrogation of Key Concepts. Oxford: Berghahn47-68.

PostillJohn (2016) ‘The Multilinearity of Protest: Understanding New Social Movements Through Their Events, Trends and Routines’. In: Othon Alexandrakis (ed). Impulse to Act: A New Anthropology of Resistance and Social Justice. Indiana University Press192-210.

PostillJohn (forthcoming) The Rise of Nerd Politics. London: Pluto.

PostillJohn & Kurniawan Saputro (2017) ‘Digital Activism in Contemporary Indonesia: Victims, Volunteers and Voices’. In: Ross Tapsell & Edwin Jurriens (Eds.) Digital Indonesia: Connectivity and Convergence. Singapore: ISEAS127-145.

ReuterThomas (2015) ‘Political Parties and the Power of Money in Indonesia and Beyond’. TRaNS: Trans-Regional-and-National Studies of Southeast Asia3(2) 267-278.

SahalAkhmad (201224 August) ‘Pemimpin Non Muslim Haram?’ (Is a Non-Muslim Leader Forbidden?). Jakarta Beatretrieved 13 August 2017 from

SchäferSaskia (2015) ‘Renegotiating Indonesian Secularism through Debates on Ahmadiyya and Shia’. Philosophy & Social Criticism41(4-5) 497-508.

Setara Institute (2014) Stagnasi Kebebasan Beragama (Stagnation on Religious Freedom). Jakarta: Pustaka Masyarakat Setara. Retrieved 13 August 2017 from

SewellWilliam H. (2005) Logics of History: Social Theory and Social Transformation. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

SofjanDicky (2013) Religion and Television in Indonesia. Geneva, Switzerland:

Suara Pembaruan (2010) ‘Fahira Fahmi Idris Islam Mengajarkan Damai’ (Fahira Fahmi Idris: Islam Teaches Peace). Retrieved 13 August 2017 from

TapsellRoss (201229 September) ‘The Era of Convergent Media’. Inside Indonesia retrieved 13 August 2017 from

TapsellRoss (2015) ‘Platform Convergence in Indonesia: Challenges and Opportunities for Media Freedom’. Convergence: The International Journal of Research into New Media Technologies21(2) 182-197.

TapsellRoss (2017) ‘The Political Economy of Digital Media’. In: Ross Tapsell & Edwin Jurriens (Eds.) Digital Indonesia: Connectivity and Convergence. Singapore: ISEAS56-74.

TurnerVictor (1974) Dramas Fields and Metaphors: Symbolic Action in Human Society. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.

VaragurKrithika (201616 December) ‘Fake News Roils Indonesian Politics’. voa News retrieved 13 August 2017 from

Wahid Institute (2013) Laporan Kebebasan Beragama/Berkeyakinan dan Toleransi (Report on Religious Freedom and Tolerance). Jakarta retrieved 13 August 2017 from

WidjajaHenky (201211 August) ‘Convenient Thugs’. Inside Indonesia retrieved 13 August 2017 from

WinstonKimberley (201219 July) ‘Atheists Rally for Persecuted Unbeliever in Indonesia’. Washington Post.

Index Card

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 79 79 25
Full Text Views 23 23 16
PDF Downloads 3 3 3
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0