Dostoevsky, Consciousness and Romantic Irony

in The Dostoevsky Journal
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?


This article reconsiders Dostoevsky in relation to Schlegel’s idea of irony, which is based on the premise that the human subject is self-dividing. The romantic imagines to achieve a stable and united self, but that wish is continually shown futile in an infinite process of self-reflection. Romantic irony therefore is a mode of existence marked by a desire for an organic whole and the realization that such desire is impossible. The Dostoevsky’s hero is thrown to such ironic situation, where human subjectivity is continually confirmed and disconfirmed. The article first discusses references to Russian romanticism in Dostoevsky’s writings. It then moves on to a rereading of Notes from Underground and The Brothers Karamazov. Schlegel’s critical fragments are used throughout to illuminates the ironic quality of Dostoevsky’s writings. The article ends with a comparison between Dostoevsky and Schlegel’s views on irony.

Dostoevsky, Consciousness and Romantic Irony

in The Dostoevsky Journal



Albert Georgia Understanding Irony: Three essais on Friedrich Schlegelmln 108 (1993): 825848.

Bakhtin Mikhail The Problems of Dostoevsky’s PoeticsTheory and History of Literature Vol. 8 ed. and trans. Emerson Caryl (Minneapolis mn: University of Minnesota Press1984).

Behler Ernst Irony and the Discourse of Modernity (Seattle and London: University of Washington Press1990).

Bloom Harold (ed.) Fyodor Dostoevsky (New York; Philadelphia: Chelsea House Publishers1989).

Booth Wayne C. A Rhetoric of Irony (Chicago and London: The University of Chicago Press1974).

Colebrook Claire Irony: The New Critical Idiom (London; New York: Routledge2004).

Dostoevsky Fyodor A Writer’s Diary Vol. 1 1873–1876 trans. Lantz Kenneth (Evanston; Illinois: Northwestern University Press1994).

Dostoevsky Fyodor Demons trans. Pevear Richard and Volokhonsky Larissa (London: Vintage1994).

Dostoevsky Fyodor Winter’s Notes on Summer Impressions trans. Patterson David (Evanston il: Northwestern University Press1997).

Dostoevsky Fyodor The Idiot trans. Pevear Richard and Volokhonsky Larissa (New York: Vintage. 2002).

Dostoevsky Fyodor Notes from Underground trans. Pevear Richard and Volokhonsky Larissa (London: Alfred A. Knopf2004).

Dostoevsky Fyodor The Brothers Karamazov trans. Pevear Richard and Volokhonsky Larissa (London: Vintage2004).

Dostoevsky Fyodor Crime and Punishment trans. Pevear Richard and Volokhonsky Larissa (London: Vintage2004).

Dostoevsky Fyodor Humiliated and Insulted trans. Avsey Ignat (Surrey: Oneworld Classic2008).

Eichner Hans Friedrich Schlegel (New York: Twayne Publishers, Inc.1970).

Fanger Donald Dostoevsky and Romantic Realism: A Study of Dostoevsky in Relation to Balzac Dickens and Gogol (Evanston il: Northwestern University Press1998).

Fung Paul Dostoevsky and the Epileptic Mode of Being (Oxford: Legenda2014).

Furst Lilian R. Who Created “Romantische Ironie”?Pacific Coast Philology 16(1) (1981): 2937.

Hamlin Cyrus Platonic Dialogue and Romantic Irony: Prolegomenon to a Theory of Literary NarrativeCanadian Review of Comparative Literature 3 (1976): 526.

Handwerk Gary J. Irony and Ethics in Narrative: From Schlegel to Lacan (New Haven and London: Yale University Press1985).

Holquist Michael Dostoevsky and the Novel (Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University Press1977).

Jones Malcolm V. Dostoevsky and an Aspect of Schiller’s PsychologyThe Slavonic and East European Review52 (1974) 33754.

Jones Malcolm V. (ed.) The Cambridge Companion to the Classic Russian Novel (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press1998).

Kabat Geoffrey C. Ideology and Imagination: The Image of Society in Dostoevsky (New York: Columbia University Press1978).

Larmore Charles The Romantic Legacy (New York: Columbia University Press1993).

Lyngstad Alexandra Dostoevskij and Schiller (The Hague: Mouton1975).

Man Paul de The Rhetoric of Temporality’ in Blindness and Insight: Essays in the Rhetoric of Contemporary CriticismTheory and History of Literature 7 (Minneapolis mn: University of Minnesota Press1983) 187228.

Man Paul de Aesthetic Ideology ed. Warminski Andrzej (Minneapolis and London: University of Minnesota Press1996).

Millan Elizabeth Friedrich Schlegel and the Emergence of Romantic Philosophy (Albany: State University of New York Press2012).

Miller J. Hillis Others (Princeton and Oxford: Princeton University Press2001).

Muecke Douglas C. The Compass of Irony (London: Methuen1969).

Neuhäuser Rudolf . ‘Romanticism in the Post-Romantic Age: A Typological Study of Antecedents of Dostoevskii’s Man from Underground Canadian-American Slavic Studies8 (1974) 333358.

Peace Richard Dostoevsky: An Examination of Major Novels (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press1971).

Perlina Nina Varieties of Poetic Utterance: Quotation in The Brothers Karamazov (University Press of America1985).

Scanlan James P. Dostoevsky the Thinker (Ithaca and London: Cornell University Press2002).

Schlegel Friedrich Philosophical Fragments trans. Firchow Peter (Minneapolis; London: University of Minnesota Press1991).

Terras Victor Dostoevskij’s Aesthetics in its Relationship to RomanticismRussian Literature4 (1976) 1526.

Terras Victor Reading Dostoevsky (Madison; London: The University of Wisconsin University1998).

Zohrab Irene Dostoevsky and Kierkegaard in the Context of State Censorship. Problem Statement (With a Postscript on the “Hostage Syndrome”)Dostoevsky Journal14–15 (2013–2014) 65109.

Zohrab Irene Russian Imperial Censorship, with special reference to Dostoevskyanzsa CongressUniversity of New South Wales2012.

Index Card

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 33 33 21
Full Text Views 19 19 19
PDF Downloads 2 2 2
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0