One Work or Three? A Proposal for Reading 1QS-1QSa-1QSb as a Composite Work

in Dead Sea Discoveries
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

Abstract

Although it has long been acknowledged that 1QS, 1QSa, and 1QSb are part of the same manuscript, most scholars follow J.T. Milik’s interpretation of the columns of 1QSa and 1QSb as appendices to 1QS. This article examines the circumstances out of which this “appendix hypothesis” emerged, highlights its weaknesses, and takes up Philip Alexander and Géza Vermes’s call to consider the sections of the scroll together by proposing that 1QS-1QSa-1QSb is a composite work that its editor has unified through superscriptions. This study also examines the formatting between 1QS, 1QSa, and 1QSb and the evidence of a recension concerned with introducing the activity of the sons of Zadok and reframing the material for the Maskil throughout the scroll to propose that the heterogeneous and sometimes inconsistent contents are presented by its redactor as a single work rather than three distinct works in a single scroll.

One Work or Three? A Proposal for Reading 1QS-1QSa-1QSb as a Composite Work

in Dead Sea Discoveries

Sections

References

AbeggJr.Martin G. “1QSb and the Elusive High Priest.” Pages 439452 in Emanuel: Studies in Hebrew Bible Septuagint and Dead Sea Scrolls in Honor of Emanuel Tov. Edited by Shalom M. PaulRobert A. Kraft and Lawrence H. Schiffman. VTSupp 94. Leiden: Brill2003.

AlexanderPhilip S. “Rules,” EDSS 2:799803.

AlexanderPhilip S. and Géza Vermes. Qumran Cave 4. XIX: Serekh Ha-Yaḥad and Two Related Texts. DJD XIX. Oxford: Clarendon Press1998.

BarthélemyDominique and Józef T. Milik. “28a. Règle de la Congrégation (1QSa),” Pages 108118 in Qumran Cave 1. DJD I. Edited by D. Barthélemy and J.T. Milik. Oxford: Clarendon1955.

BaumgartenAlbert I. “Who Cares and Why Does It Matter? Qumran and the Essenes, Once Again!” DSD 11.2 (2004): 174190.

BaxterWayne. “1QSb: Old Divisions Made New.” Revue de Qumrân 21 (2004): 615630.

Ben-DovJonathan. “319. Otot,” Qumran Cave 4.XVI: Calendrical Texts. DJD XXI. Oxford: Clarendon2001.

Ben-DovJonathanDaniel Stökl Ben Ezra and Asaf Gayer. “Reconstruction of a Single Copy of the Qumran Cave 4 Cryptic-Script Serekh HaEdah.” RevQ 29.1 (2017): 2177.

BrookeGeorge J. “MS 1909. 1QRule of Blessings (1Q28b) Frg. 25a, 1QSb V 22–25.” Pages 273282 in Gleanings from the Caves: The Dead Sea Scrolls and Artefacts from the Schøyen Collection. Edited by Torleif Elgvin. LSTS 71. London: T&T Clark2016.

BrookeGeorge J. and James M. Robinson. A Further Fragment of 1QSb: The Schøyen Collection MS 1909. Occasional Papers 30. Claremont: Institute for Antiquity and Christianity1994.

BrookeGeorge J. and James M. Robinson. “A Further Fragment of 1QSb: The Schøyen Collection MS 1909.” JJS 46.1–2 (1995): 120133.

BurrowsMillar. The Dead Sea Scrolls. New York: Viking Press1955.

BurrowsMillar. The Dead Sea Scrolls of St. Mark’s Monastery Volume II: Fascicle 2 Plates and Transcriptions of the Manual of Discipline. New Haven, CT: American Schools of Oriental Research1951.

CarmignacJean. “Conjecture sur la première ligne de la Règle de la Communauté.” RevQ 2.1 (1959): 8587.

CarmignacJean. “Recueil des Bénédictions.” Pages 2842 in Les textes de Qumran: Traduits et Annotés. Edited by Édouard CothenetHubert Lignée and Jean Carmignac. Vol. 2. Autour de la bible. Paris: Letouzey et Ané1963.

CarmignacJean. “Règle de la Congrégation.” Pages 927 in Les textes de Qumran: Traduits et Annotés. Edited by Édouard CothenetHubert Lignée and Jean Carmignac. Vol. 2. Autour de la bible. Paris: Letouzey et Ané1963.

CharlesworthJames H. ed. Rule of the Community and Related Documents. The Dead Sea Scrolls: Hebrew Aramaic and Greek Texts with English Translations 1. Tübingen; Louisville: J.C.B. Mohr; Westminster John Knox Press1994.

CollinsJohn Joseph. Beyond the Qumran Community: The Sectarian Movement of the Dead Sea Scrolls. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans2010.

CollinsJohn Joseph. Scriptures and Sectarianism: Essays on the Dead Sea Scrolls. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans2016.

CrawfordSidnie White. “41. 4QDeutn,” Pages 117128 in Qumran Cave 4. IX: Deuteronomy Joshua Judges Kings. DJD XIV. Edited by Eugene Ulrichet al. Oxford: Clarendon1999.

De LooijerGwynned. The Qumran Paradigm: A Critical Evaluation of Some Foundational Hypotheses in the Construction of the Qumran Sect. EJL 43. Atlanta: SBL Press2015.

FieldsWeston. “Discovery and Purchase.” Pages 208212 in Encyclopedia of the Dead Sea Scrolls. Edited by Lawrence H. Schiffman and James C. VanderKam. Vol. 1. Oxford: Oxford University Press2000.

FieldsWeston. Dead Sea Scrolls: A Full History. 1st ed. Leiden: Boston2009.

FilsonFloyd V. “New Fragments of the Dead Sea Scrolls.” The Biblical Archaeologist 13.4 (1950): 99100.

FlintPeter. Qumran Cave 1. II. The Isaiah Scrolls. Part 2. DJD XXXII. Oxford: Clarendon1997.

GayerAsafDaniel Stökl Ben Ezra and Jonathan Ben-Dov. “A New Join of Two Fragments of 4QcryptA Serekh haEdah and Its Implications.” Dead Sea Discoveries 23.2 (2016): 139154.

GuilbertPierre. “La Règle de la Communauté.” Pages 1080 in Les textes de Qumran: Traduits et annotés. Edited by Jean Carmignac and Pierre Guilbert. Vol. 1. Autour de la bible. Paris: Letouzey et Ané1961.

HardingG. Lankester. “Introductory. The Discovery, the Excavation, Minor Finds” Pages 37 in Qumran Cave 1. DJD I. Edited by D. Barthélemy and J.T. Milik. Oxford: Clarendon1955.

HempelCharlotte. “Do the Scrolls Suggest Rivalry between the Sons of Aaron and the Sons of Zadok and If So Was It Mutual?” RevQ 24.1 (2009): 135153.

HempelCharlotte. “The Treatise on the Two Spirits and the Literary History of the Rule of the Community.” Pages 102120 in Dualism in Qumran. Edited by Géza G. Xeravits. Library of Second Temple Studies LSTS 76. London: T&T Clark2010.

HempelCharlotte. The Qumran Rule Texts in Context: Collected Studies. TSAJ 174. Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck2013.

HempelCharlotte. “The Long Text of the Serekh as Crisis Literature.” RevQ 27.1 (2015): 323.

HempelCharlotte. סרך.” ThWQ 2:11111117.

JokirantaJutta. “What Is ‘Serekh Ha-Yahad (S)’? Thinking about Ancient Manuscripts as Information Processing.” Pages 611635 in Sibyls Scriptures and Scrolls: John Collins at Seventy. Edited by Joel BadenHindy Najman and Eibert Tigchelaar. Vol. 1. JSJSup 175. Leiden: Brill2016.

JokirantaJutta and Hanna Vanonen. “Multiple Copies of Rule Texts or Multiple Rule Texts? Boundaries of the S and M Documents.” Pages 1160 in Crossing Imaginary Boundaries: The Dead Sea Scrolls in the Context of Second Temple Judaism. Edited by Mika S. Pajunen and Hanna Tervanotko. Publications of the Finnish Exegetical Society 108. Helsinki: Finnish Exegetical Society2015.

KuglerRobert A. “A Note on 1QS 9:14: The Sons of Righteousness or the Sons of Zadok?” DSD 3.3 (1996): 315320.

LichtJacob. The Rule Scroll. Jerusalem: Bialik Institute1965.

MartinMalachiS. J. The Scribal Character of the Dead Sea Scrolls. Vols. 1–2. Bibliothèque du Muséon 44 45. Louvain: Publications Universitaires, Institut Orientaliste1958.

MetsoSarianna. “Methodological Problems in Reconstructing History from Rule Texts Found at Qumran.” DSD 11.3 (2004): 315335.

MetsoSarianna. “Rule of the Community.” Pages 11691171 in The Eerdmans Dictionary of Early Judaism. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans2010.

MetsoSarianna. The Textual Development of the Qumran Community Rule. STDJ 21. Leiden: Brill1997.

MetsoSarianna. The Serekh Texts. London; New York: T&T Clark2007.

MilikJózef T. “28. Annexes à la Règle de la Communauté (1QS),” Pages 107108 in Qumran Cave 1. DJD I. Edited by D. Barthélemy and J. T. Milik. Oxford: Clarendon1955.

MilikJózef T. “28b. Recueil des Bénédictions (1QSb),” Pages 118129 in Qumran Cave 1. DJD I. Edited by D. Barthélemy and J. T. Milik. Oxford: Clarendon1955.

MroczekEva. The Literary Imagination in Jewish Antiquity. Oxford: Oxford University Press2016.

NajmanHindy. “Toward a Study of the Uses of the Concept of Wilderness in Ancient Judaism.” Pages 447466 in Celebrating the Dead Sea Scrolls: A Canadian Collection. Edited by Peter W. FlintJean Duhaime and Kyung S. Baek. EJL 30. Atlanta: Society of Biblical Literature2011.

PfannStephen J. “Cryptic Texts.” Pages 515702 in Qumran Cave 4. XXVI: Cryptic Texts and Miscellanea. Pt. 1. DJD XXXVI. Edited by Stephen Pfannet al.Oxford: Clarendon2000.

PikeDana M. and Andrew C. Skinner. “PAM 43.680 Pl. XXI.” Pages 147160 in Qumran Cave 4. XXIII: Unidentified Fragments. DJD XXXIII. Edited by D.M. Pike and A.C. Skinner. Oxford: Clarendon2001.

SaadYusef. The Palestine Archaeological Museum and the Dead Sea Scrolls. 5th ed. Beirut: Catholic Press1965.

SamuelAthanasius Yeshue. Treasure of Qumran: My Story of the Dead Sea Scrolls. Philadelphia: Westminster1966.

SchiffmanLawrence H. The Eschatological Community of the Dead Sea Scrolls: A Study of the Rule of the Congregation. Atlanta: Scholars Press1989.

SchiffmanLawrence H. Qumran and Jerusalem: Studies in the Dead Sea Scrolls and the History of Judaism. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans2010.

SchofieldAlison. “Rereading S: A New Model of Textual Development in Light of the Cave 4 Serekh Copies.” Dead Sea Discoveries 15.1 (2008): 96120.

SchofieldAlison. “The Wilderness Motif in the Dead Sea Scrolls.” Pages 3754 in Israel in the Wilderness: Interpretations of the Biblical Narratives in Jewish and Christian Traditions. Edited by Kenneth E. Pomykala. Themes in Biblical Narrative: Jewish and Christian Traditions 10. Leiden: Brill2008.

SchofieldAlison. “Between Center and Periphery: The Yaḥad in Context.” Dead Sea Discoveries 16.3 (2009): 330350.

SchofieldAlison. From Qumran to the Yahad: A New Paradigm of Textual Development for the Community Rule. STDJ 77. Leiden: Brill2009.

SchullerEileen. “Hodayot.” Pages 69254 in Qumran Cave 4. XX: Poetical and Liturgical Texts. Part 2. DJD XXIX. Edited by Esther Chazonet al. Oxford: Clarendon1999.

StegemannHartmut. “Some Remarks to 1QSa, to 1QSb, and to Qumran Messianism.” Revue de Qumran 17.1/4 (1996): 479505.

StegemannHartmut. The Library of Qumran: On the Essenes Qumran John the Baptist and Jesus. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans1998.

SteudelAnnette. אחרית הימים in the Texts from Qumran.” Revue de Qumrân 16.2 (1993): 225246.

TalmonShemaryahu. “The ‘Desert Motif’ in the Bible and in Qumran Literature.” Pages 3164 in Biblical Motifs: Origins and Transformations. Edited by Alexander Altmann. Studies and Texts 8. Cambridge: Harvard University Press1966.

TigchelaarEibert J. C. “In Search of the Scribe of 1QS.” Pages 439452 in Emanuel: Studies in Hebrew Bible Septuagint and Dead Sea Scrolls in Honor of Emanuel Tov. Edited by Shalom M. PaulRobert A. Kraft and Lawrence H. Schiffman. VTSupp 94. Leiden: Brill2003.

TigchelaarEibert J. C. “On the Unidentified Fragments of DJD XXXIII and PAM 43.680: A New Manuscript of 4QNarrative and Poetic Composition, and Fragments of 4Q13, 4Q269, 4Q525 and 4QSb (?).” RevQ 21.83 (2004): 477485.

TovEmanuel. “The Orthography and Language of the Hebrew Scrolls Found at Qumran and the Origin of These Scrolls.” Textus 13 (1986): 3157.

TovEmanuel. Scribal Practices and Approaches Reflected in the Texts Found in the Judean Desert. STDJ 54. Leiden: Brill2004.

TreverJohn C. “Preliminary Observations on the Jerusalem Scrolls.” BASOR 111.3 (1948): 316.

TreverJohn C. The Dead Sea Scrolls in Perspective. North Richland Hills: BIBAL2004.

UlrichEugene Charles. “4QSamc: A Fragmentary Manuscript of 2 Samuel 14–15 from the Scribe of the Serek Hay-Yaḥad (1QS).” BASOR 235 (1979): 125.

UlrichEugene Charles. The Dead Sea Scrolls and the Developmental Composition of the Bible. VTSupp 169. Leiden: Brill2015.

VanderKamJames C. “The Judean Desert and the Community of the Dead Sea Scrolls.” Pages 159171 in Antikes Judentum und frühes Christentum: Festschrift für Hartmut Stegemann zum 65 Geburtstag. Edited by Bernd KollmannWolfgang Reinbold and Annette Steudel. BZNW 97. Berlin: de Gruyter1999.

VanderKamJames C. “Questions of Canon Viewed through the Dead Sea Scrolls.” Pages 91109 in The Canon Debate. Edited by Lee Martin McDonald and James A. Sanders. Peabody, MA: Hendrickson2002.

VanderKamJames C. “Sinai Revisited.” Pages 4466 in Biblical Interpretation at Qumran. Edited by Matthias Henze. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans2005.

VermesGeza. “Qumran Forum Miscellanea I.” JJS 43.2 (1992): 299305.

VermesGeza. “The Leadership of the Qumran Community: Sons of Zadok – Priests – Congregation.” Pages 375384 in Vol. 1 of Geschichte Tradition Reflexion: Festschrift für Martin Hengel zum 70. Geburtstag. Edited by Hubert CancikHermann Lichtenberger and Peter Schäfer. Tübingen: J.C.B. Mohr1996.

VermesGeza. The Complete Dead Sea Scrolls in English: Complete Edition. Rev. ed. New York: Penguin Books2004.

YadinYigael. “Three Notes on the Dead Sea Scrolls.” IEJ 6.3 (1956): 158162.

ZeitlinSolomon. “The Medieval Mind and the Theological Speculation on the Dead Sea Scrolls.” JQR 49.1 (1958): 134.

Information

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 38 38 12
Full Text Views 62 62 41
PDF Downloads 22 22 9
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0