Provenance vs. Authenticity: An Archaeological Perspective on the Post-2002 “Dead Sea Scrolls-Like” Fragments
In: Dead Sea DiscoveriesSearch for other papers by Dennis Mizzi in
Current site
Google Scholar
Search for other papers by Jodi Magness in
Current site
Google Scholar
Abstract
This article adds an archaeological voice to the current debate surrounding the authenticity of recently acquired “Dead Sea Scrolls-like” fragments. In our opinion, since these fragments are above all archaeological artifacts, considerations of provenance should take priority over authenticity. We begin with a survey that contextualizes this debate in relation to other types of archaeological artifacts, and consider the importance of context as well as ethical, legal, moral, and economic issues relating to the acquisition and publication of unprovenanced artifacts. We conclude that any artifact that lacks verifiable documentation of its provenance—whether or not it is authentic—should not be studied or published by scholars. Finally, we urge professional organizations and publishers to establish or strengthen policies preventing the publication of such artifacts, even after primary publication or presentation elsewhere.
Purchase
Buy instant access (PDF download and unlimited online access):
Institutional Login
Log in with Open Athens, Shibboleth, or your institutional credentials
Personal login
Log in with your brill.com account
-
Anderson, Maxwell L. Antiquities: What Everyone Needs to Know. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2017.
-
Appiah, Kwame Anthony. “Whose Culture Is It?” Pages 71–86 in Whose Culture? The Promise of Museums and the Debate over Antiquities. Edited by James B. Cuno. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2012.
-
Askin, Lindsey A. “What Did Ben Sira’s Bible and Desk Look Like?” Pages 3–26 in Ancient Readers and Their Scriptures: Engaging the Hebrew Bible in Early Judaism and Christianity. Edited by Garrick Allen and John Anthony Dunne. AJEC 107. Leiden: Brill, 2018.
-
Azzarelli, Joseph M., John B. Goods, and Timothy M. Swager. “Study of Two Papyrus Fragments with Fourier Transform Infrared Microspectroscopy.” HTR 107 (2014): 165.
-
Beaumont, Peter and Oliver Laughland. “Trade in Dead Sea Scrolls Awash with Suspected Forgeries, Experts Warn.” The Guardian, 21 November 2017, https://www.theguardian.com/world/2017/nov/21/trade-in-dead-sea-scrolls-awash-with-suspected-forgeries-experts-warn?CMP=Share_iOSApp_Other.
-
Bernhard, Andrew. “Postscript: A Final Note about the Origin of the Gospel of Jesus’ Wife.” NTS 63 (2017): 305–317.
-
Boardman, John. “Archaeologists, Collectors, and Museums.” Pages 33–46 in Who Owns Objects? The Ethics and Politics of Collecting Cultural Artefacts: Proceedings of the First St Cross-All Souls Seminar Series and Workshop, Oxford, October–December 2004. Edited by Eleanor Robson, Luke Treadwell, and Chris Gosden. Oxford: Oxbow Books, 2006.
-
Brodie, Neil. “Stolen History: Looting and Illicit Trade.” Museum International 219–20 (2003): 10–22.
-
Brodie, Neil. “Smoke and Mirrors.” Pages 1–14 in Who Owns Objects? The Ethics and Politics of Collecting Cultural Artefacts: Proceedings of the First St Cross-All Souls Seminar Series and Workshop, Oxford, October–December 2004. Edited by Eleanor Robson, Luke Treadwell, and Chris Gosden. Oxford: Oxbow Books, 2006.
-
Brodie, Neil. “An Archaeologist’s View of the Trade in Unprovenanced Antiquities.” Pages 52–63 in Art and Cultural Heritage: Law, Policy and Practice. Edited by Barbara T. Hoffman. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2006.
-
Brodie, Neil. “Consensual Relations? Academic Involvement in the Illegal Trade in Ancient Manuscripts.” Pages 41–58 in Criminology and Archaeology: Studies in Looted Antiquities. Edited by Simon Mackenzie and Penny Green. OISLS. Oxford: Hart, 2009.
-
Brodie, Neil. “Archaeological Looting and Economic Justice.” Pages 261–277 in Cultural Heritage Management: A Global Perspective. Edited by Phyllis Mauch Messenger and George S. Smith. CHS. Gainesville, FL: University Press of Florida, 2010.
-
Brodie, Neil. “Scholarship and Insurgency? The Study and Trade of Iraqi Antiquities.” Paper presented at the Illicit Traffic of Cultural Objects: Law, Ethics, and the Realities Workshop hosted by the Institute of Advanced Studies at the University of Western Australia. 4–5 August 2011. Online copy: https://traffickingculture.org/publications/brodie-neil-2011-scholarship-and-insurgency-the-study-and-trade-of-iraqi-antiquities-in-illicit-traffic-of-cultural-objects-law-ethics-and-the-realities-an-institute-of-advanced-studies-works/.
-
Brodie, Neil. “Congenial Bedfellows? The Academy and the Antiquities Trade.” JCCJ 27 (2011): 408–437.
-
Brodie, Neil. “The Antiquities Market: It’s All in a Price.” Heritage & Society 7 (2014): 32–46.
-
Brodie, Neil and Morag M. Kersel. “The Social and Political Consequences of Devotion to Biblical Artifacts.” Pages 109–125 in All the King’s Horses: Essays on the Impact of Looting and the Illicit Antiquities Trade on Our Knowledge of the Past. Edited by Paula K. Lazrus and Alex W. Barker. Washington, DC: Society of American Archaeology, 2012.
-
Brodie, Neil and Morag M. Kersel. “WikiLeaks, Text, and Archaeology: The Case of the Schøyen Incantation Bowls.” Pages 198–213 in Archaeologies of Text: Archaeology, Technology, and Ethics. Edited by Matthew T. Rutz and Morag M. Kersel. JIP 6. Oxford: Oxbow Books, 2014.
-
Brodie, Neil and Colin Renfrew. “Looting and the World’s Archaeological Heritage: The Inadequate Response.” ARA 34 (2005): 343–361.
-
Brodie, Neil and Isber Sabrine. “The Illegal Excavation and Trade of Syrian Cultural Objects: A View from the Ground.” JFA 43 (2018): 74–84.
-
Brooke, George J. and James M. Robinson. “A Further Fragment of 1QSb: The Schøyen Collection MS 1909.” JJS 46 (1995): 120–133.
-
Broshi, Magen and Hanan Eshel. “Residential Caves at Qumran.” DSD 6 (1999): 328–348.
-
Brumfield, Sara. “How to Spot Fake Cuneiform Tablets.” ANE Today 6 (2018): http://www.asor.org/anetoday/2018/06/Spot-Fake-Cueiform-Tablets.
-
Charlesworth, James. “XJudges.” Pages 231–233 in Miscellanea, Part 2. Vol. 28 of Qumran Cave 4. DJD 28. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 2001.
-
Charlesworth, James H. “The Discovery of an Unknown Dead Sea Scroll: The Original Text of Deuteronomy 27?” OWU Magazine, Summer 2012, https://web.archive.org/web/20140226221353/http:/blogs.owu.edu/magazine/the-discovery-of-an-unknown-dead-sea-scroll-the-original-text-of-deuteronomy-27/.
-
Cherry, John F. “Publishing Undocumented Texts: Editorial Perspectives.” Pages 227–244 in Archaeologies of Text: Archaeology, Technology, and Ethics. Edited by Matthew T. Rutz and Morag M. Kersel. JIP 6. Oxford: Oxbow Books, 2014.
-
Cohen, Rudolf and Yigal Yisraeli. “The Excavations of Rock Shelter XII/50 and in Caves XII/52–53.” ʿAtiqot 41/1 (2002): 207–213 [Hebrew], ʿAtiqot 41/2 (2002): 185–86 [English].
-
Cotton, Hannah M. and Ada Yardeni. Aramaic, Hebrew and Greek Documentary Texts from Naḥal Ḥever and Other Sites, with an Appendix containing Alleged Qumran Texts (The Seiyâl Collection II). DJD 27. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1997.
-
Cross, Frank Moore. “Reminiscences of the Early Days in the Discovery and Study of the Dead Sea Scrolls.” Pages 931–943 in The Dead Sea Scrolls Fifty Years after their Discovery: Proceedings of the Jerusalem Congress, July 20–25, 1997. Edited by Lawrence H. Schiffman, Emanuel Tov, and James C. VanderKam. Jerusalem: Israel Exploration Society, 2000.
-
Cuno, James. Who Owns Antiquity? Museums and the Battle over Our Ancient Heritage. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2008.
-
Davis, Kipp. “High Quality Scrolls from the Post-Herodian Period.” Pages 129–138 in Gleanings from the Caves: Dead Sea Scrolls and Artefacts from the Schøyen Collection. Edited by Torleif Elgvin, Kipp Davis, and Michael Langlois. LSTS 71. London: T&T Clark, 2016.
-
Davis, Kipp. “Caves of Dispute: Patterns of Correspondence and Suspicion in the Post-2002 ‘Dead Sea Scrolls’ Fragments.” DSD 24 (2017): 229–270.
-
Davis, Kipp. “Gleanings from the Cave of Wonders? Fragments, Forgeries, and ‘Biblicism’ in the Dead Sea Scrolls.” Marginalia, 22 June 2018, https://marginalia.lareviewofbooks.org/gleanings-from-the-cave-of-wonders/.
-
Davis, Kipp, Ira Rabin, Ines Feldman, Myriam Krutzsch, Hasia Rimon, Årstein Justnes, Torleif Elgvin, and Michael Langlois. “Nine Dubious ‘Dead Sea Scrolls’ Fragments from the Twenty-First Century.” DSD 24 (2017): 189–228.
-
De Montebello, Philippe. “‘And What Do You Propose Should Be Done with Those Objects?’” Pages 55–70 in Whose Culture? The Promise of Museums and the Debate over Antiquities. Edited by James B. Cuno. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2012.
-
Depuydt, Leo. “The Alleged Gospel of Jesus’s Wife: Assessment and Evaluation of Authenticity.” HTR 107 (2014): 172–189.
-
Draper, Robert. “The Bible Hunters.” National Geographic (December 2018): 40–75.
-
Draper, Robert. “Inside the Cloak-and-Dagger Search for Sacred Texts.” National Geographic, December 2018, https://www.nationalgeographic.com/magazine/2018/12/inside-bible-collectors-search-other-original-christian-texts/.
-
Eckardt, Hella. Writing and Power in the Roman World: Literacies and Material Culture. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2018.
-
Ede, James. “Who Owns Objects? A View from the Antiquities Trade.” Pages 77–81 in Who Owns Objects? The Ethics and Politics of Collecting Cultural Artefacts: Proceedings of the First St Cross-All Souls Seminar Series and Workshop, Oxford, October–December 2004. Edited by Eleanor Robson, Luke Treadwell, and Chris Gosden. Oxford: Oxbow Books, 2006.
-
Elia, Ricardo J. “A Seductive and Troubling Work: Review of The Cycladic Spirit: Masterpieces from the Nicholas P. Goulandris Collection by Colin Renfrew and Christos Doumas.” Archaeology 46/1 (1993): 64–69.
-
Elia, Ricardo J. “Comment on ‘Irreconcilable Differences?’: Scholars for Sale.” PIA 18 (2007): 16–18.
-
Elgvin, Torleif. “Texts and Artefacts from the Judaean Desert in the Schøyen Collection: An Overview.” Pages 51–60 in Gleanings from the Caves: Dead Sea Scrolls and Artefacts from the Schøyen Collection. Edited by Torleif Elgvin, Kipp Davis, and Michael Langlois. LSTS 71. London: T&T Clark, 2016.
-
Elgvin, Torleif. “MS 4612/1. Ḥev(?)Joel (Joel 4.1–5).” Pages 223–232 in Gleanings from the Caves: Dead Sea Scrolls and Artefacts from the Schøyen Collection. Edited by Torleif Elgvin, Kipp Davis, and Michael Langlois. LSTS 71. London: T&T Clark, 2016.
-
Elgvin, Torleif. “MS 5095/7. 4Q(?)Fragment with Text from Commentary on Genesis A.” Pages 291–294 in Gleanings from the Caves: Dead Sea Scrolls and Artefacts from the Schøyen Collection. Edited by Torleif Elgvin, Kipp Davis, and Michael Langlois. LSTS 71. London: T&T Clark, 2016.
-
Elgvin, Torleif. “MS 5439/2. Ḥev(?)Unidentified Fragment.” Pages 299–300 in Gleanings from the Caves: Dead Sea Scrolls and Artefacts from the Schøyen Collection. Edited by Torleif Elgvin, Kipp Davis, and Michael Langlois. LSTS 71. London: T&T Clark, 2016.
-
Elgvin, Torleif. “Incense Altar from Naḥal Ḥever? MS 1655/4.” Pages 439–449 in Gleanings from the Caves: Dead Sea Scrolls and Artefacts from the Schøyen Collection. Edited by Torleif Elgvin, Kipp Davis, and Michael Langlois. LSTS 71. London: T&T Clark, 2016.
-
Elgvin, Torleif. “Bronze Inkwells from Naḥal Ḥever(?) and Nabataea. MS 1655/2 and MS 1987/15.” Pages 451–462 in Gleanings from the Caves: Dead Sea Scrolls and Artefacts from the Schøyen Collection. Edited by Torleif Elgvin, Kipp Davis, and Michael Langlois. LSTS 71. London: T&T Clark, 2016.
-
Elgvin, Torleif, Kipp Davis, and Michael Langlois, ed. Gleanings from the Caves: Dead Sea Scrolls and Artefacts from the Schøyen Collection. LSTS 71. London: T&T Clark, 2016.
-
Elgvin, Torleif, in collaboration with Stephen J. Pfann. “An Incense Altar from Qumran?” DSD 9 (2002): 20–33.
-
Elkins, Nathan T. “The Trade in Fresh Supplies of Ancient Coins: Scale, Organization, and Politics.” Pages 91–107 in All the King’s Horses: Essays on the Impact of Looting and the Illicit Antiquities Trade on Our Knowledge of the Past. Edited by Paula K. Lazrus and Alex W. Barker. Washington, DC: Society of American Archaeology, 2012.
-
Elkins, Nathan T. “Archaeological Views: Investigating the Crime Scene: Looting and Ancient Coins.” BAR 40/4 (2014): 26, 69.
-
Eshel, Esther. “MS 4612/3. 11Q(?)Eschatological Fragment ar.” Pages 295–298 in Gleanings from the Caves: Dead Sea Scrolls and Artefacts from the Schøyen Collection. Edited by Torleif Elgvin, Kipp Davis, and Michael Langlois. LSTS 71. London: T&T Clark, 2016.
-
Eshel, Esther and Hanan Eshel. “New Fragments from Qumran: 4QGenf, 4QIsab, 4Q226, 8QGen, and XQpapEnoch.” DSD 12 (2005): 134–157.
-
Eshel, Esther, Hanan Eshel, and Magen Broshi. “A New Fragment of XJudges.” DSD 14 (2007): 354–358.
-
Eshel, Esther, Hanan Eshel, and Årstein Justnes. “XJudg with MS 2861 [Judg 4.5–6].” Pages 193–201 in Gleanings from the Caves: Dead Sea Scrolls and Artefacts from the Schøyen Collection. Edited by Torleif Elgvin, Kipp Davis, and Michael Langlois. LSTS 71. London: T&T Clark, 2016.
-
Eshel, Hanan. “Three New Fragments from Qumran Cave 11.” DSD 8 (2001): 1–8.
-
Eshel, Hanan, Yosi Baruchi, and Roi Porat. “Fragments of a Leviticus Scroll (ArugLev) Found in the Judean Desert in 2004.” DSD 13 (2006): 55–60.
-
Fidanzio, Marcello. “De nouvelles découvertes dans la grotte XII/53 (12 ?) à Qumrân.” RevQ 29 (2017): 139–144.
-
Fields, Weston W. The Dead Sea Scrolls: A Full History: Volume One, 1947–1960. Leiden: Brill, 2009.
-
Fields, Weston W. “Dead Sea Scrolls: Significance of the Latest Development.” Youtube, 16 April 2011, https://youtu.be/cOcNhHsGKu4?t=3036.
-
Fincham, Derek. “The Fundamental Importance of Archaeological Context.” Pages 3–12 in Art and Crime: Exploring the Dark Side of the Art World. Edited by Noah Charney. Santa Barbara, CA: Praeger, 2009.
-
Földi, Zsombor. “Cuneiform Tablets and the Antiquities Market: The Archives from Dūr-Abī-ešuḫ.” DWJ 2 (2017): 7–27.
-
Gerstenblith, Patty. “Do Restrictions on Publication of Undocumented Texts Promote Legitimacy?” Pages 214–226 in Archaeologies of Text: Archaeology, Technology, and Ethics. Edited by Matthew T. Rutz and Morag M. Kersel. JIP 6. Oxford: Oxbow Books, 2014.
-
Gill, David W. J. and Christopher Chippindale. “Material and Intellectual Consequences of Esteem for Cycladic Figures.” AJA 97 (1993): 601–659.
-
Gutfeld, Oren and Ahiad Ovadia. “Old Cave—New Project: The Renewed Excavations in Qumran Cave 53.” Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the ASOR. Boston, MA, 16 November 2017.
-
Gutfeld, Oren and Randall Price. “The Discovery of a New Dead Sea Scroll Cave at Qumran.” Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the SBL. Boston, MA, 19 November 2017.
-
Harding, Anthony. “The Problem of Illicit Antiquities: An Ethical Dilemma for Scholars.” Pages 77–109 in History for the Taking? Perspectives on Material Heritage: A Report Prepared for the British Academy. London: The British Academy, 2011.
-
Hodgins, Gregory. “Accelerated Mass Spectrometry Radiocarbon Determination of Papyrus Samples.” HTR 107 (2014): 166–169.
-
Jarus, Owen. “28 Dead Sea Scroll Fragments Sold in the U.S.” CBS News, 3 April 2017, https://www.cbsnews.com/news/28-dead-sea-scroll-fragments-sold-in-the-u-s/.
-
Joffe, Alexander H. Review of Messages from the Past: Hebrew Bullae from the Time of Isaiah through the Destruction of the First Temple, by Robert Deutsch, and Biblical Period Personal Seals in the Shlomo Moussaieff Collection, by Robert Deutsch and André Lemaire. JNES 62 (2003): 119–124.
-
Johnson, Michael Brooks. “A Fragment of Instruction [Inv. MOTB.SCR.000123].” Pages 222–236 in Dead Sea Scrolls Fragments in the Museum Collection. Edited by Emanuel Tov, Kipp Davis, and Robert Duke. PMB 1. Leiden: Brill, 2016.
-
Johnson, Michael Brooks. “A Case Study in Professional Ethics concerning Secondary Publications of Unprovenanced Artefacts: The New Edition DSS F.Instruction1.” DWJ 2 (2017): 28–44.
-
Justnes, Årstein. Review of Dead Sea Scrolls Fragments in the Museum Collection, edited by Emanuel Tov, Kipp Davis, and Robert Duke. DSD 24 (2017): 310–312.
-
Justnes, Årstein. “The Post-2002 DSS-like Fragments: A Price List.” The Lying Pen of Scribes, 27 March 2018, https://lyingpen.com/2018/03/27/the-post-2002-dss-like-fragments-a-price-list/.
-
Justnes, Årstein. “Fragments for Sale: Dead Sea Scrolls.” Marginalia, 22 June 2018, https://marginalia.lareviewofbooks.org/fragments-for-sale/.
-
Justnes, Årstein. “A Lightly Annotated Chronological Bibliography of the Post-2002 Dead Sea Scrolls-like Fragments.” The Lying Pen of Scribes, 21 December 2018, https://lyingpen.com/2018/12/21/a-lightly-annotated-chronological-bibliography-of-the-post-2002-dead-sea-scrolls-like-fragments/.
-
Justnes, Årstein. “A List of Unprovenanced, Post-2002 Dead Sea Scrolls-like Fragments.” The Lying Pen of Scribes, 14 January 2019, https://lyingpen.com/2019/01/14/a-list-of-70-unprovenanced-post-2002-dead-sea-scrolls-like-fragments/.
-
Justnes, Årstein and Ludvik A. Kjeldsberg. “‘American Priest, Later Serving in Switzerland’: On Provenance.” The Lying Pen of Scribes, 28 November 2018, https://lyingpen.com/2018/11/28/american-priest-later-serving-in-switzerland-on-provenance/.
-
Justnes, Årstein and Ludvik A. Kjeldsberg. “The Post-2002 Dead Sea Scrolls Fragments: A Tentative Timeline of Acquisitions.” The Lying Pen of Scribes, 16 January 2019, https://lyingpen.com/2019/01/16/the-post-2002-dead-sea-scrolls-fragments-a-tentative-timeline/.
-
King, Karen L. “‘Jesus Said to Them, ‘My Wife …”: A New Coptic Papyrus Fragment.” HTR 107 (2014): 131–159.
-
Langlois, Michael. “Fake Scrolls at the Museum of the Bible.” The Conversation, 4 November 2018, https://theconversation.com/fake-scrolls-at-the-museum-of-the-bible-106012.
-
Lubetski, Meir and Edith Lubetski, ed. New Inscriptions and Seals Relating to the Biblical World. SBLABS 19. Atlanta, GA: Society of Biblical Literature, 2012.
-
Mazza, Roberta. “Biblical History at What Cost? Hobby Lobby, the Museum of the Bible and the Antiquities Market.” BAR, 24 July 2017, https://www.biblicalarchaeology.org/daily/biblical-artifacts/artifacts-and-the-bible/hobby-lobby-museum-of-the-bible/.
-
Merryman, John Henry. “The Nation and the Object.” Pages 183–203 in Whose Culture? The Promise of Museums and the Debate over Antiquities. Edited by James B. Cuno. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2012.
-
Meyers, Eric M. and Carol Meyers, ed. Archaeology, Bible, Politics, and the Media: Proceedings of the Duke University Conference, April 23–24, 2009. Winona Lake, IN: Eisenbrauns, 2012.
-
Norman, Naomi J. “Editorial Policy on the Publication of Recently Acquired Antiquities.” AJA 109 (2005): 135–136.
-
O’Keefe, Patrick J. “International Laws, Treaties, and Organizations.” Pages 251–260 in Cultural Heritage Management: A Global Perspective. Edited by Phyllis Mauch Messenger and George S. Smith. CHS. Gainesville, FL: University Press of Florida, 2010.
-
Ortiz, George. “Overview and Assessment after Fifty Years of Collecting in a Changing World.” Pages 15–32 in Who Owns Objects? The Ethics and Politics of Collecting Cultural Artefacts: Proceedings of the First St Cross-All Souls Seminar Series and Workshop, Oxford, October–December 2004. Edited by Eleanor Robson, Luke Treadwell, and Chris Gosden. Oxford: Oxbow Books, 2006.
-
Owen, David I. “Censoring Knowledge: The Case for the Publication of Unprovenanced Cuneiform Tablets.” Pages 125–142 in Whose Culture? The Promise of Museums and the Debate over Antiquities. Edited by James B. Cuno. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2012.
-
Price, Sally. Primitive Art in Civilized Places. 2nd ed. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press, 2001.
-
Price, Sally. “The Enduring Power of Primitivism: Showcasing the ‘Other’ in Twenty-First-Century France.” Pages 447–465 in A Companion to Modern African Art. Edited by Gitti Salami and Monica Blackmun Visonà. Chichester, West Sussex: Wiley Blackwell, 2013.
-
Puech, Émile. “Fragment d’un rouleau de la Genèse provenant du Désert de Juda.” RevQ 38 (1980): 163–166.
-
Puech, Émile. “Les manuscrits 4QJugesc (= 4Q50A) et 1QJuges (= 1Q6).” Pages 184–202 in Studies in the Hebrew Bible, Qumran, and the Septuagint Presented to Eugene Ulrich. Edited by Peter W. Flint, Emanuel Tov, and James C. VanderKam. VTSup 101. Leiden: Brill, 2006.
-
Puech, Émile. Textes araméens, deuxième partie: 4Q550–4Q575a, 4Q580–4Q587 et appendices. Vol. 27 of Qumran Cave 4. DJD 37. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 2009.
-
Puech, Émile. “Nouveaux menus fragments de la Grotte 11Q (P1344, P1345 et P1038B).” In Khirbet Qumrân et Aïn Feshkha: Vol. IVA: Cave 11Q: Archaeology and New Scroll Fragments. Edited by Jean-Baptiste Humbert and Marcello Fidanzio. NTOA.SA 8. Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, in press.
-
Puech, Émile and Annette Steudel. “Un nouveau fragment du manuscrit 4QInstruction (XQ7 = 4Q417 ou 418).” RevQ 19 (2000): 623–627.
-
Rabin, Ira. “Material Analysis of the Fragments.” Pages 61–77 in Gleanings from the Caves: Dead Sea Scrolls and Artefacts from the Schøyen Collection. Edited by Torleif Elgvin, Kipp Davis, and Michael Langlois. LSTS 71. London: T&T Clark, 2016.
-
Reed, Stephen A. “Find-Sites of the Dead Sea Scrolls.” DSD 14 (2007): 199–121.
-
Renfrew, Colin. Loot, Legitimacy and Ownership: The Ethical Crisis in Archaeology. London: Duckworth, 2000.
-
Rollston, Christopher A. “Non-Provenanced Epigraphs I: Pillaged Antiquities, Northwest Semitic Forgeries, and Protocols for Laboratory Tests.” Maarav 10 (2003): 135–193.
-
Rollston, Christopher A. “Non-Provenanced Epigraphs II: The Status of Non-Provenanced Epigraphs within the Broader Corpus of Northwest Semitic.” Maarav 11 (2004): 57–79.
-
Rollston, Christopher A. “Navigating the Epigraphic Storm: A Palaeographer Reflects on Inscriptions from the Market.” NEA 68 (2005): 69–72.
-
Rollston, Christopher A. “Modern Epigraphic Forgeries.” Rollston Epigraphy, 5 September 2009, http://www.rollstonepigraphy.com.
-
Sabar, Ariel. “The Unbelievable Tale of Jesus’s Wife.” The Atlantic, July/August 2016, https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2016/07/the-unbelievable-tale-of-jesus-wife/485573/.
-
Schøyen, Martin. “Acquisition and Ownership History: A Personal Reflection.” Pages 27–32 in Gleanings from the Caves: Dead Sea Scrolls and Artefacts from the Schøyen Collection. Edited by Torleif Elgvin, Kipp Davis, and Michael Langlois. LSTS 71. London: T&T Clark, 2016.
-
Sease, Catherine. “Conservation and the Antiquities Trade.” JAIC 36 (1997): 49–58.
-
Shanks, Hershel. “First Person: What To Do with Unprovenanced Artifacts—Publish or Perish?” BAR 39/2 (2013): 6, 64–66.
-
Tigchelaar, Eibert J. C. “Notes on the Three Qumran-Type Yadin Fragments Leading to a Discussion of Identification, Attribution, Provenance, and Names.” DSD 19 (2012): 198–214.
-
Tigchelaar, Eibert J. C. “A Provisional List of Unprovenanced, Twenty-First Century, Dead Sea Scrolls-like Fragments.” DSD 24 (2017): 173–188.
-
Tigchelaar, Eibert J. C. Review of Gleanings from the Caves: Dead Sea Scrolls and Artefacts from The Schøyen Collection, edited by Torleif Elgvin, Kipp Davis, and Michael Langlois. RevQ 29 (2017): 314–322.
-
Tov, Emanuel. “New Fragments of Amos.” DSD 21 (2014): 3–13.
-
Tov, Emanuel, Kipp Davis, and Robert Duke, ed. Dead Sea Scrolls Fragments in the Museum Collection. PMB 1. Leiden: Brill, 2016.
-
Tuross, Noreen. “Accelerated Mass Spectrometry Radiocarbon Determination of Papyrus Samples.” HTR 107 (2014): 170–171.
-
Vaux, Roland de. “Archéologie.” Pages 3–36 in Les ‘petites grottes’ de Qumran: exploration de la falaise, les grottes 2Q, 3Q, 5Q, 6Q, 7Q à 10Q, le rouleau de cuivre. DJD 3. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1962.
-
Vaux, Roland de. Archaeology and the Dead Sea Scrolls. Rev. ed. London: Oxford University Press for the British Academy, 1973.
-
Vrdoljak, Ana Filipa. International Law, Museums and the Return of Cultural Objects. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2006.
-
Walker Tubb, Kathryn. “Irreconcilable Differences? Problems with Unprovenanced Antiquities.” PIA 18 (2007): 3–11.
-
Watt, James C. Y. “Antiquities and the Importance—and Limitations—of Archaeological Contexts.” Pages 89–106 in Whose Culture? The Promise of Museums and the Debate over Antiquities. Edited by James B. Cuno. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2012.
-
Wylie, Alison. “Archaeology and the Antiquities Market: The Use of ‘Looted’ Data.” Pages 17–21 in Ethics in American Archaeology: Challenges for the 1990s. Edited by Mark J. Lynott and Alison Wylie. Washington, DC: Society for American Archaeology, 1995.
-
Yadin, Yigael. The Finds from the Bar Kokhba Period in the Cave of Letters. JDS. Jerusalem: Israel Exploration Society, 1963.
-
Yardeni, Ada. “Appendix: Documentary Texts Alleged to Be from Qumran Cave 4.” Pages 283–317 in Aramaic, Hebrew and Greek Documentary Texts from Naḥal Ḥever and Other Sites, with an Appendix containing Alleged Qumran Texts (The Seiyâl Collection II). DJD 27. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1997.
-
Yardley, James T. and Alexis Hagadorn. “Characterization of the Chemical Nature of the Black Ink in the Manuscript of the Gospel of Jesus’s Wife through Micro-Raman Spectroscopy.” HTR 107 (2014): 162–164.
-
Zahn, Molly. Review of Gleanings from the Caves: Dead Sea Scrolls and Artefacts from The Schøyen Collection, edited by Torleif Elgvin, Kipp Davis, and Michael Langlois. DSD 24 (2017): 307–309.
| All Time | Past 365 days | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 2340 | 211 | 37 |
| Full Text Views | 391 | 14 | 5 |
| PDF Views & Downloads | 559 | 34 | 16 |
Provenance vs. Authenticity: An Archaeological Perspective on the Post-2002 “Dead Sea Scrolls-Like” Fragments
In: Dead Sea DiscoveriesSearch for other papers by Dennis Mizzi in
Current site
Google Scholar
PubMed
Search for other papers by Jodi Magness in
Current site
Google Scholar
PubMed
Abstract
This article adds an archaeological voice to the current debate surrounding the authenticity of recently acquired “Dead Sea Scrolls-like” fragments. In our opinion, since these fragments are above all archaeological artifacts, considerations of provenance should take priority over authenticity. We begin with a survey that contextualizes this debate in relation to other types of archaeological artifacts, and consider the importance of context as well as ethical, legal, moral, and economic issues relating to the acquisition and publication of unprovenanced artifacts. We conclude that any artifact that lacks verifiable documentation of its provenance—whether or not it is authentic—should not be studied or published by scholars. Finally, we urge professional organizations and publishers to establish or strengthen policies preventing the publication of such artifacts, even after primary publication or presentation elsewhere.
| All Time | Past 365 days | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 2340 | 211 | 37 |
| Full Text Views | 391 | 14 | 5 |
| PDF Views & Downloads | 559 | 34 | 16 |