Criminalising Defamation of Religion and Belief

in European Journal of Crime, Criminal Law and Criminal Justice
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

This article deals with the role of criminal law in dealing with defamatory expressions about religion or belief. Defamation of religion and belief is a form of indirect defamation ‘via identification’ which, as the discussion about the Dutch group defamation law shows, stretches up the notion of ‘group defamation’ — a crime which requires that (groups of) persons are insulted because they belong to a religious group. This contribution investigates whether European states can legitimately criminalise (certain forms of) defamation of religion and belief, in light of the European Convention on Human Rights, the United Nations framework (particularly the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights) and legal theoretical considerations. The article shows how problematic it is for the criminal law — in light of the rights to freedom of expression and freedom of religion, as well as the ultima ratio principle — to combat such speech.

Sections

References

1

Venice Commission, Blasphemy, Insult and Hatred: Finding Answers in a Democratic Society (Strasbourg: Council of Europe Publishing, 2008) Appendix I.

4

 E.g., W. Sadurski, Freedom of speech and its limits (Dordrecht: Kluwer, 1999); F. Schauer, Free speech: A Philosophical Enquiry (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, !982); I. Hare and J. Weinstein, eds., Extreme Speech and Democracy (New York, ny: Oxford University Press, 2009); E. Heinze, ‘Viewpoint absolutism and hate speech’, 69 Modern Law Review (2006) pp. 543–582; Th. Rosier, Vrijheid van meningsuiting en discriminatie in Nederland en Amerika (Nijmegen: Ars Aequi Libri, 1997); B.A.M. van Stokkom, H.J.B. Sackers and J.-P. Wils, Godslastering, discriminerende uitingen wegens godsdienst en haatuitingen (Den Haag: wodc, 2006).

5

J. Vrielink, Van haat gesproken? Een rechtantropologisch onderzoek naar de bestrijding van rasgerelateerde uitingsdelicten in België (Antwerpen/Apeldoorn: Maklu, 2010).

8

Feinberg (1984–88a), pp. 47–48.

9

Feinberg (1984–88a), p. 191.

10

C. McKinnon, Toleration: A Critical Introduction (London: Routledge, 2006) p. 132.

13

Sadurski (1999), pp. 196–197.

15

D.L. Pals, Seven theories of religion (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1996) p. 271.

17

Pals (1996), p. 169, referring to M. Eliade, Patterns in comparative religion (New York, ny: Meridian Books, 1949, translation by R. Sheed, 1963)

18

Pals (1996), p. 177, referring to Eliade (1949).

19

Van Kempen (2012), p. 38; see ECtHR Leela Förderkreis E.V. v. Germany, 6 November 2008, appl. no. 58911/00.

20

 See Van Stokkom et al. (2006), p. 64.

23

 See Supreme Court 18 May 1999, nj 1999, 634 m.nt. A.C. ʼt Hart (Janmaat).

24

Supreme Court 10 March 2009, ecli:nl:hr:2009:bf0655, nj 2010, 19 (annotation by P.A.M. Mevis).

29

Utrecht District Court, 26 April 2010, ecli:nl:rbutr:2010:bm8138; Annotation Mevis for Supreme Court 10 March 2009, nj 2010, 19, nr. 9; A.J. Nieuwenhuis & E.H. Janssen, ‘De onduidelijke verhouding tussen vrijheid van meningsuiting en discriminatie. Een analyse van de groepsbelediging en het haatzaaien’, 23(4) Mediaforum (2011) pp. 94–104.

32

A.J. Nieuwenhuis, Over de grens van de vrijheid van meningsuiting (Nijmegen: Ars Aequi Libri, 2006) p. 292.

45

T. McGonagle (2010), ‘An ode to contextualization: I.A. v. Turkey’, Irish Human Rights Law Review, no. 1, p. 251 ; Th. Rosier, (2000), ‘Tolerantie en religie. Over de zaak Van Dijke en de visie van het evrm inzake godslastering’, rm Themis, no. 1, p. 3–14.

65

Nowak (2005) p. 468.

72

Parmar (2009) p. 373.

Information

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 8 8 5
Full Text Views 6 6 5
PDF Downloads 1 1 1
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0