The Politics of Regionalist Science: The Balkans as a Supranational Space in Late Nineteenth to Mid-Twentieth Century Academic Projects

in East Central Europe
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?


The article looks into the various scholarly (and disciplinary) conceptualizations of the Balkans/Southeastern Europe, which were spawned within the region itself prior to World War II. These regionalist schemes drew heavily on political values and relied on political support, while at the same time seeking to spearhead and legitimize political decisions or reformulate (geo)political visions. The article discusses the political implications of this scholarship with the idea to underscore notions of the Balkans which differed considerably from the one summarily and, in recent years, persistently conceptualized as mirroring the Western (discourse of) Balkanism. Not only were those notions more subtle and differentiated than an ‘orientalizing perspective’ would make us expect; a remarkable feature of the academic projects discussed here was their counterhegemonic thrust and the assertion that the Balkans are and should be treated as a subject.

The Politics of Regionalist Science: The Balkans as a Supranational Space in Late Nineteenth to Mid-Twentieth Century Academic Projects

in East Central Europe



“Balkanologie.” Wikipedia Die freie Enzyklopädie. Accessed on 20 December 2010.

BlochMarc. 1928. “Pour une histoire comparée des sociétés européennes.” Revue de synthèse historique 46: 1550.

—. 1964. The Historians’ Craft. New York: Vintage.

BogdanIoan. 1905. Istoriografia romană și problemele ei actuale [Romanian historiography and its current problems]. Bucharest: n.p.

BraudelFernand. 1995. The Mediterranean and the Mediterranean World in the Age of Philip II. Berkeley: University of California Press.

BudimirMilan and SkokPetar. 1934. “But et signification des études balkaniques.” Revue internationale des études balkaniques 1: 128.

——. 1936. “Destineés balkaniques.” Revue internationale des études balkaniques 2 no. 4: 601613.

ĆorovićVladimir. 1937. Borba za nezavisnost Balkana [Struggle for the independence of the Balkans]. Belgrade: Izd. Balkanskog in-ta.

CvijićJovan. 1906. Remarks on the Ethnography of Macedonian Slavs. London: n.p.

——. 1909. The Annexation of Bosnia and Herzegovina and the Serb Question. London: H. Cox.

——. 1914. Unity and the Psychic Types of the Dinaric South Slavs. London: n.p.

——. 1915. Jedinstvo Jugoslovena [The unity of Yugoslavia]. Niš: n.p.

——. 1918a. La péninsule balkanique: géographie humaine. Paris: Libraire Armand Colin.

——. 1918b. Unité ethnique et nationale des Yugoslaves. Bologna: n.p.

——. 1918c. “The Zones of Civilization of the Balkan Peninsula.” Geographical Review 5 no. 6: 470482.

——. 1922. Балканско полуострво и южнословенске земље. Основи антропогеографии [The Balkan Peninsula and the South-Slav lands. Basics of anthropogeography]. Vol. 1. Belgrade: Državna štamparija.

——. 1926. “Osnovi jugoslovenske civilizacije” [The basis of Yugoslav civilization]. Nova Evropa 6 no. 7.

——. 1930. “Studies in Yugoslav Psychology.” The Slavonic and East European Review 9 no. 26: 375390.

——. 1931. Балканско полуострво и южнословенске земље. Основи антропогеографии [The Balkan Peninsula and the South-Slav lands. Basics of anthropogeography]. Vol. 2. Belgrade: Državna štamparija.

DimitrovaSnezhana. 1994. “Йован Цвиич за периферията и центъра” [Jovan Cvijić on the periphery and the center]. Балканистичен форум 3 no. 1: 516.

Drace-FrancisAlex. 2003. “Zür Geschichte des Südosteuropakonzept bis 1914.” In Wieser Enzyklopädie des europäischen Ostens 11: Europa und die Grenzen im Kopf edited by KaserKarlGramshammer-HohlDagmar and PichlerRobert275286. Klagenfurt: Wieser Verlag.

FreemanT. W. 1967. The Geographer’s Craft. New York: Barnes & Noble.

FriedmanVictor A. 1994–1995. “The Place of Balkan Linguistics in Understanding Balkan History and Balkan Modernity.” Bulletin de l’Association des études du sud-est européen 24–25: 8794.

——. 2006. “Balkans as a Linguistic Area.” In vol. 1 of Encyclopedia of Language & Linguistics edited by BrownKeith657672. 2nd edition. Oxford: Elsevier.

——. 2007. “Balkanizing the Balkan Sprachbund. A Closer Look at Grammatical Permeability and Feature Distribution.” In Grammars in Contact: A Cross Linguistic Typology edited by AikhenvaldAlexandra J. and DixonR. M.W.201219. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

GesemannGerhard. 1943. Heroische Lebensform: Zur Literatur und Wesenskunde der balkanischen Patriarchalität. Berlin: Wiking-Verlag.

Geyer Michael. “Transnationale Geschichte”: The New Consensus Review Symposium “Transnational History.” H-Soz-u-Kult. Accessed on 19 December 2010.

HillAlette Olin and HillBoyd H.. 1980. “AHR Forum: Marc Bloch and Comparative History.” American Historical Review 85 no. 4: 828846.

IorgaNicolae. 1913. Istoria statelor balcanice în epoca modernă [History of the Balkan states in the modern era]. Vol. 3. Vălenii-de-Munte: Neamul Românesc.

——. 1914. “Inauguration de l’Institut. Discours du professeur N. Iorga (24 janvier n. st.).” Bulletin de l’Institut pour l’études de l’Europe sud-orientale (Bucharest) 1.

——. 1929a. Études byzantines. Vol. 2. Paris: Librairie universitaire J. Gamber.

——. 1929b. Le caractère commun des institutions du Sud-Est de l’Europe. Paris: Librairie universitaire J. Gamber.

——. 1935. “Eléments de communauté entre les peuples du Sud-Est Européen.” Revue Historique du Sud-est européen 12 nos. 46.

——. 1940. Ce este Sud-Estul european [What is the European South-East]. Bucharest: Datina Românească.

——. 1972. O viață de om așa cum a fost [A lifetime as it was]. Bucharest: Editura Minerva.

——. 1999. Generalităţi cu privire la studiile istorice [General issues of historical studies]. 4th edition. Iaşi: Polirom.

——. 2000. Byzantium after Byzantium. Translated by Laura Treptow. Iaşi Oxford, Portland: The Centre for Romanian Studies. Originally published in 1935.

——. 2008. Caracterul comun al instituțiilor din sud-estul Europei. Bucharest: Editura Valahia. Romanian edition of the volume Le caractère commun des institutions du Sud-Est de l’Europe.

IshirkovAtanas. 1897. “Антропогеографски бележки върху Балканския полуостров” [Anthropogeographical notes on the Balkan peninsula]. Български преглед 9: 2335.

KaserKarl. 2004. “Peoples of the Mountains, Peoples of the Plains: Space and Ethnographic Representation.” In Creating the Other: Ethnic Conflict and Nationalism in Habsburg Central Europe edited by WingfieldNancy M.216230. New York: Berghahn Books.

KopitarJernej K. 1829. “Albanische, walachische und bulgarische Sprache.” Jahrbücher der Literatur (Vienna) 46: 59106.

LeskienAugust. 1925. Balkanmärchen aus Albanien Bulgarien Serbien und Kroatien. Jena: E. Diederichs.

MeilletAntoine. 1925. La méthode comparative en linguistique historique. Paris: Champion.

MiklosichFranz. 1861. “Die slavischen Elemente im Rumunischen.” Denkschriften der Kaiserlichen Akademie der Wissenschaften Philosophisch-historische Klasse 12: 170.

NewbeginM. I.1919. “The Human Geography of the Balkans.” The Geographical Journal 53 no. 2.

OsterhammelJürgen. 2001. Geschichtswissenschaft jenseits des Nationalstaats. Studien zur Beziehungsgeschichte und Zivilisationsvergleich. Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht.

PapacosteaVictor. 1938. “Avant-Propos.” Balcania 1: iiivii.

——. 1943. “La Péninsule Balkanique et le problème des études comparées.” Balcania 6: iiixxi.

——. 1996. “Balcanologia.” Sud-Estul și Contextul European 6: 6978.

PippidiAndrei. 1991. “Reformă sau declin. A doua periodă a studiilor sud-est europene în România” [Reform or decline. The second period of Southeast European studies in Romania]. Revista istorică 2 nos. 11–12: 641649.

RarežaninRatko. 1936. “Der neue Balkan.” Revue internationale des études balkaniques 2 no. 4: 321332.

RatzelFriedrich. 1897. “Studies in Political Areas: The Political Territory in Relation to Earth and Continent.” The American Journal of Sociology 3 no. 3: 297313.

——. 1898. “Studies in Political Areas. II. Intellectual, Political and Economic Effects of Large Areas.” The American Journal of Sociology 3 no. 4: 449463.

RossetiAlexandru. 1986. Istoria limbii române de la origini pânã în secolul al XVII-lea [The history of the Romanian language from its origins into the 17th Century]. 2nd edition. Bucharest: Editura pentru literaturã.

RoucekJoseph S.1939. The Politics of the Balkans. New York: McGraw-Hill.

SandfeldKristian. 1930. Lingustique balkanique. Problèmes et résultats. Paris: Klincksieck. Originally published 1926. Copenhagen: Balkanfilologien.

SériotPatrick. 1999. Structure et totalité. Les origines intellectuelles du structuralisme en Europe centrale et orientale. Paris: Presses universitaires de France.

ShishmanovIvan D. 1894–1895. “Рецензии и книгопис” [Reviews and bibliography]. Български преглед 2.

——. 1965. Izbrani suchinenia [Selected works]. Vol. 1. Sofia: Izdatelstvo na BAN.

——. 1966. Izbrani suchinenia [Selected works]. Vol. 2. Sofia: Izdatelstvo na BAN.

——. 1973. Българо-румънски научни и културни връзки 1869-1944. Документи [Bulgarian-Romanian scholarly and cultural connections 1869-1944. Documents]. Compiled by T. Ganev. Sofia: Izdatelstvo na BAN.

StadtmüllerGeorg. 1950. Geschichte Südosteuropas. Munich: Oldenbourg.

TemperleyH. W. V. ed. 1921. A History of the Peace Conference of Paris. Vol. 4. London: Henry Frowde and Hodder & Stoughton.

TihanovGalin. 2013. “Do ‘Minor Literatures’ Still Exist? The Fortunes of a Concept in the Changing Frameworks of Literary History.” In The National-Philological Concept of Literature and the Hyphenated European Identities edited by VLadimir Biti. Amsterdam and Atlanta: Rodopi. Forthcoming.

TodorovaMaria. 1997. Imagining the Balkans. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

TrgovčevićLjubinka. 1986. Naučnici Srbije i stvaranje jugoslovenske države 1914-1920 [Serbian scholars and the creation of the Yugoslav state]. Belgrade: Srpska književna zadruga-Narodna knjiga.

TrubetzkoyN. S. 1923. “Vavilonskaja bašnja i smešenie jazykov” [The Tower of Babel and the mixture of languages]. Evrazijskij vremennik 3: 107124.

——. 1933. Psychologie du langage. Paris: Librairie Félix Alcan.

ValjavecFritz. 1941. “Der Werdegang der deutschen Südostforschung und ihr gegenwartiger Stand und Methodik.” Südost-Forschungen 6.

——. 1942. “Südosteuropa und Balkan.” Südost-Forschungen 7.

WeigandGustav. 1925. “Vorwort, zugleich Programm des Balkan-Archivs.” Balkan-Archiv 1: vxv.

“Zeitschrift für Balkanologie.” Friedrich-Schiller-Universität Jena Institut für Slawistik. Accessed on 20 December 2010.

ŽivkovićMarko. 1997. “Violent Highlanders and Peaceful Lowlanders. Uses and Abuses of Ethno-Geography in the Balkans from Versailles to Dayton.” Replika (Special issue: Ambiguous Identities in the New Europe).

ZubAlexandru. 1995. “En quête d’une synthèse: l’historiographie roumaine au xixe siècle.” Nouvelle études d’histoires 9.


Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 7 7 5
Full Text Views 18 18 6
PDF Downloads 5 5 3
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0