A Comparative Analysis of Dam Safety Assurance Laws

What are ‘Appropriate’ Legislative Arrangements for Jurisdictions with Hazardous Private Dams?

in European Journal of Comparative Law and Governance
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

A number of horrific failures of both public and privately owned dams in recent decades has triggered serious concern over the safety of dams throughout the world. However, in Australia, although much Government attention is being devoted to the medium- to large-scale dams, minimal attention is being paid to the serious potential cumulative, catchment-wide problems associated with smaller private dams. The paper determines how to consider addressing hazardous private dam safety issues generally through a comparative analysis of international dam safety policy/law systems. The analysis has identified elements of best and minimum practice that can and do exist successfully to provide deserved assurance to the community of the proper safety management of hazardous private dams at both the individual and cumulative, catchment-wide levels. These elements provide benchmarks that enable ‘appropriate’ legislative arrangements to be determined for different jurisdictional circumstances as illustrated with an Australian policy-deficient case study.

A Comparative Analysis of Dam Safety Assurance Laws

What are ‘Appropriate’ Legislative Arrangements for Jurisdictions with Hazardous Private Dams?

in European Journal of Comparative Law and Governance

Sections

References

1

Smith N. (1972) A History of Dams Citadel Press Secaucus.

2

Lewis B. and Harrison J. (2002) ‘Risk and Consequences of Farm Dam Failure’ 27thHydrology and Water Resources Symposium IEAust Melbourne Aust. May 2002.

3

Ingles O. G. (1984) ‘A Short Study of Dam Failures in Australia 1857–1983’ Civil Engineering Systems Journal UK Vol. 1 June 1984 pp. 190–194.

5

Fu S. and Qing D. (1998) A profile of dams in China In The River Dragon Has Come! The Three Gorges Dam and the Fate of China’s Yangtze River and its People Thibodeau J. G. and Williams P. B. (eds) Probe International and International Rivers Network Chapter 2.

6

Hiser W. & McDonald L. (1989) ‘Dam Safety’ Water Supply and Resources Conference Proceedings Sydney nsw Nov. 1988 pp. 163–171.

7

Engels J. (2005) Stava tailings dam failure near Trento Italy www.tailings.info/stava.htm accessed 3 June 2005.

8

Graham W. J. (1999) A Procedure for Estimating Loss of Life Caused by Dam Failure United States Dept of Interior Bureau of Reclamation Dam Safety Office Report dso-99-06 Denver Colorado.

9

Novinite (2012). Broken dam flooding kills 9 in Southeast Bulgaria. Sofia News Agency 6th February 2012. http://www.novinite.com/view news.php?id=136414 (accessed 08.02.12). Novinite (2012). Bulgaria has 600 unsafe dams – Economy Minister. Sofia News Agency 11th February 2012. http://www.novinite.com/ view news.php?id=136567 (accessed 12.02.12).

13

McKay J.M. and Pisaniello J.D. (1995) What must the reasonable private dam owner foresee? The Australian Journal of Disaster Management - The Macedon Digest Emergency Management Australia Vol 9 No. 4 pp. 27–28; Wensley R. (1994) ‘Legal Constraints in the Use of Risk Assessment’ Proc. Seminar by ancold and The Munro Centre for Civil and Environmental Engineering Acceptable Risks for Extreme Events in the Planning and Design of Major Infrastructure Sydney Aust. 26–27 April 1994.

18

Daniell T. and Hill P. (1993) ‘Flood Hydrology Study of the Onkaparinga River’ Technical Report produced in The University of Adelaide through Luminus Pty. Ltd. for The Onkaparinga Flood Study Steering Committee Adelaide.

21

Baillie C. (2008) ‘Assessment of Evaporation Losses and Evaporation Mitigation Technologies for On Farm Water Storages across Australia’ Irrigation Matters Series No. 05/08 Cooperative Research Centre for Irrigation Futures Canberra. This reference shows that the majority of private/farm dams are located in nsw and Victoria (the highest people-populated states) with each having over 300000 such dams. The remaining states including Tasmania Queensland sa and wa are not as populated and so each contain such dams only in the thousands or tens of thousands.

24

Murley K. (1987) ‘Referable Dams in Victoria – Spillway Inadequacy’ ancold Bulletin No. 76 April 1987 pp. 24–26.

25

Lake P.S. & Bond N.R. (2006) ‘Australian Futures: Freshwater ecosystems and human water usage’ Futures 39 (2007) pp. 288–305.

27

Pisaniello J.D. (1997). Analysis and Modelling of Private Dam Safety Assurance Policy and Flood Capability Design/Review Procedures PhD Thesis University of South Australia.

31

Webster K.C. and Wark R.J. (1987) ‘Australian Dam Safety Legislation’ ancold Bulletin No.78 Dec. 1987 pp. 63–78; Pisaniello (n 27); Pisaniello and McKay (n 30).

36

un ipcc (2007) Summary for policy makers. In: Climate Change 2007:The Physical Science Basis Contribution of Working Group 1 to the Fourth Assessment Report of the United Nations Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. [Solomon S. D. Qin M. Manning Z. Chen M. Marquis K. B. Averyt M. Tignor and H. L. Miller (eds)]. Cambridge University Press Cambridge United Kingdom and New York ny usa.

40

Pisaniello and McKay (2005) The need for private dam safety assurance policy – demonstrative case studies 10 years later The Australian Journal of Emergency Management 20(3) 15–21.

43

Sheuard N. (1993) ‘Dam Safety Requirements’ Proceedings of the Seminar on Farm Dams hosted by Hydrological Society of South Australia Hahndorf April 7 1993 pp. 43–46.

45

Harrison J.F. (1992) Central Hills Region Councils - Study of Flooding on 30th August 1992 and 8th October 1992 District Council of Stirling sa October 1992 pp. 1–15.

50

Pisaniello J.D. and McKay J.M. (1998) ‘The Need for Private Dam Safety Assurance Policy - A Demonstrative Case Study’ The Australian Journal of Emergency Management Emergency Management Australia Vol 13 No. 3 pp. 46–49.

55

McMurray D. (2004) Farm Dam Volume Estimations from Simple Geometric Relationships Dept of Water Land and Biodiversity Conservation Govt of South Australia Report No dwlbc 2004/48; denr (1996) ‘Farm Dam Storage Assessment in the Mount Lofty Ranges’ Report for Mt. Lofty Ranges Catchment Centre by Department of Environment and Natural Resources sa August 1996; sa Parliament Hansard (1985) Parliamentary Debates - Dam Safety Bill 45th Parliament Third Session House of Assembly May 78 and 9 1985 Adelaide pp. 3934–3992.

72

dpiw (2008) ‘Dam Construction Permits’ Website of the Dept of Primary Industries and Water Tasmania www.dpiw.tas.gov.au/inter.nsf/WebPages/RPIO-4YG57U?open accessed 31 July 2008.

93

 For example: dpiw (2007) Dam Works Code 2007 Dept of Primary Industries and Water Tasmania August 2007; dpiw (n 72); dpiwe (n 82).

97

Ditchfield S. (2009) Personal Communication Dams Safety Engineer Dept of Primary Industries and Water Tasmania November 2013.

102

US Federal Government (1972) Public Law 92–367 - National Dam Inspection Program U.S Congress August 8 1972; US Dept. of Interior (1980) Safety Evaluation of Existing Dams A Water Resources Technical Publication Denver Colorado 1980.

110

Smith G.F. (2003) ‘The status of dam safety legislation in Canada’ Canadian Dam Association Bulletin Spring 2003.

113

Alberta Dept. of Environment (1991) Dam and Canal Safety Guidelines Publication D.S. 3 Revision 2 Canada.

116

Moffat A.I.B. (1976) ‘British Reservoir Legislation and the Reservoirs Act 1975’ Engineering Foundation Conference Proceedings on The Evaluation of Dam Safety Pacific Grove California 28 Nov-3 Dec 1976 pp. 39–56.

119

Charnock A. (1983) ‘Dam Data Fuels Fears on Safety’ New Civil Engineer London Feb. 3 pp. 18–19.

125

Institution of Civil Engineers (2003) ‘Flooding and Emergency Planning’ ice Seminar March 25 London www.floodrisknet.org.uk/events/Event.2003-03-10.5112/view accessed 28 March 2005; see also Hope (n 120).

128

Nortje J.H. (1997) Fact Sheet Director General Dam Safety Office Dept. of Water Affairs and Forestry South Africa May 1997.

135

Up to 1995and afterwards the specific dam safety Act was simply implanted into another “water” Act.

143

Sand P. H. (2002) ‘The Right to Know: Environmental Information Disclosure by Government and Industry’ Conf Proc “Human Dimensions of Global Environmental Change: Knowledge for the Sustainability Transition” Berlin 7 Dec 2002. This paper refers to the US Federal Emergency Planning and Community Right to Know Act 1986 which establishes a Toxics Release Inventory in addition to at least 25 US States’ ‘right to know’ laws- the US experience is what prompted Australia to also establish the Pollutant Release and Transfer Register in the late 1990s.

Information

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 27 27 6
Full Text Views 95 95 60
PDF Downloads 3 3 1
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0