Is the Nordic model of combating the trafficking of women for sexual purposes to be followed by all member states of the eu? At the moment, the member states still differ considerably in their legislative approaches towards prostitution and the extent to which this is linked to the combat against sex trafficking. In this article the differences between the Nordic and the legalisation model as well as their effects on forced prostitution, human trafficking and women’s right to self-determination will be a central focus. The authors will discuss and compare the approaches and effects as found in Sweden and the Netherlands. By this comparison they will establish whether the Nordic model indeed should be endorsed.
J. Goodey‘Human trafficking: Sketchy data and policy responses’Criminology and Criminal Justice8 (2008) 421–442; R. Weitzer ‘Sex Trafficking and the Sex Industry: The need for Evidence-Based Theory and Legislation’ Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology 101(4) (2011) 1337–1369; J.A. Chuang ‘Rescuing Trafficking from Ideological Capture: Prostitution reform and Anti-Trafficking Law and Policy’ University of Pennsylvania Law Review 158 (2010) 1655–1728.
M. Farley‘Prostitution Harms Women Even if Indoors: Reply to Weitzer’Violence Against Women11(7) (2005) 950–964; D.M. Hughes ‘Accommodation or Abolition?’ National Law Review Online (2003); M.M. Dempsey ‘Sex Trafficking and Criminalization: In Defense of Feminist Abolitionism’ University of Pennsylvania Law Review 158 (2010) 1729–1778.
L.M. AugustinSex at the Margins: Migration Labour Markets and the Rescue Industry (London and New York: Zed Books Ltd2007); C.M. Jacobsen and M. Skilbrei ‘Reproachable Victims? Representation and Self- Representation of Russian Women Involved in Transnational Prostitution’ Ethnos: Journal of Anthropology 75(2) (2010) 190–212.
Daalder‘Prostitutie in Nederland anno 2014’ (n 52); Weitzer ‘Sex Trafficking and the Sex Industry: The need for Evidence-Based Theory and Legislation’ (n 6); J. Pitcher and M. Wijers, ‘The impact of different regulatory models on the labour conditions, safety and welfare of indoor-based sex workers’Criminology and Criminal Justice14 (2014) 549–564.
J. Outshoorn‘Policy change in prostitution in the Netherlands. From legalization to strict control’Sexuality Research and Social Policy9 (2012) 233–243; Pitcher and Wijers ‘The impact of different regulatory models on the labour conditions safety and welfare of indoor-based sex workers’ (n 66); H. Dekker R. Tap and G. Homburg Evaluation of lifting the ban on brothels; the social position of prostitutes in 2006 (Amsterdam: Regioplan beleidsonderzoek wodc 2007) found that a third of the prostitutes participating in their research preferred to be independent and self-employed because of the greater control over working situation anonymity finances and no red tape.