The Mélange of Innovation and Tradition in Maltese Law: The Essence of the Maltese Mix?

in European Journal of Comparative Law and Governance
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.

Help

 

Have Institutional Access?

Login with your institution. Any other coaching guidance?

Connect

The aim of this paper is to provide valuable insights into the Maltese legal system with a special focus on private law. The assumption is that this legal system is the by-product of the “mixing” of innovation and tradition, resulting from the interaction of English law and continental law. A major role in the development of the system is played by courts. Some examples (moral damages and pre-contractual liability) are considered which highlight the importance of the function displayed by Maltese judges.

Sections
References
  • BisazzaV.J. (1971). Precontractual Responsibility LLD Thesis University of Malta.

  • BonavitaI.Saggio Sulla Prova Giudiziaria Considerata in Rapporto All’attuale Legislazione Maltese (Malta1849).

  • CiliaF.Quantifying damages for lucrum cessans in tort; a fusion of sources creating a unique legal structure for MaltaJCLS (2011): 331353.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • CostantiniC.The keepers of traditions. The English common lawyers and the presence of lawComparative Law Review (2010): 112.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • CremonaF.Storia della Legislazione Maltese (Malta1936).

  • CremonaJ.J.The jury system in MaltaAJCL (1964): 570583.

  • De BonoP.Sommario di Storia della Legislazione Maltese (Malta1897).

  • Dingli A. Appunti (University of Malta Library).

  • FrankenbergG.Constructing legal traditions: Introductory remarks on the public/private distinction as traditionComparative Law Review (2011): 112.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • GanadoA.The historical development of the criminal codeLaw Journal (1949): 211231.

  • GanadoJ.M.British public law and the civil law in MaltaCurrent Legal Problems (1950): 195213.

  • GanadoJ.M.Malta: A microcosm of international influences’. In Studies in Legal Systems: Mixed and Mixing. eds. ÖrücüE.AttwoolE. & CoyleS. (The Hague: Kluwer1996) 225247.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • GanadoM.An Introduction to Maltese Financial Services (Valletta: Allied Publications2009).

  • GlennH.P.Tradizioni Giuridiche Nel Mondo. La Sostenibilità della Differenza (translated from the original English by S Ferlito) (Il Mulino Bologna 2011).

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • GorlaG.I Precedenti Storici Dell’art.12 disp.prel.cod.civ’. In Diritto Comparato e Diritto Comune Europeo (Giuffré Milano1981) 443474.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • GourlayD.Andrew Jameson and the origins of the criminal code of MaltaMelita Historica (2009): 109134.

  • GuliaW.P.Governmental Liability in Malta (Tal-Qroqq Malta University Press1974).

  • HardingH.W.History of Roman Law in Malta (Malta: Progress Press1950).

  • HardingH.W.Maltese Legal History Under British Rule (1801–1836) (Malta: Progress Press1968).

  • HardmanW.A History of Malta During the Period of the French and British Occupations 1798–1815 (London: Longmans, Green and Co1909).

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • HobsbawmE.J. & RangerT. eds. L’invenzione della Tradizione (translated from the original English by E. Basaglia) (Einaudi Torino2002).

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • MalliaT.Pre-contractual liability in MaltaLaw & Practice (2005): 2527.

  • MarkesinisB. & FedtkeJ.Giudici e Diritto Straniero. La Pratica del Diritto Comparato (translated from the original English by A Taruffo) (Il Mulino Bologna 2009).

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • MariniG.Foreword - Legal traditions: A critical appraisalComparative Law Review (2011): 15.

  • MatteiU.RuskolaT. & GidiA.Schlesinger’s Comparative Law 7th ed (New York: Foundation Press2009).

  • MichallefG.A.Riflessioni Storico-critiche Sull’isola di Malta Durante il Governo Gerosolimitano e il Presente Governo Britannico (Malta: Francesco Naudi ed.1839).

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Micallef-GrimaudC.Moral damages outside the ambit of the Maltese civil codeId-dritt Law Journal (2011): 109139.

  • Micallef-GrimaudC.Art 1045 of the Maltese civil code: Is compensation for moral damages compatible therewithJCLS (2011): 481513.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • MifsudA.Origine della Sovranità Inglese su Malta (Malta: Tipografia del Malta1907).

  • MonateriP.G.The ‘weak law’: Contaminations and legal cultures (borrowing of legal and political forms)Transnat’l L & Contemp Probs (2003): 575593.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • MuscatA.Principles of Maltese Company Law (Malta: Malta Univeristy Press2007).

  • ÖrücüE.An exercise on the internal logic of legal systemsLegal Studies (1987): 310318.

  • ÖrücüE.Law as transpositionInt Comp L Quart (2002): 205223.

  • ÖrücüE.Family trees for legal systems: Towards a contemporary approach’. In Epistemology and Methodology of Comparative Law. ed. Van HoeckeM. (Oxford: Hart2004) 359375.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • PalmerV.V.The many guises of equity in a mixed jurisdiction: A functional view of equity in LouisianaTulane Law Review (1994): 770.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • PalmerV.V.Mixed Jurisdictions Worldwide: The Third Legal Family (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press2001).

  • ReidK.C.The idea of mixed legal systemsTulane Law Review (2003–2004): 5-?.

  • RoulandN.Antropologia Giuridica (translated from the original French by R Aluffi Beck-Peccoz) (Giuffré Milano1992).

  • SaccoR.Legal formants: A dynamic approach to comparative lawAJCL (1991): 134.

  • SammutM.A.The place of the Codice Municipale di Malta in European legal historyId-Dritt Law Journal (2009): 330354.

  • SciclunaJ. (2003). Pre-Contractual Liability: Comparative Perspectives LLD Thesis University of Malta.

  • TarelloG.Storia della Cultura Giuridica Moderna. Assolutismo e Codificazione del Diritto (Il Mulino Bologna1976).

  • VassalloS. (2010). The Principle of Good Faith in the Negotiation and Performance of Contracts: A Comparative Perspective LLD Thesis University of Malta.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • XuerebG.A comparative study of the theory of precontractual responsibilityId-Dritt Law Journal (1978): 8089.

  • Promises of Marriage Law Act (1834)

  • British Settlements Act (1887)

  • Foreign Jurisdiction Act (1890)

  • Attard v Xuereb (First Hall Civil Court 13 October 2003)

  • Baldacchino v Chairman of Enemalta (First Hall Civil Court 11 October 2006)

  • Bezzina Noe v Direttur tal-Kuntratti (First Hall Civil Court 12 October 2006)

  • Busuttil v La Primadauye (Prim’Aula 15 February 1894)

  • Busuttil Pro et Noe et v Salvatore Muscat Noe et (First Hall Civil Court 28 October 1998)

  • Butler v Heard (Court of Appeal 22 December 1967)

  • Cassar v Campbell Preston Noe et (Commercial Court 19 November 1971)

  • Cassar Desain v Forbes (Court of Appeal 7 January 1935)

  • Debattista v JK Properties Ltd (Court of Appeal 7 December 2005)

  • Sammut v Strickland 1938 3 All ER 693

  • Scicluna Enterprises (Gozo) Ltd v Enemalta Corporation (Court of Appeal 25 May 2007)

  • MariniG.La Costruzione delle Tradizioni Giuridiche Nell’epoca della Globalizzazione (2010) www.comparazioneedirittocivile.it [date of use 12 Dec 2011].

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • PalmerV.V.Two rival theories of mixed legal systemsEJCL (2007) www.ejcl.org/121/art121-16.pdf [date of use 12 Dec 2011].

  • 7)

    In a case of 1875the Maltese Court of Appeal held that the Codice de Rohan was still observed by the Courts of Justice of these Islands and was never abrogated expressly or impliedly (“è conservato in osservanza nelle corti di Giustizia di queste isole e non fu abrogato né espressamente né implicitamente”).On the Code de Rohan see Sammut 2009Id-Dritt Law Journal 330.

Index Card
Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 54 54 0
Full Text Views 174 174 0
PDF Downloads 7 7 0
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0