From Madrasa to College: The Islamic Influence in the Birth of the Christian Foundation
In: Endowment StudiesSearch for other papers by Thomas Adam in
Current site
Google Scholar
Abstract
This article explores the origins of the foundation in Christian Europe. When in 1264 Walter de Merton founded Merton College in Oxford, he broke with established tradition in that he did not entrust his gift to an existing religious order but instead created with Merton College a new legal body that was endowed with self-management and self-government. Up until the creation of Merton College, Christian donors customarily gave their gifts to the Catholic Church or an institution of the Church (monastery or religious order) thereby creating endowments that were administered by the Church. Merton decided against this tradition. Since there was no model within Christian Europe for this new kind of institution (foundation), scholars have long suggested that Merton took inspiration from the Islamic waqf in the creation of his foundation. This article will deepen this explanation by exploring the transition from creating endowments to creating foundations in medieval Europe.
Purchase
Buy instant access (PDF download and unlimited online access):
Institutional Login
Log in with Open Athens, Shibboleth, or your institutional credentials
Personal login
Log in with your brill.com account
-
Adam 2009 = Thomas Adam. Buying Respectability: Philanthropy and Urban Society in Transnational Perspective, 1840s to 1930s. Bloomington and Indianapolis.
-
Adam 2012 = Thomas Adam. Intercultural Transfers and the Making of the Modern World, 1800–2000. New York.
-
Adam 2013 = Thomas Adam. “New Ways to Write the History of Western Europe and the United States: The Concept of Intercultural Transfer.” History Compass 11, 10: 880–892.
-
Adam 2016 = Thomas Adam. Philanthropy, Civil Society, and the State in German History, 1815–1989. Rochester.
-
Adam 2017 = Thomas Adam. “Interreligious and Intercultural Transfers of the Tradition of Philanthropy.” Ed. Julia R. Lieberman and Michal Jan Rozbicki. Charity in Jewish, Christian, and Islamic Traditions. Lanham et al.: 45–65.
-
Adam 2019 = Thomas Adam. Approaches to the Study of Intercultural Transfer. London and New York.
-
Adam and Mettele 2009 = Ed. Thomas Adam and Gisela Mettele. Two Boston Brahmins in Goethe’s Germany: The Travel Journals of Anna and George Ticknor. Lanham et al.: Lexington Books 2009.
-
Baer 2005 = Gabriel Baer. “The Muslim Waqf and Similar Institutions in Other Civilizations.” Ed. Michael Borgolte. Stiftungen in Christentum, Judentum und Islam vor der Moderne: Auf der Suche nach ihren Gemeinsamkeiten und Unterschieden in religiösen Grundlagen, praktischen Zwecken und historischen Transformationen. Berlin: 257–280.
-
Bailey et al. 2009 = Ed. Lisa Bailey, Lindsay Diggelmann and Kim M. Phillips. Old Worlds, New Worlds: European Cultural Encounters, c. 1000–1750. Turnhout.
-
Belgum 2005 = Kirsten Belgum. “Reading Alexander von Humboldt: Cosmopolitan Naturalist with an American Spirit.” Ed. Lynne Tatlock and Matt Erlin. German Culture in Nineteenth-Century America: Reception, Adaptation, Transformation. Rochester: 107–127.
-
Bentley 1993 = Jerry H. Bentley. Old World Encounters: Cross-Cultural Contacts and Exchanges in Pre-Modern Times. New York and Oxford.
-
Berkey 2007 = Jonathan P. Berkey. “Madrasas Medieval and Modern: Politics, Education, and the Problem of Muslim Identity.” Ed. Robert W. Hefner and Muhammad Quasim Zaman. Schooling Islam: The Culture and Politics of Modern Muslim Education. Princeton and Oxford: 42–44.
-
Borgolte 2012 = Michael Borgolte. “Planen für die Ewigkeit – Stiftungen im Mittelalter.” Geschichte in Wissenschaft und Unterricht 63.1–2: 37–49.
-
Borgolte 2014 = Michael Borgolte. “Universität und Intellektueller – Erfindungen des Mittelalters unter dem Einfluß des Islam?” Ed. Tillman Lohse and Benjamin Scheller. Michael Borgolte. Mittelalter in der größeren Welt Essays zur Geschichtsschreibung und Beiträge zur Forschung. Berlin: 261–282.
-
Borgolte 2017 = Michael Borgolte, Weltgeschichte als Stiftungsgeschichte von 3000 v. u. Z bis 1500 u. Z. Darmstadt.
-
Brodrick 1885 = George C. Brodrick. Memorials of Merton College with Biographical Notices of the Wardens and Fellows. Oxford.
-
Bulliet 2004 = Richard W. Bulliet. The Case for Islamo-Christian Civilization. New York.
-
Christ et al. 2016 = Georg Christ et al. Transkulturelle Verflechtungen: Mediävistische Perspektiven. Göttingen.
-
Ҫizakça 2000 = Murat Ҫizakça. A History of Philanthropic Foundations: The Islamic World from the Seventh Century to the Present. Istanbul.
-
Ҫizakça 2006 = Murat Ҫizakça. “Cross-cultural Borrowing and Comparative Evolution of Institutions between Islamic World and the West.” Ed. Simonetta Cavaciocchi. Relazioni economiche tra Europa e mondo Islamico, Secc xiii–xviii . Florence: 671–698.
-
Ҫizakça 2014 = Murat Ҫizakça. “How Civilizations Borrow Institutions From Each Other.” Ed. Murat Ҫizakça. Islam and the Challenges of Western Capitalism. Cheltenham and Northampton: 38–55.
-
De Santillana 1931 = David De Santillana. “Law and Society.” Ed. Sir Thomas Arnold and Alfred Guillaume. The Legacy of Islam. Oxford: 284–294.
-
Drews and Scholl 2016 = Wolfram Drews and Christian Scholl. “Transkulturelle Verflechtungsprozesse in der Vormoderne. Zur Einleitung.” Ed. Wolfram Drews and Christian Scholl. Transkulturelle Verflechtungsprozesse in der Vormoderne. Berlin and Boston: vii–xxiii.
-
Espagne and Werner 1988 = Michel Espagne and Michael Werner. “Deutsch-französischer Kulturtransfer als Forschungsgegenstand. Eine Problemskizze.” Ed. Michel Espagne and Michael Werner. Transferts. Les relations interculturelles dans l’espace franco-allemand (XVIIIe et XIXe siècle). Paris: 11–34.
-
Gaudiosi 1988 = Monica M. Gaudiosi. “The Influence of the Islamic Law of Waqf on the Development of the Trust in England.” University of Pennsylvania Law Review 136: 1231–1261.
-
Geffken and Tykocinski 1905 = Heinrich Geffcken and Hayim Tykocinski. Stiftungsbuch der Stadt Leipzig. Leipzig.
-
Geelhaar 2007 = Tim Geelhaar. “Stiftungszweck Bildung? Die mittelalterlichen Pariser Universitätskollegien im interkulturellen Vergleich mit der islamischen Madrasa.” Ed. Jonas Flöter and Christian Ritzi. Bildungsmäzenatentum: Privates Handeln – Bürgersinn – kulturelle Kompetenz seit der frühen Neuzeit. Cologne, Weimar and Vienna: 39–72.
-
Haskins 1923 = Charles Homer Haskins. The Rise of Universities. New York.
-
Hennigan 2004 = Peter C. Hennigan. The Birth of a Legal Institution: The Formation of the Waqf in Third-Century A.H. Hanafi Legal Discourse. Leiden.
-
Irrgang 2013 = Stephanie Irrgang. “Studienförderung und Stipendienwesen an deutschen Universitäten im Mittelalter.” Ed. Matthias Asche and Stefan Gerber. Studienförderung und Stipendienwesen an deutschen Universitäten von den Anfängen bis zur Gegenwart. Stuttgart: 19–36.
-
Kogelmann 2012 = Franz Kogelmann. “Das islamische Stiftungswesen.” Geschichte in Wissenschaft und Unterricht 63.1–2: 66–80.
-
Kortländer 1995 = Bernd Kortländer. “Begrenzung – Entgrenzung: Kultur- und Wissenschaftstransfer in Europa.” Ed. Lothar Jordan and Bernd Kortländer. Nationale Grenzen und internationaler Austausch: Studien zum Kultur- und Wissenschaftstransfer in Europa. Tübingen: 1–11.
-
La Matire 2017 = Corrodo la Martire. “Inventionen, Innovationen und Imitationen im interkulturellen Kontakt. Die islamwissenschaftliche Perspektive.” Ed. Michael Borgolte. Enzyklopädie des Stiftungswesens in Mittelalterlichen Gesellschaften. Band 3: Stiftung und Gesellschaft. Berlin and Boston: 454–462.
-
Liermann 1963 = Hans Liermann. Handbuch des Stiftungsrechts I. Band: Geschichte des Stiftungsrechts. Tübingen.
-
Lingelbach 2019 = Gabriele Lingelbach. “Comparative History, Intercultural Transfer Studies, and Global History: Three Modes of Conceptualizing History beyond the Nation State.” Yearbook of Transnational History 2: 1–19.
-
Lohse 2017 = Tillmann Lohse. “Inventionen, Innovationen und Imitationen im interkulturellen Kontakt. Die mediävistische Perspektive.” Ed. Michael Borgolte. Enzyklopädie des Stiftungswesens in Mittelalterlichen Gesellschaften. Band 3: Stiftung und Gesellschaft. Berlin and Boston: 451–454.
-
Makdisi 1970 = George Makdisi. “Madrasa and University in the Middle Ages.” Studia Islamica 32: 255–264.
-
Makdisi 1981 = George Makdisi. The Rise of Colleges: Institutions of Learning in Islam and the West. Edinburgh.
-
Makdisi 1985 = George Makdisi. “The Guilds of Law in Medieval Legal History: An Inquiry into the Origins of the Inns of Court.” Cleveland State Law Review 34.3: 3–18.
-
Makdisi 1999 = John A. Makdisi. “The Islamic Origins of the Common Law.” North Carolina Law Review 77.5: 1635–1740.
-
Meyerhof 1931 = Max Meyerhof. “Science and Medicine.” Ed. Sir Thomas Arnold and Alfred Guillaume. The Legacy of Islam. Oxford: 344–354.
-
Nakosteen 1964 = Mehdi Nakosteen. History of Islamic Origins of Western Education A.D. 800–1350 with an Introduction to Medieval Muslim Education. Boulder.
-
Paulmann 1998 = Johannes Paulmann. “Internationaler Vergleich und interkultureller Transfer. Zwei Forschungsansätze zur europäischen Geschichte des 18. bis 20. Jahrhunderts.” Historische Zeitschrift 267.3: 649–685.
-
Rashdall 1936 = Hastings Rashdall. The Universities of Europe in the Middle Ages: A New Edition in Three Volumes edited by F. M. Powicke and A. B. Emden Volume ii: English Universities – Student Life. Oxford.
-
Riaz 2008 = Ali Riaz. Faithful Education: Madrassahs in South Asia. New Brunswick and London.
-
Rodgers 1998 = Daniel T. Rodgers. Atlantic Crossings: Social Politics in a Progressive Age. Cambridge and London.
-
Rüegg 1992 = Walter Rüegg. “Themes.” E. Hilde D Ridder-Symoens. A History of the University in Europe Volume 1: Universities in the Middle Ages. Cambridge: 3–34.
-
Schäfer 1977 = Volker Schäfer. “‘Zur Beförderung der Ehre Gottes und Fortpflanzung der Studien’: Bürgerliche Studienstiftungen an der Universität Tübingen zwischen 1477 und 1750.” Ed. Erich Maschke and Jürgen Sydow. Stadt und Universität im Mittelalter und in der früheren Neuzeit. Sigmaringen: 99–111.
-
Singer 2008 = Amy Singer. Charity in Islamic Societies. Cambridge.
-
Stanton 1990 = Charles Michael Stanton. Higher Learning in Islam: The Classical Period, A.D. 700–1300. Savage, Md.
-
Thomas 1949 = Ann Van Wynen Thomas. “Note on the Origin of Uses and Trusts – Waqfs.” Southwestern Law Journal 3.2: 162–166.
-
Van Cleve 1972 = Thomas Curtis van Cleve. The Emperor Frederick ii of Hohenstaufen: Immutator Mundi. Oxford.
-
Verger 1992 = Jacques Verger. “Patterns.” Ed. Hilde de Ridder-Symoens. A History of the University in Europe Volume I: Universities in the Middle Ages. Cambridge: 35–74.
-
Watt 1972 = W. Montgomery Watt. The Influence of Islam on Medieval Europe. Edinburgh.
-
Werner and Zimmermann 2006 = Michael Werner and Bénédicte Zimmermann. “Beyond Comparison: Histoire Croisée and the Challenge of Reflexivity.” History and Theory 45.1: 30–50.
From Madrasa to College: The Islamic Influence in the Birth of the Christian Foundation
In: Endowment StudiesSearch for other papers by Thomas Adam in
Current site
Google Scholar
PubMed
Abstract
This article explores the origins of the foundation in Christian Europe. When in 1264 Walter de Merton founded Merton College in Oxford, he broke with established tradition in that he did not entrust his gift to an existing religious order but instead created with Merton College a new legal body that was endowed with self-management and self-government. Up until the creation of Merton College, Christian donors customarily gave their gifts to the Catholic Church or an institution of the Church (monastery or religious order) thereby creating endowments that were administered by the Church. Merton decided against this tradition. Since there was no model within Christian Europe for this new kind of institution (foundation), scholars have long suggested that Merton took inspiration from the Islamic waqf in the creation of his foundation. This article will deepen this explanation by exploring the transition from creating endowments to creating foundations in medieval Europe.
