Power in Global Nutrition Governance

A Critical Analysis of the Establishment of the Scaling Up Nutrition (SUN) Partnership

in Global Governance: A Review of Multilateralism and International Organizations
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

Abstract

Global public-private partnerships for health and nutrition have proliferated since the 1990s—a trend raising important questions about authority and legitimacy in global governance. Yet within the fields of international relations and public health, there has been only limited empirical research into the global politics and power dynamics behind such partnerships. This article explores how and why the Scaling Up Nutrition partnership was established. Drawing on interviews, observations, and document analysis, it demonstrates how public and private actors exercise combinations of instrumental, structural, and discursive power to normalize and institutionalize their interests and values at the global level. The study highlights as such the complexities behind the increased privatization of global nutrition governance and the importance of power analysis to uncover the normative contestations and asymmetries of power behind global partnership creation.

Power in Global Nutrition Governance

A Critical Analysis of the Establishment of the Scaling Up Nutrition (SUN) Partnership

in Global Governance: A Review of Multilateralism and International Organizations

Sections

References

  • Andonova Liliana B. Governance Entrepreneurs: International Organizations and the Rise of Public-Private Partnerships (New York: Cambridge University Press 2017).

  • Barnett Michael and Raymond Duvall eds. Power in Global Governance (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press 2005).

  • Bezanson Keith and Paul Isenman. “Moving toward Consensus: A Global Action Plan for Scaling Up Nutrition.” Policy Brief (Draft November 2009). www.unscn.org/files/Annual_Sessions/2009_Brussels/GAPpolicybrief_newcover.doc.

  • Bhagwati Jagdish et al. “Ranking the Opportunities.” Part II pp. 605–645 in Global Crises Global Solutions ed. Bjorn Lomborg (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press 2004).

  • Bhutta Zulfiqar A. Tahmeed Ahmed Robert E. Black Simon Cousens Kathryn Dewey Elsa Giugliani Batool A. Haider et al. “What Works? Interventions for Maternal and Child Undernutrition and Survival.” The Lancet 371(9610) (2008) 417–440.

  • Cannon Geoffrey Wenche Barth Eide Asbjorn Eide Catherine Geissler Ted Greiner Elisabet Helsing et al. “Open Letter to the SCN Steering Committee” (21 April 2010).

  • Clapp Jennifer and Doris Fuchs eds. Corporate Power in Global Agrifood Governance (Cambridge: MIT Press 2009).

  • Clapp Jennifer and Gyorgy Scrinis. “Big Food Nutritionism and Corporate Power.” Globalizations 14 (4) (2016) 578–595.

  • Fejerskov Adam. “The New Technopolitics of Development and the Global South as a Laboratory of Technological Experimentation.” Science Technology and Human Values 42 (5) (2017) 947–968.

  • Friel Sharon. “Global Governance for Nutrition and the Role of UNSCN.” Discussion Paper. United Nations System Standing Committee on Nutrition March Rome: Italy (2017). Available at: https://www.unscn.org/uploads/web/news/document/GovernPaper-EN-may17-WEB.pdf

  • Fuchs Doris. “Commanding Heights? The Strength and Fragility of Business Power in Global Politics.” Millennium: Journal of International Studies 33 (3) (2005) 771–801.

  • Fuchs Doris and Katharina Glaab. “Material Power and Normative Conflict in Global and Local Agrifood Governance: The Lessons of ‘Golden Rice’ in India.” Food Policy 36 (6) (2011) 729–735.

  • Fuchs Doris and Markus M.L. Lederer. “The Power of Business.” Business and Politics 9 (3) (2007) 1–17.

  • GAIN (Global Alliance for Improved Nutrition). “SUN Nutrition Hub” (2018). https://www.gainhealth.org/knowledge-centre/event/the-sun-nutrition-hub-how-can-we-strengthen-the-enabling-environment-for-business-to-take-action-in-improving-nutrition/.

  • Gillespie Stuart Milla McLachlan and Roger Shrimpton. “Combating Malnutrition: Time to Act” (Washington DC: World Bank 2003).

  • Haddad Lawrence Harold Alderman Simon Appletan Lina Song and Yisehac Yohannes. “Reducing Child Malnutrition: How Far Does Income Growth Take Us?” World Bank Economic Review 17 (1) (2003) 107–131.

  • Hanefeld Johanna and Gill Walt. “Knowledge and Networks: Key Sources of Power in Global Health; Comment on ‘Knowledge Moral Claims and the Exercise of Power in Global Health.’ ” International Journal of Health Policy and Management 4 (2) (2015) 119–121.

  • Harman Sophie. “The Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation and Legitimacy in Global Health Governance.” Global Governance 22 (3) (2016) 349–368.

  • Hoddinot John Stuart Gillespie and Yosef Sivan. “Public-Private Partnerships and the Reduction of Undernutrition in Developing Countries.” Discussion Paper 01487 (International Food Policy Research Institute [IFPRI] Washington DC. 2015).

  • Horton Sue Harold Alderman and Juan A. Rivera. “Copenhagen Consensus 2008 Challenge Paper: Hunger and Malnutrition” (Copenhagen: Copenhagen Consensus Center 2008).

  • IFPRI (International Food Policy Research Institute). “Global Nutrition Report 2014: Actions and Accountability to Accelerate the World’s Progress on Nutrition” (Washington DC: IFPRI 2014).

  • Isenman Paul Keith Bezanson and Lola Gostelow. “Stewardship of the SUN Movement: Taking SUN to the Next Level” (SUN 30 September 2011). http://docs.scalingupnutrition.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/Stewardship-Study-Final-Report.pdf.

  • Jonsson Urban. “The Rise and Fall of Paradigms in World Food and Nutrition Policy.” Commentary. World Nutrition 1 (3) (2010) 128–158.

  • Kraak Vivica Paige B. Harrigan Mark Lawrence Paul J. Harrison Michaela A. Jackson & Boyd Swinburn “Balancing the Benefits and Risks of Public-Private Partnerships to Address the Global Double Burden of Malnutrition.” Public Health Nutrition 15 (3) (2011) 503–517.

  • Levine Ruth and Danielle Kuczynski. “Global Nutrition Institutions: Is There an Appetite for Change?” (Washington DC: Center for Global Development 2009).

  • Longhurst Richard. “Global Leadership for Nutrition: The UN’s Standing Committee on Nutrition (SCN) and Its Contributors.” IDS Discussion Paper No. 390 (Brighton: Institute of Development Studies [IDS] 2010).

  • “Maternal and Child Nutrition.” Series from the Lancet journals. The Lancet (6 June 2013). http://www.thelancet.com/series/maternal-and-child-nutrition

  • McDougall Lori. “Power and Politics in the Global Health Landscape: Beliefs Competition and Negotiation among Global Advocacy Coalitions in the Policy-Making Process.” International Journal of Health Policy and Management 5 (5) (2016) 309–320.

  • McKeon Nora. Food Security Governance: Empowering Communities Regulating Corporations (Oxon England: Routledge 2015).

  • McKeon Nora. “Are Equity and Sustainability a Likely Outcome when Foxes and Chickens Share the Same Coop? Critiquing the Concept of Multistakeholder Governance of Food Security.” Globalizations 14 (3) (2017) 379–398.

  • Mokoro. “Independent Comprehensive Evaluation of the Scaling Up Nutrition Movement: Final Report—Main Report” (Oxford England: Mokoro Ltd. 2015a).

  • Mokoro. “Strategic Evaluation: Joint Evaluation of Renewed Efforts against Child Hunger and Undernutrition (REACH)—2011–2015.” Evaluation Report Vol. 1 No. OEV/2015/026 World Food Program Rome (October 2015b). http://www.fao.org/3/a-bd907e.pdf.

  • Morris Saul S. Bruce Cogill and Ricardo Uauy. “Effective International Action against Undernutrition: Why Has It Proven so Difficult and What Can Be Done to Accelerate Progress?” The Lancet 371 (9612) (2008) 608–621.

  • Nabarro David. “Introducing the Policy Brief ‘Scaling Up Nutrition: A Framework for Action.’ ” High-Level Nutrition Event World Bank–IMF spring meetings Washington DC April 2010. http://www.g20dwg.org/documents/pdf/view/65/.

  • Nabarro David. Special adviser on the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development. Intervention at the inaugural meeting of the new Lead Group of the Scaling Up Nutrition Movement New York 21 September 2016. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=efdDfeaLNlc.

  • NBAR (National Bureau of Asian Research). “The Global Nutrition Challenge: Getting a Healthy Start.” Report from the Pacific Health Summit 16–18 June 2008. http://pacifichealthsummit.org/downloads/2008%20Summit/2008%20Summit%20Report.pdf.

  • Nisbett Nicholas Stuart Gillespie Lawrence Haddad and Jody Harris. “Why Worry about the Politics of Childhood Undernutrition?” World Development 64 (2014) 420–433.

  • Partzsch Lena and Doris Fuchs. “Philanthropy: Power with in International Relations.” Journal of Political Power 5 (3) (2012) 359–376.

  • Richter Judith. “Public-Private Partnerships for Health: A Trend with No Alternatives?” Development 47 (2) (2004) 43–48.

  • Sandberg Kristin Steinar Andresen and Gunnar Bjune. “A New Approach to Global Health Institutions? A Case Study of New Vaccine Introduction and the Formation of the GAVI Alliance.” Social Science and Medicine 71 (7) (2010) 1349–1356.

  • Schuftan Claudio and Ted Greiner. “The Scaling Up Nutrition (SUN) Initiative.” pp. 22–23 in Right to Food and Nutrition Watch: Alternatives and Resistance to Policies that Generate Hunger eds. Anne C. Bellows Carolin Callenius Christine Campeau Marcos Arana Cedeño Maarten Immink Kathy McNeely Stineke Oenema et al. (Bread for the World FIAN International and ICCO Cooperation 2013). Available at: https://www.righttofoodandnutrition.org/files/Watch_2013_Full_Watch_ENG.pdf

  • Shiffman Jeremy. “Knowledge Moral Claims and the Exercise of Power in Global Health.” International Journal of Health Policy and Management 3 (6) (2014) 297–299.

  • Shiffman Jeremy and Stephanie Smith. “Generation of Political Priority for Global Health Initiatives: A Framework and Case Study of Maternal Mortality.” The Lancet 370 (9595) (2007) 1370–1379.

  • Shiffman Jeremy Hans Peter Schmitz David Berlan Stephanie L. Smith Kathryn Quissel Uwe Gneiting and David Pelletier “The Emergence and Effectiveness of Global Health Networks: Findings and Future Research.” Health Policy and Planning 31 (2016) i110–i123.

  • Stoeva Preslava. “International Relations and the Global Politics of Health: A State of the Art.” Global Health Governance 10 (3) (2016) 97–109.

  • Storeng Katerini T. and Dominique P. Behague. “Lives in the Balance: The Politics of Integration in the Partnership for Maternal Newborn and Child Health.” Health Policy and Planning 31 (8) (2016): 992–1000.

  • SUN (Scaling Up Nutrition). “A Road Map for Scaling Up Nutrition” 1st ed. (September 2010). http://siteresources.worldbank.org/NUTRITION/Resources/SUNRoadMapSeptember2010.pdf.

  • SUN. “How Is the Movement Supported.” (2015) http://scalingupnutrition.org/sun-supporters/how-is-the-movement-supported/.

  • SUN. “Strategy at a Glance: 2016–2020” (2016). http://docs.scalingupnutrition.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/09/strategy2016-in-a-second.pdf.

  • SUN Business Network. “SUN Business Network Company Commitments” (9 January 2017). http://sunbusinessnetwork.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2015/01/SUN-Business-Network-Company-Commitments-09-Jan-2017.pdf.

  • SUN Civil Society Network. “List of Members” (2017). http://www.suncivilsociety.com/documents/List_Of_Members_2017.pdf.

  • SUN UN Network. “Governance” (2015). http://scalingupnutrition.org/sun-supporters/un-network-for-sun/.

  • UN Department of Public Information. “Press Conference by Global Alliance for Improved Nutrition (GAIN).” UN Special Session on Children 9 May 2002. https://www.unicef.org/specialsession/press/02bngain.htm.

  • UNSCN (UN Standing Committee on Nutrition). “Report of the Standing Committee on Nutrition at Its Thirty-Fifth Session.” (Hanoi: UNSCN 3–6 March 2008).

  • UNSCN. “Report on High Level Meeting on Nutrition” (Brussels: UNSCN and European Commission 23–24 November 2009). http://www.unscn.org/files/Annual_Sessions/2009_Brussels/Brussels_High_Level_Nutrition_Meeting_report__final.pdf.

  • UNSCN. “UNSCN Nutrition Partners Kick-Off Meeting Report” (Rome: Food and Agriculture Organization [FAO] 14–15 December 2010). http://www.unscn.org/files/Activities/Other_Meetings/UNSCN_kick_off_meeting_minutes_14_15_Dec_2010.pdf.

  • UNSCN. “UN Agency Contributions to UNSCN Core Budget 1994–2013.” UNSCN Secretariat Archive (November 2016).

  • UNSCN Civil Society Constituency. “NGO/CSO Report to the 35th SCN Meeting” (March 6 2008).

  • Utting Peter and Ann Zammit. “United Nations-Business Partnerships: Good Intentions and Contradictory Agendas.” Journal of Business Ethics 90 (2009) 39–56.

  • Valente Flavio. “The Corporate Capture of Food and Nutrition Governance: A Threat to Human Rights and Peoples’ Sovereignty.” pp. 16–17 in Anne C. Bellows Antonio Onorati Bernhard Walter Biraj Patnaik Francisco Sarmento Manigueuigdinapi J.S. Icaza Marcos A. Cedeño et al. (eds) Right to Food and Nutrition Watch Bread for the World FIAN International and ICCO Cooperation (2015). https://www.righttofoodandnutrition.org/files/R_t_F_a_N_Watch_2015_eng_single-page_Web.pdf.

  • Valente Flavio. “The Corporate Capture of Food and Nutrition Governance Revisited: A Threat to Human Rights and People’s Sovereignty.” Colloquium Paper No. 62 (The Hague: International Institute of Social Studies 2016).

  • WFP (World Food Programme). “Nutrition Forum.” (Rome: WFP and the City of Rome 31 May–1 June 2010). http://www.unscn.org/files/Newsletters/Microsoft_Word_-_WFPNUTRITIONFORUM_SUNMTGOVERVIEW_AGENDA.pdf.

  • WFP and UNICEF (UN Children’s Fund). “Global Framework for Action: Ending Child Hunger and Undernutrition Initiative.” Revised Draft (December 2006). https://www.unicef.org/about/execboard/files/Global_Framework_for_Action1.0--Dec2006.pdf.

  • WHO (World Health Organization). “New Global Alliance Brings Food Fortification to World’s Poor.” Global Alliance for Improved Nutrition (GAIN) press release Durban 12 June 2003. http://www.who.int/mediacentre/news/releases/2003/prgain/en/.

  • World Bank. “Repositioning Nutrition as Central to Development—A Strategy for Large Scale Action.” Directions in Development (Washington DC: World Bank 2006).

  • World Bank. “A Global Action Plan for Scaling-Up Nutrition Investments.” Draft outline. (Washington DC: World Bank 16 April 2009).

  • World Bank. “Scaling Up Nutrition: Report of a High-Level Meeting” (Washington DC: World Bank Canadian International Development Agency (CIDA) Japan and US Agency for International Development [USAID] April 2010). http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/892361468059697624/Scaling-up-nutrition-report-of-a-high-level-meeting.

  • Youde Jeremy. “Global Health Governance in International Society.” Global Governance 23 (4) (2017) 583–600.

Figures

  • View in gallery
    Figure 1

    Simplified overview of the institutional development of SUN

Index Card

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 191 191 129
Full Text Views 14 14 11
PDF Downloads 13 13 10
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0