In Anti-Individualism and Knowledge Jessica Brown criticises views of content that combine Fregean Sense and anti-individualism. Brown assumes that all Fregean theories are motivated by a picture of the rational thinker as someone who will always have transparent access to the simple inferential consequences of his thoughts. This picture, Brown argues, is incompatible with anti-individualism about content. While traditional Fregean theories have indeed had such motivation, Brown’s mistake is in attributing this motivation to the modern Fregean anti-individualist. My goal in this paper is to bring to light a different, and seldom discussed, motivation for Fregean views of content which is immune to Browns objections.
CampbellJohn2007. “If Truth is Dethroned what Role Is Left for It?” In: Library of Living Philosophers: The Philosophy of Michael Dummett
. Edited by AuxierRandall E. and HahnLewis Edwin. Chicago: Open Court Press281–300.