The Responsibility to Protect Human Rights and the RtoP: Prospective and Retrospective Responsibility

in Global Responsibility to Protect
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

This article argues that—contrary to the way that it is often framed—the first pillar of the Responsibility to Protect (RtoP) is not best understood as an instantiation of a broader international responsibility to protect human rights. Firstly, the RtoP reverts to a discourse of powerful savours and passive victims, which runs against advocates’ claim that the RtoP is a ‘rights-based norm’. Secondly, although it distinguishes between prevention and response, the RtoP is still fundamentally a discussion of retrospective responsibility. The responsibility to protect human rights, by contrast, is importantly prospective. The article’s separation of prospective/retrospective responsibility from the responsibility to prevent and to respond is an independent contribution, with broader significance beyond the RtoP context. Thirdly, the RtoP becomes activated when atrocity is building, imminent or underway; whereas the responsibility to protect human rights may be breached even without a clear causal link to harm.

The Responsibility to Protect Human Rights and the RtoP: Prospective and Retrospective Responsibility

in Global Responsibility to Protect

Sections

References

2

Alex J. Bellamy‘The Responsibility to Protect - Five Years On’Ethics & International Affairs 24:2 (2010) pp. 161–62.

4

Saladin Meckled-Garcia‘The Practice-Dependence Red Herring and Better Reasons for Restricting the Scope of Justice’Raisons Politiques 51 (2013) pp. 97–120.

5

Hugh Breakey‘Protection Norms and Human Rights: A Rights-Based Analysis of the Re-s­ponsibility to Protect and the Protection of Civilians in Armed Conflict’Global Responsibility to Protect 4:3 (2012) pp. 309–33; see also Melissa T. Labonte ‘Whose Responsibility to Protect? The Implications of Double Manifest Failure for Civilian Protection’ International Journal of Human Rights 16:7 (2012) pp. 982–1002.

9

Gareth Evans‘From Humanitarian Intervention to the Responsibility to Protect’Wisconsin International Law Journal 24:3 (2006–7) pp. 101–20; Gareth Evans ‘The Responsibility to Protect: An Idea Whose Time Has Come… and Gone?’ International Relations 22:3 (2008) p. 295.

10

United Nations Secretary-GeneralImplementing the Responsibility to Protect p. 8 para. 10(c).

13

United Nations Secretary-GeneralImplementing the Responsibility to Protect pp. 8 para. 10(b) emphasis added.

15

Beth A. SimmonsMobilizing for Human Rights: International Law in Domestic Politics (New York: Cambridge University Press2009).

17

Stephen D. KrasnerSovereignty: Organized Hypocrisy (Princeton: Princeton University Press1999).

18

Stephen HopgoodThe Endtimes of Human Rights (Ithaca: Cornell University Press2013).

20

Peter Singer‘Famine, Affluence, and Morality’Philosophy and Public Affairs 1:3 (1972) pp. 229–43; Allen Buchanan ‘Justice and Charity’ Ethics 97:3 (1987) pp. 558–75. See also: William Easterly The White Man’s Burden: Why the West’s Efforts to Aid the Rest Have Done So Little Good (Oxford: Oxford University Press 2006).

21

Hannah ArendtThe Origins of Totalitarianism (New York: Harcourt1968) pp. 267–302.

22

David Jason KarpResponsibility for Human Rights: Transnational Corporations in Imperfect States (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press2014) p. 78.

23

Gareth Evans‘The Responsibility to Protect: Ending Mass Atrocity Crimes Once and for All’Irish Studies in International Affairs 20:1 (2009) p. 9.

25

H.L.A. HartPunishment and Responsibility (Oxford: Clarendon1968); Graham Haydon ‘On Being Responsible’ Philosophical Quarterly 28:110 (1978) pp. 46–57; Peter Cane Responsibility in Law and Morality (Oxford: Hart Publishing 2002).

26

HartPunishment and Responsibility pp. 210–30.

30

United Nations General Assembly2005 World Summit Outcome p. 31.

33

United Nations Secretary-GeneralImplementing the Responsibility to Protect p. 14 para. 27.

34

United Nations Secretary-GeneralResponsibility to Protect: State Responsibility and Prevention p. 5 paras. 22 and 24.

35

United Nations Secretary-GeneralImplementing the Responsibility to Protect p. 12 para. 21.

36

Jeffrey Gettleman‘Disputed Vote Plunges Kenya Into Bloodshet’New York Times31 December 2007.

37

Evans‘The Responsibility to Protect: Ending Mass Atrocity Crimes Once and for All’ p. 11; Abdullahi Boru Halakhe ‘"R2P in Practice": Ethnic Violence Elections and Atrocity Prevention in Kenya’ Global Centre for the Responsibility to Protect Occasional Paper Series 4 (2013).

39

Christopher CramerCivil War Is Not a Stupid Thing: Accounting for Violence in Developing Countries (London: C. Hurst & Co.2006); Mark Duffield Security Development and Unending War: Governing the World of Peoples (Cambridge: Polity Press 2007); David Chandler ‘R2P or not R2P? More Statebuilding Less Responsibility’ Global Responsibility to Protect 2:1 (2010) pp. 161–66; Jan Selby ‘The Myth of Liberal Peacebuilding’ Conflict Security and Development 13:1 (2013) pp. 57–86.

44

Thomas PoggeWorld Poverty and Human Rights (Cambridge: Polity2002) ch. 2.

45

Joel FeinbergHarm to Others: The Moral Limits of the Criminal Law volume 1 (Oxford: Oxford University Press1984) pp. 105–25.

46

KarpResponsibility for Human Rights pp. 116–51.

47

FeinbergHarm to Others pp. 31–64.

48

Johan Galtung‘Violence, Peace, and Peace Research’Journal of Peace Research 6:3 (1969) pp. 167–91; Karp ‘The Concept of Human Rights Protection’ in Mills and Karp (eds.) Human Rights Protection in Global Politics p. 142.

51

Andrew Linklater‘The Harm Principle and Global Ethics’Global Society 20:3 (2006) pp. 329–43.

52

Donald A. Dripps‘The Liberal Critique of the Harm Principle’Criminal Justice Ethics 17:2 (1998) pp. 3–18.

53

John R. SearleThe Construction of Social Reality (London: Penguin1995) pp. 27–29.

Index Card

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 16 16 12
Full Text Views 13 13 13
PDF Downloads 4 4 4
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0