Frozen Music: Music and Architecture in Vitruvius’ De Architectura

in Greek and Roman Musical Studies
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

Abstract

This paper explores the convergence of musical and architectural theory in Vitruvius’ De Architectura. Section 1 describes Vitruvius’ architectural lexicon, borrowed from Aristoxenus (I.2), and explores his description of the laws of harmony, modeled on Elementa Harmonica (V.4). Section 2 explores how Vitruvius proposes using music theory in practical architectural design, including construction of columns using architectural orders analogous to Aristoxenian genera (I.2.6; IV.1); acoustical designs for theatres (V.5); and the development of machines, including siege engines ‘tuned’ like musical instruments (X.12) and water-organs [hydrauli] constructed to execute all the different varieties of tuning (X.8). Section 3 reflects on Vitruvius’ use of analogies with a musical instrument, the sambuca, to explain his understanding of cosmic harmony and architectural form, and his possible sources (VI.1). Finally, Section 4 discusses Vitruvius’ ideas about the importance of a liberal arts education that includes study of music theory. The best architects, Vitruvius explains, can discover in music the secrets to forms they both encounter in nature and create themselves.

Sections

References

BallouG. Handbook for Sound Engineers 2013 Burlington, MA

BarbaroD. Vitruvius Pollio, De architectura [. . .] 1556 Venice

BarbaroD. I Dieci libri dell’Architettura di M. Vitruvio 1567 Venice

BarkerA. Greek Musical Writings: II. Harmonic and Acoustic Theory 1989 Cambridge

BellM. Stylobate and Roof in the Olympieion at Akragas American Journal of Archaeology 1980 84 3 359 372

BrownF.E. Vitruvius and the Liberal Art of Architecture Bucknell Review 1963 11 99 107

BurkertW. Hellenistische Pseudopythagorica Philologus 1961 105 226 246

BuryR.G. Plato. Works Vol. 11: Laws. Part 2. Books 7-12 1926 Cambridge, Mass

CallebatL. Rhetorique et architecture dans le De Architectura de Vitruve Le Projet de Vitruve. Object, destinataires et réception du De Architectura 1994 Rome 31 46

CallebatL. Vitruve: De L’architecture. Livre VI 2004 Paris

CallebatL.FleuryP. Vitruve: De L’architecture. Livre X 1986 Paris

CapitaniU. Una presenza di Vitruvio in Vegezio? Maia 1970 31 1 179 185

CopelandR. Rhetoric, Hermeneutics, and Translation in the Middle Ages 1995 Cambridge

CreeseD.E. The Monochord in Ancient Greek Harmonic Science 2010 Cambridge

DoodyA. Pliny’s “Natural History: Enkuklios Paideia” and the Ancient Encyclopedia Journal of the History of Ideas 2009 70 1 1 21

EckermannJ.P. Gespräche mit Goethe 1986 Stuttgart

FalkenerE. A Description of Some Important Theatres and Other Remains in Crete 1854 London

FleuryP. Vitruve: De L’architecture. Livre I 2003 Paris

HagelS. Ancient Greek Music: A New Technical History 2009 Cambridge

HettW.S. Aristotle—Minor Works 1963 Cambridge, Mass.

HowardD.LongairM. Harmonic Proportion and Palladio’s Quattro Libri, Journal of the Society of Architectural Historians 1982 41 2 116 143

HuffmanC.A. Archytas of Tarentum 2005 Cambridge

HuffmanC.A. Aristoxenus of Tarentum: Discussion 2012 New Brunswick

HydeW.W. The Recent Discovery of an Inscribed Water-Organ at Budapest Transactions and Proceedings of the American Philological Association 1938 69 392 410

IsaacB.H. The Invention of Racism in Classical Antiquity 2006 Princeton

JannoneA. BarbotinE. Aristote: De l’âme 1966 Paris

JonesM.W. Principles of Roman Architecture 2000 New Haven

JouannaJ. Hippocrate: Airs, eaux, lieux 1996 Paris

KappraffJ.McClainE. The System of Proportions of the Parthenon: A Work of Musically Inspired Architecture Music in Art 2005 XXX 1-2 5 16

LandelsJ.G. Assisted Resonance in Ancient Theatres Greece & Rome II 1967 14 1 80 94

LandelsJ.G. Ship-Shape and Sambuca-Fashion The Journal of Hellenic Studies 1966 86 69 77

LaloyL. Aristoxène de Tarente et la musique de l’antiquité 1904 Paris

MacranH. S. The Harmonics of Aristoxenus 1902 Oxford

MastersonM. Status, Pay, and Pleasure in the “De Architectura” of Vitruvius The American Journal of Philology 2004 125 3 387 416

MathiesenT.J. Apollo’s Lyre: Greek Music and Music Theory in Antiquity and the Middle Ages 1999 Lincoln, NE.

McEwenI.K. Vitruvius: Writing the Body of Architecture 2003 Cambridge, MA

PearsonL. Aristoxenus. Elementa Rhythmica 1990 Oxford

PerrotJ. L’Orgue: de ses origines hellénistiques à la fin du XIIIE siècle 1965 Paris

PolychronopoulosS.KougiasD. The Use of Resonators in Ancient Greek Theatres Acta Acoustica 2013 99 64 69

PoulleB. Les vases acoustiques du théâtre de Mummius Achaicus Revue Archéologique 2000 37 50 n.s. fasc. 1,

RowlandI.HoweT.N.DewarM.J. Vitruvius: Ten Books on Architecture 1999 Cambridge

SaliouC. Vitruve: De L’architecture. Livre V 2009 Paris

SchellingF.W.J. Werke: Auswahl in drei Bänden 1907 Volume 3 Leipzig

SchofieldP.H. The Theory of Proportion in Architecture 1958 Cambridge

SearF. Roman Theatres: An Architectural Study 2006 Oxford

WehrliF. Die Schule des Aristoteles. Heft II. Aristoxenos 1967 Basel

WestM.L. Ancient Greek Music 1992 Oxford

Winnington-IngramR.P. Aristoxenus and the Intervals of Greek Music The Classical Quarterly 1932 26 3/4 195 208

Winnington-IngramR.P. Aristidis Quintiliani De Musica libri tres 1963 Leipzig

WinterT.N. The Mechanical Problems in the Corpus of Aristotle Faculty Publications, Classics and Religious Studies Department 2007 68 <http://digitalcommons.unl.edu/classicsfacpub/68>

WittkowerR. Architectural Principles in the Age of Humanism 1998 West Sussex

YongeC.D. Cicero’s Tusculan Disputations 1899 New York

1

Schelling 1907, 241. The idea was echoed in Goethe’s remark of March 23, 1829, invoking the same analogy to observe that “the mood that arises from architecture comes close to the effects of music.” Cf. Eckermann 1986, 340.

2

Schelling 1907, 241.

7

Saliou 2009, 180. Creese 2010 points out that the monochord did not actually date back to Pythagoras, although many imagined it did; the monochord does not appear in any references before the late fourth century bc.

8

See Saliou 2009, 181.

9

See Brown 1963.

15

Jones 2000, 41: “For Vitruvius, the task of the architect was to imitate Nature, not literally, but rather by analogy”. To illustrate this point, Vitruvius famously describes in III.1.1-3 how the ratios of various measurements taken from the human body fit together, explaining that ‘similarly . . . the elements of holy temples should have dimensions for each individual part that agree with the full magnitude of the work’.

16

Jones 2000, 41.

17

Jones 2000, 43. He explains that “symmetria . . . brings abstract beauty, but not necessarily visual beauty. This is the realm of eurythmia. . . .”

18

Cf. Barbaro 1556, 24, “[B]eautiful manner in music as well as in architecture is called eurythmia”; Barbaro 1567, 282, the architect should be “aware of numero . . . for those proportions which give delight to the ears in sound, applied to architectural forms, give delight to the eyes”; Barbaro 1567, 124-5, “that which is consonance to the ears is bellezza to the eyes”. For more on the Renaissance use of harmonic proportions in architecture, with a particular emphasis on Palladio’s applications, see Wittkower 1998 and Howard/Longair 1982.

19

See Jones 2000, 231 n. 47.

22

Saliou 2009, XXXVIII-XXXIX. Her chart shows that Book V.4 follows the order of El. Harm. more closely than the other authors from the Aristoxenian tradition. See also Copeland 1995, who defines ordinatio as the “hierarchical arrangement of information” (206).

36

See Landels 1967, Poulle 2000 and Hagel 2009, 251-5.

37

As Hagel 2009, 251 explains, this row is ‘associated with harmonia’, referring not to the pitches of the enharmonic genus, but rather to the ‘fixed’ notes of the so-called Perfect System. In this row, Vitruvius excludes the lowest pitch, the proslambanomenos but includes the nêtê synêmmenôn.

38

V.5.5. See Landels 1967, 88-89.

40

Hagel 2009, 255: ‘[. . .] the specific design reported by Vitruvius perfectly suits the general requirements of Roman Imperial music’.

42

See Saliou 2009, 387-409.

43

See Falkener 1854, 19.

44

See Sear 2006, 146 and Saliou 2009, 397-399.

45

Polychronopolous 2013, 67.

51

Saliou 2009, 225.

55

X.8.6. See Hyde 1938 and West 1992, 114-8.

58

See Section IIb and Saliou 2009, 225.

59

West 1992, 76 describes the shape of the sambuca as a “primitive arched harp”; see also Mathiesen 1999, 275-280.

64

See Rowland 1999, 256 and Callebat 2004, 82.

65

See Hagel 2009, 117-22.

66

See Isaac 2006, 60-69.

70

See Callebat 2004, 71.

71

Callebat 2004, 72.

72

Cf. Callebat 2004, 74.

73

Doody 2009, 13.

75

Doody 2009, 13.

76

Masterson 2004, 391.

77

Ibid., 388.

78

Ibid., 393. Doody 2009, 13: “the more impressive the breadth of enkyklios paideia, the more exalted the subject [must be]”.

79

Ibid., 387.

Information

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 27 27 20
Full Text Views 10 10 10
PDF Downloads 3 3 3
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0