Around the Origins of Bagpipes: Relevant Hypotheses and Evidences

in Greek and Roman Musical Studies
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

This article addresses the complex question of the origins of bagpipes. One of the major problems is to determine the defining features of the instrument, as the denomination includes a broad and heterogeneous family. We propose an explanatory typology based on only three main profiles, interrelated but substantially different: circular breathing (initial and polygenetic), the addition of an external pipe bag (documented in some early civilizations), and the medieval one, which leads to the modern European bagpipe (with bag, one or more drones and the morphology that has survived to the present). Attention is also paid to the intense social symbolism that has surrounded the instrument since ancient times. The study reveals that bagpipes had a marginal position in Greco-Roman culture, associated with livestock and beggars; but in the medieval world their roles and contexts expanded unstoppably.

Around the Origins of Bagpipes: Relevant Hypotheses and Evidences

in Greek and Roman Musical Studies

Sections

References

AgricolaM. Musica Instrumentalis Deudsch 1529 [revised edition 1545] Wittemberg

AlterA. Garhwali Bagpipes: Syncretic Processes in a North Indian Regional Musical Tradition 1997 29 1 Asian Music 1 16

ÁlvarezR. Los instrumentos musicales en los códigos alfonsinos: su tipología, su origen y su uso. Algunos problemas iconográficos Revista de Musicología 1987 X 1 67 104

AndrésR. Diccionario de instrumentos musicales. De Píndaro a J.S. Bach 1995 Barcelona

AlexandreC. La Cornemuse du Languedoc 1977 30 Folklore 2 24

ArasseD. Leonardo da Vinci 1998 New York

AvenaryH. Hieronymus’ Epitel über die Musikinstrumente und ihre altöstlichen Quellen 1961 16 Anuario musical 55 80

BainesA. Bagpipes 1995 [1960]. Oxford

BainesA. The Bagpipe by Francis Collinson 1975 3 3 Early Music 269 271

BarkerA. Greek Musical Writings: I. The Musician and his Art 1984 Cambridge

BarryP. On Luke xv. 25, συμϕωνία: Bagpipe 1904 23 2 Journal of Biblical Literature 180 190

BarryP. Daniel 3:5, Sūmpōnyāh 1908 27 2 Journal of Biblical Literature 99 127

BélisA. Les Musiciens dans l’Antiquité 1999 Paris

BlockE. Chaucer’s Millers and their Bagpipes 1954 29 2 Speculum 239 243 Part 1

BoardmanJ. Engraved Gems. The Ionides Collection 1968 London

BoenigR. The Miller’s Bagpipe: A Note on the Canterbury Tales A565-566 1983 21 1 English Language Notes 1 6

BothA. Music Archaeology: Some Methodological and Theoretical Considerations 2009 41 Yearbook for Traditional Music 1 11

BulloughD. Carolingian Renewal. Sources and Heritage 1991 Manchester

BundrickS.D. Music and Image in Classical Athens 2005 Cambridge

CamposJ. Fiesta, identidad y contracultura. Contribuciones al estudio histórico de la gaita en Galicia 2007 Pontevedra

CamposJ. La Música Popular Gallega en los Años de la Transición Política (1975-1982): Reificaciones Expresivas del Paradigma Identitario 2009 Madrid Published in electronic format: http://eprints.ucm.es/8801/

CannonR. Bagpipes in English Works of Art 1989 42 The Galpin Society Journal 10 31

CannonR. The Highland Bagpipe and its Music 2002 Edinburgh

CarpinteroP. Gaitas e gaitas de fol galegas con cantores de tipo clarinete 2008 11 Etno-Folk 46 58

CharrierM. La respiración circular o espiración continua http://www.adolphesax.com/Html/articulos/MBcircular.htm retrieved 17 November 2004.

CobasV. Esbozo de un estudio sobre la gaita gallega 1955 Santiago de Compostela

CocksW.BainesA.CannonR. Bagpipe, in: The New Grove Dictionary of Music and Musicians 1980 vol. 2 London 19 32

CocksW.BainesA.CannonR. Bagpipe, in: The New Grove Dictionary of Music and Musicians 2005 Oxford

CollinsonF. The Bagpipe. The History of a Musical Instrument 1975 London/Boston

ConnorS. Seeing Sound: The Displaying of Marsyas 2002 http://www.stevenconnor.com/marsyas/ retrieved 5 January 2014.

CookeP. Response to ‘Echoes of our forgotten ancestors’ 2006 48 2 The World of Music 93 100

GerbertM. De Cantu et Musica Sacra 1774 St. Blaise 2 vol.

GrauerV. Echoes of our forgotten ancestors 2006a 48 2 The World of Music 5 58

GrauerV. ‘Echoes of our forgotten ancestors’: author’s reply 2006b 48 2 The World of Music 101 134

HoppinR. La música medieval 2000 Madrid

LandelsJ.G. Music in ancient Greece and Rome 1999 London/New York

LawergrenB. Extant Silver Pipes from Ur, 2450 bc 2000 II Studien zur Musikarchäologie 121 132

Le MoigneR. Quelques éléments sur la tradition populaire de la veuze dans le pays nantais 1979 Nantes

López-AcuñaF.AlonsoX. CañadaS. Gaita Gran Enciclopedia Gallega 1974 vol. 14 Gijón 190 211

MalmW.P. Culturas musicales del Pacífico, el Cercano Oriente y Asia 1985 Madrid

MartialM.V. Epigrams 1920 2 vol. London

MayerH. Bladder pipe, in: The New Grove Dictionary of Music and Musicians 1980 vol. 2 London 770 771

McGeeT. KiblerWilliam W. Musical Instruments Medieval France. An Encyclopedia 1995 New York/London 1223 1227

MillsA. History of the Bagpipe http://www.ccsf.edu/Events_Pubs/Guardsman/f991108/feat05.shtml retrieved 6 December 2004.

MontaguJ. The world of Medieval & Renaissance musical instruments 1976 Woodstock

MooreG.F. Συμϕωνία Not a Bagpipe 1905 24 2 Journal of Biblical Literature 166 175

MunrowD. Instruments of the Middle Ages and Renaissance 1976 London

NovaA. CiammittiL.OstrowS.SettisS. Giorgione’s Inferno with Aeneas and Anchises for Taddeo Contarini Dosso’s Fate: Painting and Court Culture in Renaissance Italy 1998 41 62

PageC. Biblical instruments in Medieval Manuscript Illustration 1977 5 3 Early Music 299 309

ParkerI. The performance of troubadour and trouvere songs. Some facts and conjectures 1977 5 2 Early Music 184 207

PéchéV. Vendries Musique et spectacles dans la Rome antique et dans l’Occident Romain 2001 Paris

PraetoriusM. Syntagma Musicum 1958 [1619] Kassel

RemnantM. Chorus (iii) The New Grove Dictionary of Music and Musicians 1980 vol. 4 London 357 358

RemnantM. Historia de los instrumentos musicales 2002 Barcelona

RolfeJ. Suetonius 1914 London

RomeroP. De foliada en San Pedro de Vilas http://www.galileo-mc.com/cd.php?formatid=77 retrieved 15 Abril 2005.

RonströmO. Making Use of History: The Revival of the Bagpipe in Sweden in the 1980s 1989 21 Yearbook for Traditional Music 95 108

SachsC. La música en la antigüedad 1934 Barcelona

SachsC. The History of Musical Instruments 1940 New York

SachsC. Historia universal de los instrumentos musicales 1947 Buenos Aires

SalazarA. La música como proceso histórico de su invención 1953 México

SchaeffnerA. Origine des Instruments de Musique: Introduction Enthnologigue a L’Histoire de la Musique Instrumentale 1968 [1936] Paris

SchlesingerK. Researches into the Origin of the Organs of the Ancients 1901 2 Sammelbände der Internationalen Musikgesellschaft 167 202

ScottJ.E. Roman music, in: The new Oxford history of music 1986 vol. 1 404 420

StephensD. History at the margins: Bagpipers in Medieval Manuscripts 1989 38 8 History Today 42 48

TranchefortF.R. Instrumentos del mundo 2000 [1980] Madrid

TupperF. The Riddles of the Exeter Book 1910 Boston

VendriesC. Questions d’iconographie musicale: L’apport des terres cuites à la connaissance de la musique dans l’Égypte hellénistique et romaine 2013 1 Greek and Roman Musical Studies 195 227

VirdungS. Musica getutscht 1993 [1511] Cambridge

VoigtA. A Contribution to the History of the Bagpipe 1933 74 1085 The Musical Times 604 605

WardleM.A. Musical Instruments in the Roman World 1981 London 2 vol.

WestM.L. Ancient Greek music 1992 Oxford

WinternitzE. Musical Instruments and Their Symbolism in Western Art: Studies in Musical Iconology 1967 New York/London

WinternitzE. Strange Musical Instruments in the Madrid Notebooks of Leonardo da Vinci 1969 2 Metropolitan Museum Journal 115 126

WinternitzE. Leonardo da Vinci as a musician 1982 New Haven/Londres

2

As an example see Barry (1904) contested by Moore (1905). There was a last reply by Barry (1908) again in the same journal. This literature is today virtually ignored.

22

Parker 1977187. Remnant also assumes enflabotz as bagpipe (2002 207) and Alexandre clarifies that in the language of troubadours bot or botz were parts of the cornemuse (1977 3). See also McGee 1995.

25

Woodcut by Erhard Schön ca. 1530. Image and permission kindly provided by the Herzogliches Museum of Gotha (Germany) cat. 372.

33

Analysis based on Boardman 196821-22 and 93; image on page 63. This Marsyas with bagpipe is probably Hellenistic adds Boardman judging by the secure and bold cutting then dominated for gems by a technique originating in Alexandria.

Figures

Index Card

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 24 24 10
Full Text Views 12 12 11
PDF Downloads 3 3 3
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0