‘Musics’, Bellermann’s Anonymi, and the Art of the Aulos

in Greek and Roman Musical Studies
No Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Apart from the better studied musical ‘handbooks’ of the Roman period, mostly focused on matters of harmonics and sometimes rhythmics, there was a type of text known as ‘Musics’. The article discusses their characteristics, their function in ancient schooling and their relation to extant texts and excerpts, most notably the collection known as Bellermann’s Anonymi. The ‘instrumental exercises’ found at the end of these are evaluated as instrumental pieces posing various challenges to beginners on the aulos; a new rhythmical reconstruction is proposed for one of them.

‘Musics’, Bellermann’s Anonymi, and the Art of the Aulos

in Greek and Roman Musical Studies



  • BarkerA. (1989). Greek Musical Writings 2. Harmonic and Acoustic Theory. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

  • BarkerA. (1994). Greek Musicologists in the Roman Empire. Apeiron 27.4 pp. 53-74.

  • BélisA. (1984). Auloi grecs du Louvre. BCH 108.1 pp. 111-122.

  • BellermannF. (1841). Anonymi scriptio de musica. Bacchii senioris Introductio artis musicae. Berlin: A. Förstner.

  • D’AngourA. (2016). Vocables and Microtones in Ancient Greek Music. In: Greek and Roman Musical Studies 4.2 pp. 273-285.

  • GroningenB.A. van (1940). Short Manual of Greek Palaeography. Leiden: Sijthoff.

  • HagelS. (2000). Modulation in altgriechischer Musik: Antike Melodien im Licht antiker Musiktheorie. Frankfurt: Peter Lang.

  • HagelS. (2004). Calculating Auloi—The Louvre Aulos Scale. In: E. Hickmann and R. Eichmann eds Music-Archaeological Sources: Excavated Finds Oral Transmission Written EvidenceStudien zur Musikarchäologie (Orient-Archäologie) 4 (15)Rahden: Leidorf pp. 373-390.

  • HagelS. (2005). Twenty-four in Auloi: Aristotle, Met. 1093b, the Harmony of the Spheres, and the Formation of the Perfect System. In: S. Hagel and C. Harrauer eds Ancient Greek Music in PerformanceVienna: Österreichischen Akademie der Wissenschaften pp. 51-91.

  • HagelS. (2008a). Ancient Greek Rhythm: The Bellermann Exercises. QUCC 117 (n.s. 88.1) pp. 125-138.

  • HagelS. (2008b). Re-evaluating the Pompeii Auloi. JHS 128 pp. 52-71.

  • HagelS. (2009a). Ancient Greek Music: A New Technical History. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

  • HagelS. (2009b). Reconstructing the Hellenistic Professional Aulos. In: M.C. Martinelli ed. La Musa dimenticata: aspetti dell’esperienza musicale greca in età ellenisticaPisa: Edizioni della Normale pp. 227-246.

  • HagelS. (2010). Understanding the Aulos Berlin Egyptian Museum 12461/12462. In: E. Hickmann and R. Eichmann eds Musical Perceptions Past and Present. On Ethnographic Analogy in Music ArchaeologyStudien zur Musikarchäologie (Orient-Archäologie) 7 (25)Rahden: Leidorf pp. 67-87.

  • HagelS. (2012). The Pompeii Auloi: Improved Data and a Hitherto Unknown Mechanism. In: R. Eichmann and F. Jianjun eds Sound from the Past: The Interpretation of Musical Artifacts in Archaeological ContextStudien zur Musikarchäologie (Orient-Archäologie) 8 (27)Rahden: Leidorf pp. 103-114.

  • HagelS. (2014). Better Understanding the Louvre Aulos. In: R. EichmannF. Jianjun and L.-Ch. Koch eds Papers from the 8th Symposium of the International Study Group on Music Archaeology in Suzhou and Beijing China 20-25 October 2012Studien zur Musikarchäologie (Orient-Archäologie) 9 (33)Rahden: Leidorf pp. 131-142.

  • HagelS. (2016). ‘Leading notes’ in Ancient Near Eastern and Greek music and their Relation to Instrument Design. In: R. EichmannF. Jianjun and L.‐Ch. Koch eds Sound–Object–Culture–HistoryStudien zur Musikarchäologie (Orient-Archäologie) 10 (37)Rahden: Leidorf pp. 135-152.

  • HagelS. (2017). Language and Dance: A Non-Platonising View. In: L. Gianvittorio ed. Choreutika. Performing Dance in Archaic and Classical GreecePisa/Roma: Fabrizio Serra pp. 198-214.

  • HagelS. and LynchT. (2015). Musical Education in Greece and Rome. In: W.M. Bloomer ed. A Companion to Ancient EducationChichester: Wiley-Blackwell pp. 401-412.

  • HirschfeldG. (1875). Inschrift von Teos. Hermes 9 pp. 501-503.

  • HowardA.A. (1893). The Αὐλός or Tibia. HSPh 4 pp. 1-60.

  • HughesD.W. (2000). No Nonsense: The Logic and Power of Acoustic-Iconic Mnemonic Systems. British Journal of Ethnomusicology 9.2 pp. 93-120.

  • JanK. von (1895). Musici scriptores Graeci. Aristoteles Euclides Nicomachus Bacchius Gaudentius Alypius et melodiarum veterum quidquid exstat. Lipsiae: Teubner.

  • MurphyD.J. (1995). Hyphens in Greek manuscripts. GRBS 36 pp. 293-314.

  • NajockD. (1972). Drei anonyme griechische Traktate über die Musik. Kassel: Bärenreiter.

  • NajockD. (1975). Anonyma de musica scripta Bellermanniana. Leipzig: Teubner.

  • PöhlmannE. (1970). Denkmäler altgriechischer Musik. Sammlung Übertragung und Erläuterung aller Fragmente und Fälschungen. Nürnberg: Hans Carl.

  • PöhlmannE. (1975). Rev. of D. NajockDrei anonyme griechische Traktate über die Musik (Göttingen 1972). Die Musikforschung 28 pp. 482f.

  • PöhlmannE. (1994). Musiktheorie in spätantiken Sammelhandschriften. In: A. BierlP. v. Möllendorf and S. Vogt eds Orchestra: Drama Mythos BühneStuttgart/Leipzig: Teubner pp. 182-194.

  • PöhlmannE. (1995). Griechenland. A. Antike Musik. In: MGG2 Sachteil Bd. 3.

  • PöhlmannE. (2018). Ἀνωνύµου σύγγραµµα περὶ µουσικῆς (Anonymi Bellermann). An Agglomeration of Five Musical Handbooks. GRMS 6 pp. 115-127. doi: 10.1163/22129758-12341315

  • PöhlmannE. and WestM.L. (2001). Documents of Ancient Greek Music. The Extant Melodies and Fragments. Oxford: Clarendon Press.

  • PsaroudakesS. (2010). The Hellenistic Side Flute and the Koile-Athens Instrument. Rudiae 22 pp. 519-554.

  • ReinachTh. (1896). Deux fragments de musique grecque. REG 9 pp. 186-215.

  • ReinachTh. (1897). Fragments musicologiques inédits. REG 10 pp. 313-327.

  • RuelleCh.É. (1908). La Solmisation chez les anciens Grecs. Sammelbände der Internationalen Musikgesellschaft 9 pp. 512-530.

  • SutkowskaO. (2012). One of Nine Tibiae from a Villa Rustica in the Vesuvian Area Re-discovered. In: R. Eichmann and F. Jianjun eds Sound from the Past: The Interpretation of Musical Artifacts in Archaeological ContextStudien zur Musikarchäologie (Orient-Archäologie) 8 (27)Rahden: Leidorf pp. 115-125.

  • SutkowskaO. (2015). Archäologische Auloi/Tibia Funde mit Mechanismen. Die Tonkunst 9 pp. 412-422.

  • TerzēsCh. (2014). Koile Plagiaulos Fingering Chart. <https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=690006661090389> (accessed: 2017-10-01).

  • VincentA. (1847). Notices et extraits des manuscrits de la bibliothèque du roi et autres bibliothèques 16.2. Notice sur divers manuscrits grecs relatifs à la musique. Paris: Imprimerie royale.

  • WestM.L. (1992). Ancient Greek Music. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

  • WestphalR. (1865). Allgemeine griechische Metrik. Leipzig: Teubner.

  • Winnington-IngramR.P. (1975). Rev. of D. NajokDrei anonyme griechische Traktate über die Musik (Göttingen 1972). Gnomon 47 pp. 416-418.

  • Winnington-IngramR.P. (1955). Fragments of Unknown Greek Tragic Texts, with Musical Notation (P. Osl. inv. no 1413). ii: The music. SO 31 pp. 29-87.

  • ZanoncelliL. (1990). La manualistica musicale greca. (Euclide) Cleonide Nicomaco Excerpta Nicomachi Bacchio il Vecchio Gaudenzio Alipio Excerpta Neapolitana. Milano: Guerini.



Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 150 150 22
Full Text Views 287 287 41
PDF Downloads 18 18 0
EPUB Downloads 21 21 0