Czech Question as an Answer? The Problem of Unpredictability of National Myths
In: International Journal for History, Culture and ModernitySearch for other papers by Vladimír Štrama in
Current site
Google Scholar
Abstract
The field of nationalism studies has stagnated for the past three decades. What looks like a breath of fresh air is Gerárd Bouchard’s theory of national myths, offering a new perspective on the hitherto largely overlooked study of myths. But while Bouchard brings us closer to the practical utilisation of myths, his theory also implies that the process of mythification is largely unpredictable. Myths seem to emerge and disappear in a rather mysterious manner, preventing us from effectively controlling them. The story of Tomáš Garrigue Masaryk, the first Czechoslovak president, demonstrates this problem. Masaryk originally succeeded in constructing a democratic Czechoslovak myth, but later historical developments rendered his efforts not only ineffective but also counter-productive. The culprit, however, should not be sought in Masaryk’s philosophy or actions, as some authors have suggested, but rather in the unpredictable nature of the mythification process itself.
Purchase
Buy instant access (PDF download and unlimited online access):
Institutional Login
Log in with Open Athens, Shibboleth, or your institutional credentials
Personal login
Log in with your brill.com account
-
Arendt, Hannah. The Human Condition (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1958).
-
Auerbach, Yehudith. “The Reconciliation Pyramid: A Narrative-based Framework for Analyzing Identity Conflicts.” Political Psychology 20 (2) (2009), 291–318.
-
Barnard, Frederick M. “Humanism and Titanism: Masaryk and Herder.” In T. G. Masaryk (1850–1937) Volume 1: Thinker and Politician, ed. Stanley B. Winters (London: MacMillan, 1990), 23–43.
-
Bělohradský, Václav. “Antipolitický Národ v Čechách a na Moravě.” In Česká Otázka a Dnešní Doba, eds. Jan Svoboda and Aleš Prázný (Prague: Filosofia, 2017), 127–136.
-
Bottici, Chiara. A Philosophy of Political Myth (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2007).
-
Bouchard, Gerárd. “Introduction.” In National Myths: Constructed Pasts, Contested Presents, ed. Gérard Bouchard (London: Routledge, 2013), XI–XIV.
-
Bouchard, Gerárd. “The Small Nation With a Big Dream: Québec National Myths (Eighteenth–Twentieth Centuries).” In National Myths: Constructed Pasts, Contested Presents, ed. Gérard Bouchard (London: Routledge, 2013), 1–23.
-
Bouchard, Gerard. Social Myths and Collective Imaginaries, trans. H. Scott (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 2015).
-
Boym, Svetlana. Common Places: Mythologies of Everyday Life in Russia (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1994).
-
Breda, Vito. “Constitutional Patriotism.” In Handbook of Patriotism, ed. Mitja Sardoč (Cham: Springer, 2020), 179–192.
-
Čapek, Karel. Hovory s T. G. Masarykem (Prague: Československý Spisovatel, 1990).
-
Charumbira, Ruramisai. “Gender, Nehanda, and the Myth of Nationhood in the Making of Zimbabwe.” In National Myths: Constructed Pasts, Contested Presents, ed. Gérard Bouchard (London: Routledge, 2013), 206–222.
-
Chlup, Radek. “Competing Myths of Czech Identity.” New Perspectives 28 (2) (2020), 179–204.
-
Chlup, Radek. Czech Auxiliary and Derivative Myths, unpublished paper.
-
Ćwiek-Rogalska, Karolina. “Deceptive Eights and The Czech Question: Tomáš Garrigue Masaryk’s Writing Strategies.” Adeptus 12 (2018), 1–17.
-
Czarniawska, Barbara. Narratives in Social Science Research (London: Sage, 2004).
-
Della Sala, Vincent. “Myth and the Postnational Polity: The case of the European Union.” In National Myths: Constructed Pasts, Contested Presents, ed. Gérard Bouchard (London: Routledge, 2013), 157–172.
-
Dikici, Erdem. “Nationalism Is Dead, Long Live Nationalism! In Pursuit of Pluralistic Nationalism: A Critical Overview.” Ethnicities 22 (1) (2022), 146–173.
-
Dokulil, Miloš. “Rámec Poválečné Politiky Prezidenta Masaryka (Paradoxy, Kritéria a Jistoty Portrétu).” In Masarykova Filozofie Pojetí Demokracie a Existence Pluralitního Politického Systému 1. Republiky, Sborník Příspěvků ze 4. Ročníku Semináře Masarykova Muzea v Hodoníně 21. – 22. 11. 1996, ed. Taťána Martonová (Hodonín: Masarykovo muzeum v Hodoníně, 1997), 32–40.
-
Drozenová, Wendy. “T. G. Masaryk’s Involvement in the Jewish Issue.” Ethics & Bioethics (in Central Europe) 12 (1–2) (2022), 21–28.
-
Eisenstadt, Shmuel. “Multiple Modernities” Daedalus 129 (1) (2000), 1–29.
-
Fukuyama, Francis. “A Country of Their Own: Liberalism Needs the Nation.” Foreign Affairs 101 (3) (2022), 80–91.
-
Gellner, Ernest. “The Price of Velvet: Thomas Masaryk and Václav Havel.” Czech Sociological Review 3 (1) (1995), 45–57.
-
Gonda, Peter., and Zajac, Peter., eds. Socializmus: Realita Namiesto Mýtov (Bratislava: Konzervatívny inštitút M. R. Štefánika, 2020).
-
Gustavsson, Gina., and Miller, David., eds. Liberal Nationalism and its Critics: Normative and Empirical Questions (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2020).
-
Gustavsson, Gina. “Liberal National Identity: Thinner Than Conservative, Thicker Than Civic?” Ethnicities 19 (4) (2019), 693–711.
-
Gyáni, Gábor. A Nation Divided by History and Memory: Hungary in the Twentieth Century and Beyond (London: Routledge, 2021).
-
Hazony, Yoram. The Virtue of Nationalism (New York: Basic Books, 2018).
-
Hoggett, Paul., and Thompson, Simon. Politics and the Emotions: The Affective Turn in Contemporary Political Studies (New York: Bloomsbury Publishing, 2012).
-
Kolakowski, Leszek. The Presence of Myth (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1989).
-
Kosatík, Pavel. Slovenské Století (Prague: Torst, 2021).
-
Krekovič, Eduard., and Mannová, Elena., and Krekovičová, Eva., eds. Mýty Naše Slovenské (Bratislava: Premedia, 2013).
-
Lesser, Jeffrey. “Ethnic Myths as National Identity in Brazil.” In National Myths: Constructed Pasts, Contested Presents, ed. Gérard Bouchard (London: Routledge, 2013), 65–75.
-
Machovec, Milan. Tomáš G. Masaryk (Prague: Melantrich, 1968).
-
Masaryk, T. G., Světová Revoluce za Války a ve Válce 1914–1918 (Prague: Orbis, 1925).
-
Masaryk, T., Česká Otázka (Prague: Městská knihovna v Praze, 2013).
-
Masaryk, T., Sebevražda Hromadným Jevem Společenským Moderní Osvěty (Prague: Jan Laichter, 1904).
-
Mayer, Frederick W. Narrative Politics: Stories and Collective Action (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2014).
-
Meehl, Paul E. Clinical Versus Statistical Prediction: A Theoretical Analysis and a Review of the Evidence (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 1958).
-
Merry, Michael S. “Critical Patriotism.” In Handbook of Patriotism, ed. Mitja Sardoč (Cham: Springer, 2020), 163–178.
-
Mock, Steven J. “Civic Patriotism Versus Ethnic Nationalism.” In Handbook of Patriotism, ed. Mitja Sardoč (Cham: Springer, 2020), 531–544.
-
Nathanson, Stephen. “Moderate Patriotism” In Handbook of Patriotism, ed. Mitja Sardoč (Cham: Springer, 2020), 141–162.
-
Nielsen, Kai. “Cultural Nationalism, Neither Ethnic nor Civic.” In Theorizing Nationalism, ed. Ronald Beiner (Albany: State University of New York Press, 1999), 119–130.
-
Novotný, Zdeněk. “Masarykovo filosofické vlastenectví.” In Česká Otázka a Dnešní Doba, eds. Jan Svoboda and Aleš Prázný (Prague: Filosofia, 2017), 171–176.
-
Orzoff, Andrea. Battle for the Castle: The Myth of Czechoslovakia in Europe, 1914–1948 (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2009).
-
Pecka, Emanuel., and Pána, Lubomír. “Masarykův Realismus a Formování České Politické Kultury.” In Česká Otázka a Dnešní Doba, eds. Jan Svoboda and Aleš Prázný (Prague: Filosofia, 2017), 229–240.
-
Peroutka, Ferdinand. Budování státu I (1918–1919) (Prague: Lidové noviny, 1991).
-
Prázný, Aleš. “Světová Politika Malého Národa: Česká Otázka Jako Úkol Vzdělanosti.” In Česká Otázka a Dnešní Doba, eds. Jan Svoboda and Aleš Prázný (Prague: Filosofia, 2017), 263–288.
-
Sayer, Derek. The Coasts of Bohemia: A Czech History (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1998).
-
Schöpflin, George. “The Functions of Myths and Taxonomy of Myths.” In Myths and Nationhood, eds. Geoffrey Hosking and George Schöpflin (New York: Routledge, 1997), 19–35.
-
Skutil, Jan. “Reflexe Masarykova Humanismu v Jeho Politické Práci a ve Volbách za První Republiky.” In Masarykova Filozofie Pojetí Demokracie a Existence Pluralitního Politického Systému 1. Republiky, Sborník Příspěvků ze 4. Ročníku Semináře Masarykova Muzea v Hodoníně 21. – 22. 11. 1996, ed. Taťána Martonová (Hodonín: Masarykovo muzeum v Hodoníně, 1997), 40–45.
-
Soutphommasane, Tim. “Liberal Patriotism”. In Handbook of Patriotism, ed. Mitja Sardoč (Cham: Springer, 2020), 105–126.
-
Storm, Eric. “A New Dawn in Nationalism Studies? Some Fresh Incentives to Overcome Historiographical Nationalism.” European History Quarterly 48 (1) (2018), 113–129.
-
Subramanian, Narendra. “Myths of the Nation, Cultural Recognition, and Personal Law in India.” In National Myths: Constructed Pasts, Contested Presents, ed. Gérard Bouchard (London: Routledge, 2013), 259–275.
-
Sutherland, Claire. “Nationalism.” In Handbook of Patriotism, ed. Mitja Sardoč (Cham: Springer, 2020), 513–530.
-
Tetlock, P. E., Expert Political Judgment: How Good Is It? How Can We Know?, 2nd ed. (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2017).
-
Tismaneanu, Vladimir. Fantasies of Salvation: Democracy, Nationalism, and Myth in Post-Communist Europe (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1998).
-
Trapl, Miloš. “Úloha T. G. Masaryka v demokratickém systému Československa.” In Masarykova Filozofie Pojetí Demokracie a Existence Pluralitního Politického Systému 1. Republiky, Sborník Příspěvků ze 4. Ročníku Semináře Masarykova Muzea v Hodoníně 21. – 22. 11. 1996, ed. Taťána Martonová (Hodonín: Masarykovo muzeum v Hodoníně, 1997), 3–8.
-
Trojan, Jakub S. “T. G. Masaryk a Náš Dnešek.” In Česká Otázka a Dnešní Doba, eds. Jan Svoboda and Aleš Prázný (Prague: Filosofia, 2017), 73–82.
-
Van den Beld, Antonie. Humanity: The Political and Social Philosophy of Thomas G. Masaryk (The Hague: Mouton, 1975).
-
Wawrzyniak, Joanna., and Pakier, Malgorzata. “Memory Studies in Eastern Europe: Key Issues and Future Perspectives” Polish Sociological Review 183 (2013), 257–279.
-
Wertsch, J. V. How Nations Remember: A Narrative Approach (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2021).
-
Zátka, Vlastimil. “Masarykova Idea Osvícenského Humanismu (Herder, Rousseau, Kant) a Jeho Kritika Romantické Historiografie.” In Česká Otázka a Dnešní Doba, eds. Jan Svoboda and Aleš Prázný (Prague: Filosofia, 2017), 241–262.
-
Zubryzcki, Geneviéve. “Polish Mythology and the Traps of Messianic Martyrology.” In National Myths: Constructed Pasts, Contested Presents, ed. Gérard Bouchard (London: Routledge, 2013), 110–132.
Czech Question as an Answer? The Problem of Unpredictability of National Myths
In: International Journal for History, Culture and ModernitySearch for other papers by Vladimír Štrama in
Current site
Google Scholar
PubMed
Abstract
The field of nationalism studies has stagnated for the past three decades. What looks like a breath of fresh air is Gerárd Bouchard’s theory of national myths, offering a new perspective on the hitherto largely overlooked study of myths. But while Bouchard brings us closer to the practical utilisation of myths, his theory also implies that the process of mythification is largely unpredictable. Myths seem to emerge and disappear in a rather mysterious manner, preventing us from effectively controlling them. The story of Tomáš Garrigue Masaryk, the first Czechoslovak president, demonstrates this problem. Masaryk originally succeeded in constructing a democratic Czechoslovak myth, but later historical developments rendered his efforts not only ineffective but also counter-productive. The culprit, however, should not be sought in Masaryk’s philosophy or actions, as some authors have suggested, but rather in the unpredictable nature of the mythification process itself.