The Labor Question in America: Economic Democracy in the Gilded Age, Rosanne Currarino, Champaign, IL.: University of Illinois Press, 2011

in Historical Materialism
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



It is said we live in a second Gilded Age, which makes our understanding of the first all the more relevant. Rosanne Currarino’s The Labor Question in America makes the bold claim that, far from being a period of defeat for the Left, the original Gilded Age saw an expansion of democratic citizenship. A group of economists, social reformers and labour organisers transformed our understanding of political participation from the earlier, producerist to a more modern, consumerist ideal of social inclusion and collective agency. However, on her own telling, Currarino’s ‘expansion’ comes across more as a ‘substitution’. Some workers gained in wages what they lost in control of the means of production. Though Currarino fairly identifies the utopian aspirations underlying the demand for higher levels of consumption, her narrative relies on an overly rigid distinction between production and consumption, missing out on the way in which consumption came to be defined in ways that assumed the workplace would be a site of submission. Finally, The Labor Question fails to include, as parts of its narrative, the extraordinary violence that marked struggles over the labour question. In this context, the shift from ‘producerist’ emphases on worker control to ‘consumerist’ views of economic citizenship look more like an ideological displacement than they do a progressive expansion of democracy.

The Labor Question in America: Economic Democracy in the Gilded Age, Rosanne Currarino, Champaign, IL.: University of Illinois Press, 2011

in Historical Materialism



AdamicLouis Dynamite: The Story of Class Violence in America 1971 New York Chelsea House Publishers

BrecherJeremy Strike! 1999 Cambridge, MA. South End Press

EagletonTerry Ideology: An Introduction 1991 London Verso

FinkLeon Workingmen’s Democracy: The Knights of Labor and American Politics 1985 Urbana and Chicago University of Illinois Press

ForbathWilliam Law and the Shaping of the American Labor Movement 1991 Cambridge, MA. Harvard University Press

PowderlyTerence Knights of Labor ‘Knights of Labor Platform’ Labor: Its Rights and Wrongs 1886 Washington, DC. The Labor Publishing Company

LeikinSteven The Practical Utopians: American Workers and the Cooperative Movement in the Gilded Age 2004 Detroit Wayne State University Press

LeuchtenburgWilliam E. Franklin D. Roosevelt and the New Deal: 1932–1940 1963 New York Harper Colophon Books

LiebknechtKarl Militarism 1917 New York B.W. Huebsch

MarxKarl MooreSamuelAvelingEdward Capital Volume I 1887 Moscow Progress Publishers available at: <>

MarxKarl ‘Critique of the Gotha Programme’ Marx/Engels Selected Works 1970 Volume 3 Moscow Progress Publishers available at: <>

MontgomeryDavid Workers’ Control in America: Studies in the History of Work Technology and Labor Struggles 1979 Cambridge Cambridge University Press

OestreicherRichard ‘A Note on Knights of Labor Membership Statistics’ Labor History 1984 25 1 102 108

OrrenKaren Belated Feudalism: Labor the Law and Liberal Development in the United States 1992 Cambridge Cambridge University Press

PaulArnold Conservative Crisis and the Rule of Law: Attitudes of Bar and Bench 1887–1895 1960 Ithaca Cornell University Press

PopeJames Gray ‘Labor’s Constitution of Freedom’ Yale Law Journal 1997 106 4 941 1031

RanaAziz The Two Faces of American Freedom 2010 Cambridge, MA. Harvard University Press

StewardIra The Eight Hour Movement: A Reduction of Hours Is an Increase of Wages 1865 Boston Boston Labor Reform Association

StewardIra The Meaning of the Eight Hour Movement 1868 Boston Ira Steward

StewardIra ‘Poverty’ Fourth Annual Report of the Bureau of Statistics of Labor 1873 edited by the Massachusetts Bureau of Statistics of Labor Boston: Wright & Potter State Printers

SylvisWilliam H. SylvisJames C. ‘Address Delivered at Chicago, January 9, 1865’ The Life Speeches Labors and Essays of William H. Sylvis 1872 Philadelphia Claxton, Remsen & Haffelfinger

TaftPhilipRossPhilip GrahamHugh DavisGurrTed Robert ‘American Labor Violence: Its Causes, Character, and Outcome’ The History of Violence in America: A Report to the National Commission on the Causes and Prevention of Violence 1969 available at: <>

The Journal of United Labor ‘Integral Co-operation’ 1884a April 25 694 695

The Journal of United Labor ‘Wages Slavery and Chattel Slavery’ 1884b May 25 702

The Journal of United Labor ‘Chapters on Labor: Chapter I’ 1885 June 10 997 999


Liebknecht 1917pp. 140–1.


Taft and Ross 1969p. 328.


Taft and Ross 1969p. 280.


Forbath 1991p. 104.


Liebknecht 1917p. 146.


Knights of Labor 1886p. 33.


Marx 1887.


Rana 2010quoted at pp. 251–2.


Rana 2010quoted at p. 246. See Rana’s excellent discussion of the limits of consumer citizenship and the ‘new democracy’ (Rana 2010 pp. 242–57).


Fink 1985.


Montgomery 1979.


Leikin 2004.


Marx 1970.


Steward 1865pp. 11–12.


Steward 1873p. 434.


Steward 1868p. 15.


Sylvis 1872p. 172.


See Eagleton 1991pp. 1–31.


Pope 1997passim.


Quoted in Leuchtenburg 1963p. 114.


Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 16 16 8
Full Text Views 17 17 14
PDF Downloads 4 4 2
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0