Rearticulating Contemporary Populism

Class, State, and Neoliberal Society

in Historical Materialism
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

Oriented, descriptively, by recent liberal definitions of populism, this essay pursues a historical-materialist definition that grounds populist antagonisms in class struggles as ‘crystallised’ in the capitalist state. A critical assessment of Laclau’s early equation of populism and socialism inaugurates the reading of Poulantzas’s relational account of class and state as a nascent framework for a theory of populism, centred on the state and its ideological crystallisation of individualisation, the mental/manual-labour division and the ‘people-nation’. This framework is then expanded to articulate the political-economic core of populist antagonisms, the specific character of ‘neoliberal populism’ today, and the potential, in relation to theories of ‘popular politics’ and a ‘communist people’, that left-wing populism might hold as a process of new political productions of class. This reading provides for a more expansive account of such movements’ potentials, beyond a threat to or correction of pre-determined democratic or Marxist schemas.

Rearticulating Contemporary Populism

Class, State, and Neoliberal Society

in Historical Materialism

Sections

References

AgarwalaRina HerringRonald J.AgarwalaRina ‘From Work to Welfare: A New Class Movement in India’ Whatever Happened to Class? Reflections from South Asia 2008 Delhi Daanish Books

Angosto-FerrándezLuis Fernando Angosto-FerrándezLuis Fernando ‘Indigenous Peoples, Populist Logics, and Polarization: Understanding the Pivotal Role of Indigeneity in Venezuelan Elections’ Democracy Revolution and Geopolitics in Latin America: Venezuela and the International Politics of Discontent 2014 London Routledge

ArnoldKathleen R. America’s New Working Class: Race Gender and Ethnicity in a Biopolitical Age 2009 University Park The Pennsylvania State University Press

BadiouAlain MaceyDavidCorcoranSteve The Communist Hypothesis 2010 London Verso

BalibarÉtienne Masses Classes Ideas: Studies on Politics and Philosophy Before and After Marx 1994 London Routledge

BalibarÉtienne We the People of Europe? Reflections on Transnational Citizenship 2004 Princeton Princeton University Press

BalibarÉtienne IngramJames Equaliberty: Political Essays 2014 Durham, NC Duke University Press

BalibarÉtienneWallersteinImmanuel Race Nation Class: Ambiguous Identities 1991 London Verso

BarkerColin BarkerCoxKrinskyNilsen ‘Class Struggle and Social Movements’ 2013 2013

BarkerColin CoxLaurenceKrinskyJohnNilsenAlf Gunvald Marxism and Social Movements Historical Materialism 2013 Leiden Brill Book Series

BerezinMabel Illiberal Politics in Neoliberal Times: Culture Security and Populism in the New Europe 2009 Cambridge Cambridge University Press

BosteelsBruno The Actuality of Communism 2011 London Verso

BrassTom Peasants Populism and Postmodernism: The Return of the Agrarian Myth 2000 Abingdon Frank Cass Publishers

BrayMichael ‘El Estado Somos Todos, El Pueblo Soy Yo? – On Chavismo and the Necessity of the Leader’ Theory & Event 2014 17 1 available at: <http://muse.jhu.edu/login?auth=0&type=summary&url=/journals/theory_and_event/v017/17.1.bray.html >

BrayMichael ‘The Market Thinks It Knows Better than You! – Why Neoliberalism Breeds Populism and What the People Can Do About It’ 2014 paper presented at the Western Political Science Association conference 18 April

BrownWendy ‘Neoliberalism and the End of Liberal Democracy’ Edgework: Critical Essays on Knowledge and Politics 2005 Princeton Princeton University Press

CammackPaul ‘The Resurgence of Populism in Latin America’ Bulletin of Latin American Research 2000 19 2 149 161

CanovanMargaret ‘Trust the People! Populism and the Two Faces of Democracy’ Political Studies 1999 47 1 2 16

CanovanMargaret MényYvesSurelYves ‘Taking Politics to the People: Populism as the Ideology of Democracy’ Democracies and the Populist Challenge 2002 Basingstoke Palgrave

CastelRobert BoydRichard From Manual Workers to Wage Laborers: The Transformation of the Social Question 2002 New Brunswick Transaction Publishers

Ciccariello-MaherGeorge We Created Chávez: A People’s History of the Venezuelan Revolution 2013 Durham, NC Duke University Press

ClarkeSimon ‘Was Lenin a Marxist? The Populist Roots of Marxism-Leninism’ Historical Materialism 1998 3 1 3 28

CoronilFernando The Magical State: Nature Money and Modernity in Venezuela 1997 Chicago University of Chicago Press

DavidsonNeil BarkerCoxKrinskyNilsen ‘Right-Wing Social Movements: The Political Indeterminacy of Mass Mobilisation’ 2013 2013

DaviesWilliam The Limits of Neoliberalism: Authority Sovereignty and the Logic of Competition 2014 London Sage

DeanJodi The Communist Horizon 2012 London Verso

D’EramoMarco ElliotGregory ‘Populism and the New Oligarchy’ New Left Review 2013 II 82 5 28

DischLisa RosenthalTrost ‘The Tea Party: A “White Citizenship” Movement?’ 2012 2012

Di TellaTorcuato S. VelizClaudio ‘Populism and Reform in Latin American’ Obstacles to Change in Latin America 1965 Oxford Oxford University Press

DuménilGérardLévyDominique The Crisis of Neoliberalism 2011 Cambridge, MA Harvard University Press

DusselEnrique ‘Cinco Tesis Sobre el “Populismo” ’ 2007 available at: <http://enriquedussel.com/txt/Populismo.5%20tesis.pdf >.

DusselEnrique Ciccariello-MaherGeorge Twenty Theses on Politics 2008 Durham, NC Duke University Press

EllnerSteve ‘Social and Political Diversity and the Democratic Road to Change in Venezuela’ Latin American Perspectives 2013 40 3 63 82

EvansBradReidJulian EvansBradReidJulian ‘Fascism in All Its Forms’ Deleuze and Fascism – Security: War: Aesthetics 2013 London Routledge

FrankThomas One Market under God: Extreme Capitalism Market Populism and the End of Economic Democracy 2000 New York Doubleday

FraserNancyGordonLinda ‘A Genealogy of Dependence: Tracing a Keyword of the U.S. Welfare State’ Signs 1994 19 2 309 336

García LineraÁlvaro Plebeian Power: Collective Action and Indigenous Working-Class and Popular Identities in Bolivia Historical Materialism 2014 Leiden Brill Book Series

GermaniGino Authoritarianism Fascism and National Populism 1978 New Brunswick Transaction Books

GoldbergDavid Theo The Racial State 2002 Oxford Blackwell

GoodwynLawrence Democratic Promise: The Populist Movement in America 1976 New York Oxford University Press

GramsciAntonio ButtigiegJoseph A. Prison Notebooks 2007 Volume 3 New York Columbia University Press

GudynasEduardo DávilaRhonSchuldtAcostaBarandiarán ‘Diez tesis urgentes sobre el nuevo extractivismo. Contextos y demandas bajo el progresismo sudamericano actual’ 2009 cedla Bolivia Bebbington Alayza and Gudynas 2009

GuerraFrancois-Xavier ‘The Spanish-American Tradition of Representation and Its European Roots’ Journal of Latin American Studies 1994 26 1 1 35

HayekFriedrich August von CaldwellBruce The Collected Works of F.A. Hayek Volume 15: The Market and Other Orders 2014 Chicago University of Chicago Press

JansenRobert S. ‘Populist Mobilization: A New Theoretical Approach to Populism’ Sociological Theory 2011 29 2 75 96

JessopBob Nicos Poulantzas: Marxist Theory and Political Strategy 1985 New York St Martin’s Press

JessopBob State Theory: Putting the Capitalist State in Its Place 1990 Cambridge Polity

JessopBob State Power: A Strategic-Relational Approach 2008 Cambridge Polity

KalbDon KalbDonHalmaiGábor ‘Introduction’ Headlines of Nation Subtexts of Class: Working Class Populism and the Return of the Repressed in Neoliberal Europe 2011 New York Berghahn Books

KlimanAndrew The Failure of Capitalist Production: Underlying Causes of the Great Recession 2012 London Pluto Press

KoningsMartijn The Development of American Finance 2011 Cambridge Cambridge University Press

KrippnerGreta R. Capitalizing on Crisis: The Political Origins of the Rise of Finance 2012 Cambridge, MA Harvard University Press

LaclauErnesto Politics and Ideology in Marxist Theory: Capitalism Fascism Populism 1977 London New Left Books

LaclauErnesto On Populist Reason 2007 London Verso

LapavitsasCostas Profiting Without Producing: How Finance Exploits Us All 2014 London Verso

LoClarence Y.H. RosenthalTrost ‘Astroturf versus Grass Roots: Scenes from Early Tea Party Mobilization’ 2012 2012

MirowskiPhilip Never Let a Serious Crisis Go to Waste: How Neoliberalism Survived the Financial Meltdown 2013 London Verso

ModonesiMassimo Subalternity Antagonism Autonomy: Constructing the Political Subject 2013 London Pluto Press

MottaSara C. ‘Populism’s Achilles’ Heel: Popular Democracy Beyond the Liberal State and the Market Economy in Venezuela’ Latin American Perspectives 2011 38 1 28 46

MouzelisNicos ‘Ideology and Class Politics: A Critique of Ernesto Laclau’ New Left Review 1978 I 112 45 61

MuddeCas ‘The Populist Zeitgeist’ Government & Opposition 2004 39 4 542 563

MuddeCasKaltwasserCristóbal Rovira MuddeCasKaltwasserCristóbal Rovira ‘Populism and (Liberal) Democracy: A Framework for Analysis’ Populism in Europe and the Americas: Threat or Corrective for Democracy? 2012 Cambridge Cambridge University Press

MuhrThomas Venezuela and the ALBA: Counter-Hegemony Geographies of Integration and Development and Higher Education for All 2011 Saarbrücken VDM Verlag

PollackNorman The Humane Economy: Populism Capitalism and Democracy 1990 New Brunswick Rutgers University Press

PoulantzasNicos O’HaganTimothy Political Power and Social Classes 1973 [1968] London New Left Books

PoulantzasNicos FernbachDavid Classes in Contemporary Capitalism 1975 [1974] London New Left Books

PoulantzasNicos CamillerPatrick State Power Socialism 1980 [1978] London Verso

RabyD.L. Democracy and Revolution: Latin America and Socialism Today 2006 London Pluto Press

Rhon DávilaFranciscoJürgenSchuldtAlbertoAcostaAlbertoBarandiarán cedla Bolivia, Anthony Bebbington, Alejandra Alayza and Eduardo Gudynas Extractivismo política y sociedad 2009 Quito CAAP/CLAES

RobertsKenneth M. de la TorreCarlosArnsonCynthia J. ‘Parties and Populism in Latin America’ Latin American Populism in the Twenty-First Century 2013 Washington, DC Woodrow Wilson Center Press

RöpkeWilhelm The Moral Foundations of Civil Society 1996 New Brunswick Transaction Publishers

RosenthalLawrence TrostChristine Steep: The Precipitous Rise of the Tea Party 2012 Berkeley University of California Press

SassenSaskia Expulsions: Brutality and Complexity in the Global Economy 2014 Cambridge, MA Belknap Press

ShaninTeodor Late Marx and the Russian Road: Marx and ‘The Peripheries of Capitalism’ 1983 New York Monthly Review Press

SpronkSusan WebberJeffery R.CarrBarry ‘Neoliberal Class Formation(s): The Informal Proletariat and “New” Workers’ Organizations in Latin America’ The New Latin American Left: Cracks in the Empire 2012 Lanham, MD Rowman and Littlefield

StreeckWolfgang CamillerPatrick Buying Time: The Delayed Crisis of Democratic Capitalism 2014 London Verso

TaggartPaul A. Populism 2000 Buckingham Open University Press

ThomasPeter D. GallasAlexanderBretthauerLarsKannankulamJohnStützleIngo ‘Conjuncture of the Integral State? Poulantzas’s Reading of Gramsci’ Reading Poulantzas 2011 Pontypool Merlin Press

TrotskyLeon EastmanMax History of the Russian Revolution 2008 Chicago Haymarket Books

VeltmeyerHenryPetrasJames The New Extractivism: A Post-Neoliberal Development Model or Imperialism of the Twenty-First Century? 2014 London Zed Books

WeylandKurt ‘Clarifying a Contested Concept: Populism in the Study of Latin American Politics’ Comparative Politics 2001 34 1 1 22

ŽižekSlavoj The Parallax View 2006 Cambridge, MA The MIT Press

ŽižekSlavoj In Defense of Lost Causes 2008 London Verso

2

Motta 2011.

5

Weyland 2001pp. 11 14.

6

Taggart 2000.

7

Canovan 1999 and 2002.

8

Mudde and Rovira Kaltwasser 2012p. 8. This definition was first formulated in Mudde 2004.

10

Laclau 1977pp. 143–98.

11

Laclau 1977pp. 196–7.

12

Raby 2006; Cammack 2000.

13

Laclau 1977p. 159.

14

Germani 1978; Di Tella 1965.

15

Laclau 1977pp. 150–1.

16

Laclau 1977p. 161.

17

Laclau 1977pp. 172–3.

18

Laclau 1977p. 165.

19

Laclau 1977p. 108.

20

Laclau 1977pp. 104–5.

21

Laclau 1977p. 107.

22

Laclau 1977p. 106.

23

Mouzelis 1978p. 57.

25

Laclau 1977p. 167. See also Laclau 1977 p. 196: ‘the resolution of “the people”/power bloc contradiction can only consist in the suppression of the State as an antagonistic force with respect to the people.’

26

Laclau 1977p. 171.

29

Laclau 1977p. 69.

30

Poulantzas 1975p. 21. I follow Bob Jessop here in emphasising ‘strategic-relational’ elements as the most fruitful if still provisional aspects of Poulantzas’s work. See Jessop 1985 and 2008.

31

Cf. Balibar 1994p. 140: ‘there is no “pure” process of exploitation: there is always some domination involved. In fact the idea of “pure exploitation” the purely calculable difference between the value of labour-power and capitalizable surplus value is nothing but an illusion resulting from the contractual form in which the “seller” and “buyer” of labourpower “exchange” their respective “properties.” ’

32

Poulantzas 1980p. 19. This conception of the state encompasses the ‘extended’ or ‘integral’ concept of the state that Gramsci first developed i.e. ‘state + civil society’.

34

Poulantzas 1980p. 62.

35

Poulantzas 1980pp. 65–6.

36

Poulantzas 1973pp. 188–91; Poulantzas 1980 pp. 63–5.

37

Poulantzas 1980p. 73.

39

Balibar and Wallerstein 1991p. 96. The ethnic character of each people-nation highlights the central intersection of populism (but not only populism) with nationalism and racism a connection manifest in most right-wing populisms but also present (if more obscured or ‘historicised’) in left-wing forms. If all modern states are racial (Goldberg 2002) then so must be all people-nations (and all ethnic formations as both Balibar and Goldberg highlight are also gendered/sexualised especially though their (imaginary) connections to kinship and family). Populism in other words is located at the core of ‘the confrontation as well as the reciprocal interaction between the two notions of the people’: ethnos ‘the “people” as an imagined community of membership and filiation’ and demos ‘the “people” as the collective subject of representation decision making and rights’ (Balibar 2004 p. 9). A full rearticulation of contemporary populism must reckon with the specific effects and implications of this confrontation and interaction. In a few subsequent notes I gesture towards elements of such an account but the principal focus here is on the intersection of class antagonisms and demos. A full critical engagement with the notion of ethnos and ultimately how to understand the tensions and intersections between the two is the second core element of my book project on contemporary populism of which this article represents the first. What should be avoided above all is the presumption that populism is intrinsically more racist than other modern political forms. This presumption merely combines ‘neo-racism’ which posits a ‘natural’ basis of xenophobia (Balibar and Wallerstein 1991 p. 26) with a ‘class racism’ which posits the more ‘natural’ or ‘primitive’ character of the dominated classes.

40

Poulantzas 1980pp. 128–9.

41

Poulantzas 1980p. 75.

42

Poulantzas 1980p. 56. Also Poulantzas 1975 pp. 233–4: ‘[T]his division . . . forms in every mode of production divided into classes the concentrated expression of the relationship between political and ideological relations . . . in their articulation to the relations of production . . .’ It is not grounded in the technical character of specific forms of labour – as if there were pure ‘manual’ work that involved no thought or ‘mental’ work of a incorporeal mind. Rather the division itself is the (shifting) product of ideological-political forms that constitute the relations of production.

43

Balibar 2014p. 10. See also Cammack 2000 p. 153.

44

Poulantzas 1980p. 56.

45

As Bob Jessop notes (cf. Poulantzas 1980p. 63) Poulantzas’s account of the unity of the state never escapes an implicit functionalist presumption – the state unifies because that is its necessary function – and so tends to eclipse any account of precisely how such unity is constructed. What populism suggests is that such unity is inherently fragile and contested. The nation-people can become a term in an antagonist confrontation as much as the integrative term for a fragmented set of individuals. The inverse side of this critique is that Poulantzas ‘overlooks the implications of the “isolation effect” for the creation of hegemony in favor of a class reductionist account of political forces and ideologies’ (Jessop 1990 p. 188). Populism is precisely one of the key such implications especially as argued below given neoliberalism’s intensification of that effect. At the same time the homogenising character of race is a central factor in the construction of such unity (Goldberg 2002).

46

Quoted in Modonesi 2013pp. 16–17 (Q25 § 5: 2289).

47

Jessop 1990p. 96.

48

Roberts 2013p. 42. Despite his identification of ‘economic’ initiating causes Roberts retains a liberal discursive definition of populism.

49

Cammack 2000p. 155.

50

Poulantzas 1975p. 311.

51

Poulantzas 1980p. 89.

53

Poulantzas 1980p. 168.

54

Poulantzas 1980p. 169.

55

García Linera 2014pp. 294–5.

59

Pollack 1990; Konings 2011.

61

Fraser and Gordon 1994.

62

Pollack 1990p. 13.

65

For a range of accounts see Lapavitsas 2014Kliman 2012 and Duménil and Lévy 2011.

66

Castel 2002p. xv.

67

Lapavitsas 2014.

69

Barker 2013p. 43.

72

Hayek 2014p. 307.

73

Mirowski 2013p. 81.

74

Röpke 1996p. 159.

75

Davies 2014p. 89. This basic change allows a number of ‘discoveries’ in economics and state regulation including that large corporations do not impede ‘competition’ and that situations that are not strictly speaking ‘markets’ can be rationalised through the application of market-logics of assessment and rational choice.

76

Frank 2000p. xiv.

78

See amongst many others Krippner 2012.

82

Streeck 2014pp. 79–82.

83

Angosto-Ferrández 2014.

84

The obvious exception is Laclau 2007which defines populism as the ground of all politics. The account offered here suggests that the plausibility of such a claim lies rather in the historical conditions of neoliberalism. For elements of a critique of Laclau’s later account of populism see Bray 2014a.

85

D’Eramo 2013p. 20.

86

Dussel 2007p. 4.

87

Badiou 2010; Dean 2012; Bosteels 2011.

91

Dean 2012p. 98; Compare Dussel 2007 p. 12.

92

Dussel 2008p. 74.

93

Dean 2012p. 80.

94

Dean 2012p. 97.

95

Dussel 2008p. 76. I find more unresolved tensions in Dussel’s use of ‘potentia’ and ‘potestas’ than Ciccariello-Maher suggests. Compare the claim that ‘without organization the power of the people remains pure potential . . . objective nonexistence ideal voluntarism and anarchism’ (Dussel 2008 p. 98).

97

Dussel 2008p. 76.

98

Dean 2012p. 69.

100

Žižek 2006p. 269.

101

Muhr 2011p. 41.

102

Sassen 2014.

103

García Linera 2014pp. 229 238 308.

104

García Linera 2014p. 239.

105

Ellner 2013p. 65. The question of whether ethnic/racial identities might undergo analogous (re)formations through such processes in such places must remain an open one here. Something similar at least seems to be projected in Goldberg’s query as to whether states (or peoples?) could become ‘the principal terrains in which social life is played out in all its cultural – what one might characterize as ethnoracial – thickness’ (Goldberg 2002 p. 274).

107

Lo 2012. Also Davidson 2013 p. 292: ‘The people organized by such movements may well be morally and politically misguided but it is patronizing – and above all politically useless – to pretend that they are simply being manipulated by élite puppetmasters’.

108

Agarwala 2008; Spronk 2012.

109

Davidson 2013; Kalb 2011p. 15.

110

Konings 2011p. 52.

113

García Linera 2014p. 156.

114

Gudynas 2009; Veltmeyer and Petras 2014. On the ‘magical state’ see Coronil 1997.

Information

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 80 80 34
Full Text Views 101 101 63
PDF Downloads 10 10 6
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0