Labor’s Conflict: Big Business, Workers and the Politics of Class by Tom Bramble and Rick Kuhn, A Review

in Historical Materialism
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?


The Australian Labor Party (alp) has, until recent years, exercised almost unchallenged hegemony over Australian Left and working-class politics. Tom Bramble and Rick Kuhn have ambitiously crafted the first Marxist history of the party in over 50 years, deploying an analysis of its material constitution as a ‘capitalist workers’ party’ to underpin arguments for a revolutionary socialist alternative. From its emergence in class struggles of the late nineteenth century, to its early electoral successes, to multiple internal crises and splits, and its more recent role in driving neoliberal restructuring, the party’s contradictory character is analysed with clarity. However, despite containing much suggestive material, key issues – including the party’s unparalleled success despite its betrayals, failures and crises; radical challenges from within and without the party; the nature of its appeal to reformist consciousness; the shape of Marxist and Left debates about the alp; and the party’s centrality to a wider sphere of politics in capitalist society – remain thinly theorised, thereby inadvertently weakening the authors’ case for a revolutionary alternative.

Labor’s Conflict: Big Business, Workers and the Politics of Class by Tom Bramble and Rick Kuhn, A Review

in Historical Materialism



ArcherRobin Why Is there no Labor Party in the United States? 2010 Princeton Princeton University Press

BeilharzPeter Transforming Labor: Labour Tradition and the Labor Decade in Australia 1994 Cambridge Cambridge University Press

BrambleTom Trade Unionism in Australia: A History from Flood to Ebb Tide 2008 Cambridge Cambridge University Press

BrambleTomKuhnRick ‘Making Capitalism Acceptable? The Economic Policy of Australian Social Democracy since the 1970s’ Marxism 21 2010 7 4 306 338

CatleyBobMcFarlaneBruce WheelwrightE.L.BuckleyKen ‘Technocratic Laborism – The Whitlam Government’ Essays in the Political Economy of Australian Capitalism Volume One 1975 Sydney Australia and New Zealand Book Company

CavalierRodney Power Crisis: The Self Destruction of a State Labor Party 2010 Melbourne Cambridge University Press

CollettiLucio Marx ‘Introduction’ 1975 1975

DyrenfurthNickSoutphommasaneTim All That’s Left: What Labor Should Stand For 2010 Sydney University of New South Wales Press

GriffithsPhil ‘The Decline of Free Trade in Australian Politics, 1901–1909’ 1998 Department of Modern History Macquarie University Sydney available at: <>

HawkerBruce The Rudd Rebellion: The Campaign to Save Labor 2013 Melbourne Melbourne University Press

HowesPaul Confessions of a Faceless Man: Inside Campaign 2010 2010 Melbourne Melbourne University Press

HumphrysElizabethTietzeTad ‘Anti-politics: Elephant in the Room’ 2013 available at: <>

KirkNeville Labour and the Politics of Empire: Britain and Australia 1900 to the Present 2011 Manchester Manchester University Press

KuhnRick ‘Alternative Strategies: Left Nationalism and Revolutionary Marxism’ Journal of Australian Political Economy 1982 12/13 93 109

KuhnRick ‘The Limits of Social Democratic Economic Policy in Australia’ Capital & Class 1993 17 3 17 52

KuhnRick Henryk Grossman and the Recovery of Marxism 2007 Chicago University of Illinois Press

KuhnRick Class and Struggle in Australia 2005 Frenchs Forest Pearson

KuhnRickO’LincolnTom Class & Class Conflict in Australia 1996 Melbourne Longman Australia

LavelleAshley ‘In the Wilderness: Federal Labor in Opposition’ 2004 doctoral dissertation School of Politics and Public Policy Griffith University Brisbane available at: <>

LeninVladimir Ilyich ‘Speech on Affiliation to the British Labour Party’ Collected Works 1965 Volume 31 Moscow Progress Publishers [1920] available at: <>

LeninVladimir Ilyich ‘In Australia’ Collected Works 1977 Volume 19 Moscow Progress Publishers [1913] available at: <>

ManneRobertMcKnightDavid Goodbye to All That? On the Failure of Neo-Liberalism & the Urgency of Change 2010 Melbourne Black Inc. Agenda

MarxKarl BentonGregorLivingstoneRodney Early Writings 1975 Harmondsworth Penguin Books

McQueenHumphrey A New Britannia: An Argument Concerning the Social Origins of Australian Radicalism and Nationalism 1970 Ringwood Penguin Books

McQueenHumphrey ‘Afterword’ A New Britannia: An Argument Concerning the Social Origins of Australian Radicalism and Nationalism 1986 Revised Edition Ringwood Penguin Books

RobinsonGeoff When the Labor Party Dreams: Class Politics and Policy in NSW 1930–2 2008 Melbourne Australian Scholarly Publishing

RuddKevin ‘The Global Financial Crisis’ The Monthly 2009 February 20 29

TeepleGary Marx’s Critique of Politics 1842–1847 1984 Toronto University of Toronto Press

ThomasPaul Alien Politics: Marxist State Theory Revisited 1994 London Routledge

TietzeTad ‘The Greens, the Crisis and the Left’ Overland 2010 199 27 35

TietzeTad ‘A Change in the Order of Things’ Overland 2013 212 19 27


Kirk 2011p. 54.


Howes 2010; Hawker 2013.


Dyrenfurth and Soutphommasane (eds.) 2010.


Manne and McKnight (eds.) 2010.


Cavalier 2010.


Bramble 2008.


Rudd 2009.


Lavelle 2004pp. 86–7.


Robinson 2008.


Griffiths 1998.


Catley and McFarlane 1975p. 265.


Kuhn 1982.


McQueen 1970; McQueen 1986.


Humphrys and Tietze 2013.


Colletti 1975; Teeple 1984; Thomas 1994.


Marx 1975.


See for example Archer 2010.

Index Card

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 10 10 6
Full Text Views 8 8 8
PDF Downloads 1 1 1
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0