Intersectionality and Social-Reproduction Feminisms

Toward an Integrative Ontology

in Historical Materialism
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

Seeking to capture the multi-layered, contradictory, nature of subjectivities and social positions through a framework which insists upon the complex, dynamic nature of the social, intersectionality feminism has inspired Marxist-Feminists to push the social-reproduction feminism paradigm beyond a narrow preoccupation with gender/class relations. Yet even its most politically radical articulations stop short of fully theorising the integrative logic they espouse. This article explores the roots of this under-theorisation, and suggests that a more fully integrative ontology informs certain formulations of social-reproduction feminism. In understanding the social as constituted by practical human activity whose object (the social and natural world) is organised capitalistically, social-reproduction feminism highlights the dialectical relationship between the capitalist whole and its differentiated parts. The challenge for Marxist-Feminism is to embrace this dialectical approach while building on the insights of intersectionality feminism to more convincingly capture the unity of a complex, diverse social whole.

Intersectionality and Social-Reproduction Feminisms

Toward an Integrative Ontology

in Historical Materialism

Sections

References

  • AckerlyBrookeMcDermottRose ‘Introduction. Recent Developments in Intersectionality Research: Expanding beyond Race and Gender’ Politics & Gender 2012 8 367 370

  • AnthiasFloya ‘Hierarchies of Social Location, Class and Intersectionality: Towards a Translocational Frame’ International Sociology 2012 28 1 121 138

  • Arat-KoçSedef BezansonLuxton ‘Whose Social Reproduction? Transnational Motherhood and Challenges to Feminist Political Economy’ 2006 2006

  • BakkerIsabellaSilveyRachel Beyond States and Markets: The Challenges of Social Reproduction 2008 London Routledge

  • BannerjiHimani ‘Building from Marx: Reflections on Class and Race’ Social Justice 2005 32 4 144 160

  • BannerjiHimani BakanAbigail B.DuaEnakshi ‘Marxism and Anti-Racism in Theory and Practice: Reflections and Interpretations’ Theorizing Anti-Racism: Linkages in Marxism and Critical Race Theories 2014 Toronto University of Toronto Press

  • BezansonKateLuxtonMeg Social Reproduction: Feminist Political Economy Challenges Neo-Liberalism 2006 Montreal and Kingston McGill-Queen’s University Press

  • BilgeSirma ‘Intersectionality Undone: Saving Intersectionality from Feminist Intersectionality Studies’ Du Bois Review 2013 10 2 405 424

  • ButlerJudith Gender Trouble: Feminism and the Subversion of Identity 1990 London Routledge

  • CarbadoDevonCrenshawKimberléMaysVickieTomlinsonBarbara ‘Intersectionality: Mapping the Movements of a Theory’ Du Bois Review 2013 10 2 303 312

  • ChangGrace Disposable Domestics: Immigrant Women Workers in the Global Economy 2000 Cambridge, MA South End Press

  • ColenShellee GinsburgFaye D.RappRayna ‘“Like a Mother to Them”: Stratified Reproduction and West Indian Childcare Workers and Employers in New York’ Conceiving the New World Order: The Global Politics of Reproduction 1995 Berkeley University of California Press

  • CrenshawKimberlé Demarginalizing the Intersection of Race and Sex: A Black Feminist Critique of Antidiscrimination Doctrine Feminist Theory and Antiracist Politics 1989 Chicago University of Chicago Legal Forum

  • DavisKathy ‘Intersectionality as Buzzword: A Sociology of Science Perspective on What Makes a Feminist Theory Successful’ Feminist Theory 2008 9 1 67 85

  • DhamoonRita Kaur ‘Considerations on Mainstreaming Intersectionality’ Political Research Quarterly 2011 64 1 230 243

  • FergusonSusan ‘Building on the Strengths of the Socialist Feminism Tradition’ Critical Sociology 1999 25 1 1 15

  • FergusonSusan ‘Canadian Contributions to Social Reproduction Feminism: Race and Embodied Labor’ Race Gender Class 2008 15 1/2 42 57

  • FergusonSusanMcNallyDavid ‘Capital, Labour-power, and Gender-relations: Introduction to the Historical Materialism Edition of Marxism and the Oppression of Women 2013 Vogel 2013.

  • FergusonSusanMcNallyDavid PanitchLeoAlboGreg ‘Precarious Migrants: Gender, Race and the Social Reproduction of a Global Working Class’ Socialist Register 2015: Transforming Classes 2014 London Merlin Press

  • Gibson-GrahamJ.K. The End of Capitalism (As We Knew It): A Feminist Critique of Political Economy 2006 Minneapolis University of Minnesota Press [1996]

  • GlennEvelyn Nakano ‘From Servitude to Service Work: Historical Continuities in the Racial Division of Paid Reproductive Labor’ Signs 1992 18 1 1 43

  • GramsciAntonio SmithGeoffrey N.HoareQuintin Selections from the Prison Notebooks 1971 New York International Publishers [1929–35]

  • HennesseyRosemary Fires on the Border: The Passionate Politics of Labor Organizing on the Mexican Frontera 2013 Minneapolis University of Minnesota Press

  • Hill CollinsPatricia Black Feminist Thought: Knowledge Consciousness and the Politics of Empowerment 1990 London Routledge

  • Hontagneu-SoteloPierretteAvillaErnestine ZinnMaxine B.Hontagneu-SoteloPierretteMessnerMichael A. ‘“I’m Here, but I’m There”: The Meanings of Latina Transnational Motherhood’ Gender Through the Prism of Difference 2000 Boston Allyn and Bacon

  • KatzCindi ‘Vagabond Capitalism and the Necessity of Social Reproduction’ Antipode 2001 33 709 738

  • KernerIna ‘Questions of Intersectionality: Reflections on the Current Debate in German Gender Studies’ European Journal of Women’s Studies 2012 19 2 203 218

  • LaslettBarbaraBrennerJohanna ‘Gender and Social Reproduction: Historical Perspectives’ Annual Review of Sociology 1989 15 381 404

  • LeBaronGenevieve ‘The Political Economy of the Household: Neoliberal Restructuring, Enclosures, and Daily Life’ Review of International Political Economy 2010 17 5 889 912

  • LeBaronGenevieve ‘Unfree Labor beyond Binaries: Social Hierarchy, Insecurity, and Labor Market Restructuring’ International Feminist Journal of Politics 2014 17 1 1 19

  • LuxtonMeg BezansonLuxton ‘Feminist Political Economy in Canada and the Politics of Social Reproduction’ 2006 2006

  • LuxtonMegFergusonSusanScheinRebeccaCartyLinda ‘Alternatives Forum: Reclaiming Marxist Feminism’ Studies in Political Economy 2014 94 135 184

  • MarxKarl StruikDirk J. MilliganMartin The Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts of 1844 1964 New York International Publishers [1844]

  • MarxKarl Grundrisse 1973 available at: <http://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/download/Marx_Grundrisse.pdf> [1857–61]

  • MarxKarl FowkesBen Capital: A Critique of Political Economy. Volume One 1976 Harmondsworth Penguin

  • MarxKarlEngelsFriedrich The German Ideology 1932 available at: <http://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1845/german-ideology/index.htm> [1846]

  • McCallLeslie ‘The Complexity of Intersectionality’ Signs 2005 30 3 1771 1800

  • McNallyDavid ‘The Dialectics of Unity and Difference in the Constitution of Wage-labour: On Internal Relations and Working Class Formation’ Capital & Class 2015 39 1 131 146

  • MiandaGertrude ‘Féminisme africain: divergences ou convergences des discours?’ Présence Africaine: Revue culturelle du monde noir 1997 155 87 99

  • MilesRobert Racism 1989 London Routledge

  • NashJennifer C. ‘Re-thinking Intersectionality’ Feminist Review 2008 89 1 15

  • OllmanBertell Alienation: Marx’s Conception of Man in Capitalist Society 1971 available at: <www.dialecticalmarxism.com>

  • PalmerPhyllis Domesticity and Dirt: Housewives and Domestic Servants in the United States 1920–1945 1989 Philadelphia Temple University Press

  • PicchioAntonella Social Reproduction: The Political Economy of the Labour Market 1992 Cambridge Cambridge University Press

  • RoedigerDavid R. The Wages of Whiteness: Race and the Making of the American Working Class 1991 London Verso

  • SayersSean Reality and Reason: Dialectic and the Theory of Knowledge 1985 Oxford Basil Blackwell

  • SimienEvelyn M.HancockAnge-Marie ‘Mini-Symposium: Intersectionality Research’ Political Research Quarterly 2011 64 1 185 186

  • VogelLise Marxism and the Oppression of Women: Toward a Unitary Theory 1983 London Pluto Press

  • VogelLise Woman Questions: Essays for a Materialist Feminism 1995 London Routledge

  • VogelLise Marxism and the Oppression of Women: Toward a Unitary Theory 2013 Leiden Brill

  • WilliamsRaymond Marxism and Literature 1977 Oxford Oxford University Press

  • WinkerGabrieleDegeleNina ‘Intersectionality as Multi-level Analysis: Dealing with Social Inequality’ European Journal of Women’s Studies 2011 18 1 51 66

  • WrightMelissa Disposable Women and other Myths of Global Capitalism 2006 London Routledge

  • Yuval-DavisNira ‘Intersectionality and Feminist Politics’ European Journal of Women’s Studies 2006 13 3 193 209

  • ZackNaomi Inclusive Feminism: A Third-Wave Theory of Women’s Commonality 2005 Lanham, MD Rowman and Littlefield Publishers

  • 2

    See Ferguson 19992008; Luxton 2006; Luxton Ferguson Schein and Carty 2014.

  • 4

    Sayers 1985p. 16.

  • 8

    Nash 2008p. 4.

  • 10

    Ackerly and McDermott 2012p. 367.

  • 11

    Davis 2008p. 68.

  • 12

    Ackerly and McDermott 2012p. 367. See Davis 2008 p. 75 for a snapshot of the literature. Also see Butler 1990; Bannerji 2005; McCall 2005; Nash 2008; Winker and Degele 2011.

  • 13

    Yuval-Davis 2006p. 195. The term ‘camp’ is in scare-quotes because each ‘camp’s’ adherents do not rigidly subscribe to and/or defend the distinctions Yuval-Davis draws.

  • 14

    Nash 2008pp. 6 7.

  • 16

    Carbado Crenshaw Mays and Tomlinson 2013p. 206.

  • 17

    Nash 2008p. 12.

  • 18

    See Dhamoon 2011p. 233; Nash 2008 pp. 6–7; and Yuval-Davis 2006 pp. 195–8 for elaborations on these criticisms. See Carbado et al. for a partial rebuttal (Carbado Crenshaw Mays and Tomlinson 2013 p. 308).

  • 20

    Yuval-Davis 2006p. 195.

  • 21

    Nash 2008p. 10.

  • 22

    See for example Yuval-Davis 2006p. 195. Crenshaw and others who take an additive approach will describe oppressions as interdependent but this is asserted rather than explained.

  • 23

    Hill Collins 1990p. 222. Hill Collins uses the term ‘interlocking’ to evoke the necessary relation of systems of oppression in the broader social context (as opposed to the more contingent ‘intersectional’ historical moments).

  • 24

    Dhamoon 2011p. 234.

  • 25

    Dhamoon 2011pp. 238–9.

  • 26

    Anthias 2012p. 130.

  • 27

    Yuval-Davis 2006p. 195.

  • 29

    Dhamoon 2011pp. 238–9 (emphasis added).

  • 30

    Anthias 2012p. 132. Anthias does not explicitly equate ‘translocational’ with ‘transnational’ but is unclear about what else might constitute the former.

  • 31

    Anthias 2012pp. 133 and 131.

  • 33

    See Davis 2008. As well Dhamoon’s ‘matrixes of meaning-making’ (Dhamoon 2011) seem to see power primarily in discursive terms.

  • 35

    See McNally 2015.

  • 36

    Williams 1977pp. 83–9.

  • 37

    Bannerji 2005p. 146.

  • 38

    Bannerji 2014p. 128.

  • 41

    See for example Nash 2008p. 13; and Anthias 2012 p. 131.

  • 42

    Laslett and Brenner 1989p. 382.

  • 43

    Marx 1964p. 111; Marx and Engels 1932 Volume 1 Chapter 1. If this expansive understanding of labour is indeed a premise of history its internal differentiation (over time and across space) needs to be explained. An exclusive focus on any particular form of labour (value-creating or domestic or peasant for instance) risks occluding the wider picture.

  • 44

    Gramsci 1971pp. 34–5.

  • 48

    Ferguson and McNally 2013p. xxv.

  • 50

    For example see Picchio 1992.

  • 51

    Luxton 2006pp. 36–7.

  • 52

    Marx 1973p. 29.

  • 53

    Marx 1976pp. 275 716.

  • 56

    Miles 1989p. 70.

  • 57

    Ferguson 2008; see also Katz 2001.

  • 61

    Ollman 1971Section iii.

  • 68

    See McNally 2015pp. 142–4.

Index Card

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 791 790 88
Full Text Views 546 546 39
PDF Downloads 171 171 31
EPUB Downloads 6 6 2