The Role and Place of ‘Commodity Fetishism’ in Marx’s Systematic-dialectical Exposition in Capital

in Historical Materialism
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



This article aims to contribute to the literature on Marx’s systematic-dialectical method through a critical reading and discussion of the significance and presentational ‘architecture’ of the section on commodity fetishism in the dialectical sequence of form-determinations in Capital. In order to undertake this task, the paper firstly explores the content and expositional structure of the first three sections of Chapter 1 of Capital. This sets the stage for a methodologically-minded close examination of Marx’s presentation of the fetish character of the commodity, which shows that there is a precise systematic sequence which gives unity to the flow of his argument within the section on ‘The Fetishism of the Commodity and its Secret’. The conclusion is that only through a proper grasp of the dialectical method can the full systematic significance and implications of Marx’s account of commodity fetishism be uncovered.

The Role and Place of ‘Commodity Fetishism’ in Marx’s Systematic-dialectical Exposition in Capital

in Historical Materialism



AlbrittonRobert and John Simoulidis (eds.) 2003New Dialectics and Political EconomyBasingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.

AlthusserLouis 2001Lenin and Philosophy and Other Essays translated by Ben BrewsterNew EditionNew York: Monthly Review Press.

AlthusserLouis and Étienne Balibar 1970Reading Capital translated by Ben BrewsterLondon: New Left Books.

ArthurChristopher J. 2001‘Value, Labour and Negativity’Capital & Class73: 1539.

ArthurChristopher J. 2002The New Dialectic and Marx’s CapitalHistorical Materialism Book SeriesLeiden: Brill.

ArthurChristopher J. 2004‘Money and the Form of Value’ in The Constitution of Capital: Essays on Volume I of Marx’s ‘Capital’ edited by Riccardo Bellofiore and Nicola TaylorBasingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.

ArthurChristopher J. 2009‘The Concept of Money’ in Karl Marx and Contemporary Philosophy edited by Andrew Chitty and Martin McIvorBasingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.

BackhausHans G. 2005‘Some Aspects of Marx’s Concept of Critique in the Context of his Economic-Philosophical Theory’ in Bonefeld and Psychopedis (eds.) 2005.

BalibarEtienne 2007The Philosophy of Marx translated by Gregory Elliott and Chris TurnerLondon: Verso.

BellofioreRiccardo 2009‘A Ghost Turning into a Vampire: The Concept of Capital and Living Labour’ in Bellofiore and Fineschi (eds.) 2009.

BellofioreRiccardo 2014‘Lost in Translation? Once Again on the Marx–Hegel Connection’ in Moseley and Smith (eds.) 2014.

BellofioreRiccardo and Roberto Finelli 1998‘Capital, Labour and Time: The Marxian Monetary Theory of Value as a Theory of Exploitation’ in Marxian Economics: A Reappraisal. Volume 1: Essays on Volume III of Capital – Method Value and Money edited by Riccardo BellofioreBasingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.

BellofioreRiccardo and Roberto Fineschi (eds.) 2009Re-reading Marx: New Perspectives after the Critical EditionBasingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.

BonefeldWerner 2010‘Abstract Labour: Against its Nature and On its Time’Capital & Class342: 257276.

BonefeldWerner 2011‘Debating Abstract Labour’Capital & Class353: 475479.

BonefeldWerner and Kosmas Psychopedis (eds.) 2005Human Dignity: Social Autonomy and the Critique of CapitalismAbingdon: Ashgate.

CarchediGuglielmo 2009‘The Fallacies of “New Dialectics” and Value-Form Theory’Historical Materialism171: 145169.

CarchediGuglielmo 2011aBehind the Crisis: Marx’s Dialectics of Value and KnowledgeHistorical Materialism Book SeriesLeiden: Brill.

CarchediGuglielmo 2011b‘A Comment on Bonefeld’s “Abstract Labour: Against its Nature and On its Time” ’Capital & Class352: 307309.

ClarkeSimon 1991Marx Marginalism and Modern Sociology: From Adam Smith to Max WeberBasingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.

De AngelisMassimo 1995‘Beyond the Technological and the Social Paradigms: A Political Reading of Abstract Labour as the Substance of Value’Capital & Class193: 107134.

de VroeyMichael 1982‘On the Obsolescence of the Marxian Theory of Value: A Critical Review’Capital & Class62: 3459.

DimoulisDimitri and John Milios 2004‘Commodity Fetishism vs. Capital Fetishism: Marxist Interpretations vis-à-vis Marx’s Analyses in Capital’Historical Materialism123: 342.

EhrbarHans G. 2010‘Annotations to Karl Marx’s “Capital” ’available at: <>.

EldredMichael and Marnie Haldon 1981‘Reconstructing Value-Form Analysis’Capital & Class13: 2459.

ElsterJon 1985Making Sense of MarxCambridge: Cambridge University Press.

FitzsimonsAlejandro 2012‘Relaciones Mercantiles y Conciencia: una Discusión a partir de los Desarrollos de Marx sobre el Fetichismo’ in Relaciones Económicas y Políticas. Aportes para el Estudio de su Unidad con Base en la Obra de Karl Marx edited by Gastón Caligaris and Alejandro FitzsimonsBuenos Aires: FCE, UBA.

FreemanAlanAndrew Kliman and Julian Wells (eds.) 2004The New Value Controversy and the Foundations of EconomicsCheltenham: Edward Elgar.

HarveyDavid 2010A Companion to Marx’s CapitalLondon: Verso.

HeinrichMichael 2009‘Reconstruction or Deconstruction? Methodological Controversies about Value and Capital, and New Insights from the Critical Edition’ in Bellofiore and Fineschi (eds.) 2009.

HeinrichMichael 2011¿Cómo leer El Capital de Marx? Indicaciones de Lectura y Comentario del Comienzo de El CapitalMadrid: Escolar y Mayo.

HeinrichMichael 2012An Introduction to the Three Volumes of Karl Marx’s ‘Capital’ translated by Alexander LocascioNew York: Monthly Review Press.

HollowayJohn 1992‘Crisis, Fetishism, Class Composition’ in Open Marxism. Volume II: Theory and Practice edited by Werner BonefeldRichard Gunn and Kosmas PsychopedisLondon: Pluto Press.

Iñigo CarreraJuan 2007Conocer el capital hoy. Usar críticamente El CapitalBuenos Aires: Imago Mundi.

Iñigo CarreraJuan 2008El Capital: Razón Histórica Sujeto Revolucionario y ConcienciaBuenos Aires: Ediciones Cooperativas.

Iñigo CarreraJuan 2012‘El capital: determinación económica y subjetividad política’Crítica Jurídica34: 5169.

Iñigo CarreraJuan 2013‘The Method, from the Grundrisse to Capital’ in In Marx’s Laboratory: Critical Interpretations of the Grundrisse edited by Riccardo BellofioreGuido Starosta and Peter D. ThomasHistorical Materialism Book SeriesLeiden: Brill.

Iñigo CarreraJuan 2014‘Dialectics on its Feet, or the Form of the Consciousness of the Working Class as Historical Subject’ in Moseley and Smith (eds.) 2014.

KautskyKarl 1903The Economic Doctrines of Karl MarxLondon: N.C.L.C. Publishing Societyavailable at: <>.

KayGeoffrey 1999‘Abstract Labour and Capital’Historical Materialism5: 255280.

KicillofAxel and Guido Starosta 2007a‘On Materiality and Social Form: A Political Critique of Rubin’s Circulationist Value-Form Theory’Historical Materialism153: 943.

KicillofAxel and Guido Starosta 2007b‘Value-Form and Class Struggle: A Critique of the Autonomist Theory of Value’Capital & Class312: 1340.

KicillofAxel and Guido Starosta 2011‘On Value and Abstract Labour: A Reply to Werner Bonefeld’Capital & Class352: 295305.

LukácsGeorg 1971History and Class Consciousness: Studies in Marxist Dialectics translated by Rodney LivingstoneLondon: Merlin Press.

MarxKarl 1975‘Notes on Adolf Wagner’ in Karl Marx: Texts on Method edited by Terrell CarverOxford: Basil Blackwell.

MarxKarl 1976a‘Results of the Immediate Process of Production’ in Marx 1976c.

MarxKarl 1976bValue: Studies by Marx edited by J.A. DragstedtLondon: New Park Publications.

MarxKarl 1976cCapital: A Critique of Political Economy. Volume One translated by Ben FowkesHarmondsworth: Penguin.

MarxKarl 1987‘Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy’ in Karl Marx–Frederick Engels Collected WorksVolume 29Marx: 1857–1861London: Lawrence and Wishart.

MarxKarl 1988 [1861–3]‘Economic Manuscripts 1861–3’ in Karl Marx–Frederick Engels Collected WorksVolume 30Marx: 1861–1863London: Lawrence and Wishart.

MarxKarl 1993 [1939]Grundrisse: Foundations of the Critique of Political Economy translated by Martin NicolausHarmondsworth: Penguin.

MavroudeasStavros D. 2004‘Forms of Existence of Abstract Labour and Value-Form’ in FreemanKliman and Wells (eds.) 2004.

McGloneTed and Andrew Kliman 2004‘The Duality of Labour’ in FreemanKliman and Wells (eds.) 2004.

MohunSimon and Susan Himmelweit 1978‘The Anomalies of Capital’Capital & Class23: 67105.

MoseleyFred (ed.) 1993Marx’s Method in Capital: A ReexaminationAtlantic Highlands, NJ: Humanities Press.

MoseleyFred and Martha Campbell (eds.) 1997New Investigations of Marx’s MethodAtlantic Highlands, NJ: Humanities Press.

MoseleyFred and Tony Smith (eds.) 2014Marx’s Capital and Hegel’s Logic: A ReexaminationHistorical Materialism Book SeriesLeiden: Brill.

MurrayPatrick 1988Marx’s Theory of Scientific KnowledgeAtlantic Highlands, NJ: Humanities Press.

MurrayPatrick 2000‘Marx’s “Truly Social” Labour Theory of Value: Part I, Abstract Labour in Marxian Value Theory’Historical Materialism6: 2766.

MurrayPatrick 2002‘Reply to Geert Reuten’Historical Materialism101: 155176.

O’KaneChris 2013Fetishism and Social Domination in Marx Lukács Adorno and Lefebvreunpublished PhD Dissertation Centre for Social and Political Thought University of Sussex uk.

OllmanBertell 2003‘Marx’s Method is More than a Mode of Exposition: A Critique of Systematic Dialectics’ in Albritton and Simoulidis (eds.) 2003.

PostoneMoishe 1996Time Labor and Social Domination: A Reinterpretation of Marx’s Critical TheoryCambridge: Cambridge University Press.

ReicheltHelmut 1995‘Why did Marx Conceal his Dialectical Method?’ in Open Marxism. Volume III: Emancipating Marx edited by Werner BonefeldRichard GunnJohn Holloway and Kosmas PsychopedisLondon: Pluto Press.

ReicheltHelmut 2005‘Social Reality as Appearance: Some Notes on Marx’s Conception of Reality’ in Bonefeld and Psychopedis (eds.) 2005.

ReicheltHelmut 2007‘Marx’s Critique of Economic Categories: Reflections on the Problem of Validity in the Dialectical Method of Presentation in Capital’Historical Materialism154: 352.

ReutenGeert 1993‘The Difficult Labor of a Theory of Social Value: Metaphors and Systematic Dialectics at the Beginning of Marx’s “Capital” ’ in Moseley (ed.) 1993.

ReutenGeert 2000‘The Interconnection of Systematic Dialectics and Historical Materialism’Historical Materialism7: 137166.

ReutenGeert 2014‘An Outline of the Systematic-Dialectical Method: Scientific and Political Significance’ in Moseley and Smith (eds.) 2014.

ReutenGeert and Michael Williams 1989Value-Form and the State: The Tendencies of Accumulation and the Determination of Economic Policy in Capitalist SocietyLondon: Routledge.

RobertsBruce 2004‘Value, Abstract Labour and Exchange Equivalence’ in FreemanKliman and Wells (eds.) 2004.

Robles BáezMario L. 2004‘On the Abstraction of Labour as a Social Determination’ in FreemanKliman and Wells (eds.) 2004.

RubinIsaak Illich 1972Essays on Marx’s Theory of Value translated by Miloš Samardžija and Fredy PerlmanDetroit: Black and Red.

Saad-FilhoAlfredo 1997‘Concrete and Abstract Labour in Marx’s Theory of Value’Review of Political Economy94: 457477.

SchulzGuido 2012‘Marx’s Distinction between the Fetish Character of the Commodity and Fetishism’Studies in Social and Political Thought20: 2545.

SmithTony 1990The Logic of Marx’s Capital: Replies to Hegelian CriticismsAlbany: SUNY Press.

StarostaGuido 2008‘The Commodity-Form and the Dialectical Method: On the Structure of Marx’s Exposition in Chapter 1 of Capital’Science & Society723: 295318.

StarostaGuido 2016Marx’s Capital Method and Revolutionary SubjectivityHistorical Materialism Book SeriesLeiden: Brill.

ZelenýJindich 1980The Logic of MarxOxford: Basil Blackwell.

Index Card

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 61 61 32
Full Text Views 32 32 32
PDF Downloads 9 9 9
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0