Limits of the Universal: The Promises and Pitfalls of Postcolonial Theory and Its Critique

in Historical Materialism
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



This article seeks to reassess the potential merits and weaknesses of the Subaltern Studies project through the prism of Vivek Chibber’s much-publicised and controversial book Postcolonial Theory and the Specter of Capital. By critically examining Chibber’s work, the article aims to better pinpoint exactly what is ‘right’ and ‘wrong’ with the Subaltern Studies project, while drawing out some productive points of engagement between Marxism and postcolonial theory more generally. In particular, we argue that an understanding of the origins of capitalist modernity remains a relatively unexplored omission within postcolonial thought that problematises their broader project of ‘provincialising Europe’. Against this backdrop, the article explores the affinities between Leon Trotsky’s notion of uneven and combined development and postcolonialism, demonstrating how the former can provide a theoretical solution to the problem of Eurocentrism that the Subaltern Studies project correctly identifies but inadequately conceptualises.

Limits of the Universal: The Promises and Pitfalls of Postcolonial Theory and Its Critique

in Historical Materialism



AcharyaAmitav 2011‘Dialogue and Discovery: In Search of International Relations Theories beyond the West’Millennium – Journal of International Studies393: 619637.

AhmadAijaz 1992In Theory: Classes Nations LiteraturesLondon: Verso.

AhmedTalat 2014‘Theories of Difference: The Subaltern Project Examined’International SocialismII144available at: <>.

AlcoffLinda and Nancy Fraser 2005Visible Identities: Race Gender and the SelfOxford: Oxford University Press.

AndersonPerry 1992English QuestionsLondon: Verso.

AnievasAlexander and Kerem Nişancıoğlu 2015How the West Came to Rule: The Geopolitical Origins of CapitalismLondon: Pluto Press.

AnievasAlexander and Kerem Nişancıoğlu 2016‘Why Europe? Anti-Eurocentric Theory, History, and the Rise of Capitalism’Spectrum: Journal of Global Studies81: 7098.

BanajiJairus 2010Theory as History: Essays on Modes of Production and Exploitation Historical Materialism Book SeriesLeiden: Brill.

BandyopadhyaySekhar 2004Caste Culture and Hegemony: Social Dominance in Colonial BengalNew Delhi: Sage Publications.

BartolovichCrystal and Neil Lazarus (ed)s. 2002Marxism Modernity and Postcolonial StudiesCambridge: Cambridge University Press.

BhabhaHomi K. 2012The Location of CultureLondon: Routledge.

BhambraGurminder K. 2007Rethinking Modernity and the Sociological ImaginationLondon: Routledge.

BhambraGurminder K. 2011‘Talking among Themselves? Weberian and Marxist Historical Sociologies as Dialogues without “Others” ’Millennium393: 667681.

BlaneyDavid and Naeem Inayatullah 2010Savage Economics: Wealth Poverty and the Temporal Walls of CapitalismNew York: Routledge.

BrennanTimothy 2014Borrowed Light: Vico Hegel and the ColoniesStanford: Stanford University Press.

BryceDerek 2013‘The Absence of Ottoman, Islamic Europe in Edward W. Said’s Orientalism’Theory Culture & Society301: 99121.

ChakrabartyDipesh 2000Re-Writing Working Class History: Bengal 1890–1940Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

ChakrabartyDipesh 2005‘Subaltern Studies and Postcolonial Historiography’Nepantla: Views from South11: 932.

ChakrabartyDipesh 2008Provincializing Europe: Postcolonial Thought and Historical DifferenceSecond EditionPrinceton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

ChatterjeePartha 1983‘Peasants, Politics and Historiography: A Response’Social Scientist115: 6465.

ChatterjeePartha 1993The Nation and Its Fragments: Colonial and Postcolonial HistoriesPrinceton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

ChatterjeePartha 2010‘A Brief History of Subaltern Studies’ in Empire and Nation: Selected EssaysNew York: Columbia University Press.

ChatterjeePartha 2013‘Subaltern Studies and Capital’Economic & Political Weekly4837: 6975.

ChattopadhyayaUtathya 2014‘Time to Move On? A Response to Vivek Chibber’KritikUnit for Criticism and Interpretive TheoryUniversity of Illinois available at: <>.

ChibberVivek 2011‘What Is Living and What Is Dead in the Marxist Theory of History?’Historical Materialism 192: 6091.

ChibberVivek 2013Postcolonial Theory and the Specter of CapitalLondon: Verso.

ChibberVivek 2014a‘Revisiting Subaltern Studies’Economic & Political Weekly499: 8285.

ChibberVivek 2014b‘Making Sense of Postcolonial Theory: A Response to Gayatri Chakravorty Spivak’Cambridge Review of International Affairs273: 617624.

CooperFrederick 2005Colonialism in Question: Theory Knowledge HistoryBerkeley: University of California Press.

CoronilFernando 1996‘Beyond Occidentalism: Toward Nonimperial Geohistorical Categories’Cultural Anthropology111: 5187.

DavidsonNeil 2012How Revolutionary Were the Bourgeois Revolutions?Chicago: Haymarket Books.

DelphyChristine and Diana Leonard 1984Close to Home: A Materialist Analysis of Women’s Oppression translated and edited by Diana LeonardLondon: Hutchinson in association with the Explorations in Feminism Collective.

DirlikArif 1997The Postcolonial Aura: Third World Criticism in the Age of Global CapitalismOxford: Westview Press.

FanonFrantz 1963The Wretched of the Earth translated by Constance FarringtonNew York: Grove Press.

FedericiSilvia 2012Revolution at Point Zero: Housework Reproduction and Feminist StruggleOakland, CA: PM Press.

GoswamiManu 2004Producing India: From Colonial Economy to National SpaceChicago: University of Chicago Press.

GuhaRanajit 1982‘On Some Aspects of the Historiography of Colonial India’Subaltern Studies1: 18.

GuhaRanajit 1997Dominance without Hegemony: History and Power in Colonial IndiaCambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

HalperinSandra 2006‘International Relations Theory and the Hegemony of Western Conceptions of Modernity’ in Decolonizing International Relations edited by Branwen Gruffydd JonesLanham, MD: Rowman and Littlefield.

InayatullahNaeem and David L. Blaney 2004International Relations and the Problem of DifferenceNew York: Routledge.

JaniPranav 2014‘Marxism and the Future of Postcolonial Theory’International Socialist Review922available at: <>.

Journal of World-Systems Research 2014‘Book Review Symposium on Postcolonial Theory and the Specter of Capital by Vivek Chibber’ edited by Ho-fung Hung221: 281317.

KaiwarVasant 2004‘Towards Orientalism and Nativism: The Impasse of Subaltern Studies. Review of Provincializing Europe: Postcolonial Thought and Historical Difference by Dipesh Chakrabarty and Dominance without Hegemony: History and Power in Colonial India by Ranajit Guha’Historical Materialism122: 189247.

KaiwarVasant 2014The Postcolonial Orient: The Politics of Difference and the Project of Provincialising Europe Historical Materialism Book Series, Leiden: Brill.

LarsenNeil 2001Determinations: Essays on Theory Narrative and Nation in the AmericasLondon: Verso.

LazarusNeil 2002‘The Fetish of “The West” in Postcolonial Theory’ in Marxism Modernity and Postcolonial Studies edited by Crystal Bartolovich and Neil LazarusCambridge: Cambridge University Press.

LazarusNeil 2011The Postcolonial UnconsciousCambridge: Cambridge University Press.

LazarusNeil 2016‘Vivek Chibber and the Specter of Postcolonial Theory’Race & Class573: 88106.

LazarusNeil and Rashmi Varma 2008‘Marxism and Postcolonial Studies’ in Critical Companion to Contemporary Marxism edited by Jacques Bidet and Stathis KouvelakisHistorical Materialism Book SeriesLeiden: Brill.

LevienMichael 2013‘Subalternists Scrutinized. Review of Postcolonial Theory and the Specter of Capital by Vivek Chibber’European Journal of Sociology543: 485497.

LöwyMichael 1981The Politics of Combined and Uneven Development: The Theory of Permanent RevolutionLondon: Verso.

MarxKarl 1973Grundrisse: Foundations of the Critique of Political Economy translated by Martin NicolausHarmondsworth: Penguin.

MatinKamran 2013‘Redeeming the Universal: Postcolonialism and the Inner Life of Eurocentrism’European Journal of International Relations192: 353377.

MillsCharles W. 1997The Racial ContractIthaca, NY: Cornell University Press.

MurphetJulian 2014‘No Alternative’The Cambridge Journal of Postcolonial Literary Inquiry11: 157163.

NilsenAlf Gunvald 2015‘Passages from Marxism to Postcolonialism: A Comment on Vivek Chibber’s Postcolonial Theory and the Specter of Capital’Critical SociologyOnlineFirst <>.

ParryBenita 2004Postcolonial Studies: A Materialist CritiqueLondon: Routledge.

ParryBenita 2017‘The Constraints of Chibber’s Criticism’Historical Materialism251: 185206.

RosenbergJustin 2006‘Why Is There No International Historical Sociology?’European Journal of International Relations123: 307340.

RosenbergJustin 2013‘The Philosophical Premises of Uneven and Combined Development’Review of International Studies393: 569597.

RoyAnanya 2015‘Who Is Afraid of Postcolonial Theory?’International Journal of Urban and Regional ResearchOnlineFirst <>.

SaidEdward 1978Orientalism: Western Conceptions of the OrientLondon: Routledge and Kegan Paul.

SchwartzMichael 2014‘Capitalist Development, Structural Constraint and Human Agency in the Global South’Journal of World-Systems Research202: 294299.

SethSanjay 2014‘Review of Postcolonial Theory and the Spectre of Capital by Vivek Chibber’American Historical Review1194: 12181220.

ShilliamRobbie 2009‘The Atlantic as a Vector of Uneven and Combined Development’Cambridge Review of International Affairs221: 6988.

SpivakGayatri Chakravorty 2014‘Postcolonial Theory and the Specter of Capital’Cambridge Review of International Affairs271: 184198.

TaylorMarcus 2010‘Histories of World Capitalism, Methodologies of World Labour: Rethinking Uneven Development’paper presented at the ECPR Standing Group on International RelationsStockholm15 July.

TenbruckFriedrich 1994‘Internal History of Society or Universal History’Theory Culture & Society11: 7593.

TrotskyLeon D. 1962 [1931/1906]The Permanent Revolution and Results & ProspectsLondon: New Park Publications.

TrotskyLeon D. 1969 [1907]1905Paris: Les Éditions de Minuit.

TrotskyLeon D. 1972 [1933]‘Uneven and Combined Development and the Role of American Imperialism: Minutes of a Discussion’ in Writings of Leon Trotsky 1932–33 edited by George Breitman and Sarah LovellNew York: Pathfinder.

TrotskyLeon D. 2008 [1930–1932]The History of the Russian Revolution translated by Max EastmanChicago: Haymarket Books.

VanaikAchin 2013‘Powerful Critique of Postcolonial Theory’Economic & Political Weekly4828: 2731.

WashbrookDavid 1990‘South Asia, the World System, and World Capitalism’The Journal of Asian Studies493: 479482.

WatsonMatthew C. 2013‘The Poverty of Postcolonial Theory?’Postcolonial Studies162: 230232.

YoungRobert J.C. 2001Postcolonialism: An Historical IntroductionOxford: Blackwell.

Index Card

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 54 54 49
Full Text Views 24 24 24
PDF Downloads 6 6 6
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0