Thinking Through Balibar’s Dialectics of Emancipation

A Review of Equaliberty: Political Essays by Étienne Balibar

in Historical Materialism
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



In this review, I discuss Balibar’s ‘proposition of equaliberty’ with regard to its theoretical status and contribution, its relationship to other contemporary theories of radical democracy as well as to the problematic of bourgeois versus communist emancipation in Marx. The primary interest of this essay is to develop a detailed understanding of Balibar’s analytical schema, which draws a complex picture of our contemporary ‘human condition’, and to place it within his own theoretical development since his contribution to Reading Capital in the 60s. On that basis, it will be possible to assess his contribution to thinking politics with and after Marx and place it more concretely within the generalised radical-democratic turn in post-Marxist theory.

Thinking Through Balibar’s Dialectics of Emancipation

A Review of Equaliberty: Political Essays by Étienne Balibar

in Historical Materialism



AbensourMiguel 2011Democracy against the State: Marx and the Machiavellian Moment edited by Martin Breaugh and translated by Max BlechmanCambridge: Polity Press.

AlthusserLouis 2014On The Reproduction of Capitalism: Ideology And Ideological State ApparatusesLondon: Verso.

ArendtHannah 1965On RevolutionHarmondsworth: Penguin.

ArendtHannah 1972Crises of the Republic: Lying in Politics – Civil Disobedience – On Violence – Thoughts on Politics and RevolutionNew York: Mariner Books.

ArendtHannah 1973The Origins of TotalitarianismNew EditionNew York: Harcourt, Inc.

ArtousAntoine 2010Démocratie citoyenneté émancipation: Marx Lefort Balibar Rancière Rosanvallon Negri…Paris: Éditions Syllepse.

BadiouAlain 2001Ethics: An Essay on the Understanding of Evil translated by Peter HallwardLondon: Verso.

BadiouAlain 2008Peut-on penser la politique?Paris: Seuil.

BalibarÉtienne 1974Cinq Études du matérialisme historiqueParis: François Maspero.

BalibarÉtienne 1977On the Dictatorship of the Proletariat translated by Grahame LockAtlantic Highlands, NJ.: Humanities Press.

BalibarÉtienne 1981a‘De Charonne à Vitry’Le Nouvel Observateur852available at: <>accessed 11 September 2017.

BalibarÉtienne 1981b‘Marx, le joker ou le tiers inclus’ in BalibarFerryLacoue-LabartheLyotard and Nancy (eds.) 1981.

BalibarÉtienne 1985‘Marx, the Joker in the Pack (or the Included Middle)’Economy and Society141: 127.

BalibarÉtienne 1987La Contradiction infinie: éléments d’une philosophie dans l’histoireDoctoral ThesisUniversiteit Katholieke te Nijmegen.

BalibarÉtienne 1991‘Citizen Subject’ in Who Comes after the Subject? edited by Eduardo CadavaPeter Connor and Jean-Luc NancyLondon: Routledge.

BalibarÉtienne 1993Die Grenzen der DemokratieHamburg: Argument.

BalibarÉtienne 1994aMasses Classes Ideas: Studies on Politics and Philosophy before and after MarxLondon: Routledge.

BalibarÉtienne 1994b‘Subjection and Subjectivation’ in Supposing the Subject edited by Joan CopjecLondon: Verso.

BalibarÉtienne 1995‘The Infinite Contradiction’Yale French Studies88: 142164.

BalibarÉtienne 1996‘Structural Causality: Overdetermination and Antagonism’ in Postmodern Materialism and the Future of Marxist Theory: Essays in the Althusserian Tradition edited by Antonio Callari and David F. RuccioMiddletown, CT.: Wesleyan University Press.

BalibarÉtienne 1997a‘Un Jacobin nommé Marx?’ in La Crainte des masses: Politique et philosophie avant et après MarxParis: Éditions Galilée.

BalibarÉtienne 1997bSpinoza: From Individuality to TransindividualityDelft: Eburon Academic Publishers.

BalibarÉtienne 1998Droit de citéLa Tour d’Aigues: Éditions de l’Aube.

BalibarÉtienne 2002Politics and the Other Scene translated by Christine JonesJames Swenson and Chris TurnerLondon: Verso.

BalibarÉtienne 2004We the People of Europe?: Reflections on Transnational Citizenship translated by James SwensonPrinceton: Princeton University Press.

BalibarÉtienne 2010Violence et civilité: Wellek Library Lectures et autres essais de philosophie politiqueParis: Éditions Galilée.

BalibarÉtienne 2011Citoyen sujet et autres essais d’anthropologie philosophiqueParis: Presses Universitaires de France.

BalibarÉtienne 2012‘Les questions du communisme’available at: <>accessed 11 September 2017.

BalibarÉtienne 2013Marx’ PhilosophieBerlin: b_books.

BalibarÉtienne 2014aEqualiberty: Political Essays translated by James IngramDurham, NC.: Duke University Press.

BalibarÉtienne 2014bThe Philosophy of Marx translated by Gregory Elliott and Chris TurnerLondon: Verso.

BalibarÉtienne 2015Violence and Civility: On the Limits of Political Philosophy translated by G.M. Goshgarian New York: Columbia University Press.

BalibarÉtienne 2016Citizen Subject: Foundations for Philosophical Anthropology translated by Steven Miller New York: Fordham University Press.

BalibarÉtienneLuc FerryPhilippe Lacoue-LabartheJean-François Lyotard and Jean-Luc Nancy (eds.) 1981Rejouer le politique: travaux du Centre de recherches philosophiques sur le politiqueParis: Éditions Galilée.

BalibarÉtienneCesare Luporini and André Tosel 1979Marx et sa critique de la politiqueParis: François Maspero.

BalibarÉtienne and Gérard Raulet (eds.) 2001Marx démocrate: le manuscrit de 1843Paris: Presses Universitaires de France.

BehrentMichael 2004‘Religion, Republicanism and Depoliticisation: Two Intellectual Itineraries – Régis Debray and Marcel Gauchet’ in After the Deluge: New Perspectives on the Intellectual and Cultural History of Postwar France edited by Julian BourgLanham, MD.: Lexington Books.

BrombergSvenja 2014‘Badiou’s Recommencement of the Young-Hegelian Purification of Politics: A Response to Ishay Landa’International Critical Thought43: 367383.

BrombergSvenja 2017Thinking ‘Emancipation’ after Marx: A Conceptual Analysis of Emancipation between Citizenship and Revolution in Marx and BalibarPhD Dissertation Goldsmiths University of London (unpublished).

CelikatesRobin 2010‘Ziviler Ungehorsam und radikale Demokratie: konstitutierende vs. konstituierte Macht?’ in Das Politische und die Politik edited by Thomas Bedorf and Kurt RöttgersFrankfurt: Suhrkamp.

FarrisSara 2014‘From the Jewish Question to the Muslim Question: Republican Rigorism, Culturalist Differentialism and Antinomies of Enforced Emancipation’Constellations212: 296307.

FedericiSilvia 2012 [2008]‘The Reproduction of Labor Power in the Global Economy and the Unfinished Feminist Revolution’ in Revolution at Point Zero: Housework Reproduction and Feminist StruggleOakland, CA.: PM Press.

FischerSibylle 2004Modernity Disavowed: Haiti and the Cultures of Slavery in the Age of RevolutionDurham, NC.: Duke University Press.

FuretFrançois 1981Interpreting the French Revolution translated by Elborg ForsterCambridge: Cambridge University Press.

FuretFrançoisJacques Julliard and Pierre Rosanvallon 1989La République du centre: La fin de l’exception françaiseParis: Hachette Littérature.

Gaille-NikodimovMarieJustine Lacroix and Diogo Sardinha 2014Pourquoi Balibar?Rennes: Presses Universitaires de Rennes.

GastautYvan 2000L’immigration et l’opinion en France sous la Ve RépubliqueParis: Seuil.

HabermasJürgen 1988‘Natural Law and Revolution’ in Theory and Practice translated by John ViertelBoston: Beacon Press.

IngramJames D. 2015‘Democracy and Its Conditions: Étienne Balibar and the Contribution of Marxism to Radical Democracy’ in Thinking Radical Democracy: The Return to Politics in Post-War France edited by Martin BreaughChristopher HolmanRachel MagnussonPaul Mazzocchi and Devin PennerToronto: University of Toronto Press.

JainchillAndrew and Samuel Moyn 2004‘French Democracy between Totalitarianism and Solidarity: Pierre Rosanvallon and Revisionist Historiography’The Journal of Modern History761: 107154.

KouvelakisStathis 2005‘The Marxian Critique of Citizenship: For a Rereading of On the Jewish QuestionSouth Atlantic Quarterly1044: 707721.

LaclauErnesto 2007Emancipation(s)London: Verso.

LefortClaude 1986The Political Forms of Modern Society: Bureaucracy Democracy Totalitarianism edited by John B. ThompsonCambridge, MA.: The MIT Press.

MaihoferAndrea 1992Das Recht bei Marx. Zur dialektischen Struktur von Gerechtigkeit Menschenrechten und RechtBaden-Baden: Nomos Verlagsgesellschaft.

MarxKarl 1975Early Writings translated by Rodney Livingstone and Gregor BentonHarmondsworth: Penguin.

MezzadraSandro and Brett Neilson 2013Border as Method or The Multiplication of LaborDurham, NC.: Duke University Press.

MontagWarren and Hanan Elsayed (eds.) 2017Balibar and the Citizen SubjectEdinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.

MoynSamuel 2012aThe Last Utopia: Human Rights in HistoryCambridge, MA.: Belknap Press.

MoynSamuel 2012b‘The Politics of Individual Rights: Marcel Gauchet and Claude Lefort’ in French Liberalism from Montesquieu to the Present Day edited by Raf Geenens and Helena RosenblattCambridge: Cambridge University Press.

NegriAntonio 2009Insurgencies: Constituent Power and the Modern State translated by Maurizia BoscagliSecond Revised EditionMinneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.

NiederbergerAndreas 2008‘Wie viel Gemeinwohl braucht die Republik? Überlegungen zu neuen Varianten des Republikanismus jenseits von substantieller Gemeinschaft und Tugend’ in Politik der Gemeinschaft: zur Konstitution des Politischen in der Gegenwart edited by Janine Böckelmann and Claas MorgenrothBielefeld: transcript Verlag.

OgilvieBertrand 2012La Seconde Nature du Politique. Essai d’anthropologie négativeParis: L’Harmattan.

RancièreJacques 1999Disagreement: Politics and Philosophy translated by Julie RoseMinneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.

RancièreJacques 2004‘Who Is the Subject of the Rights of Man?’The South Atlantic Quarterly1032/3: 297310.

RancièreJacques 2007Hatred of Democracy translated by Steve CorcoranLondon: Verso.

ReadJason 2003The Micro-Politics of Capital: Marx and the Prehistory of the PresentAlbany: State University of New York Press.

ReadJason 2015The Politics of TransindividualityHistorical Materialism Book SeriesLeiden: Brill.

RobbinsBruce 2013‘Balibarism!’n+1 16 available at: <>accessed 11 September 2017.

WalkerGavin 2012‘Citizen-Subject and the National Question: On the Logic of Capital in Balibar’Postmodern Culture223.

WoodEllen Meiksins 1995Democracy against Capitalism: Renewing Historical MaterialismCambridge: Cambridge University Press.

ŽižekSlavoj 2014‘Barbarism with a Human Face’London Review of Books369: 3637available at: <>accessed 11 September 2017.


  • View in gallery
    Equaliberty schema, inspired by Balibar 2014a, pp. 53, 64.


Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 126 126 16
Full Text Views 99 99 61
PDF Downloads 24 24 16
EPUB Downloads 9 9 2