Feminism Against Crime Control: On Sexual Subordination and State Apologism

in Historical Materialism
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Its critics call it ‘feminism-as-crime-control’, or ‘Governance Feminism’, diagnosing it as a pernicious form of identity politics. Its advocates call it taking sexual violence seriously – by which they mean wielding the power of the state to ‘punish perpetrators’ and ‘protect vulnerable women’. Both sides agree that this approach follows from the radical feminist analysis of sexual violence most strikingly formulated by Catharine MacKinnon. The aim of this paper is to rethink the Governance Feminism debate by questioning this common presupposition. I ask whether taking MacKinnon’s analysis of sexual violence seriously might, in fact, itself give us reason to be critical of political strategies that embrace the punitive state. By raising this question, I hope to persuade radical feminists to listen to critics of carceral politics rather than dismissing them as rape apologists, and critics of carceral politics to listen to radical feminists rather than dismissing them as state apologists.

Feminism Against Crime Control: On Sexual Subordination and State Apologism

in Historical Materialism



AdornoTheodor W. 1973 [1966]Negative Dialectics translated by E.B. AshtonLondon: Routledge & Kegan Paul.

AgustinLaura María 2007Sex at the Margins: Migration Labour Markets and the Rescue IndustryLondon: Zed Books.

AlexanderMichelle 2011The New Jim Crow: Mass Incarceration in the Age of ColorblindnessNew York: The New Press.

BarbagalloCamille 2015‘Leaving Home: Slavery and the Politics of Reproduction’Viewpoint Magazine31 Octoberavailable at: <https://www.viewpointmag.com/2015/10/31/leaving-home-slavery-and-the-politics-of-reproduction/>.

BernsteinElizabeth 2010‘Militarized Humanitarianism Meets Carceral Feminism: The Politics of Sex, Rights, and Freedom in Contemporary Anti-Trafficking Campaigns’Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society361: 4572.

BernsteinElizabeth 2012‘Carceral Politics as Gender Justice? The “Traffic in Women” and Neoliberal Circuits of Crime, Sex, and Rights’Theory and Society413: 233259.

BrownWendy 1995States of Injury: Power and Freedom in Late ModernityPrinceton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

BrownWendy and Janet E. Halley (eds.) 2002Left Legalism/Left CritiqueDurham, NC: Duke University Press.

ButlerJudith 1990Gender Trouble: Feminism and the Subversion of IdentityLondon: Routledge.

ChenChing-InJai Dulani and Leah Lakshmi Piepzna-Samarasinha (eds.) 2011The Revolution Starts at Home: Confronting Intimate Violence within Activist CommunitiesNew York: South End Press.

Clinks 2017Women’s Breakout: Chances to Change. Key Facts’available at: <http://womensbreakout.org.uk/about-womens-breakout/key-facts/>.

CohenGerald Allan 1983‘The Structure of Proletarian Unfreedom’Philosophy and Public Affairs121: 333.

Dalla CostaMariarosa forthcomingWomen and the Subversion of the Community: A Mariarosa Dalla Costa Reader edited by Camille BarbagalloOakland, CA: AK Press.

DavisAngela Y. 1981‘Racism, Birth Control and Reproductive Rights’ in Women Race & ClassLondon: The Women’s Press.

DavisAngela Y. 2003Are Prisons Obsolete?New York: Seven Stories.

DuffKoshka 2014Review of Living Less Wrongly: Adorno’s Practical Philosophy by Fabian Freyenhagen and Adorno by Brian O’ConnorMarx and Philosophy Review of Books2 Februaryavailable at: <http://www.marxandphilosophy.org.uk/reviewofbooks/reviews/2014/948>.

DuffKoshka 2017‘The Criminal Is Political: Policing Politics in Real Existing Liberalism’Journal of the American Philosophical Association34: 485502<https://doi.org/10.1017/apa.2017.39>.

FedericiSylvia 2012Revolution at Point Zero: Housework Reproduction and Feminist StruggleOakland, CA: PM Press.

FinlaysonLorna 2015‘How to Screw Things with Words: Feminism Unrealized’ in The Political Is Political: Conformity and the Illusion of Dissent in Contemporary Political PhilosophyLondon: Rowman & Littlefield International.

FinlaysonLorna 2016Introduction to FeminismCambridge: Cambridge University Press.

FinlaysonLorna 2018‘Can the Law Be Feminist?’Review of Butterfly Politics by Catharine MacKinnonLondon Review of Books402: 2931.

FoucaultMichel 1990The History of Sexuality. Volume 1: An Introduction translated by Robert HurleyNew York: Vintage.

GayleDamien 2016‘Police “Used Sexualised Violence against Fracking Protesters” ’The Guardian23 Februaryavailable at: <https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2016/feb/23/fracking-police-sexualised-violence-barton-moss-protest>.

GentlemanAmelia and Damien Gayle 2016‘Sarah Reed’s Mother: “My Daughter Was Failed by Many and I Was Ignored” ’The Guardian17 Februaryavailable at: <https://www.theguardian.com/society/2016/feb/17/sarah-reeds-mother-deaths-in-custody-holloway-prison-mental-health>.

GinnStephen 2013‘Women Prisoners’BMJ11 January<https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.e8318>.

GoldbergAdrian 2016‘The Girl Who Was Strip-Searched Aged 12 by Police’BBC News30 Octoberavailable at: <http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-37801760>.

GriersonJamie 2016‘Hundreds of Police in England and Wales Accused of Sexual Abuse’The Guardian8 Decemberavailable at: <https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2016/dec/08/hundreds-police-officers-accused-sex-abuse-inquiry-finds>.

HalleyJanet E. 2006Split Decisions: How and Why to Take a Break from FeminismPrinceton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

HalleyJanet E. 2008‘Rape in Berlin: Reconsidering the Criminalisation of Rape in the International Law of Armed Conflict’Melbourne Journal of International Law91: 78124.

HalleyJanet E.Prabha KotiswaranHila Shamir and Chantal Thomas 2006‘From the International to the Local in Feminist Legal Responses to Rape, Prostitution/Sex Work and Sex Trafficking: Four Studies in Contemporary Governance Feminism’Harvard Journal of Law & Gender292: 336423.

HanhardtChristina B. 2014Safe Space: Gay Neighbourhood History and the Politics of ViolenceDurham, NC: Duke University Press.

JenkinsKatharine 2016‘Amelioration and Inclusion: Gender Identity and the Concept of WomanEthics1262: 394421.

LambleSarah 2013‘Queer Necropolitics and the Expanding Carceral State: Interrogating Sexual Investments in Punishment’Law and Critique243: 229253.

LangtonRae 2009Sexual Solipsism: Philosophical Essays on Pornography and ObjectificationOxford: Oxford University Press.

LawVictoria 2014‘Against Carceral Feminism’Jacobin17 Octoberavailable at: <https://www.jacobinmag.com/2014/10/against-carceral-feminism/>.

MacKinnonCatharine A. 1987Feminism Unmodified: Discourses on Life and LawCambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

MacKinnonCatharine A. 1991Toward a Feminist Theory of the StateSecond EditionCambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

MacKinnonCatharine A. 2007Are Women Human? And Other International DialoguesCambridge, MA: Belknap Press.

MacKinnonCatharine A. 2017Butterfly PoliticsCambridge, MA: Belknap Press.

MarxKarl 1976 [1867]Capital: A Critique of Political Economy. Volume One translated by Ben FowkesHarmondsworth: Penguin.

MarxKarl 1994 [1844]‘On the Jewish Question’ in Early Political Writings edited by Joseph J. O’MalleyCambridge: Cambridge University Press.

MillsCharles 2007‘White Ignorance’ in Race and Epistemologies of Ignorance edited by Shannon Sullivan and Nancy TuanaNew York: SUNY Press.

MolloyParker Marie 2014‘CeCe McDonald: Rebuilding Her Life after 19 Months in Prison’Advocate3 Marchavailable at: <https://www.advocate.com/politics/transgender/2014/03/03/cece-mcdonald-rebuilding-her-life-after-19-months-prison%20>.

O’ConnorBrian 2013AdornoAbingdon: Routledge.

PollakSorcha 2013‘Trauma of Spy’s Girlfriend: “Like Being Raped by the State” ’The Guardian24 Juneavailable at: <https://www.theguardian.com/uk/2013/jun/24/undercover-police-spy-girlfriend-child>.

RitchieAndrea J. 2017Invisible No More: Police Violence against Black Women and Women of ColorBoston, MA: Beacon Press.

RobertsWilliam Clare 2016Marx’s Inferno: The Political Theory of CapitalPrinceton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

Rojas DurazoAna ClarissaAlisa BierriaMimi Kim (eds.) 2011‘Community Accountability: Emerging Movements to Transform Violence’Special Issue of Social Justice: A Journal of Crime Conflict & World OrderVolume 37Issue 4.

SambrookClare 2013‘Strip-Searched in Derbyshire’Open Democracy1 Octoberavailable at: <https://www.opendemocracy.net/ourkingdom/clare-sambrook/strip-searched-in-derbyshire>.

SmithMolly 2013‘Soho Police Raids Show Why Sex Workers Live in Fear of Being “Rescued” ’The Guardian11 Decemberavailable at: <https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2013/dec/11/soho-police-raids-sex-workers-fear-trafficking>.

SudburyJulia (ed.) 2005Global Lockdown: Race Gender and the Prison-Industrial ComplexAbingdon: Routledge.

SunsteinCass R. 1992‘Neutrality in Constitutional Law (with Special Reference to Pornography, Abortion, and Surrogacy)’Columbia Law Review921: 152.

TaylorDiane 2015‘Dossier Calling for Yarl’s Wood Closure Chronicles Decades of Abuse Complaints’The Guardian15 Juneavailable at: <https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2015/jun/15/yarls-wood-report-calling-for-closure-decade-abuse-complaints>.

ThreadcraftShatema 2014‘Intimate Injustice, Political Obligation, and the Dark Ghetto’Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society393: 735760.

TicktinMiriam 2008‘Sexual Violence as the Language of Border Control: Where French Feminist and Anti-immigrant Rhetoric Meet’Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society334: 863889.

WangJackie 2012‘Against Innocence: Race, Gender, and the Politics of Safety’Lies: A Journal of Materialist Feminism1available at: <http://www.liesjournal.net/volume1-10-againstinnocence.html>.

WillowCarolyne 2013‘Many Thousands of Children Stripped Naked in Custody. Ignites Memories of Being Raped’Open Democracy4 Marchavailable at: <https://www.opendemocracy.net/shinealight/carolyne-willow/many-thousands-of-children-stripped-naked-in-custody-ignites-memories-of>.

WittigMonique 1992The Straight Mind and Other EssaysLondon: Harvester Wheatsheaf.

YoungIris Marion 1990Justice and the Politics of DifferencePrinceton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

YoungIris Marion 1994‘Gender as Seriality: Thinking about Women as a Social Collective’Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society193: 713738.


Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 40 40 16
Full Text Views 128 128 75
PDF Downloads 14 14 8
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0