Lineages of Capital

in Historical Materialism
No Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Our reply focuses on three key themes raised in the symposium. First, we discuss an enduring issue in Marxist International Relations: ‘the problematic of the international’ and the problems of methodological internalism. We examine how our interlocutors have responded to this problematic and why we consider these responses insufficient. Specifically, we suggest that the source of our disagreement is grounded in two divergent understandings of the problem of internalism itself. We then reassert the value of our chosen response to the problematic – uneven and combined development (UCD). Second, we respond to the criticism that our extension of UCD as a ‘transmodal’ general abstraction is problematic by further explicating the significance and role of general abstractions in Marxist theory – a point yet addressed by our critics. Finally, we return to the fundamental question at the core of the transition debate: what is capitalism and how do we theorise it?

Lineages of Capital

in Historical Materialism



AllenRobert C. 2000‘Economic Structure and Agricultural Productivity in Europe, 1300–1800’European Review of Economic History41: 125.

AndersonPerry 2005Spectrum: From Left to Right in the World of IdeasLondon: Verso.

AnievasAlexander 2016‘History, Theory, and Contingency in the Study of International Relations: The Global Transformation Revisited’International Theory83: 468480.

AnievasAlexander and Kerem Nişancıoğlu 2013‘What’s at Stake in the Transition Debate? Rethinking the Origins of Capitalism and the “Rise of the West”’Millennium: Journal of International Studies421: 78102.

AnievasAlexander and Kerem Nişancıoğlu 2015How the West Came to Rule: The Geopolitical Origins of CapitalismLondon: Pluto Press.

AnievasAlexander and Kerem Nişancıoğlu 2016a‘Why Europe? Anti-Eurocentric Theory, History, and the Rise of Capitalism’Spectrum: Journal of Global Studies81: 7098.

AnievasAlexander and Kerem Nişancıoğlu 2016b‘The Being and Becoming of Capitalism’Progress in Political Economy13 Octoberavailable at: <>.

AnievasAlexander and Kerem Nişancıoğlu 2017‘How Did the West Usurp the Rest? Origins of the Great Divergence over the Longue DuréeComparative Studies in Society and History591: 3467.

BanajiJairus 2010Theory as History: Essays on Modes of Production and ExploitationHistorical Materialism Book SeriesLeiden: Brill.

BanajiJairus 2018‘Globalising the History of Capital: Ways Forward’Historical Materialism263: 143166.

BeckertSven 2014Empire of Cotton: A Global History New York: Alfred A. Knopf.

BielerAndreas 2016‘How the West Came to Rule? Challenging Eurocentrism’Progress in Political Economy4 Octoberavailable at: <>.

BonacichEdna and Jake B. Wilson 2008Getting the Goods: Ports Labor and the Logistics RevolutionIthaca, NY: Cornell University Press.

BraudeRichard 2016‘How the West Came to Rule’Capital & Class401: 181188.

BrennerRobert P. 1986‘The Social Basis of Economic Development’ in Analytical Marxism edited by John RoemerCambridge: Cambridge University Press.

BrennerRobert P. 1999‘Competition and Class: A Reply to Foster and McNally’Monthly Review517: 2444.

BrennerRobert P. 2001‘The Low Countries in the Transition to Capitalism’Journal of Agrarian Change12: 169241.

BrennerRobert P. 2007‘Property and Progress: Where Adam Smith Went Wrong’ in Marxist History-writing for the Twenty-first Century edited by Chris WickhamOxford: Oxford University Press/The British Academy.

ButlerJudith 1997‘Merely Cultural’Social Text52/53: 265277.

ChakrabartyDipesh 2007Provincializing Europe: Postcolonial Thought and Historical DifferenceSecond EditionPrinceton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

CooperLuke 2013‘Can Contingency Be “Internalized” into the Bounds of Theory? Critical Realism, the Philosophy of Internal Relations and the Solution of “Uneven and Combined Development”’Cambridge Review of International Affairs263: 573597.

CowenDeborah 2014The Deadly Life of Logistics: Mapping Violence in Global TradeMinneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.

DavidsonNeil 2003Discovering the Scottish Revolution 1692–1746London: Pluto Press.

DavidsonNeil 2010‘Many Capitals, Many States: Contingency, Logic or Mediation?’ in Marxism and World Politics: Contesting Global Capitalism edited by Alexander AnievasLondon: Routledge.

DavidsonNeil 2012How Revolutionary Were the Bourgeois Revolutions?Chicago: Haymarket Books.

DavidsonNeil 2018‘The Frontiers of Uneven and Combined Development’Historical Materialism263: 5278.

DijkmanJessica 2011Shaping Medieval Markets: The Organisation of Commodity Markets in Holland c.1200 – c.1450Leiden: Brill.

DimmockSpencer 2014The Origin of Capitalism in England 1400–1600Historical Materialism Book SeriesLeiden: Brill.

DimmockSpencer 2017‘The Eastern Origins of Capitalism?’Historical Materialismavailable at: <>.

DuzgunEren 2016‘International Relations, Historical Sociology and the Eurocentrism Debate’Spectrum: Journal of Global Studies81: 620.

EmighRebecca Jean 1998‘The Mystery of the Missing Middle-tenants: The “Negative” Case of Fixed-term Leasing and Agricultural Investment in Fifteenth-century Tuscany’Theory and Society273: 351375.

FanonFrantz 2008Black Skin White Masks translated by Charles Lam MarkmannLondon: Pluto Press.

FarrisSara R. 2015‘The Intersectional Conundrum and the Nation-State’Viewpoint Magazine4 Mayavailable at: <>.

FrenchH.R. 2015Review of The Origin of Capitalism in England, 1400–1600 by Spencer DimmockEnglish Historical Review130546: 12191221.

GordonLewis R. 2005‘Through the Zone of Nonbeing: A Reading of Black Skin, White Masks in Celebration of Fanon’s Eightieth Birthday’The CLR James Journal111: 143.

HartmanSaidiya V. 1997Scenes of Subjection: Terror Slavery and Self-making in Nineteenth-century AmericaOxford: Oxford University Press.

KnafoSamuel and Benno Teschke 2017‘The Rules of Reproduction of Capitalism: A Historicist Critique’Working Paper Nº 12 January CGPEThe University of Sussex.

LoweLisa 2015The Intimacies of Four ContinentsDurham, NC: Duke University Press.

MatinKamran 2007‘Uneven and Combined Development in World History: The International Relations of State-formation in Premodern Iran’European Journal of International Relations133: 419447.

MatinKamran 2014Recasting Iranian Modernity: International Relations and Social ChangeLondon: Routledge.

MedvedMladen 2018‘A Combined Argument: Beyond Wallerstein?’Historical Materialism263: 125142.

NişancıoğluKerem 2016‘Combination as “Foreign Policy”: The Intersocietal Origins of the Ottoman Empire’ in Historical Sociology and World History: Uneven and Combined Development over the Longue Durée edited by Alexander Anievas and Kamran MatinLanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield International.

PalMaïa 2018‘“My Capitalism Is Bigger than Yours!”: Against Combining “How the West Came to Rule” with “The Origins of Capitalism”’Historical Materialism263: 99124.

PerssonKarl Gunnar 1991‘Labor Productivity in the Medieval Economy: The Case of Tuscany and the Low Countries’ in Land Labour and Livestock: Historical Studies in European Agricultural Productivity edited by B.M.S. Campbell and Mark OvertonManchester: Manchester University Press.

PerssonKarl Gunnar 2014‘Markets and Coercion in Medieval Europe’ in The Cambridge History of Capitalism Volume 1. The Rise of Capitalism: From Ancient Origins to 1848 edited by Larry Neal and Jeffrey G. WilliamsonCambridge: Cambridge University Press.

PijlKees van der 2007Nomads Empires States: Modes of Foreign Relations and Political EconomyVolume ILondon: Pluto Press.

PostCharles 2002‘Comments on the Brenner–Wood Exchange on the Low Countries’Journal of Agrarian Change21: 8895.

PostCharles 2018‘The Use and Misuse of Uneven and Combined Development: A Critique of Anievas and Nişancıoğlu’Historical Materialism263: 7998.

RosenbergJustin 2006‘Why Is There No International Historical Sociology?’European Journal of International Relations123: 307340.

SayerDerek 1987The Violence of Abstraction: The Analytical Foundations of Historical MaterialismOxford: Basil Blackwell.

SmallwoodStephanie E. 2009Saltwater Slavery: A Middle Passage from Africa to American DiasporaCambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

TeschkeBenno 2003The Myth of 1648: Class Geopolitics and the Making of Modern International RelationsLondon: Verso.

TeschkeBenno 2005‘Bourgeois Revolution, State Formation and the Absence of the International’Historical Materialism132: 326.

TsingAnna 2009‘Supply Chains and the Human Condition’Rethinking Marxism212: 148176.

WickhamChris 2008‘Productive Forces and the Economic Logic of the Feudal Mode of Production’Historical Materialism162: 322.

WildersonFrank B.III 2003‘Gramsci’s Black Marx: Whither the Slave in Civil Society’Social Identities92: 225240.

WoodEllen Meiksins 2002‘The Question of Market Dependence’Journal of Agrarian Change21: 5087.


Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 73 73 24
Full Text Views 94 94 37
PDF Downloads 28 28 3
EPUB Downloads 1 1 0